Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Discriminação. Mostrar todas as mensagens
Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Discriminação. Mostrar todas as mensagens

quarta-feira, 6 de fevereiro de 2013

U. K: - “Alteração de definição de casamento coloca católicos sob pressão”

In RR 

A Câmara dos Comuns aprovou ontem, por maioria, o chamado casamento entre homossexuais. Um bispo católico diz que os efeitos para católicos poderão ser graves.

O bispo de Portsmouth, Inglaterra, disse ontem que a aprovação do “casamento” entre homossexuais coloca os católicos sob uma pressão moral intolerável.

Phillip Egan disse aos jornalistas que católicos que trabalham no registo civil, por exemplo, poderão ser obrigados a escolher entre as suas consciências e a profissão.

Egan tece comparações com o efeito da lei que permitiu a adopção por homossexuais e que levou ao encerramento de todas as agências de adopção católica, uma vez que o Governo e os tribunais não admitiram uma excepção para organizações religiosas.

“Tal como a Igreja teve de abandonar os seus serviços de adopção, também alguns católicos que trabalham na área da saúde e serviços sociais poderão encontrar-se sob pressões morais intoleráveis. Pressões que se poderão fazer sentir também nas escolas católicas, por professores, funcionários e pais”.

No Reino Unido, como em Portugal, os casamentos na Igreja Católica também servem para efeitos civis. Mas com esta alteração isso pode mudar, sugere o bispo: “Torna-se claro que a visão católica do matrimónio será, no futuro, marcadamente diferente daquilo a que a sociedade chamará casamento. Uma consequência possível disto é que a Igreja seja forçada a retirar-se do registo civil de casamentos”.

Mas o bispo também fez algumas críticas internas. Segundo ele a culpa da redefinição da definição de casamento também deve ser partilhada pela Igreja que desde os anos 60 não soube “explicar de forma atractiva” a visão cristã desta instituição.

A lei que legaliza o “casamento” entre homossexuais foi aprovada na Câmara de Comuns por maioria. Contudo, o Partido Conservador, cujo líder e primeiro-ministro David Cameron apoiou fortemente a medida, ficou claramente dividido, com uma maioria dos seus representantes a votar contra a proposta. A lei foi aprovada com o apoio dos Liberais Democratas e do Partido Trabalhista, com algumas excepções.

Antes de se tornar lei do país a medida deve agora ser aprovada pela Câmara dos Lordes antes de entrar em vigor.

As preocupações da Igreja Católica são sentidas também, mas em maior grau, pela Igreja de Inglaterra. Os bispos anglicanos opuseram-se à proposta e não se deixam convencer pelas garantias do Governo de que nenhuma confissão possa ser obrigada a realizar “casamentos” entre homossexuais. Os bispos alertam para a possibilidade de recurso ao Tribunal Europeu dos Direitos do Homem, que poderá entender que tal garantia é discriminatória, sobretudo tendo em conta que a Igreja Anglicana é a confissão oficial do Estado.



domingo, 21 de outubro de 2012

When Cultural Radicals speak of “diversity,” they mean no such thing - by Msgr. Charles Pope

In AoW

You may have read in the news that a faculty member of the Gallaudet University in Washington DC has been placed on “administrative leave,” due to the fact that she signed a petition requesting referendum on the issue of gay marriage in Maryland.
 
Angela McCaskill is “Chief Diversity Officer” at Gallaudet University in Washington DC. She was at church one Sunday, and requested to sign the petition that would permit the voters of Maryland to vote on the issue of gay “marriage.” She signed the petition and says she did so because she favors democracy and allowing citizens to vote on such controversial issues, as opposed to having legislatures and courts force so-called “gay marriage” on the populace. (More HERE)

But the administrators at Gallaudet University consider her signing of the petition to be unacceptable. Apparently, as “Chief Diversity Officer,” they don’t consider her kind of diversity the right kind of diversity.
To be sure, it is refreshing and surprising to hear that a “diversity officer” would have signed a petition opposing Gay “marriage” and insist that gay marriage be brought to a vote, instead of merely being imposed. As most social conservatives know, and have experienced, the usual “diversity office” at a campus is anything but diverse in its views. And, that a diversity officer might actually understand that there more than one side to the issue of Gay “marriage” surprises not only social conservatives, but also (apparently) social leftists. In effect, the leadership at Gallaudet University sees Ms. McCaskill’s actions as incompatible with their notion of diversity, and are saying, in effect, “How could you!”

But merely expressing surprise is not usually enough for radicals on the left. Thus, they have placed her on “administrative leave.” Never mind all the usual calls for tolerance from the radicals, never mind the “free exchange of ideas” that they so often extol on college campuses. Never mind all that, according to them, Ms. McCaskill has to go.

The reaction well demonstrates that when leftist cultural radicals speak of “diversity,” they don’t mean it in any fair minded or straight forward definition of the word.

The word diversity comes from the Latin word diversus: di (two) + versa (turns or sides). Thus, the true meaning of the word “diversity” means “two sides.” Or by extension, “more than one side,” “more than one viewpoint” or just “different.”

But the cultural radicals mean no such thing. In their lexicon “diversity” means you have to accept anything they propose. But it does not that they should accept you, or that they should even consider the fact that you might be troubled that they propose anything, no matter how deviant the behavior has historically been seen to be. In their lexicon, being “open-minded” means that you agree with them. “Tolerance” is your obligation to agree with them, but not their obligation to accept you, or your deeply held Christian beliefs, no matter how ancient or how well attested.

And, in their form of diversity, tolerance and open-mindedness, if they can punish your non-compliance or even just your non-placet, they will do so with a sense of righteousness, and they will do so firmly and swiftly.

The central point is, when cultural radicals use these terms, they mean no such thing.

To be sure, I am not hereby articulating a position that diversity is an absolute quality or virtue. There are certain diversities to be celebrated and/or tolerate. But there are certain behaviors, which ought not be tolerated, illicit sexual union and Gay “marriage” among them.

The intent in this post is merely call the cultural radicals on their bluff. When they talk about diversity, they don’t really mean it. When they try to parade around in clothes of openness, tolerance, and diversity, they are misrepresenting themselves. When they celebrate “diversity” they don’t mean you, especially if you are a traditional Christian. Their ‘diversity” doesn’t include the Scriptures or the ancient Judeo-Christian tradition, or Natural Law. And don’t even think about mentioning the Catholic Church to them, you’re certain to be shown the door out of their “diverse” world.

To them these things are not something to celebrate or tolerate. They are something to abhor, to legally block, and for some of them, even something to destroy.

Just remember, when they speak of diversity they don’t mean it. And if they mean it all, it is only for them and their favored groups. But they certainly don’t mean it for you, especially if you are a traditional, Bible believing Christian. No, you are not part of the rainbow, you are not part of their tapestry, or their mosaic. You have no place at their table, no place in their celebration.

The views of diversity officer Angela McCaskill regarding (so called) “gay marriage,” are not clear. But one thing is clear, she has (wittingly or unwittingly) called the bluff of the diversity motif of the cultural radicals, and has incurred special wrath because she has done so.

To them she is “off message.” She actually took the word diversity to me what it says. How wrong was that! And now she is cast out of the “hallowed halls” the radicals think they own. She is proof that when cultural radicals speak of diversity they don’t mean you, they only mean themselves.

Disclaimer: I have chosen the words “cultural radicals” carefully. I am willing to admit that there are many who oppose the Church’s teaching on Biblical marriage who are far less radical, who are of good will, and may also be shocked at what happened to Angela McCaskill. There are some who are willing to allow the cultural debates of our time to be conducted in an open and honest way, and accept that varying groups, including Christians, have the rights of any citizens to engage in the political process, and to seek to influence the discussions in the on-going cultural shifts of the West.

But the radicals have no such room in their world for opposition or even discussion, and they want to silence any questioning of their agenda. They are growing in number, especially in university and government settings, and it is to them that I address the concerns of this blog.

quarta-feira, 26 de setembro de 2012

Christian leaders praise Romney, Republican platform

.- A diverse group of 28 Christian leaders has sent a letter to GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney praising him for the social policies included in the Republican Party's 2012 platform.

“On those matters of social policy that address our deepest concerns—the sanctity of human life, compassion for the downtrodden and persecuted, the identity of the family, and religious freedom, the Republican platform speaks clearly and powerfully,” the letter says.

The group also says the platform demonstrates the principles that will guide his administration if Romney is elected president.

The letter includes selections of the platform which its signatories particularly admire.

The Republican Party's “compassion for the downtrodden and persecuted” is exemplified in the letter by its allegiance to ending religious persecution overseas, to ending human trafficking, and a commitment to non-discrimination.
The letter applauds the defense of conscience and religious freedom in the platform, as well as the definition of marriage as the union of one man and one woman.

The letter also focuses on the moral principles in the Republican platform, which are “squarely within the Judeo-Christian tradition” and are “at stake in today's society.”
Romney and his running mate, Paul Ryan, are thanked for running on a platform which is a “political compass” in the “confusing moral thickets of our day.”

The signers encourage support for Romney even though there may be “differences in a candidate's theological doctrine.” This is despite the fact that “some have tempered their enthusiasm” for the Mormon candidate. Government policy is the issue, the letter says, not theology.

The letter is signed by 28 Christian leaders, both Catholic and Protestant, and includes the organizations to which each of the individuals belongs.

The Catholic signatories include Leonard Leo of The Catholic Association; Raymond Flynn, US Ambassador to the Vatican under President Clinton; Father Frank Pavone of Priests for Life; and Deal Hudson of The Catholic Advocate.

They are joined by Anthony Lauinger of National Right to Life; Peggy Hartshorn of Heartbeat International; Jim Daly of Focus on the Family; and Tony Perkins of Family Research Council.

Also signing were Frank Wright of National Religious Broadcasters and Alveda King, niece of Martin Luther King, Jr. and director of African American Outreach for Priests for Life.

The full text of the letter is as follows.

Mitt Romney
Romney for President
585 Commercial Street
Boston, MA 02109


Dear Governor Romney,

In this election year, matters of religious belief are once again highly visible in the public square. Some have tempered their enthusiasm for sound governing principles by their concern over differences in a candidate’s theological doctrine. It is time to remind ourselves that civil government is not about a particular theology but rather about public policy, and the question we ask is this one: what are the policy principles that will govern your administration should you prevail on Election Day.

For that answer we must look to the Republican platform, the document that most clearly defines your principles, and those of your party, on a wide range of topics. Among them are those that derive from Biblical truth, an important source of our nation’s political philosophy. As you know, this year the platform proposals received hearty debate and intense scrutiny by Republican delegates from every state just prior to the party convention in Tampa. The platform was adopted resoundingly and embraced wholeheartedly by you and your running mate Paul Ryan.

From our perspective as leaders who are motivated by Christian faith, it is a remarkably strong document and we congratulate you for it. On those matters of social policy that address our deepest concerns – the sanctity of human life, compassion for the downtrodden and persecuted, the identity of the family, and religious freedom, the Republican platform speaks clearly and powerfully. Its principles are squarely within the Judeo-Christian tradition, and we affirm the compelling words that convey its positions. Here are some of them:

Sanctity of Human Life

“Faithful to the 'self-evident' truths enshrined in the Declaration of Independence, we assert the sanctity of human life and affirm that the unborn child has a fundamental individual right to life which cannot be infringed. We support a human life amendment to the Constitution and endorse legislation to make clear that the Fourteenth Amendment’s protections apply to unborn children … (p. 14)”

“We also salute the many States that have passed laws for informed consent, mandatory waiting periods prior to an abortion, and health-protective clinic regulation. We seek to protect young girls from exploitation through a parental consent requirement; and we affirm our moral obligation to assist, rather than penalize, women challenged by an unplanned pregnancy (p.14).”

Defense of Marriage

“A serious threat to our country’s constitutional order … is an activist judiciary, in which some judges usurp the powers reserved to other branches of government. A blatant example has been the court-ordered redefinition of marriage in several States … It is an assault on the foundations of our society, challenging the institution which, for thousands of years in virtually every civilization, has been entrusted with the rearing of children and the transmission of cultural values.
“That is why Congressional Republicans took the lead in enacting the Defense of Marriage Act, affirming the right of States and the federal government not to recognize same-sex relationships licensed in other jurisdictions … We affirm our support for a Constitutional amendment defining marriage as the union of one man and one woman. We applaud the citizens of the majority of states which have enshrined in their constitutions the traditional concept of marriage, and we support the campaigns underway in several other States to do so. (p. 10).”


Religious Freedom

“The Republican Party includes Americans from every faith and tradition, and our policies and positions respect the right of every American to follow his or her beliefs and underscore our reverence for the religious freedom envisioned by the Founding Fathers of our nation and of our party. (p. 9).”
“We pledge to respect the religious beliefs and rights of conscience of all Americans and to safeguard the independence of their institutions from government … we assert every citizen’s right to apply religious values to public policy and the right of faith-based organizations to participate fully in public programs without renouncing their beliefs, removing religious symbols, or submitting to government-imposed hiring practices (p.12).”

Religious Persecution

“To those who stand in the darkness of tyranny, America has always been a beacon of hope, and so it must remain … Religious minorities across the Middle East are being driven from their ancient homelands, fanaticism leaves its bloody mark on both West and East Africa, and even among America’s Western friends and allies, pastors and families are penalized for their religious convictions. A Republican Administration will return the advocacy of religious liberty to a central place in our diplomacy (p. 45).”

Human Trafficking

As we approach the 150th anniversary of the Emancipation Proclamation, issued by the first Republican President Abraham Lincoln, we are reminded to be vigilant against human bondage in whatever form it appears. We will use the full force of the law against those who engage in modern-day forms of slavery, including the commercial sexual exploitation of children and the forced labor of men, women, and children (p.46).”

Non-discrimination

“... We consider discrimination based on sex, race, age, religion, creed, disability, or national origin unacceptable and immoral. We will strongly enforce anti-discrimination statutes and ask all to join us in rejecting the forces of hatred and bigotry and in denouncing all who practice or promote racism, anti-Semitism, ethnic prejudice, or religious intolerance (p.9).”

“The Republican Party includes Americans from every faith and tradition, and our policies and positions respect the right of every American to follow his or her beliefs and underscore our reverence for the religious freedom envisioned by the Founding Fathers of our nation and of our party. (p. 9).”

These then are some of the concepts in the Republican platform that speak to the moral principles at stake in today’s society. No such document will satisfy everyone, and its enactment will only be as vigorous as the political leaders we elect. Nonetheless, the platform is a strong statement of social principles, and we encourage everyone to judge it for themselves (it is available at http://whitehouse12.com/republican-party-platform/). In the confusing moral thickets of our day, this is a political compass that provides clear and sharp direction, a guide that is sorely needed by our country’s office holders. Once again we congratulate you and the Republican Party for your diligent work in producing the 2012 platform.


Cc: Reince Priebus, Chairman
 Republican National Committee

Signed by the following as individuals (affiliations listed for identification purposes only)
Raymond Ruddy
President, Gerard Health Foundation

Tom Minnery
Executive Director, Citizen Link

Margaret H. (“Peggy”) Hartshorn, Ph.D.
President, Heartbeat International

Jonathan Falwell
Thomas Road Baptist Church

Kristan Hawkins
President, Students for Life of America

Ralph Reed
President, Faith and Freedom Coalition

Leonard Leo
Director, The Catholic Association

Anthony Lauinger
Executive Vice President, National Right to Life

Joel Belz
Founder, World Magazine

Dr. Jack C. Willke, MD
President, Life Issue Institute

Joseph A. Brinck
President, Sanctity of Life Foundation

James Bopp, Jr.
The Bopp Law Firm

Raymond L. Flynn
Former Mayor of Boston and U.S. Ambassador to the Vatican

Andrea S. Lafferty
President, Traditional Values Coalition

Rev Louis P. Sheldon
Chairman and Founder, Traditional Values Coalition

Fr. Frank Pavone
National Director, Priests for Life
President, National Pro-life Religious Council

Dr. Alveda King
Director, African American Outreach Priests For Life

Tim Wildmon
President, American Family Association and American Family Radio

Penny Young Nance
President, Concerned Women for America

Jim Daly
President, Focus on the Family

Deal Hudson
The Catholic Advocate

Tony Perkins
President, Family Research Council

Franklin Graham
President, Samaritan’s Purse

Gary Bauer
President,
American Values

Allen & Leslee Unruh
Alpha Center & National Abstinence Clearinghouse

Jerry Falwell, Jr.
Chancellor and President, Liberty University

Rev. Samuel Rodriguez
President NHCLC Hispanic Evangelical Association

Frank Wright, Ph.D.
President and CEO, National Religious Broadcasters

segunda-feira, 27 de agosto de 2012

Veementíssimo Protesto! - por Nuno Serras Pereira


O P. Nuno Serras Pereira não pára de nos bombardear com os seus incessantes textos, integralmente reaccionários, fundamentalistas e retrógrados. Este sacerdote vive mentalmente no tempo das cavernas e cuida que prega para australopitecos. Não se entende como é que a Igreja o admitiu à Ordenação e a Ordem franciscana à Profissão Solene. Uma vez que não deixa de nos escandalizar e torturar com os seus escritos, que arrombam e irrompem desaforada e brutalmente pela caixa dos nossos correios electrónicos. É totalmente incompreensível que não lhe decepem as mãos (ou melhor, as patas, ainda mais rigorosamente, as garras) ou lhe destruam o computador ou lhe cortem a internet ou o dêem oficialmente como inimputável ou o ponham a fazer penitência nos frios congeladores do antárctico ou nos calores abrasadores do sará de modo a paralisar aquela língua viperina ou fazer com que ela se cole ao céu-da-boca.

Mas por que raio, desculpem-me a expressão mais própria do capitão Haddock, é que terei que suportar um artigo tão ignominioso como, por exemplo, o intitulado Nada te assuste… onde me dá por doente e enfermo? Já basta de discriminações e de incitamentos ao ódio. Esse mentecapto, pulha orientofóbico, ignorará por desventura que a OMS (Organização Mundial dos Salutares) já retirou esses termos do vocabulário existindo mesmo uma resolução de AOM (Acordo Otográfico Mundial) que exige a remoção dessas pseudopalavras de todos os Dicionários e a expurgação dos mesmos da Bíblia, de todas as obras literárias e demais escritos? Não estará ele ao facto de que hoje existe um consenso global de que aquilo a que antes chamavam doenças e enfermidades não passam de características, de variantes naturais da saúde, de orientações salutares diferentes? Pois se o não sabe tinha a estrita obrigação de estar informado antes de redigir enormidades monstruosas como essa. 

Ou será que ele quererá voltar à opressão e perseguição milenar que têm submetido às piores das torturas e às mais vis das prisões, somente comparáveis às infâmias da tenebrosa Inquisição, como são os esventramentos, mutilações, e demais crueldades a que chamavam eufemisticamente operações cirúrgicas; ou como são os calabouços, cárceres e ergástulos a que, numa engenharia verbal execrável e atroz, se denominavam hospitais, casas de saúde, centros de reabilitação!!!??

Os tempos horrendos e detestáveis que o P. Serras Pereira, obviamente, procura ressuscitar devem ser banidos definitivamente da memória colectiva se é que queremos novos tempos de paz e de harmonia. E o facto de ele, P. Nuno Serras Pereira, querer fazer de mim, P. Nuno Serras Pereira, um doente e um enfermo, em vez de alguém que vive uma variante da saúde, uma orientação saudável diferente só revela o seu incitamento ao ódio, a sua promoção da discriminação e a tentativa malvada, nefanda e desalmada de conservar e aumentar o resto de caturras empedernidos, caguinchas supersticiosos e recalcitrantes testudos.

Pelo que deixo escrito facilmente se compreenderá que caso as autoridades eclesiásticas competentes não puserem cobro imediato a este tremendo e colossal abuso ao meu bom nome, a esta calúnia velhaca; caso não procurem reparar a ofensa abominável à minha reputação, à minha honra!, e às demais vítimas deste crime de ódio, não me restará outra alternativa senão a de recorrer aos tribunais civis.

Enfim, não me esquecendo que sou Sacerdote franciscano, peço a todos com abundantes lágrimas e grandes suspiros que rezem pela conversão desse obstinado e perverso pecador o P. Nuno Serras Pereira.


27. 08. 2012

quinta-feira, 2 de fevereiro de 2012

The Same-Sex “Marriage” Proposal is Unjust Discrimination - by Patrick Lee


The conjugal conception of marriage is just and coherent; the same-sex marriage proponents’ conception of marriage is unjust and incoherent.

The “marriage equality movement”: that’s the name chosen for themselves by same-sex “marriage” supporters. The implicit argument is that the state’s granting marriage licenses only to opposite-sex couples is undue discrimination. The claim has an initial plausibility: the state grants a marriage license to John and Mary but not to Jim and Steve. Isn’t that unequal treatment? But this charge, I will show, rests on a profound confusion about both marriage and equality. A state’s recognition that marriage is only between a man and a woman is not unjust. What’s more, a state’s endorsement of same-sex “marriage” does create an arbitrary and invidious discrimination.

A law is unjust only if the distinction it creates is not essentially related to a legitimate purpose of law. But whatever one holds about the morality of homosexual acts, it is clear that the state does have an interest in promoting and regulating marriage as traditionally defined, and that the sexual relationships of same-sex couples are distinct in kind from that. So, even if—contrary to fact—the state did have an interest in promoting same-sex sexual relationships, that interest would be different from the one served by promoting marriage. And so the two types of relationships or arrangements should not be lumped together. Moreover, falsely to equate the two is to obscure the nature of marriage.

What is marriage? The traditional view of marriage is: the union of a man and a woman, who have consented to share their lives, on the bodily (sexual), emotional, and spiritual levels, in the kind of community that would be fulfilled by having and raising children together.

Two points need emphasis here. First, marriage is a bodily union, as well as emotional and spiritual. For in sexual intercourse—which consummates the marital union—the spouses become biologically one: they complete each other to form a single subject of a single biological action, the kind of action that could procreate, provided conditions outside their conduct are present. This biological union (a procreative-type act) embodies their procreative-type union (provided they have consented to share their lives in that kind of union).

Second, marriage is the kind of union whose fruition is procreation. It is the kind of union that would be fulfilled by having and raising children together; the union of the spouses is embodied, prolonged, and enriched by enlarging into family. Still, marriage is not a mere means in relation to procreation, but a sharing of lives (bodily, emotionally, and spiritually) that is good in itself—and so a man and a woman who have consented to such a multi-leveled union are genuinely married, and have an intrinsically fulfilling marital union, even if it turns out they cannot procreate together.

Now of course not all agree with the traditional definition of marriage. But the point I want to make is simply this: marriage, as traditionally defined, is a distinct type of community and not an arbitrary set. Unmarried cohabitators have a different type of relationship. Alliances to raise children also are not necessarily marriages: a group of celibate religious women running an orphanage, for example, are not married. And, plainly, same-sex sexual relationships are a different kind of relationship: they cannot become biologically one, nor is their relationship of the kind that would find its fruition in conceiving, bearing, and raising children together. (True, same-sex partners can form an alliance to raise children—for example, those from a previous marriage or produced by artificial reproduction; but that alliance is not an extension or prolongation of a bodily-emotional-spiritual union already begun, as is the case in marriage.)

Now it is precisely the distinctive features of marriage that ground the state’s interest in promoting and regulating it, and that make the general strength or health of marriage a public good. First, marriage is a distinctive way in which men and women are fulfilled, an irreducible aspect of their flourishing, and one that can be easily misunderstood. And so marriage needs cultural support—and can be harmed by cultural confusion about it. Clarity within the general culture about the value and nature of marriage enables young men and women, as well as those already married, to participate more fully than they otherwise would in this distinctive good—just as a clear public understanding of health or learning assists individuals and families to participate more fully in those goods.

Second, while good in itself, and not a mere means to an extrinsic end, marriage also provides the crucial social function of encouraging parents (and potential parents) to commit to each other and to whatever children they may have. A healthy and strong marriage culture will provide the safest and healthiest environment for children. For these reasons it is in everyone’s interest for the state to promote a sound understanding of marriage, and certainly to avoid obscuring its nature.

Since a same-sex couple is unable to form the kind of union marriage is, not granting same-sex couples marriage licenses is simply a decision by the state not to engage in a confusing and harmful fiction. Marriage is a certain kind of union. Denying a marriage license—or the privileges, protections, and obligations of marriage—to those who are unable to marry is not unjust discrimination. The state denies marriage licenses to threesomes or foursomes (refraining from declaring polyamorous groups marriages) and denies marriage licenses to twelve-year-olds (requiring valid consent for a marriage). These denials are not unjust because threesomes, foursomes, and twelve-year-olds are unable to form the kind of union that marriage is. But the same is true of same-sex couples. So, just as the distinction between eighteen-year-olds and twelve-year-olds is relevant to the purpose of marriage—because the former but not the latter are actually able to form the union that is marriage—in the same way, the distinction between opposite-sex couples and same-sex couples is relevant to the purpose of the marriage laws, because the former but not the latter can actually form the kind of union that marriage is.

According to same-sex “marriage” proponents, the public interest served by marriage laws is the stability of households. For example, in striking down California’s pro-marriage constitutional amendment called Proposition 8, Judge Vaughn Walker claimed: “The state regulates marriage because marriage creates stable households, which in turn form the basis of a stable, governable populace.” Stability of households might of course be a legitimate public aim, but laws to promote that (and to provide benefits and privileges for stable households as such) are not marriage laws. Such laws, benefits, and so on, would—if applied justly—have to be given also to groups who do not have sexual relationships and groups not pledging permanence and exclusivity.

Clearly, though, same-sex “marriage” supporters want much more than certain benefits and privileges. Discussion of concrete benefits such as hospital visitation, inheritance rights, and so on, is really a side issue—such benefits could be secured by other means for individuals who need them (for example, a durable power of attorney for health care, a will, etc.). Nor—contrary to how it is usually portrayed—is the same-sex marriage proposal aimed at tolerance, since persons with same-sex attractions are already free to engage in private sexual behavior and to establish for themselves long-term romantic and sexual relationships. Rather, what proponents of same-sex “marriage” principally desire is the social affirmation and endorsement of homosexual relationships as such. Judge Walker indicated this point clearly in his Proposition 8 decision: “Plaintiffs [some same-sex couples] seek to have the state recognize their committed relationships . . . . Perry and Stier seek to be spouses; they seek the mutual obligation and honor that attend marriage.”

So, the proposal is for the state to promote something called marriage, and that marriage is to be understood in a way that will include same-sex partners. This sounds like old news. But what, on their view, is the thing called “marriage,” and why should the state promote it? What distinguishes marital unions from others, such that the state should promote them? One cannot just pronounce that these couples will now count as married; there must be something one means by “being married,” something held in common by all married couples. But the same-sex “marriage” position cannot provide a coherent account of what that something is.

If marriage is not a bodily, emotional, and spiritual union of a man and a woman, of the kind that would be fulfilled by procreation, then what makes a union marriage and why should the state support it? It is not simply a union that is formed by a wedding ceremony: that would be a circular definition. Nor is every romantic and sexual relationship a marriage, and certainly there is no point in the state promoting all such relationships. Perhaps one will say that it is a stable, committed, and exclusive romantic-sexual relationship. But how stable would a romantic-sexual relationship need to be in order to be a marriage? Suppose John and Mary have a romantic-sexual relationship while college students but plan to go their separate ways after graduation: is that stable enough to be a marriage? If not, why not?

Or suppose Joe, Jim, and Steve have a committed, stable, romantic-sexual relationship among themselves—a polyamorous relationship. On what ground can the state promote the relationship between couples, but not the relationship among Joe, Jim, and Steve? The argument here is not a slippery slope one. Rather, the point is: There must be some non-arbitrary features shared by relationships that the state promotes which make them apt for public promotion, and make it fair for the state not to promote in the same way other relationships lacking those features. Without this the distinction is invidious discrimination. The conjugal understanding of marriage has a clear answer: (a) marriage is a distinct basic human good, that needs social support and that uniquely provides important social functions; (b) marriage’s organic bodily union and inherent orientation to procreation distinguish it from other relationships similar in superficial respects to it. But the same-sex marriage proposal’s conception of marriage has no answer. In fact, its conception of marriage is actually an arbitrarily selected class, and so the enactment of this proposal would be unjust.

The problem is not solved if one adds to one’s description or definition of marriage, that it must be a permanent commitment (as Judge Margaret Marshall did in her decision striking down Massachusetts’ marriage law: “It is the exclusive and permanent commitment of the marriage partners to one another, not the begetting of children, that is the sine qua non of civil marriage”). For it is fair to ask: why should the commitment be exclusive and permanent? The college students’ relationship (lacking permanence) and the celibate monks’ relationship (lacking exclusivity—others can join the religious order), both form households and contribute to social stability. In contrast, the conjugal understanding of marriage allows a clear answer to these questions: since marriage is a bodily and procreative-type union, and an irreducible basic good, it is non-arbitrarily distinct from other types of relationships. The promotion of this kind of relationship, for its own sake (because it is a basic good), and for the sake of children generally (since a strong marriage culture provides a safe haven for children), makes it in accord with justice to recognize, as marriage, only a relationship between a man and a woman, pledged to be permanent and exclusive. The conjugal conception of marriage is just and coherent; the same-sex marriage proponents’ conception of marriage is unjust and incoherent.

Patrick Lee is John N. and Jamie D. McAleer Professor of Bioethics at Franciscan University of Steubenville.

sábado, 3 de setembro de 2011

A Injustiça da não Discriminação

por P. Gonçalo P. de Almada


É injusto discriminar o que é igual, mas não o que é diferente

É como a gripe, esta recorrente mania: todos os anos, mais dia menos dia, lá aparece o vírus da não discriminação, a propagar a epidemia do igualitarismo e a exigir, em consequência, a reestruturação de algum órgão ostensivamente discriminatório, ou a aprovação de leis que combatam a exclusão dos grupos sociais mais desfavorecidos.

Exagero? De modo algum! Em plena silly season, dois artigos do Público, de 10 de Agosto passado, pugnam pela não discriminação.

No primeiro, o autor insurge-se contra a composição alfacinha do Conselho de Estado. Segundo o dito ensaísta, este órgão só tem duas mulheres; não tem ninguém mais à esquerda do que os conselheiros de esquerda que já lá estão; não tem membros que não sejam de Lisboa, excepto os que o não são, como o autarca de Gaia e os líderes insulares; não tem nenhum representante da Igreja Católica, nem das artes, nem das letras, nem da sociologia (?!), nem da história, etc. Tudo, claro, por culpa do Presidente da República que, apesar de algarvio confesso, «lisboetizou», segundo a escrita do mesmo autor, o supostamente nacional Conselho de Estado.

Não me compete, como é óbvio, comentar a sua opinião política que, ao exigir a representatividade institucional dos vários grémios profissionais e sociais, parece eivada de um certo saudosismo corporativista. Não posso, contudo, deixar de registar a sua curiosa tese de que a justiça decorre da igual, ou proporcional, representação, nesse órgão consultivo do chefe de Estado, das mais expressivas condições ideológicas, regionais, religiosas, etc.

A bem dizer, com a mesma razão, ou falta dela, também se deveria exigir que o sexo feminino, o norte transmontano, o barlavento algarvio, os evangélicos, os fadistas e os mais exímios pensadores pátrios estivessem representados na nossa selecção de futebol, cuja composição também parece muito politicamente incorrecta, sobretudo se se pensar que essa equipa deveria ser, de algum modo, representativa da nação.

O outro texto versa sobre a Moldávia que, não obstante o assédio da libertina Comunidade Europeia, ainda resiste à política da total permissividade em relação à orientação sexual. Segundo «um estudo de percepções da população» – vá-se lá saber o que isto seja! – «os moldavos, afinal, discriminam. Discriminam, sobretudo, deficientes físicos ou mentais, pobres, portadores de VIH, homossexuais, ciganos, mulheres». Pelos vistos, segundo a abalizada opinião da autora do artigo, em que não falta o coitadinho do costume, este é o principal crime dos moldavos: «discriminam»! E, claro, uma nação que discrimina, não pode fazer parte da nossa moderna e decadente Europa.

Mas, afinal, discriminar é mau? Por exemplo, quando se impede uma senhora corcunda de ser top-model, está-se a cometer uma injustiça? E quando se proíbe que um invisual seja árbitro de futebol, pode-se afirmar que se está a ser iníquo? A não-aceitação de um paralítico, como membro da equipa nacional de atletismo, é um acto punível, por arbitrário e contrário às convenções internacionais dos direitos humanos e de defesa dos deficientes? A norma que impede os cidadãos originariamente estrangeiros, mas naturalizados portugueses, de concorrerem à presidência da República, é ilegal por ser xenófoba? Uma escola que não aceita, para seu professor, um analfabeto, está a cometer um crime contra a igualdade de direitos que a Constituição consagra? A atribuição do Prémio Nobel da Química, a um determinado cidadão, tipifica um delito de injúrias aos restantes químicos? E se um encenador recusar a uma qualquer Julieta o papel de Romeu, ou a um qualquer Romeu o papel de Julieta, está também a incorrer num comportamento ilícito, neste caso por razão do respectivo sexo?

Discriminar é, apenas, distinguir. Será injusto quando distingue o que é igual, mas não quando diferencia o que é diverso. Os corcundas, os cegos, os paralíticos, os cidadãos nacionais de origem estrangeira, os analfabetos, os cientistas, os homens todos e todas as mulheres são iguais quanto à sua comum e inviolável dignidade humana. Mas não quanto às suas capacidades físicas e intelectuais, nem às correspondentes aptidões sociais, políticas e profissionais.

Aliás, a justiça não é, por definição, igualitária, mas discriminatória. Não trata a todos por igual, mas procura atribuir a cada qual o que lhe compete, não apenas em função da sua dignidade humana, mas também das suas características pessoais objectivas que, obviamente, não podem ser ignoradas, sobretudo quando se trata de lhes reconhecer uma específica função social. Não deixa de ser curioso que os grupos que antes mais apelavam à igualdade na diferença, sejam também agora os que mais reivindicam a indiferença na desigualdade, na medida em que não toleram a discriminação do que é, logicamente, diferente.

Todos iguais? Com certeza, no que respeita à comum natureza e dignidade do ser humano, bem como a todos os direitos e liberdades fundamentais. Mas todos diferentes também. A ditadura do igualitarismo, ou da não discriminação, não serve a causa da justiça: só seremos efectivamente todos iguais quando se reconhecer, também a nível social e jurídico, que somos todos diferentes.