quarta-feira, 31 de março de 2010

Médicos católicos deploran "furia" de medios contra el Papa y la Iglesia


ROMA, 31 Mar. 10 / 12:14 am (ACI)

La Federación Internacional de Asociaciones de Médicos Católicos (FIAMC) emitió una nota de prensa en la que expresa su rechazo a la "furia" con que diversos medios en varios países del mundo están atacando al Papa Benedicto XVI y la Iglesia Católica, tomando como excusa algunos casos de abusos sexuales cometidos por miembros del clero.

El texto firmado por el Presidente de la FIAMC, Dr. Jose María Simón Castellví, señala que "la responsabilidad de los eclesiásticos individualmente, y eventualmente de sus superiores directos, es extendida a toda la Iglesia, y no faltan tampoco intentos de interpretar tales abusos como inevitable consecuencia de los principios del magisterio, de la concepción del ministerio sacerdotal y de la moral católica".

Para los médicos católicos "esta campaña mediática suscita la sospecha de que grupos editoriales, y los centros de poder que los sostienen, quieren desacreditar la autoridad de la Iglesia, que es la voz más consciente en la defensa de la vida desde la concepción hasta la muerte natural, en la defensa de la familia y la moral sexual católica tradicional, y en la defensa del género humano ante peligrosas aventuras en el campo de la genética".

"Ya se ha visto claras condenas de los casos de abuso sexual, pero también se ha dejado claro que no es posible ni legítimo atribuirle la responsabilidad de ellos a la Iglesia Católica universal", prosigue.

Finalmente la FIAMC "manifiesta su plena solidaridad al Santo Padre".


Expertos responden a artículo del Washington Post que difunde "Gran Mentira" sobre abusos


WASHINGTON D.C., 31 Mar. 10 / 02:45 am (ACI)

George Weigel, conocido apologeta estadounidense, y el P. Jay Scott Newman, canonista, responden alturada y acuciosamente a un artículo publicado por el Washington Post el
Domingo de Ramos, escrito por la polémica cantante irlandesa Sinead O’Connor. Para ambos expertos, este texto es una pieza más del engranaje mediático que busca enlodar al Papa Benedicto XVI presentándolo como "encubridor" de algunos casos de abusos sexuales cometidos por miembros del clero, cuando no lo es y nunca lo ha sido.

En el artículo titulado "Difundiendo la Gran Mentira: ¿Por qué el Washington Post publica en Domingo de Ramos un malicioso artículo de Sinead O’ Connor sobre los abusos en la Iglesia Católica?", los expertos explican que la controvertida cantante tienen derecho a expresarse, incluso en contra del Papa, pero "no tiene derecho a manipular la enseñanza y las leyes de la Iglesia Católica para respaldar su alegato sobre que la Iglesia es una ‘organización abusadora’ y que amenaza con la excomunión a quienes denuncian a los abusadores sexuales entre el clero".

"Eso es, en última instancia, falso. Si la Sra. O’Connor es consciente de su falsedad, entonces ha mentido. Lo que es más probable es que ella haya tomado estos argumentos sin sentido de quienes están tratando de mostrar a la Iglesia Católica como una conspiradora global formada por predadores sexuales, para aplastar a la Iglesia moral y financieramente y llevarla a la vergüenza en medio de la esfera pública".

Los expertos explican luego que "el actual torbellino de controversia que gira alrededor del Papa Benedicto XVI está repleto de Grandes Mentiras. Una de ellas –que Benedicto, cuando era el Cardenal Ratzinger, impidió se sancione al diabólico sacerdote que había abusado de 200 niños sordos a su cuidado– se explotó recientemente. Otra Gran Mentira es que Benedicto XVI es suave ante los abusos, y como la Sra. O’Connor sugiere, está más preocupado en defender la reputación de clérigos mayores que en ir a la raíz del mal del abuso sexual".

"La aguda respuesta del Papa a los obispos de Irlanda y su franca condena a los sacerdotes y religiosas abusadores el pasado 20 de marzo en su carta a los católicos irlandeses revelan lo falso que es el alegato de la cantante".

Otra de las Grandes Mentiras que citan ambos autores tiene que ver con la afirmación de que "los abusos por parte de clérigos y el mal manejo episcopal de los mismos fueron permitidos por un documento vaticano de 1962 Crimen sollicitationis ( El Crimen de Solicitación)" así como por una carta del entonces Cardenal Ratzinger del año 2001, De delictis gravioribus (Sobre crímenes más serios).

Weigel y el P. Newman explican que el primero fue escrito para "asegurar que si un sacerdote solicitaba a un católico cometer un pecado sexual durante la confesión, él o ella podía denunciar al presbítero sin ser expuesto al escándalo público. Sinead O’Connor (y muchos, muchos otros que han difundido esta Gran Mentira en particular) lo han entendido todo mal".

Crimen sollicitationis "no fue escrito para proteger a sacerdotes abusadores del castigo, sino para permitir que la Iglesia llegue a la verdad sobre estos sacerdotes sin avergonzar a sus víctimas o romper el secreto de confesión. De hecho, la protección requerida en este documento alentaba a las víctimas de abuso a darlo a conocer. Al exigir el secreto al obispo y a los sacerdotes que manejan una denuncia sobre un sacerdote-confesor que era un predador sexual, la Iglesia trataba de proteger la confidencialidad del confesionario y la privacidad de la víctima, no buscaba prevenir que se denunciar a la policía, quien nunca estuvo obligada al secreto".

Esta misma analogía, explican, de algo que Sinead O’ Connor no comprende, se aprecia "en el secreto de aquellos diarios que escogen no publicar los nombres de la víctimas de violación".

Este documento de 1962 se mantuvo en vigor hasta el año 2001, cuando el entonces Cardenal Ratzinger, como Prefecto de la Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, publicó un nuevo documento De delictis gravioribus "que prosiguió en el esfuerzo de proteger la confidencialidad de la confesión y la privacidad de los católicos abusados por confesores y permitía a la Iglesia responder efectiva y consistentemente a las acusaciones contra sacerdotes, quienes como cualquier otro, tienen el derecho a la presunción de inocencia".

"Cualquiera con un mínimo de conocimiento sobre cómo Ratzinger manejó estos casos en ese dicasterio entiende que Benedicto XVI está muy comprometido en un honesto recuento de la inconductas sacerdotal y en la reforma que está en marcha para la vida y ministerio de los sacerdotes".

"Estos son hechos –prosiguen–. Pueden ser verificados por cualquier canonista competente. Por qué el Washington Post escogió el Domingo de Ramos, mientras Benedicto XVI celebraba una de las más bellas liturgias del año en la Plaza de San Pedro, para publicar un artículo malicioso e ignorante de Sinead O’Connor, cuya aversión por la Iglesia es conocida, no es algo que nos toque juzgar".

"Lo que podemos decir, como otro hecho, es que al hacerlo sin el básico recuento de hechos concretos, los editores del Post han contribuido a la difusión de una Gran Mentira", concluyen.


terça-feira, 30 de março de 2010

Murphy Case: NYT Never Talked to Judge

Tuesday, March 30, 2010, 8:30 AM

In a remarkable piece, we get a sense of confirmation, that the New York Times and the mainstream press are doing their best -during Holy Week, as usual- to (at the very least) foment disgust at the Pontiff and the Catholic Church and/or (at worst) create a climate that “demands” a papal abdication.

But curiously, as the media talk endlessly about an extremely sick case out of Wisconsin, the Times -which “broke” the story- seems to have been very selective in their sources. Fr. Thomas Brundage, JLC appears not to be considered “useful” to the sensationalists in the press:

I was the Judicial Vicar for the Archdiocese of Milwaukee . . . I presided over four canonical criminal cases, one of which involved Father Lawrence Murphy.
…
I will limit my comments, because of judicial oaths I have taken as a canon lawyer and as an ecclesiastical judge. However, since my name and comments in the matter of the Father Murphy case have been liberally and often inaccurately quoted in the New York Times and in more than 100 other newspapers and on-line periodicals, I feel a freedom to tell part of the story of Father Murphy’s trial from ground zero.

As I have found that the reporting on this issue has been inaccurate and poor in terms of the facts, I am also writing out of a sense of duty to the truth.

The fact that I presided over this trial and have never once been contacted by any news organization for comment speaks for itself.

Emphasis mine. But read on:

My intent in the following paragraphs is to . . . assert that Pope Benedict XVI has done more than any other pope or bishop in history to rid the Catholic Church of the scourge of child sexual abuse and provide for those who have been injured;

To set the record straight with regards to the efforts made by the church to heal the wounds caused by clergy sexual misconduct.

Set the record straight? You mean we’re not getting the whole story from the mainstream press? I’m gobsmacked!

Read on. It is gut-wrenching and unpleasant stuff. Then there is this: (Emphasis mine, again)

With regard to the inaccurate reporting on behalf of the New York Times, the Associated Press, and those that utilized these resources, first of all, I was never contacted by any of these news agencies but they felt free to quote me. Almost all of my quotes are from a document that can be found online with the correspondence between the Holy See and the Archdiocese of Milwaukee. In an October 31, 1997 handwritten document, I am quoted as saying ‘odds are that this situation may very well be the most horrendous, number wise, and especially because these are physically challenged , vulnerable people. “ Also quoted is this: “Children were approached within the confessional where the question of circumcision began the solicitation.”

The problem with these statements attributed to me is that they were handwritten. The documents were not written by me and do not resemble my handwriting. The syntax is similar to what I might have said but I have no idea who wrote these statements, yet I am credited as stating them. As a college freshman at the Marquette University School of Journalism, we were told to check, recheck, and triple check our quotes if necessary. I was never contacted by anyone on this document, written by an unknown source to me. Discerning truth takes time and it is apparent that the New York Times, the Associated Press and others did not take the time to get the facts correct.

Additionally, in the documentation in a letter from Archbishop Weakland to then-secretary of the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith Archbishop Tarcisio Bertone on August 19, 1998, Archbishop Weakland stated that he had instructed me to abate the proceedings against Father Murphy. Father Murphy, however, died two days later and the fact is that on the day that Father Murphy died, he was still the defendant in a church criminal trial. No one seems to be aware of this. Had I been asked to abate this trial, I most certainly would have insisted that an appeal be made to the supreme court of the church, or Pope John Paul II if necessary. That process would have taken months if not longer.

Second, with regard to the role of then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI), in this matter, I have no reason to believe that he was involved at all. Placing this matter at his doorstep is a huge leap of logic and information.

Third, the competency to hear cases of sexual abuse of minors shifted from the Roman Rota to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith headed by Cardinal Ratzinger in 2001. Until that time, most appeal cases went to the Rota and it was our experience that cases could languish for years in this court. When the competency was changed to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, in my observation as well as many of my canonical colleagues, sexual abuse cases were handled expeditiously, fairly, and with due regard to the rights of all the parties involved. I have no doubt that this was the work of then-Cardinal Ratzinger.

Fourth, Pope Benedict has repeatedly apologized for the shame of the sexual abuse of children in various venues and to a worldwide audience. This has never happened before. He has met with victims. He has reigned in entire conferences of bishops on this matter, the Catholic Bishops of Ireland being the most recent. He has been most reactive and proactive of any international church official in history with regard to the scourge of clergy sexual abuse of minors. Instead of blaming him for inaction on these matters, he has truly been a strong and effective leader on these issues.

Read on, read on. Read it all.

We’re in Lent; it’s Holy Week. This time of the year, it’s always something, and it’s always something that “changes everything!” If it’s not someone declaring that The Gospel of Judas (April, 2006) invalidates Christianity, then it’s someone claiming they’ve found Jesus’ casket (February, 2007). If it is not a Lent-long hype for a stupid movie, it’s the “Jesus was a racist” silliness (February, 2009)

This year, the NY Times managed to co-ordinate its Big Inaccurate Scoop of Sensationalism with a demonstration in Rome.

Look, as I said in this long response to a young man, we Catholics understand with devastating clarity what has been done, and what a burden falls upon the whole church, now. We know we have a difficult penance before us. As I wrote when Benedict visited the US in 2008:

The terrible sin of some of our priests, compounded by their bishops, has been a source of sickening and unrelenting shame for us. We have felt the disgust in our bellies and wished we could push the whole story away, because the pain is so abysmal and vast. But it can be pushed away no longer, and Benedict said that even before his plane hit the ground at Andrews AFB, and every day after.

But understanding and sympathizing with the victims, and their quests for attention, validation, justice and -most importantly- healing, does not mean we stand by while a different injustice is perpetrated against a man who, as Fr. Brundage attests, “has been most reactive and proactive of any international church official in history with regard to the scourge of clergy sexual abuse of minors.”

To levy a heinous charge against the pope without even talking to relevant parties, and to parlay a notion that “possibly he knew or may have known something at some point and maybe did or did not do enough, which renders all that he has done to insufficiency and he should resign” is not only reckless; it creates an precedent by which, in the future, virtually no cardinal elected to the Chair of Peter would be safe from gossip about “something that happened, somewhere, that maybe he heard about three decades ago…”

In other words, we could then be facing at a string of pontiffs seated under a cloud and loudly slandered throughout their pontificates, until that glorious day when a “progressive” Pope who advocates birth control, divorce, female ordination, gay marriage and so forth is seated, at which point, all whispers will miraculously cease.

What has become clear to me, via emails and several requests from media outlets who want to discuss “the possibility of the pope resigning,” is that Pope Benedict is under siege because some want him to be under siege and would like nothing better than to take down this pontiff.

The quest for the Petrine scalp is a quest to do more than destroy a man; it is a quest to destroy any vestige of an institutional, organized Christian Church, and to send its members swirling into a spiritual maelstrom that will leave them untethered, dispirited and at the mercy of the secularist authorities. Displace the Roman centering pole from the Big Tent of Christianity, and the collapse snuffs out the flames of a million smaller churches born of this taproot.

Pope Benedict XVI has made some people very unhappy since even before his election, and certainly since his warning against the “dictatorship of relativism” which left some secularists, for whom relativism is paramount, in an uproar. That this aged pope attracts youthful crowds is something that cannot be endured. This pope is meeting with abuse victims; he is taking espicopal resignations, he is making room for Anglicans and making progress with Muslims and with the Orthodox church, too. He is making some feel threatened by “going backwards” and strengthening the church simultaneously.

No wonder a sloppy report founded on two dubious sources, and with no serious investigatory measures taken, is being given Watergate-level credence. Watergate, after all, took down a government.

The church’s own errors have brought us to this point, where she is truly vulnerable to attack, but let us not allow some to pretend that real changes have not been instituted under this pope, who has been zealous about addressing what he calls “the filth.” Let us not allow some to pretend that penance is not being done, and that substantial reform is not being undertaken and enforced.

We must understand that this attack is not simply upon the pope. It is meant to be a much-rallied battering ram pounded upon the gates of the church -and the churches- entire.

Meanwhile, the discussions go on. Some of them manage to be thoughtful, clear and considered, and others, not so much.

Related:
Strong words from Dolan
Fr. Daren J. Zehnle answers the Times
Evident and Despicable Intent
“NY Times Should be Held to Account”
Doubts About JP’s Sainthood
Palm Sunday Address
Cultural Obamalypse Attack on Pope
Praying for the Pope

Pope Benedict being 'scourged at the pillar,' says New York archbishop

.- In remarks following Palm Sunday Mass, Archbishop Timothy Dolan of New York urged Catholics “to express our love and solidarity” for Pope Benedict, who, given the recent media onslaught over sex abuse allegations, is “now suffering some of the same unjust accusations, shouts of the mob, and scourging at the pillar, as did Jesus.”

Following the March 28 Mass in St. Patrick's Cathedral, the prelate began his brief statement by stating that the “somberness of Holy Week is intensified for Catholics this year” as the “recent tidal wave of headlines about abuse of minors by some few priests, this time in Ireland, Germany, and a re-run of an old story from Wisconsin, has knocked us to our knees once again.”

“Anytime this horror, vicious sin, and nauseating crime is reported, as it needs to be, victims and their families are wounded again, the vast majority of faithful priests bow their heads in shame anew, and sincere Catholics experience another dose of shock, sorrow, and even anger,” Archbishop Dolan said.

But the Archbishop of New York found a more troubling aspect of the recent spate of news. “What deepens the sadness now is the unrelenting insinuations against the Holy Father himself, as certain sources seem frenzied to implicate the man who, perhaps more than anyone else has been the leader in purification, reform, and renewal that the Church so needs,” the archbishop asserted.

“Sunday Mass is hardly the place to document the inaccuracy, bias, and hyperbole of such aspersions,” he added.“But, Sunday Mass is indeed the time for Catholics to pray for … Benedict our Pope.”

“And Palm Sunday Mass is sure a fitting place for us to express our love and solidarity for our earthly shepherd now suffering some of the same unjust accusations, shouts of the mob, and scourging at the pillar, as did Jesus.”

Archbishop Dolan then defended Pope Benedict from the articles attempting to establish that he mismanaged sexually abusive priests.

“No one has been more vigorous in cleansing the Church of the effects of this sickening sin than the man we now call Pope Benedict XVI,” Archbishop Dolan stressed. “The dramatic progress that the Catholic Church in the United States has made – documented again just last week by the report made by independent forensic auditors – could never have happened without the insistence and support of the very man now being daily crowned with thorns by groundless innuendo.”

“Does the Church and her Pastor, Pope Benedict XVI, need intense scrutiny and just criticism for tragic horrors long past?” the prelate asked. “Yes! He himself has asked for it, encouraging complete honesty, at the same time expressing contrition, and urging a thorough cleansing.”

“All we ask is that it be fair, and that the Catholic Church not be singled-out for a horror that has cursed every culture, religion, organization, institution, school, agency, and family in the world.”

“Sorry to bring this up,” Archbishop Dolan concluded, “… but, then again, the Eucharist is the Sunday meal of the spiritual family we call the Church. At Sunday dinner we share both joys and sorrows. The father of our family, il papa, needs our love, support, and prayers.”

U.S. bishops profoundly grateful for Pope's work in combating sexual abuse

.- This morning the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops expressed “profound gratitude” for the assistance that Pope Benedict XVI has given the bishops in their “efforts to respond to victims, deal with perpetrators and to create safe environments for children.” The statement comes in the midst of numerous media reports attempting to link the Pope to mishandling of sex abuse cases.

The bishops opened their March 30 statement by saying that “the recent emergence of more reports of sexual abuse by clergy saddens and angers the Church and causes us shame.” If “there is anywhere that children should be safe, it should be in their homes and in the Church,” the bishops said.

The latest reports of sexual abuse to surface have come from Europe and have been accompanied by attempts, both in Europe and the U.S., to connect the mishandling of the abusive priests to Pope Benedict.

In today's statement, the American bishops came to the Pope's defense, stating, “(w)e know from our experience how Pope Benedict is deeply concerned for those who have been harmed by sexual abuse and how he has strengthened the Church's response to victims and supported our efforts to deal with perpetrators.”

“We continue to intensify our efforts to provide safe environments for children in our parishes and schools,” the statement added. “Further, we work with others in our communities to address the prevalence of sexual abuse in the larger society.”

Citing an example of the Pope's commitment to the healing of sex abuse victims within the Church, the bishops recalled how one “of the most touching moments of the Holy Father’s visit to the United States in 2008 was his private conversation with victims/survivors at the Apostolic Nunciature in Washington.”

“Pope Benedict heard firsthand how sexual abuse has devastated lives. The Holy Father spoke with each person and provided every one time to speak freely to him. They shared their painful experiences and he listened, often clasping their hands and responding tenderly and reassuringly.”

The U.S. bishops also underscored how “the support of both Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI” has allowed them make a “vigorous commitment to do everything in our power to prevent abuse from happening to children.”

After the sex abuse scandal wracked the Church in the U.S., the bishops adopted the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People in 2002 at a meeting in Dallas. The charter calls on the Church to “respond with compassion to victims/survivors, to work diligently to screen those working with children and young people in the Church, to provide child abuse awareness and prevention education, to report suspected abuse to civil law enforcement, and to account for our efforts to protect children and youth through an external annual national audit,” the bishops noted.

The bishops concluded their remarks in Tuesday's statement by saying that as “we accompany Christ in His passion and death during this Holy Week, we stand with our Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI in prayer for the victims of sexual abuse, for the entire Church and for the world.”

segunda-feira, 29 de março de 2010

Arzobispo de Nueva York: Benedicto XVI es líder en purificación y reforma de la Iglesia


NUEVA YORK, 29 Mar. 10 / 01:21 pm (ACI)

El Arzobispo de Nueva York, Mons. Timothy Dolan, salió al paso de la campaña difamatoria "casi frenética" contra el Papa Benedicto XVI y resaltó que el Santo Padre "es un líder en la purificación, en la reforma y la renovación de la Iglesia".

En su homilía de la Misa de Domingo de Ramos en la Catedral de San Patricio en Manhattan, el Prelado invitó a todos los fieles a rezar por el Pontífice.

Refiriéndose luego a los graves de casos de abusos sexuales cometidos por algunos miembros del clero, el Arzobispo indicó que "cada vez que este horror, que este crimen nauseabundo es denunciado –como es justo que se haga– las víctimas y sus familias son nuevamente heridos, la gran mayoría de sacerdotes baja la cabeza como signo de vergüenza y los católicos sinceros son expuestos a una nueva dosis de shock, disgusto e incluso rabia".

El Arzobispo dijo también que la tristeza es más intensa "por las graves insinuaciones contra el mismo Santo Padre mientras en ciertos ambientes se ha lanzado una campaña casi frenética para implicar a este gran hombre".

Para Mons. Dolan, los progresos de la Iglesia Católica para afrontar este tema en Estados Unidos nunca se hubieran dado "sin la insistencia y el apoyo del mismo hombre (el Papa) ahora coronado todos los días por las espinas de la maldad que no tienen ningún fundamento".


A Response to the New York Times

By Fr. Raymond J. de Souza

In National Review online

The New York Times on March 25 accused Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, of intervening to prevent a priest, Fr. Lawrence Murphy, from facing penalties for cases of sexual abuse of minors.

The story is false. It is unsupported by its own documentation. Indeed, it gives every indication of being part of a coordinated campaign against Pope Benedict, rather than responsible journalism.

Before addressing the false substance of the story, the following circumstances are worthy of note:

• The New York Times story had two sources. First, lawyers who currently have a civil suit pending against the Archdiocese of Milwaukee. One of the lawyers, Jeffrey Anderson, also has cases in the United States Supreme Court pending against the Holy See. He has a direct financial interest in the matter being reported.

• The second source was Archbishop Rembert Weakland, retired archbishop of Milwaukee. He is the most discredited and disgraced bishop in the United States, widely known for mishandling sexual-abuse cases during his tenure, and guilty of using $450,000 of archdiocesan funds to pay hush money to a former homosexual lover who was blackmailing him. Archbishop Weakland had responsibility for the Father Murphy case between 1977 and 1998, when Father Murphy died. He has long been embittered that his maladministration of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee earned him the disfavor of Pope John Paul II and Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, long before it was revealed that he had used parishioners’ money to pay off his clandestine lover. He is prima facie not a reliable source.

• Laurie Goodstein, the author of the New York Times story, has a recent history with Archbishop Weakland. Last year, upon the release of the disgraced archbishop’s autobiography, she wrote an unusually sympathetic story that buried all the most serious allegations against him (New York Times, May 14, 2009).

• A demonstration took place in Rome on Friday, coinciding with the publication of the New York Times story. One might ask how American activists would happen to be in Rome distributing the very documents referred to that day in the New York Times. The appearance here is one of a coordinated campaign, rather than disinterested reporting.

It’s possible that bad sources could still provide the truth. But compromised sources scream out for greater scrutiny. Instead of greater scrutiny of the original story, however, news editors the world over simply parroted the New York Times piece. Which leads us the more fundamental problem: The story is not true, according to its own documentation.

The New York Times made available on its own website the supporting documentation for the story. In those documents, Cardinal Ratzinger himself does not take any of the decisions that allegedly frustrated the trial. Letters are addressed to him; responses come from his deputy. Even leaving that aside, though, the gravamen of the charge — that Cardinal Ratzinger’s office impeded some investigation — is proven utterly false.

The documents show that the canonical trial or penal process against Father Murphy was never stopped by anyone. In fact, it was only abandoned days before Father Murphy died. Cardinal Ratzinger never took a decision in the case, according to the documents. His deputy, Archbishop Tarcisio Bertone, suggested, given that Father Murphy was in failing health and a canonical trial is a complicated matter, that more expeditious means be used to remove him from all ministry.

To repeat: The charge that Cardinal Ratzinger did anything wrong is unsupported by the documentation on which the story was based. He does not appear in the record as taking any decision. His office, in the person of his deputy, Archbishop Bertone, agreed that there should be full canonical trial. When it became apparent that Father Murphy was in failing health, Archbishop Bertone suggested more expeditious means of removing him from any ministry.

Furthermore, under canon law at the time, the principal responsibility for sexual-abuse cases lay with the local bishop. Archbishop Weakland had from 1977 onwards the responsibility of administering penalties to Father Murphy. He did nothing until 1996. It was at that point that Cardinal Ratzinger’s office became involved, and it subsequently did nothing to impede the local process.

The New York Times flatly got the story wrong, according to its own evidence. Readers may want to speculate on why.

Here is the relevant timeline, drawn from the documents the New York Times posted on its own website.

15 May 1974

Abuse by Fr. Lawrence Murphy is alleged by a former student at St. John’s School for the Deaf in Milwaukee. In fact, accusations against Father Murphy go back more than a decade.

12 September 1974

Father Murphy is granted an official “temporary sick leave” from St. John’s School for the Deaf. He leaves Milwaukee and moves to northern Wisconsin, in the Diocese of Superior, where he lives in a family home with his mother. He has no official assignment from this point until his death in 1998. He does not return to live in Milwaukee. No canonical penalties are pursued against him.

9 July 1980

Officials in the Diocese of Superior write to officials in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee about what ministry Father Murphy might undertake in Superior. Archbishop Rembert Weakland, archbishop of Milwaukee since 1977, has been consulted and says it would be unwise to have Father Murphy return to ministry with the deaf community. There is no indication that Archbishop Weakland foresees any other measures to be taken in the case.

17 July 1996

More than 20 years after the original abuse allegations, Archbishop Weakland writes to Cardinal Ratzinger, claiming that he has only just discovered that Father Murphy’s sexual abuse involved the sacrament of confession — a still more serious canonical crime. The allegations about the abuse of the sacrament of confession were in the original 1974 allegations. Weakland has been archbishop of Milwaukee by this point for 19 years.

It should be noted that for sexual-abuse charges, Archbishop Weakland could have proceeded against Father Murphy at any time. The matter of solicitation in the sacrament of confession required notifying Rome, but that too could have been done as early as the 1970s.

10 September 1996

Father Murphy is notified that a canonical trial will proceed against him. Until 2001, the local bishop had authority to proceed in such trials. The Archdiocese of Milwaukee is now beginning the trial. It is noteworthy that at this point, no reply has been received from Rome indicating that Archbishop Weakland knew he had that authority to proceed.

24 March 1997

Archbishop Tarcisio Bertone, Cardinal Ratzinger’s deputy at the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, advises a canonical trial against Father Murphy.

14 May 1997

Archbishop Weakland writes to Archbishop Bertone to say that the penal process against Father Murphy has been launched, and notes that the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith has advised him to proceed even though the statute of limitations has expired. In fact, there is no statute of limitations for solicitation in the sacrament of confession.

Throughout the rest of 1997 the preparatory phases of penal process or canonical trial is underway. On 5 January 1998 the Tribunal of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee says that an expedited trial should be concluded within a few months.

12 January 1998

Father Murphy, now less than eight months away from his death, appeals to Cardinal Ratzinger that, given his frail health, he be allowed to live out his days in peace.

6 April 1998

Archbishop Bertone, noting the frail health of Father Murphy and that there have been no new charges in almost 25 years, recommends using pastoral measures to ensure Father Murphy has no ministry, but without the full burden of a penal process. It is only a suggestion, as the local bishop retains control.

13 May 1998

The Bishop of Superior, where the process has been transferred to and where Father Murphy has lived since 1974, rejects the suggestion for pastoral measures. Formal pre-trial proceedings begin on 15 May 1998, continuing the process already begun with the notification that had been issued in September 1996.

30 May 1998

Archbishop Weakland, who is in Rome, meets with officials at the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, including Archbishop Bertone but not including Cardinal Ratzinger, to discuss the case. The penal process is ongoing. No decision taken to stop it, but given the difficulties of a trial after 25 years, other options are explored that would more quickly remove Father Murphy from ministry.

19 August 1998

Archbishop Weakland writes that he has halted the canonical trial and penal process against Father Murphy and has immediately begun the process to remove him from ministry — a quicker option.

21 August 1998

Father Murphy dies. His family defies the orders of Archbishop Weakland for a discreet funeral.