Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta filhos. Mostrar todas as mensagens
Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta filhos. Mostrar todas as mensagens

quarta-feira, 15 de maio de 2013

Take Back Your Kids: How to Teach and Get Respect - by William J. Doherty

In CERC 

We are facing an epidemic of insecure parenting. We may now have the most child-sensitive generation of parents the world has ever known and — the most confused and insecure.
 
This generation has determined not to repeat the mistakes of its own parents, who expected unquestioning obedience. But in rejecting outmoded models of authority, parents are now skittish about exercising any authority at all. 
  Children raised with insecure parents grow up too soon, become preoccupied with consumer goods and peer acceptance, and focus their lives on frenetic activity outside the home.  They know that their parents love them deeply and want to communicate sensitively with them, but they also know that their parents are unsure about what to require of them and how to say "no" to them.

A family now in therapy has a 10-year-old boy, who is an angel in school, but who has started to call his mother a "bitch" at home.  Rather than exercising legitimate authority, his mother responds by feeling sorry that her son is so distraught.  (An appropriate exercise of parental authority: "You may not speak to me like that EVER, not even when you are angry.  Go to your room and come back when you have a letter of apology.")

Another example: Our local newspaper has been running a series on alcohol and teens.  Kids in earlier generations drank alcohol, often to excess.  The difference now, as documented in the newspaper articles, is that parents supply the keg of beer, the house or hotel room, and the funds to enjoy a Mexican frolic of booze and sex during spring break. Most parents who were interviewed were reluctant to let their children go on a Mexican spring break this year, but were unable to say "no," particularly when most of the other kids announced they were going.


The Consumer Culture of Childhood


In the new culture of childhood, children are viewed as consumers of parental services, and parents are viewed as providers of parental services and brokers of community services for children.  What gets lost is the other side of the human equation: children bearing responsibilities to their families and communities.

Children should not only receive from adults but also actively contribute to the world around them, help care for the younger and the infirm, add their own marks to the quality of family life, and contribute to the common good in their school and communities.  If children live only as consumers of parental and community services, then they are not active citizens of families and communities.

If we see ourselves only as providers of services to our children, we end up confused about our authority, anxious about displeasing our children, insecure about whether we are providing enough opportunities, and worried that we are not keeping up with the output of other parents.  In a market economy, the service provider must offer what is newest and best, and at all costs, must avoid disappointing the customer.
When applied to the family, this is a recipe for insecure parents and entitled kids.  (One 17-year-old said to his parents, "Why should I mow the lawn?  It's not my lawn.")


The Therapeutic Culture of Parenting

How to Expect and Get Respect
  1. Respect Your Child. Let your children express their own opinions, tastes, and values — if they do so respectfully.
  2. Expect respect. Respect should be an expectation in your family because without it, little else will go well. Use terms such as "respect," "disrespect," "polite," and "rude" to develop a common language of respect.
  3. Explain your new policy on respect to your children. If they've been previously allowed to get away with disrespect, many children are unaware that they are being disrespectful. Meet with your kids at a quiet time to explain your new policy.
  4. Tune your ears to the sound of respect and disrespect. Sometimes parents fail to recognize the sound of their child's disrespect because they may be focusing too much on the content of what is said (interruptions, accusations, name-calling) and not listening to the child's tone of voice. A raised voice is not necessarily a sign of disrespect, but attacking, intrusive, sarcastic, and mean words and tone are.
  5. Nip disrespectful behavior in the bud. Respond immediately by saying sharply: "That was disrespectful."
  6. Use a special tone of voice in response to disrespect that communicates to your child, "You're in dangerous territory — back off immediately."
  7. Use time-outs for non-cooperation when the child will not stop the disrespectful behavior. After pointing out the disrespectful behavior in a firm voice, if your child continues, give a warning that a time-out will be enforced if they don't stop. If that doesn't work, enforce the time-out. Don't allow a nasty conversation to continue. With a teen, you may want to walk away from the conversation rather than try to enforce a time-out against physical opposition. The key is to pronounce the behavior as disrespectful and end the conversation rather than letting it escalate.
  8. Be firm but keep your cool. Confident parenting is almost always calm, clear, focused, and assertive in times of conflict.
  9. Combine zero tolerance with a long-term view. Challenge every disrespectful behavior–without exception — because that's the only way your child will understand your expectations and the meaning of the behavior you want to extinguish. Don't expect an immediate cessation of rudeness, but a steady decrease towards zero.
  10. If the problem is chronic and these strategies don't work, consider seeking family therapy to focus on your parenting skills. If you and your spouse or co-parent can't agree on a parenting style, consider getting professional help.


We also live in the era of therapeutic parenting.  The parent becomes a junior therapist, and the child is seen as requiring special treatment that only a professional — or a trained parent — can provide.  Starting back in the 1970s with Parent Effectiveness Training, a then popular book by Thomas Gordon, parents have been taught to act like therapists with their children.

A therapist is supposed to be consistently attentive, low key, accepting, non-directive, and non-judgmental.  When the child acts up in a therapy session, say, by speaking disrespectfully to the therapist, the therapist's job is to explore the underlying reasons rather than focus on the child's immediate behavior.  In addition to distorting parents' reactions to their children's misconduct, the therapeutic culture of parenting suggests that children's psyches are fragile, easily broken by a parent who says the wrong thing.
The reality, according to loads of research, is that, if underlying parental care and attachment are present, most children are resilient in the face of ordinary mistakes in parenting.  If children can handle most of our non-abusive mistakes, they can certainly handle our strong responses to them when these responses are fully called for.  Children mostly know when they are off base, and feel safer when their parents step in assertively.
We know from research and observation that parents have a strong influence on their teenagers' behavior.  Teenagers whose parents talk to them regularly about avoiding drugs are much less likely to use drugs.  Teenagers whose parents give them both nurturing and firm limits are less likely to be involved in sexual activity.  They are also more likely to study hard.


How to Teach Teens Respect


We can restore parents' confidence in their authority without returning to authoritarian parenting.  There is a middle way between being dictatorial and insensitive on the one hand, and cajoling and debating with children on the other hand. 

A personal example: When my son Eric was 13, we had a brief but memorable encounter in the kitchen.  I was on the telephone with a friend in the early evening.  Unbeknownst to me, Eric wanted to make a phone call to one of his friends.  When I hung up the phone, Eric said to me, in an irritated, peremptory tone of voice, "Who was that?"
How do you think I should have responded?  Consider several possible responses I could have made, and then I'll tell you what I actually said.

Response 1:   (delivered in a mildly defensive tone): "I was on the phone with Mac.  I didn't know you wanted to use the phone."

The problem with this response is that it accepts the child's right to grill the parent about adult activities.  The key is not the question itself, but the disrespectful demand. 

Response 2:   (delivered with a mild reprimand): "I didn't know you were waiting to use the phone.  You should let me know.  How am I supposed to know?"
This might be an appropriate response to a spouse or another adult peer who has equal rights to the telephone and is therefore free to express annoyance if you are clogging its use.  Said to Eric, however, it would have accepted his implied claim of peer status, like a sibling he competes with for use of the shower or TV.

Response 3:   (delivered with a stern reprimand): "Who do you want to call anyway?  You are on the phone far too much.  You should be doing your homework."

This counterattack appears strong but misses the main point: The problem of the moment is not Eric's phone use but his disrespectful question.  To simply assert parental authority over his phone use would make him resentful and would not teach him about this disrespectful action or forestall his next.

I've made my share of mistakes as a parent, but somewhere I learned to have an instant awareness when one of my children is talking disrespectfully to me — and to make that the point of my response.  So here's what I said, making eye contact and speaking firmly:
You don't get to ask me that question, and particularly in that tone of voice.
The discussion was over.  Eric absorbed my comment and then went to the other room to make his phone call.  I did not name the person I was on the phone with.  I did not defend myself.  I did not counterattack.  I did not make Eric defend his question.  I did not punish him.
 
What I did was to directly defend and assert my right to respect as a parent.  And I did not feel angry at him during the rest of the evening.  During the subsequent years ahead we had the normal parent-adolescent hassles, but he never spoke disrespectfully to me again.
If I had taken a different path that evening, one that would lead to similar encounters in the future, my son's adolescence and our family life might have been much different.


Teaching Respect to Young Children


Four-year-old Jason developed the annoying habit of demanding his food.  At dinner, he would shout, "Pour me milk!" or "Give me more French fries!"

It's not as if Jason had an impulse control disorder.  He was a model of appropriate behavior in preschool where the standards for politeness were clear and consistently enforced.
How did Jason's parents respond to his demanding behavior?  Often they tried to shut him up by immediately fetching what he demanded.  Other times they got irritated with him and told him to ask nicely — but they still fetched his food without making him ask politely.  Psychologists describe this as reinforcing the child's behavior.

Parents whose children treat them disrespectfully will eventually start to fear and resent their children.  Parents will start withdrawing emotionally, or become punitive.  They will have explosions of anger they feel bad about later.  Or they will become sarcastic and passive-aggressive.

How did Jason's parents turn around his behavior at meals?  They firmly challenged him every time he asked for something rudely and waited for him to politely restate his request before giving him the item.  If he refused to ask politely, they withheld the food item and went about finishing the meal.  Jason eventually learned the meaning of "polite," and the incidence of demanding behavior at the table declined drastically.


Why Anger-Free Parenting Doesn't Work


To many parents, anger is one short step away from verbal and physical abuse of children.  But anger is a normal human emotion that signals "something's got to change here — right now." Without anger, parents are wishy-washy in the face of their children's willfulness.  Fear of showing anger to our children is at the heart of the impotence problem among many contemporary parents.

Recently I observed the following scenario: A boy (about 4) and his mother were walking on the beach.  The boy ran ahead.  He went under a fence and into a flower garden that was about 6 feet from a 30-foot drop to the railroad tracks below.

As she approached her son, I heard the mother say to him in a very mild tone, "Sweetie, I don't think it's a good idea for you to be back there."

The boy stood and waited for her to arrive.  Leaning over the fence, she put out her arm and said:
Jeffrey, come.  Please get out of there.  Those are flowers you are standing in, and you are too near the tracks.
Motionless and defiant, the boy just looked at her.  "Here, take my hand," she pleaded.  Still no movement.  It was clear that the child was enjoying this moment of stubborn victory.
As my wife and I continued our walk, I looked back for a while to see if there was any progress.  The mother was leaning as far as she could over the fence and begging her son to take her hand, while he stared at her.

Scenes such as this one point out the danger of anger-free parenting.  Trying to remain cool and rational in a situation of defiance and danger makes parents look foolish.


Problematic Advice From the "Experts"


No parenting expert would have supported the mother's pitiful pleading approach to this problem, but how would experts suggest she respond?

Thomas Gordon's Parent Effectiveness Training would tell the mother to calmly deliver an "I message" such as, "I get very scared when I see you standing there because it's dangerous."

The assumption is that your child will spontaneously decide to cooperate if you express your true feelings.
But what if your child, like the boy behind the fence, is enjoying seeing you afraid in demonstrating your lack of control over him?  Sharing your vulnerable feelings is not going to get the job done in that case.


The Consequences Approach


Another major school of parenting advice from the 1970s (written about extensively by Haim Ginott) would recommend a "consequences" approach.  You would give your son a choice: If he continues to stand there, he is choosing to accept a negative consequence you have promised.  You could tell him that there will be no more walks this week unless he cooperates.
Children mostly know when they are off base, and feel safer when their parents step in assertively.
Laying out consequences and waiting for the child to make a choice is a normal technique for effective parenting.  When your teenager won't do the dishes in a timely fashion, it's generally better to connect the chore with a consequence — say, no watching TV or talking on the phone that evening — and let the child choose to cooperate.  Continued non-cooperation means escalating consequences, until almost all kids will decide it's less hassle to do the dishes.

A limitation of the consequences approach to discipline, however, is that it is not powerful and immediate enough for some situations.  The defiant little boy in the flower bed required a stronger response than the mother laying out the consequences for his continuing to stand there.  In moments of willful confrontation, some children don't care about future consequences — they want things their way right now, thank you.  In these situations, discussing future consequences rather than rising to the occasion comes across as weak.

What most of the rational, anger-free parenting advice misses is the importance of occasional angry power assertions by a parent.  I say "occasional" because research has clearly pointed out that rigid, authoritarian parenting ("I'm the boss; be quiet and do what you're told") that doesn't explain the reasons for a directive or allow kids to express a point of view, is counter-productive because it tends to breed anxiety and rebellion.


Appropriate Power Assertion


What do I mean by appropriately angry power assertion?  In the case of the mother and her defiant boy, I would call him by name and say in a strong, loud voice:
"Jeffrey, get out of there right now!"
I would be moving towards him as I said these words.
If he did not immediately move back towards the fence, I would shout
"Come here!" as I arrived at the fence.
If he did not instantly move towards me, I would climb the fence and retrieve him physically.  Then I would get down face to face with him, and say:
I am FURIOUS with you.  First, you went under a fence and into the flowers — and you know better.  Second, you were near the railroad tracks — and you know better.  And third, you did not come back when I told you to.  You are in big trouble with me.
I would take him home, with no further discussion.
Later in the day, I would talk calmly with him about what happened on that walk, and what level of cooperation I wanted on walks in the future.  I would expect him to agree to cooperate better in the future.
The new parenting problem is "anger phobia."

There are psychological levels deeper than what I have described, levels that could be explored after the original power assertion is successful.  Perhaps the child's behavior, if it's unusual for him, reflects the stress of a recent family move.  Perhaps he is angry at his mother about something.  Perhaps he is testing his newly found 4-year-old independence.  On the other hand, if the behavior is chronic, then it also suggests a misalignment of authority between parent and child.

But whatever the deeper meaning of the boy's risky, defiant behavior, the parent must deal with the immediate situation.  If a child is stealing because of a troubled childhood, we must first stop the stealing; then we can talk about the underlying problem.

The new parenting problem is "anger phobia."  We end up with bland parents who refuse to ever show anger to their children.  They consequently lack authority and allow their children to walk over them.  In my experience as a therapist, however, I have found that such parents can take back their kids if they have a mind to.

Parenting Resources

20 Gifts of Life: Bringing Out the Best in Our Kids, Grandkids & Others We Care About by Hal Urban The Biggest Job We'll Ever Have: Character-Based Education & Parenting by Laura and Malcolm Gauld Boys Should Be Boys: 7 Secrets to Raising Healthy Sons by Meg Meeker, M.D. Character Building: A Guide for Parents & Teachers by David Isaacs Character Matters by Thomas Lickona Compass: A Handbook on Parent Leadership by James Stenson The Difficult Child by Stanley Turecki & Leslie Tonner Endangered: Your Child in a Hostile World by Johann Christoph Arnold The Family Virtues Guide by Linda K. Popov Help Me Be Good (series) by Joy Berry How to Talk So Kids Will Listen and Listen So Kids Will Talk by Adele Faber & Elaine Mazlish The Intentional Family by William Doherty MegaSkills: Building Our Children's Character and Achievement for School and Life by Dorothy Rich Negotiation Generation: Take Back Your Parental Authority Without Punishment by Lynne Reeves Griffin No More Misbehavin': 38 Difficult Behaviors and How to Stop Them by Michele Borba Parenting for Character: Equipping Your Child for Life by Andrew Mullins Parenting for Character: Five Experts, Five Practices David Streight, Editor Parenting for Good by Marvin Berkowitz Parents, Kid, & Character by Helen LeGette The Parents We Mean to Be by Richard Weissbourd Raising Good Children by Thomas Lickona Raising Respectful Children in a Disrespectful World by Jill Rigby Sex, Love, & You (for teens) by Tom & Judy Lickona and William Boudreau, M.D. Strong Fathers, Strong Daughters by Meg Meeker, M.D. You're Teaching My Child What? A Physician Exposes the Lies of Sex Ed and How They Harm Your Child by Miriam Grossman, M.D. The 6 Most Important Decisions You'll Ever Make (for teens) by Sean Covey The 7 Habits of Highly Effective Families by Stephen Covey
 

quinta-feira, 9 de maio de 2013

Melhor investimento - Emprego mais bem remunerado - por Nuno Serras Pereira



09. 05. 2013

Bem sei, bem sei; nunca estudei economia nem finanças. Nem tenho formação académica em filosofia política, nem em sociologia; nem, além disso, tenho qualquer tipo de licenciatura. Mais não sou do que um tosco remendo na nas vestes da gloriosa Ordem franciscana. E, no entanto, ninguém me despersuade de que o melhor e mais urgente investimento, por parte de uma nação e de um estado como nosso, é na renovação das gerações, no crescimento da natalidade; apesar de todos os dias ouvir e ler opiniões dos mais graúdos economistas e fiscalistas que, na sua generalidade, ignoram petulantemente este “factor”.

Na suposição de que aquilo que afirmo é verdade, então daí derivará, como consequência inevitável, de que o trabalho, a profissão – que neste caso coincide com a vocação -, mais bem paga deverá ser, sem margens para dúvida, a da paternidade/maternidade (expressões como “parentalidade”, para além de não serem bom português, são ideologicamente venenosas), principalmente no matrimónio – isto é, no casamento natural -, onde os filhos são gerados, nutridos, educados e socializados. O casamento natural, e a família que dele resulta, é a sementeira e o útero, das sociedades sãs, das nações com futuro, da convivência amistosa, da justiça misericordiosa.

Se o estado obtuso se tem, cretinamente, nas últimas décadas, como a diluviana evidência o tem demonstrado à saciedade, empenhado com todas as veras na limitação dos nascimentos e na destruição da família; e se monetariamente em tudo corta menos nessa persecução suicida, então a única salvação, por mais abstrusa que se afigure aos católicos deformados e aos descrentes, será confiar na Providência Divina e acolher os filhos, sem manhas contraceptivas, que Deus quiser, obrigando, desse modo, à mudança de mentalidades e de comportamentos dos actuais ídolos eclesiásticos, dos poderes partidários, governamentais e estatais. 

Parece uma temeridade. Não é. Não queiramos fazer a figura da mãezinha que preocupada com a ida do filho para a força aérea, lhe recomendava instantemente: filhinho voa baixinho e devagarinho…

segunda-feira, 8 de abril de 2013

If Knot Now, When? The Impact of Delayed Marriage Among Twenty-somethings - by Meg McDonnell

In The Public Discourse

Michelle was 22 when she found herself pregnant. She was in a committed relationship with all signs pointing to marriage, she says, but since she had just completed college, with ambitious career plans for her future, children weren’t on the horizon yet.

“Although I did want a baby with my now-husband (even at the young age of 22), I was devastated because I felt like my life was ruined,” she writes in a blog post. “Everything I wanted to accomplish—everything I wanted to be—was now gone. And I didn’t get this from my own head—I got it from friends, family, TV, movies, and complete strangers.”

Most young adults are putting off starting a family in their twenties, she notes, and the cultural expectations surrounding delayed marriage aided in the initial devastation that surrounded Michelle’s pregnancy.

“My body felt ready, but my brain didn’t,” she elaborates. And though she went on to marry the father of her child and raise their now four-year-old son, her decision was not made without a lot of anxiety and despair.

"I do wish that someone would have told me that my life wouldn’t be ruined. That I could go on to have a successful career, a happy marriage, and a fulfilling life,” she lamented. “I wish someone had told me that choosing earlier-than-expected pregnancy isn’t a tragedy, but just a different lifestyle decision. I wish someone would have told me that a 22-year-old mother can be the best kind of mother.”

Michelle’s story of her unplanned and unmarried twenty-something pregnancy is not that uncommon, though her success in achieving a happy balance between marriage, family, and career may be.

A new report, co-authored by Kay Hymowitz, Jason Carroll, W. Bradford Wilcox, and Kelleen Kaye, and co-sponsored by the National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy, The Relate Institute, and the National Marriage Project, shows us the new face of unmarried motherhood: twenty-something women.

According to the report, titled “Knot Yet: The Benefits and Costs of Delayed Marriage in America,” unmarried twenty-something mothers are more common than teen mothers. “By age 25, 44 percent of women have had a baby, while only 38 percent have married,” the report details. “By the time they turn 30, about two-thirds of American women have had a baby, typically out of wedlock. Overall, 48 percent of first births are to unmarried women, most of them in their twenties.”

Among women with college degrees, 12 percent of first births are to unmarried women. However, for those with less than college degrees, the percentages are much higher.
Among those women with high school degrees and perhaps some college education, 58 percent of first births are to unmarried women. Among high school dropouts, 83 percent of firstborn children are born to unmarried women. For these women, an economic recession and a struggling job market have already hindered upward mobility, but out-of-wedlock childrearing only further reduces chances of prosperity and flourishing.

But much like Michelle, many of these young adults are torn by the tension of their desire to have a child with the seemingly bad timing or situation of their pregnancy. In fact, according to the Knot Yet report, “roughly half of unmarried young adults . . . said they would like to have a baby now if things were different (53 percent of men and 47 percent of women), and even among those who said it was important to avoid pregnancy right now, over a third went on to say they would be happy if they got pregnant.”

“Not surprisingly,” the report continues, “this ambivalence rises as education levels, marriage prospects, and job opportunities fall.”

The Harms of Delayed Marriage for Children

In an age of ever-changing beliefs and public acceptance of different family structures, many may not consider twenty-something unmarried parenting to be that bad. Yet sociological data indicate, the report notes, that children born to a single parent or cohabiting couples on average suffer emotionally, academically, and financially in comparison to their peers in homes where the mother and father are married to each other.

A footnote in the Knot Yet report points to research by Adam Thomas and Isabel Sawhill that suggests “that recent increases in single parenthood have played an important role in driving up child poverty in the United States.”

A recent federal study, as explained by Knot Yet co-author Brad Wilcox, shows that children living with their mother and her boyfriend, as opposed to their married biological mother and father, are eleven times more likely to experience sexual, physical, or emotional abuse, and six times more likely to experience physical, emotional, and educational neglect.

Children living with their biological parents who are cohabiting but not married experience all the same struggles, only to a slightly lesser degree, when compared to their peers living with their married mother and father. Children being raised by their unmarried but cohabiting parents are four times more likely to be sexually, physically, or emotionally abused, and three times more likely to be physically, emotionally, or educationally neglected than their peers living with their married biological parents.

“The science tells us,” Wilcox explains, “that children are not only more likely to thrive but are also more likely to simply survive when they are raised in an intact home headed by their married parents, rather than in a home headed by a cohabiting couple.”

These young unmarried mothers and fathers are struggling, too. Parents between the ages of 24 and 29 who are not married are more likely to report struggles with depression and drunkenness, as well as lower levels of life satisfaction than their peers who are married parents, according to data surveyed in the Knot Yet report.

For those currently aged 18-29, being a good parent is important, more important than having a successful marriage. According to Pew Social Trends, 52 percent of today’s 18-29-year-olds say being a good parent is “one of the most important things in their life,” whereas only 30 percent say having a successful marriage is one of the most important things.

Marriage remains a life goal for most young adults, as Hymowitz, Carroll, Wilcox, and Kaye point out, with about 80 percent of all young adults reporting that marriage is an important part of their life plans. Marriage also continues to bring emotional and financial benefits for adults and children alike. So, why are young adults delaying marriage but not parenthood?

A host of reasons contribute, including economic factors related to the recession. But the report suggests that many young adults are unintentionally putting the “baby carriage in front of marriage” due to today’s relationship culture, which “offers virtually no signposts for young adults seeking to navigate romance, sex, and relationships in ways that will be fruitful for their current lives and their future families.”

Still, they conclude that “we can and should bring marriage and childbearing back into sync,” for the sake of today’s twenty-somethings and their children. They admit this will be difficult; “there are no panaceas for strengthening family formation among contemporary young adults.” But many young adults and their children are struggling in the current relationship culture, and as a result, America is seeing a demographic shift in family formation that is not promising emotional, physical, or fiscal flourishing for most of the individuals involved.

The National Campaign’s Wrong Approach to Sex

The National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy is in a prime position to partner in efforts to relink marriage and children. With reported success in helping to lower the national teen-pregnancy rate, the National Campaign has the ears of government leaders and significant amounts of money (from both donors and the government); they consult for various television programs and movies; and they have an extensive staff of researchers and talented social activists.

They’ve already started working to curb twenty-something unplanned pregnancy. But a review of their efforts, especially in conjunction with the Knot Yet report findings, indicates that their work may not be a sweeping success.

Their three-year multimedia public-service campaign, called Bedsider, is co-sponsored with the Ad Council. Its goal is to promote consistent and effective use of birth control among twenty-something women by way of making birth control use “sexy.”

With a mix of humor, sleek imaging, and practical data on the basics and logistics of artificial contraception, Bedsider is “an online support network for women ages 18-29” with one main focus—a sex life that is fun and baby-free.

Blog posts at Bedsider are too X-rated to sum up here, but some recent headline posts here, here, and here are samples enough to see that sex is depicted as essentially recreational, at least in the eyes of the National Campaign staff working on this project.

Bedsider’s tag line is “You didn’t give up on sex, don’t give up on birth control.” Its “About Us” section touts a woman’s right to “a happy, healthy sex life without worrying about an unplanned pregnancy.” And it offers members a “Booty Log” app that encourages anonymous sharing of one’s sexcapades in an online database.

Indeed, Bedsider has stuck to its goal of making birth control “sexy,” making the site almost all about sex and much less about properly aligning relationships with future goals for marriage and family.

The National Campaign didn’t set out to create a site promoting contraception, Bill Albert, its Chief Program Operator (who is given editorial acknowledgment in the Knot Yet report), told me in an interview about a year ago. Their research showed them, he said, that young adults were having sex frequently but were uninformed about contraception and didn’t trust it.

Their research, conducted by the Guttmacher Institute, also showed that nearly nine out of ten young adults between ages 18-29 have had sex, and 78 percent of these have had sex within the past year. The overwhelming majority of these unmarried young adults—94 percent of men and 86 percent of women—believe pregnancy should be planned. Despite the fact that 82 percent of these unmarried adults have used contraception at some point in their sexual activity, nearly one in five are currently not using any contraception.

The National Campaign’s data indicate that 30 percent of 18-29-year-olds say “they know little or nothing about condoms.” Sixty-three percent say “they know little or nothing about birth control pills.” And 56 percent say “they have not heard of the birth control implant.”

“Young people don’t know as much as they think they know [about contraception],” Albert told me. Citing yet another statistic from the National Campaign’s research, he pointed out that 40 percent of young adults agreed with the statement, “It doesn’t matter if you use birth control or not, when it’s your time to get pregnant, it will happen.” “[This] is simply an anti-science perspective,” Albert said, and one that the National Campaign is working to correct.

But notably missing from the conversation at Bedsider, and many other places in the culture, is a frequent reminder of the scientific fact that sex makes babies. Instead our culture, and Bedsider as well, would have us believe that “unprotected sex makes babies.”

Yet since the 1960s, when contraception became legal and more available, the percentage of nonmarital births has risen from 5 percent in 1960 to 41 percent in 2010. Further, researchers have noted that the presence of contraception has led to more “risk compensation,” the concept that the more “protected” one feels, the more risks one will take.

Indeed, Guttmacher Institute data shows that 48 percent of women facing unintended pregnancies were using contraception during the month they got pregnant. Perhaps this is due to human error or perhaps method failure, but the point remains—a pregnancy can occur, even when a woman thinks she is “protected.” And it would be good to reinforce this point with young adults as they choose partners and consider engaging in sex.

One searches Bedsider in vain for any encouragement that getting married and having children in your twenties is not only okay, but also biologically appropriate and potentially immensely fulfilling.

Their own data in Knot Yet tells them that adults and children do better when a mother and father are married as they welcome and raise children. So, the recommendation for women to “Knock Yourself Up” (the title of the book linked in a Bedsider post) raises an eyebrow. There are always exceptions to the welfare of children raised in single-parent versus married-parent homes, of course; but they are exceptions, not data-backed suggestions for a new normal.
Moreover, their suggestion to “shack up without the formality of a marriage certificate” fails to acknowledge that unintended births to cohabitating couples have risen from 14 percent of all births in 2002 to 23 percent of all births in 2010, according to the CDC.

Twenty-somethings are having sex and searching for meaning and purpose in their adult life, including in parenthood—even if they’re not married. Becoming a parent, especially a mom, often gives poor and disadvantaged young adults a sense of purpose and meaning in their often chaotic lives, according to sociologists Kathryn Edin and Maria Kefalas, authors of the book Promises I Can Keep: Why Poor Women Put Motherhood Before Marriage.

“[U]nderlying unintended pregnancy is a great deal of ambivalence—competing desires to have everything in place first versus having a baby now,” the Knot Yet report explains.
Young adults often choose to engage in sex because it feels right at the time, and they often want children; they just aren’t sure when. But many discover that unintended childbearing makes achieving their goals of a stable marriage, family, and work balance harder to obtain. And this is where those clear “signposts” for relationships are incredibly important.

The National Campaign Should Expand Its Mission

I asked Albert why they didn’t use an effort like Bedsider to try to curb unplanned pregnancy by way of encouraging young adults to enter marriage and family life sooner. He responded that the idea of marriage is “beyond mission for us.” The National Campaign’s mission is to curb “teen and unplanned pregnancy,” and “we’re not the National Campaign to promote marriage,” he said.

He admitted that the outcomes for children are frequently considered at the National Campaign, and marriage is discussed too, but promoting marriage is simply “beyond mission.”

But now that the National Campaign knows some of the causes and costs of “unplanned” pregnancy, as well as young adult desires to marry and have children, why couldn’t helping them achieve these important life goals at least play a part in their mission to curb “unplanned” twenty-something pregnancy?

Recent Bedsider content doesn’t indicate that their mission will expand. Yet one can almost be certain that young parents like Michelle, and the other 80 percent of twenty-somethings who express a desire to get married, would find a breath of fresh air in content that approaches “unplanned” pregnancy with a case for young marriage and family life.