quarta-feira, 18 de abril de 2012

Is the Natural Law Persuasive? - by R.J. Snell


One can neither deny nor question the natural law’s persuasiveness except by asking questions, conducting inquiries, achieving understandings, reaching judgments, and making choices—all of which are the natural law at work.
In conversation with two prominent public intellectuals, both having significant influence within evangelical Protestant circles (and beyond), I was asked if natural law theory ever persuaded anyone not already on board. Both are sophisticated thinkers, little prone to the knee-jerk hostility against natural law occasionally found in certain evangelical sub-communities, and I took their query to indicate two reasonable concerns. First, the observable fact that debate doesn’t always persuade committed opponents, and second, the natural law’s unfashionable reliance on reason and nature, commitments beating hasty retreat in the face of postmodern suspicion.

Is the natural law persuasive?

The question posed is not whether the natural law works as a theoretically coherent account, but whether it can convince anyone, especially now, in our current cultural climate. Not, “is the natural law true?” but, “will anyone buy this theory?” 

Can natural law persuade?

The first concern is hardly unique to natural law, for any theory suffers its opponents and detractors, and debate is always slow and partial in winning over skeptics. The natural law doesn’t suffer any unique flaw in this respect. But while the concern would seem to apply to any and all ethical theories, natural lawyers ought to embrace the potential objection, allowing it full weight, and for two initial reasons. First, we claim that the natural law is not a theory. Certainly there are various accounts and theoretical articulations about the natural law, but natural law is itself always operative, always forming the way(s) human subjects operate, query, reason, judge, and choose. Hadley Arkes recounts the mistake of those who ask about his theory, forgetting that the grounds of reasoning and judging are the principles of natural law; when people asked about his theory, “they suggested a detached onlooker standing by, watching the theories whizzing past. And somehow they manage to make judgments on just which theories or fragments they find plausible or implausible, true or false.” But persons are able to make judgments of truth or falsity only because the natural law is already operative—it is the light of reason itself. Of course, if that is true, then failure to persuade would be noteworthy. Second, we claim that our principles are self-evident, and so it’s fair to press the failure to persuade.

An adequate grasp of the natural law requires a first-person perspective. Natural law is not an “it” or a “force” or a “theory” existing out-there or in-here or up-there, but rather is the operator of our own subjectivity. As Germain Grisez articulates in an early essay, “law is not a constraint upon actions which originate elsewhere . . . rather, is a source of actions. Law makes human life possible. Animals behave without law, for they live by instinct without thought and without freedom. Man cannot begin to act as man without law.” That is, natural law is the dynamic source of our actions—including the action of reflexive theorizing about the source of our actions—and the source by which we reason or judge. “It” is not distinct from our own subjectivity, which is why Arkes responds incredulously to the query about his theory. Asking about his theory is tantamount to asking if humans have subjectivity. Well, who wants to know, and by what power do they want to know? It’s not a theory, it’s him.

The first-person aspect of natural law explains also the appeals to the self-evident. As John Finnis articulates in Fundamentals of Ethics, “ethics is not deduced or inferred from metaphysics or anthropology,” and principles are self-evident precisely in that they are not deduced from previous principles, but in no way is ethics merely intuited or asserted or mystically known. Rather, by adverting to the object(ive)s of human action—the for-the-sake-of-which rendering action intelligible—we can attend “to precisely those aspects of our experience . . . in which human good(s) became or can now become intelligible to us.” In other words, we can understand human goods rather than deduce human goods, but while understanding is not an inference it nonetheless involves insight into our experience, and without the experience and insight we would not understand. Basic goods are not deduced or derived, for they are self-evident, but there are conditions for our understanding of the goods.

The condition of coming to understand basic human goods, which serve as grounds for reasonable action, is a first-person understanding of our own reasons for acting. That is, we have to understand why we act and what we seek when we act. If an action is intelligible, that action will have some grounds which are understood as worth seeking in themselves, not requiring justification or demonstration on the basis of some other good(s). Understanding this entails self-understanding, adverting to the reasons for acting always operative in our knowing and choosing. Such self-understanding, Finnis explains, is not simply “opening one’s eyes” to take a look at oneself, nor is it an “intuition”; it is an “insight” gained by “reflecting on one’s own wanting, deciding and acting,” which occurs not by “peer[ing] inside oneself” but by noticing and understanding one’s own reasons for acting.

Space does not allow me to flesh out the entire account of natural law, obviously, but the first-personal element responds to both concerns of my two interlocutors. First, natural lawyers needn’t convince or persuade anyone, for in an important way natural law cannot be proven—law is the condition of intelligible action. Instead, our task is to have our interlocutors pay attention, not to us and our arguments, but to themselves. My failure to persuade someone of the natural law happens only if they (a) will not pay attention to themselves, or (b) if they do not understand themselves. Of course, I have neither power nor responsibility over another’s capacity to know themselves, so I’ll politely decline any such obligations for my ethics. In fact, since natural law is pre-theoretical, depending not on a system of concepts but rather on self-understanding, the more I grant that a theory must be able to persuade, the more that alternative theories such as deontology or utility fall while natural law survives, for they actually must provide a proof whereas I make no such claim, asking only for my interlocutor to advert to his performance.

Second, while I cannot prove the natural law—it not being that sort of thing—I can defeat objections to it through the method of retorsion or performative contradiction. The natural law is not a theory but rather the principles constituting our subjectivity, or as Grisez put it, there is no man without the law. The natural law thus constitutes my first-personal subjectivity, and, moreover, I come to understand the law through first-personal reflection on my reasons for acting and judging. While grasping subjectivity qua subjectivity cannot be granted by another, neither can subjectivity be denied without incoherence. Here I mean something more than logical contradiction, for as absurd as the statement “I lack subjectivity” is, the bizarreness occurs when I argue or judge that “I lack subjectivity” or “There is no natural law.” The natural law is both the power by which subjects judge (Arkes) and the understanding of intelligible reasons (Finnis), so the performance of judging or offering intelligible reasons thereby confirms the natural law. As Finnis claims in Natural Law and Natural Rights, “one who makes such an assertion, intending it as a serious contribution to rational discussion, is implicitly committed to the proposition that he believes his assertion is worth making, and worth making qua true.  . . .”

One can neither deny nor question the natural law’s persuasiveness except by asking questions, conducting inquiries, achieving understandings, reaching judgments, and making choices—all of which, if understood as the operations of our own subjectivity, are the natural law at work. And if one denies that one inquires, or understands, or judges, or chooses, one either contradicts what one is doing or one really does not inquire, understand, judge, or choose, in which case persuasion is not available to that sort of creature.

With respect to postmodern suspicion, this articulation of the natural law grounds itself in no big claims about Reason or Nature or Metaphysics. Although every account intertwines itself with big theories, natural law is not grounded in them, for it claims no foundations from which it is derived, pointing only to the easily observable (even by postmodernists) data of their own questions and judgments and the fact that the more someone suspects and argues against my account the more they refute themselves.

The natural law is persuasive because it requires nothing more than a willingness to advert to one’s own self, although, to be sure, even Socrates knew the difficulties in getting people to meet themselves for the first time.

R.J. Snell is associate professor of philosophy at Eastern University and a research director of the Agora Institute for Civic Virtue and the Common Good.

terça-feira, 17 de abril de 2012

Entrevista - Mons. Reig Pla mantiene lo dicho sobre gays y asegura que críticas lo ayudan a ser humilde

MADRID, 16 Abr. 12 / 08:15 pm (ACI/EWTN Noticias).- El Obispo de Alcalá (España), Mons. Juan Antonio Reig Pla, aseguró que no dejará de anunciar la verdad a los fieles a través de las enseñanzas de la Iglesia, a pesar de las presiones del lobby homosexual que lo puso en el ojo de la tormenta a raíz de su homilía de Viernes Santo.

A continuación la entrevista que concedió a Religión en Libertad. La primera que da a un medio luego de la polémica que suscitaron sus palabras sobre la homosexualidad:

- De su homilía durante los Oficios del Viernes Santo, que bien pudo durar unos 20 minutos, algunos medios destacaron tan sólo un párrafo que incendió una polémica en la opinión pública que muchos consideramos artificial y forzada. Usted decía lo siguiente: "Quisiera decir una palabra a aquellas personas que, llevadas por tantas ideologías, acaban por no orientar bien lo que es la sexualidad humana, piensan ya desde niño que tienen atracción hacia las personas de su mismo sexo y, a veces, para comprobarlo, se corrompen y se prostituyen, o van a clubs de hombres. Os aseguro que encuentran el infierno". ¿Podría explicar qué quiso decir exactamente con esta idea?

- Vayamos por orden. La sexualidad humana posee un sentido y significado inherente que la persona debe aprender a reconocer y descubrir respetando su lógica interna, la llamada "antropología adecuada". Sin embargo, las ideologías a las que me refería son la llamada "ideología de género" y sus sucesivas mutaciones (teoría queer, etc.). 

Muy brevemente indicaré que el principal postulado de la ideología de género es negar la diferencia sexual entre varón y mujer y afirmar que la configuración de la identidad sexual masculina y femenina es un producto de la cultura, una decisión personal construida en función de los deseos y apetencias subjetivas. Realmente, lo que se pretende es "deconstruir" la antropología humana propuesta por la naturaleza de la persona y el pensamiento coherente con la misma. Todo lo demás quedaría justificado por el principio de no discriminación y tolerancia. 

En todo caso he de advertir que la ideología de género se está quedando obsoleta ante otras propuestas más radicales de "deconstrucción de la identidad", como son la teoría queer, el transhumanismo, posthumanismo y la teoría cyborg. Naturalmente, estas teorías que desconocen la naturaleza humana, no orientan bien el verdadero sentido y significado de la sexualidad, propiciando, más bien, la confusión del corazón humano. 

La persona humana es una unidad substancial cuerpo-espíritu y la sexualidad es una dimensión esencial de la persona. El cuerpo no es una prótesis del «yo» sino una visibilización de la persona. El cuerpo modalizado como varón o como mujer es una expresión del ser personal. Su configuración «esponsal» es una llamada al amor y a la complementariedad sexual. Si confundimos el "ser sexuado" con el "deseo de elegir el modo de ser sexuado" estamos equivocando el mensaje.

Nos encontramos, pues, ante un programa de "deconstrucción" calculado y propiciado en todos los ámbitos (en la educación desde la más tierna infancia, en ciertos medios de comunicación, en el trabajo y en el ocio, etc.), que además cuenta con el impulso y protección de una gran cantidad de leyes inicuas y algunos poderosos lobbys que determinan qué es lo políticamente correcto y, por lo tanto, lo socialmente aceptable. 

Desde estos presupuestos, a muchos niños, jóvenes y adultos –cada vez más– se les invita a poner en cuestión su identidad sexual, y con el tiempo se les exhorta a "verificar y comprobar" cuáles son sus "preferencias sexuales"; algunos caen en la trampa. 

Los sacerdotes que conocemos la intimidad de las personas escuchando y ayudando a los feligreses que así lo solicitan, sabemos que las consecuencias de ello para muchas personas, son sufrimiento y destrucción, coloquialmente un "infierno" en sus vidas.

- ¿Hay algún punto de lo que usted dijo en su homilía del Viernes Santo que vaya en contra de lo que dice el Magisterio de la Iglesia Católica?

- Humildemente he de decir que todo lo que expliqué en mi homilía responde al Magisterio de la Iglesia Católica. Quise poner ejemplos actuales, que todo el mundo conoce, con la máxima delicadeza y caridad posible, pero con claridad; San Vicente Ferrer así lo sugiere en sus escritos cuando enseña cómo preparar y desarrollar las homilías. 

Pero volviendo a la cuestión del Magisterio: la Iglesia enseña que hay que distinguir entre las personas que siente inclinación sexual hacia el mismo sexo, la inclinación sexual propiamente dicha y los actos homosexuales.

Respecto a las personas con atracción sexual hacia el mismo sexo (AMS) la Iglesia enseña que "deben ser acogidos con respeto, compasión y delicadeza. Se evitará, respecto a ellos, todo signo de discriminación injusta" (Catecismo de la Iglesia Católica, n. 2358). 

En lo que se refiere a la particular inclinación de la persona con AMS, "aunque en sí no sea pecado, constituye sin embargo una tendencia, más o menos fuerte, hacia un comportamiento intrínsecamente malo desde el punto de vista moral. Por este motivo la inclinación misma debe ser considerada como objetivamente desordenada" (Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, Carta sobre la atención pastoral a las personas homosexuales, 1. X. 1986, n. 3); por cierto, esta carta está firmada por el entonces Cardenal Joseph Ratzinger.

Con respecto a los actos sexuales entre personas del mismo sexo la Iglesia afirma que "«son intrínsecamente desordenados». Son contrarios a la ley natural. Cierran el acto sexual al don de la vida. No proceden de una verdadera complementariedad afectiva y sexual. No pueden recibir aprobación en ningún caso" (Catecismo de la Iglesia Católica n. 2357). 

Hay que aclarar que esta es una valoración objetiva de dichos actos; otra cosa es que "la ignorancia involuntaria puede disminuir, y aún excusar, la imputabilidad de una falta grave, pero se supone que nadie ignora los principios de la ley moral que están inscritos en la conciencia de todo hombre. Los impulsos de la sensibilidad, las pasiones pueden igualmente reducir el carácter voluntario y libre de la falta, lo mismo que las presiones exteriores o los trastornos patológicos." (Catecismo de la Iglesia Católica, n. 1860)

- Pero entonces, ¿hay esperanza para quienes sienten atracción sexual por el mismo sexo? ¿Hay esperanza para quienes se han abandonado al así llamado "estilo de vida gay"?

- Por supuesto que sí. El corazón de cada hombre y mujer desea encontrar la verdad sobre el amor humano. "En esperanza fuimos salvados, dice san Pablo a los Romanos y también a nosotros (Rm 8,24). Según la fe cristiana, la «redención», la salvación, no es simplemente un dato de hecho. Se nos ofrece la salvación en el sentido de que se nos ha dado la esperanza, una esperanza fiable, gracias a la cual podemos afrontar nuestro presente: el presente, aunque sea un presente fatigoso, se puede vivir y aceptar si lleva hacia una meta, si podemos estar seguros de esta meta y si esta meta es tan grande que justifique el esfuerzo del camino" (Benedicto XVI, Carta encíclica Spe salvi, n. 1).

Hemos celebrado el Domingo de la Divina Misericordia; Dios es amor y también todopoderoso; lo que es imposible para los hombres es posible para Él. Nadie queda fuera de la universal voluntad salvífica de Dios. Jesús no ha venido a llamar a conversión a justos, sino a pecadores (Cf. Lc 5, 32).
Siempre con la asistencia del Espíritu Santo –que nos precede en todo– es posible iniciar el camino de retorno a la Casa del Padre. La Iglesia pone a disposición de todos los tesoros que Cristo ha depositado en ella: la Palabra de Dios, los sacramentos (en particular los de la Penitencia y la Eucaristía), la oración, etc. Con la ayuda de la gracia de Dios y acompañados por sacerdotes, orientadores y catequistas y ayudados, en su caso, por profesionales, las personas con AMS pueden vivir en castidad (dominio de sí); no sin combate, pero la vida de todo cristiano que quiere vivir según la voluntad de Dios implica batallar contra las propias concupiscencias hasta el mismo día de la muerte.

Pero además, el Pontificio Consejo para la Familia en un documento titulado "Sexualidad Humana: Verdad y Significado" (n.104) afirma que "los padres, por su parte, cuando advierten en sus hijos, en edad infantil o en la adolescencia, alguna manifestación de dicha tendencia o de tales comportamientos, deben buscar la ayuda de personas expertas y calificadas para proporcionarle todo el apoyo posible", y añade: "muchos casos, especialmente si la práctica de actos homosexuales no se ha enraizado, pueden ser resueltos positivamente con una terapia apropiada". 

A este respecto, las experiencias de las que tengo noticias, especialmente en España, Europa, Estados Unidos y Latinoamérica son muy esperanzadoras. Un itinerario que restaure las heridas en el corazón humano debería ser aquel que integre en su actuación todas las dimensiones de la persona (psíquica, somática y espiritual), ya que la sexualidad humana atraviesa todas estas dimensiones. Una ayuda epidérmica que no integre estas tres dimensiones no puede dar una respuesta adecuada. Con la pertinente unión de la ayuda espiritual y profesional, muchas personas, laicos, religiosos y sacerdotes, que voluntariamente lo han solicitado, se están viendo beneficiados por estos nuevos "itinerarios de libertad, caridad, verdad y esperanza" que conducen al dominio de sí y, en su caso, al cambio. Como dato interesante le diré que estos días he recibido muchos correos electrónicos de personas con AMS contando su experiencia de sufrimiento cuando llevaban el llamado estilo de vida gay, y explicando todo el bien que les está haciendo participar de estos "itinerarios de la esperanza"; es posible que, con la pertinente autorización, publiquemos alguna de estas experiencias en nuestra página web.

Para los que deseen conocer algunos de estos "itinerarios de la esperanza" pueden consultar la siguiente página web:
 
- ¿Proponer un itinerario hacia el gobierno de la propia persona y, en su caso, la reorientación de la inclinación sexual, puede ofender a las personas con sentimientos homosexuales? 

- No, porque nosotros sólo proponemos; sin embargo, es cierto que los lobbys parecen usar la estrategia mediática de hacerse los ofendidos si se citan en voz alta algunos textos de la Biblia o del Magisterio de la Iglesia sobre este tema. Si alguien piensa que tiene un problema y pide ayuda, sin duda la Iglesia lo atenderá. No se trata de imponer nada a nadie, sólo ofrecemos el espacio de libertad, verdad y esperanza que otorga la Iglesia para quien libremente desee escapar de la dictadura del silencio. 

Sabemos que hablar de castidad como dominio sobre la propia persona, e incluso de cambio para volver a la orientación sexual varón-mujer, no es políticamente correcto; desde luego los católicos, y yo en particular, bajo ningún concepto queremos ofender a nadie, sin embargo no renunciamos a anunciar la verdad en la caridad. 

Para quienes deseen ampliar conocimientos sobre este tema, hemos preparado en nuestra página web una sección titulada "Homosexualidad y esperanza" con información sobre documentos de la Iglesia, recursos, profesionales especialistas que abordan el tema, etc.: 

 
- ¿Se ha sentido solo ante este acoso mediático que ha tenido que soportar estos días?

- Cuando se cree en Jesucristo y en la maternidad de la Iglesia uno no está nunca solo. He recibido el apoyo de obispos, sacerdotes, religiosos y fieles laicos de España y de muchas partes del mundo, así como de importantísimas instituciones eclesiales y civiles. 

He recibido más de un millar de correos electrónicos, cartas, faxes, telegramas y llamadas telefónicas de personas que han querido mostrarme su cercanía espiritual afirmando su adhesión al Magisterio de la Iglesia y asegurándome sus oraciones por mi persona y ministerio. 

Tengo que agradecer también el apoyo a multitud de medios de comunicación (prensa, radio, televisión e Internet) de España y del extranjero. En particular quiero referirme a un medio local de Alcalá de Henares que ha escrito un editorial con evidente objetividad y buena voluntad: lo agradezco de corazón.

- Desde algunos ámbitos le han acusado de "homofobia" por sus palabras sobre la homosexualidad en la homilía del Viernes Santo, ¿qué tiene que decir al respecto?

- La precisión terminológica es aquí, como en todo, muy importante. El diccionario de la Real Academia Española (RAE) de la Lengua define la homofobia como "aversión obsesiva hacia las personas homosexuales": nada más lejos del Magisterio de la Iglesia y de mi voluntad. Como ya he recordado la Iglesia enseña que las personas con AMS deben ser acogidas "con respeto, compasión y delicadeza. Se evitará, respecto a ellos, todo signo de discriminación injusta". 

Más aún, la Iglesia acoge a todos los que, en esta situación, se acercan solicitando ayuda. Otra cosa bien distinta es la inclinación propiamente dicha (objetivamente desordenada) y los actos homosexuales (intrínsecamente desordenados). Algunos juegan a confundir conceptos, de modo que acusan, ilícita e ilegalmente, de homofobia a quienes afirmamos el desorden de dicha inclinación y de dichos actos; es una cuestión de estrategia: confundir conceptos para confundir a la opinión pública. 

En mi homilía, poniendo ejemplos de pecados concretos, hablé de las infidelidades conyugales, del aborto procurado, de los empresarios y trabajadores que cometen injusticias, de los sacerdotes que se corrompen, de los jóvenes que consumen drogas y de las personas con AMS que, a veces, se corrompen y se prostituyen, o van a clubs de hombres. Deducir de ello que incitaba al odio hacia los matrimonios, las mujeres y los médicos, los sacerdotes, los empresarios y los trabajadores, los jóvenes y las personas con AMS es simplemente, por ser parco, una colosal manipulación; al contrario, anuncié que hay esperanza, que Dios nos ama a todos, que Cristo ha muerto por nuestros pecados llamándonos a conversión, y que nadie queda fuera de su Divina Misericordia.

- Finalmente, don Juan Antonio, ¿qué les diría a quienes han manipulado y tergiversado sus palabras, y a quienes le han amenazado de muerte, le han llamado imbécil o piden que sea encarcelado o expulsado del país?

- Simplemente les diría que les quiero y les perdono. Los insultos y amenazas me ayudan a ser humilde. Como dijo un gran obispo torturado en la cárcel, los hombres para mí se dividen en dos grupos: los que son mis hermanos y los que todavía no saben que lo son.

Si me permite, por último quiero decir que considero que, en España, es muy importante mantener abierto un serio debate sobre estos temas, aportando los argumentos de la teología, de la antropología cristiana y de todas las ciencias humanas que faciliten más y mejor la propuesta del Magisterio de la Iglesia. El corazón humano es nuestro principal aliado y ese corazón espera el anuncio de la verdad y de la esperanza.

Federación Internacional de las Associciones de Médicos católicos respaldan a Mons. Reig Pla tras criticar estilo de vida gay

BARCELONA, 17 Abr. 12 / 10:03 am (ACI/EWTN Noticias).- La Federación Internacional de Asociaciones de Médicos Católicos (FIAMC) dio a conocer hoy un comunicado en el que respalda al Obispo de Alcalá de Henares (España), Mons. Juan Antonio Reig Pla, sobre lo que dijo en su homilía de Viernes Santo referente a la homosexualidad.

El comunicado firmado por el presidente de la FIAMC, Dr. José María Simón Castellví, señala que "los médicos católicos respetan profundamente a las personas con rasgos homosexuales así como a todas aquella de cualquier otra condición".

El texto afirma luego que "los médicos católicos no comparten la práctica de la homosexualidad por no estar conforme con la sana antropología ni con la Santa Biblia. La homosexualidad no es pro-natura".

Sobre la posición científica de los médicos católicos respecto a la homosexualidad, remiten al documento "Homosexualidad y esperanza" redactado por la Asociación Médica Católica Norteamericana y adoptada por la FIAMC como uno de sus textos oficiales.

En ese documento, se señala, entre otras cosas, que la homosexualidad no es innata; que no existe el gen gay ni evidencia científica que respalde esa idea ampliamente difundida actualmente, que la atracción hacia personas del mismo sexo (ams) se puede prevenir y que se puede curar a través de la terapia.

El comunicado de la FIAMC lamenta además, junto a Mons. Reig Pla, "los contenidos de algunos libros de texto, especialmente de (Educación para la) Ciudadanía, y las ‘enseñanzas’ en las que se impulsa a niños a "explorar" todas las posibilidades sexuales".

"Tenemos toda la razón para considerar perversas estas enseñanzas. Y Mons. Reig tiene toda la razón en condenar estos y otros abusos al ser humano", añade.

El texto concluye afirmando que "los médicos católicos lamentan profundamente el fracaso de los estados modernos y de las instituciones públicas supranacionales en combatir el turismo ‘sexual’, con mayores o menores, en países exóticos".

Mons. Reig Plá despertó la ira y los ataques del colectivo gay español y de los partidos de izquierda, luego de que en su homilía de Viernes Santo criticara el estilo de vida homosexual de quienes "piensan ya desde niño que tienen atracción hacia las personas de su mismo sexo y, a veces, para comprobarlo se corrompen y se prostituyen o van a clubes de hombres nocturnos. Os aseguro que encuentran el infierno".

Lo dicho es solo una brevísima parte de una homilía de 21 minutos, calificada por algunos, como brillante pastoral y doctrinalmente.

Para ver la posición cientiífica de la FIAMC sobre la homosexualidad, ingrese a: http://www.fiamc.org/bioethics/homosexuality/

domingo, 15 de abril de 2012

Esquizofrenia ou demónio? O testemunho de Aldina

The Speed of Change in the Republic of Rights - James Schaal, S. J.


In CRISIS
 
“I grew up in Kansas. When I began my book Render Unto Caesar in 2006, I had in my mind the America I always knew—or thought I knew. But that America, I admit, has been passing for fifty years, and probably longer.”
—Charles Chaput, September 2010

The Catholic thinkers, in the past century or so, argued that the Church’s tenets and principles are basically compatible with the intellectual framework of the Founding Fathers. Indeed, contrariwise, they argued that the American Founders discovered their basic principles, knowingly or not, from the Catholic tradition. One can dispute this assumption. Many of the founding principles, on further examination, were modern in origin even though they could look like holdovers from the earlier traditions of ethics, law, and metaphysics. Moreover, the present understanding of American culture has little to do either with the founding fathers or classical tradition.

Nothing is more volatile than the word “rights” and basing one’s political philosophy on its shifting premises. The intellectual “justification” for current and increasing attacks on the Church, insofar as they have any substance, is founded on this charge: the Church is against human “rights.” The word’s modern usage is from Hobbes, not Aquinas. It means that, because of individual autonomy, for whatever I need or want, I have a “right.” Since everyone else has the same “right,” yet disparate “rights” conflict, government is set up to adjudicate who gets what. The government’s own criterion for enforcing this or that “right” is based on the same principle: whatever it decides is law. The failure to notice the dangers of such an understanding of “rights” is coming home to haunt us.

Many writers and thinkers are struck by the rapidity with which the Catholic Church itself, from being relatively comfortable in Zion, has suddenly come under fire as the object of ever-increasing government control and cultural ostracism. It finds itself having to resort to “freedom of religion” and “freedom of speech” in a world in which such “freedoms” are either ignored or simply contradicted. The reason for this change is that the Church is now perceived as the principal obstacle to establishing a fully “rights-oriented” political society. This is evidently the goal of the Obama administration as revealed in its ever more invasive “decrees.” In this “rights” republic, in lieu of any dramatic action of the Supreme Court, the sole arbiter and definer of what “rights” mean is the state and what it decrees and enforces.

Many Catholics profess to be surprised by this sudden drawing of the logical conclusion to what Mary Ann Glendon called “rights talk.” Many Catholics so want “rights” to mean what they claim it means that they blind themselves to what the intellectual history of the word does mean and imply by this enigmatic term. All through recent decades, the provisions of freedom of speech and freedom of religion have been used against the Church. It was held to be against free speech and free religion. The irony today is that it is the Church that finds itself appealing to these standards over against an administration which claims the same standards. The decrees that the Church finds contrary to “rights” are precisely the ones said to be based on “rights”—abortion, contraception, sterilization, gay marriage, the works.

Numerous writers in recent years have pointed to the decay of the American family. Since the time of Aristotle’s response to Plato’s famous proposal of communality of wives and children, the family has been looked on as a bulwark, not enemy, of the political order. But there has always been in modern utopian and Marxist thought a strand that saw the elimination of the family as the key to a successful social order. What would take the place of the family?–schools, health agencies, bureaucratic employment institutions, welfare under another name. Most of these extreme notions are proposed in the name of common good and human dignity.

We’re All Rome Now

In his essay on Shakespeare’s play, Julius Caesar, Allan Bloom remarked: “The corruption of the people is the key to the mastery of Rome.” We need only to change the name of the capitol city to suspect that this observation applies to almost every democratic entity, including our own. And what is striking is that it is precisely a corruption that in almost every way concerns, touches upon, or affects the family by the institution of policies that are put forth in the name of modern “rights.”
I began these remarks by citing a brief comment of Archbishop Chaput. What struck him was the rapidity of the change in this country from the land that he “thought” that he knew. It is said by several historians of civilization that once the core principles of a culture are corrupted, the decline of that society is precipitous. The will to acknowledge the problem or the failure to see the consequence of “rights” once put into effect portend a paralysis of the good.

Since much of the culture has now accepted as “human rights” the issues that the Church has taken a firm stand against as themselves unnatural and immoral, it follows that the effects of these “rights” will henceforth dominate the public order. Single parent families, in virto families of one or another parent, free “health” service to effect abortion, contraception, euthanasia, and fetal experiment will all be available. Opposition to these issues will not be seen as “free speech,” but as “hate language.” No discussion will be allowed largely because the government understands implicitly the tenuousness and lack of validity to its own positions. The government will claim the “right” to define what religion is.

Many, if not most, religions will go along with this cultural pressure and fact. To oppose it invites marginalization and probably legal persecution. In any case, in the name of “human rights,” the government will assume control of both the public and familial orders. No longer will we find any recognition of an order of truth that is independent of the state’s own definition of itself.

Is this concern for the rapid decline of the culture far-fetched? I think not. Even a year ago, few would have suspected the rapidity with which the Church has become an object of direct political concern over its own teachings and doctrines. It will get worse if the present government and its general principles remain in power. This observation goes against the grain of many, especially of those who agree with the government’s principles and decrees. But the logic of decline and fall is already in place. We cannot stop erroneous principles from taking effect except by acknowledging their falsity. Otherwise, they carry themselves and those who hold them to their logical conclusion.

The Speed of Change

It can be delayed, but not stopped until we recognize where the problem lies. It lies in the rejection, implicit or explicit, of the nature and centrality of the family. In a sense, we have here an ancient issue. But it is now ever so present. The Catholic Church is admired for what it stands for. The Catholic Church is hated for what it stands for. The reason for this paradox lies in the logic of reason.

Etienne Gilson remarked that once we lay down our first principles, we no longer think as we may but we think as we can. We are seeing the “logic” of “rights” being carried out before our very eyes. The undermining and elimination of the family are no accidents. They follow from certain premises, the premises that place our private good at the center of reality. The rapidity of change means, I suspect, that “it is later than we think.” We are not at the beginning of the change but, as Archbishop Chaput intimated, at the end. That is why is seems so rapid. Little is left to oppose it.

sexta-feira, 13 de abril de 2012

Brasil: Voto do Presidente do STF Aborto Anencéfalo (Belíssimo)

Bispos US preparam católicos para perseguição e martírio - A Statement on Religious Liberty

In USCCB 
Our First, Most Cherished Liberty

A Statement on Religious Liberty

United States Conference of Catholic Bishops
Ad Hoc Committee for Religious Liberty

We are Catholics. We are Americans. We are proud to be both, grateful for the gift of faith which is ours as Christian disciples, and grateful for the gift of liberty which is ours as American citizens. To be Catholic and American should mean not having to choose one over the other. Our allegiances are distinct, but they need not be contradictory, and should instead be complementary. That is the teaching of our Catholic faith, which obliges us to work together with fellow citizens for the common good of all who live in this land. That is the vision of our founding and our Constitution, which guarantees citizens of all religious faiths the right to contribute to our common life together.

Freedom is not only for Americans, but we think of it as something of our special inheritance, fought for at a great price, and a heritage to be guarded now. We are stewards of this gift, not only for ourselves but for all nations and peoples who yearn to be free. Catholics in America have discharged this duty of guarding freedom admirably for many generations.

In 1887, when the archbishop of Baltimore, James Gibbons, was made the second American cardinal, he defended the American heritage of religious liberty during his visit to Rome to receive the red hat. Speaking of the great progress the Catholic Church had made in the United States, he attributed it to the "civil liberty we enjoy in our enlightened republic." Indeed, he made a bolder claim, namely that "in the genial atmosphere of liberty [the Church] blossoms like a rose."1

From well before Cardinal Gibbons, Catholics in America have been advocates for religious liberty, and the landmark teaching of the Second Vatican Council on religious liberty was influenced by the American experience. It is among the proudest boasts of the Church on these shores. We have been staunch defenders of religious liberty in the past. We have a solemn duty to discharge that duty today.

We need, therefore, to speak frankly with each other when our freedoms are threatened. Now is such a time. As Catholic bishops and American citizens, we address an urgent summons to our fellow Catholics and fellow Americans to be on guard, for religious liberty is under attack, both at home and abroad.

This has been noticed both near and far. Pope Benedict XVI recently spoke about his worry that religious liberty in the United States is being weakened. He called it the "most cherished of American freedoms"—and indeed it is. All the more reason to heed the warning of the Holy Father, a friend of America and an ally in the defense of freedom, in his recent address to American bishops:
Of particular concern are certain attempts being made to limit that most cherished of American freedoms, the freedom of religion. Many of you have pointed out that concerted efforts have been made to deny the right of conscientious objection on the part of Catholic individuals and institutions with regard to cooperation in intrinsically evil practices. Others have spoken to me of a worrying tendency to reduce religious freedom to mere freedom of worship without guarantees of respect for freedom of conscience.
Here once more we see the need for an engaged, articulate and well-formed Catholic laity endowed with a strong critical sense vis-à-vis the dominant culture and with the courage to counter a reductive secularism which would delegitimize the Church's participation in public debate about the issues which are determining the future of American society.2

 

Religious Liberty Under Attack—Concrete Examples

Is our most cherished freedom truly under threat? Sadly, it is. This is not a theological or legal dispute without real world consequences. Consider the following:
  • HHS mandate for contraception, sterilization, and abortion-inducing drugs. The mandate of the Department of Health and Human Services has received wide attention and has been met with our vigorous and united opposition. In an unprecedented way, the federal government will both force religious institutions to facilitate and fund a product contrary to their own moral teaching and purport to define which religious institutions are "religious enough" to merit protection of their religious liberty. These features of the "preventive services" mandate amount to an unjust law. As Archbishop-designate William Lori of Baltimore, Chairman of the Ad Hoc Committee for Religious Liberty, testified to Congress: "This is not a matter of whether contraception may be prohibited by the government. This is not even a matter of whether contraception may be supported by the government. Instead, it is a matter of whether religious people and institutions may be forced by the government to provide coverage for contraception or sterilization, even if that violates their religious beliefs."3
  • State immigration laws. Several states have recently passed laws that forbid what the government deems "harboring" of undocumented immigrants—and what the Church deems Christian charity and pastoral care to those immigrants. Perhaps the most egregious of these is in Alabama, where the Catholic bishops, in cooperation with the Episcopal and Methodist bishops of Alabama, filed suit against the law:
    It is with sadness that we brought this legal action but with a deep sense that we, as people of faith, have no choice but to defend the right to the free exercise of religion granted to us as citizens of Alabama. . . . The law makes illegal the exercise of our Christian religion which we, as citizens of Alabama, have a right to follow. The law prohibits almost everything which would assist an undocumented immigrant or encourage an undocumented immigrant to live in Alabama. This new Alabama law makes it illegal for a Catholic priest to baptize, hear the confession of, celebrate the anointing of the sick with, or preach the word of God to, an undocumented immigrant. Nor can we encourage them to attend Mass or give them a ride to Mass. It is illegal to allow them to attend adult scripture study groups, or attend CCD or Sunday school classes. It is illegal for the clergy to counsel them in times of difficulty or in preparation for marriage. It is illegal for them to come to Alcoholic Anonymous meetings or other recovery groups at our churches.4
  • Altering Church structure and governance. In 2009, the Judiciary Committee of the Connecticut Legislature proposed a bill that would have forced Catholic parishes to be restructured according to a congregational model, recalling the trusteeism controversy of the early nineteenth century, and prefiguring the federal government's attempts to redefine for the Church "religious minister" and "religious employer" in the years since.
  • Christian students on campus.In its over-100-year history, the University of California Hastings College of Law has denied student organization status to only one group, the Christian Legal Society, because it required its leaders to be Christian and to abstain from sexual activity outside of marriage.
  • Catholic foster care and adoption services. Boston, San Francisco, the District of Columbia, and the state of Illinois have driven local Catholic Charities out of the business of providing adoption or foster care services—by revoking their licenses, by ending their government contracts, or both—because those Charities refused to place children with same-sex couples or unmarried opposite-sex couples who cohabit.
  • Discrimination against small church congregations. New York City enacted a rule that barred the Bronx Household of Faith and sixty other churches from renting public schools on weekends for worship services even though non-religious groups could rent the same schools for scores of other uses. While this would not frequently affect Catholic parishes, which generally own their own buildings, it would be devastating to many smaller congregations. It is a simple case of discrimination against religious believers.
  • Discrimination against Catholic humanitarian services. Notwithstanding years of excellent performance by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops' Migration and Refugee Services in administering contract services for victims of human trafficking, the federal government changed its contract specifications to require us to provide or refer for contraceptive and abortion services in violation of Catholic teaching. Religious institutions should not be disqualified from a government contract based on religious belief, and they do not somehow lose their religious identity or liberty upon entering such contracts. And yet a federal court in Massachusetts, turning religious liberty on its head, has since declared that such a disqualification is required by the First Amendment—that the government somehow violates religious liberty by allowing Catholic organizations to participate in contracts in a manner consistent with their beliefs on contraception and abortion.

Religious Liberty Is More Than Freedom of Worship

Religious liberty is not only about our ability to go to Mass on Sunday or pray the Rosary at home. It is about whether we can make our contribution to the common good of all Americans. Can we do the good works our faith calls us to do, without having to compromise that very same faith? Without religious liberty properly understood, all Americans suffer, deprived of the essential contribution in education, health care, feeding the hungry, civil rights, and social services that religious Americans make every day, both here at home and overseas.

What is at stake is whether America will continue to have a free, creative, and robust civil society—or whether the state alone will determine who gets to contribute to the common good, and how they get to do it. Religious believers are part of American civil society, which includes neighbors helping each other, community associations, fraternal service clubs, sports leagues, and youth groups. All these Americans make their contribution to our common life, and they do not need the permission of the government to do so. Restrictions on religious liberty are an attack on civil society and the American genius for voluntary associations.

The Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America issued a statement about the administration's contraception and sterilization mandate that captured exactly the danger that we face:
Most troubling, is the Administration's underlying rationale for its decision, which appears to be a view that if a religious entity is not insular, but engaged with broader society, it loses its "religious" character and liberties. Many faiths firmly believe in being open to and engaged with broader society and fellow citizens of other faiths. The Administration's ruling makes the price of such an outward approach the violation of an organization's religious principles. This is deeply disappointing.5
This is not a Catholic issue. This is not a Jewish issue. This is not an Orthodox, Mormon, or Muslim issue. It is an American issue.

The Most Cherished of American Freedoms

In 1634, a mix of Catholic and Protestant settlers arrived at St. Clement's Island in Southern Maryland from England aboard the Ark and the Dove. They had come at the invitation of the Catholic Lord Baltimore, who had been granted Maryland by the Protestant King Charles I of England. While Catholics and Protestants were killing each other in Europe, Lord Baltimore imagined Maryland as a society where people of different faiths could live together peacefully. This vision was soon codified in Maryland's 1649 Act Concerning Religion (also called the "Toleration Act"), which was the first law in our nation's history to protect an individual's right to freedom of conscience.

Maryland's early history teaches us that, like any freedom, religious liberty requires constant vigilance and protection, or it will disappear. Maryland's experiment in religious toleration ended within a few decades. The colony was placed under royal control, and the Church of England became the established religion. Discriminatory laws, including the loss of political rights, were enacted against those who refused to conform. Catholic chapels were closed, and Catholics were restricted to practicing their faith in their homes. The Catholic community lived under these conditions until the American Revolution.

By the end of the 18th century, our nation's founders embraced freedom of religion as an essential condition of a free and democratic society. James Madison, often called the Father of the Constitution, described conscience as "the most sacred of all property."6 He wrote that "the Religion then of every man must be left to the conviction and conscience of every man; and it is the right of every man to exercise it as these may dictate."7 George Washington wrote that "the establishment of Civil and Religious Liberty was the Motive that induced me to the field of battle."8 Thomas Jefferson assured the Ursuline Sisters—who had been serving a mostly non-Catholic population by running a hospital, an orphanage, and schools in Louisiana since 1727—that the principles of the Constitution were a "sure guarantee" that their ministry would be free "to govern itself according to its own voluntary rules, without interference from the civil authority."9

It is therefore fitting that when the Bill of Rights was ratified, religious freedom had the distinction of being the First Amendment. Religious liberty is indeed the first liberty. The First Amendment guarantees that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof."

Recently, in a unanimous Supreme Court judgment affirming the importance of that first freedom, the Chief Justice of the United States explained that religious liberty is not just the first freedom for Americans; rather it is the first in the history of democratic freedom, tracing its origins back the first clauses of the Magna Carta of 1215 and beyond. In a telling example, Chief Justice Roberts illustrated our history of religious liberty in light of a Catholic issue decided upon by James Madison, who guided the Bill of Rights through Congress and is known as the architect of the First Amendment:
[In 1806] John Carroll, the first Catholic bishop in the United States, solicited the Executive's opinion on who should be appointed to direct the affairs of the Catholic Church in the territory newly acquired by the Louisiana Purchase. After consulting with President Jefferson, then-Secretary of State James Madison responded that the selection of church "functionaries" was an "entirely ecclesiastical" matter left to the Church's own judgment. The "scrupulous policy of the Constitution in guarding against a political interference with religious affairs," Madison explained, prevented the Government from rendering an opinion on the "selection of ecclesiastical individuals."10
That is our American heritage, our most cherished freedom. It is the first freedom because if we are not free in our conscience and our practice of religion, all other freedoms are fragile. If citizens are not free in their own consciences, how can they be free in relation to others, or to the state? If our obligations and duties to God are impeded, or even worse, contradicted by the government, then we can no longer claim to be a land of the free, and a beacon of hope for the world.

Our Christian Teaching

During the civil rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s, Americans shone the light of the Gospel on a dark history of slavery, segregation, and racial bigotry. The civil rights movement was an essentially religious movement, a call to awaken consciences, not only an appeal to the Constitution for America to honor its heritage of liberty.

In his famous "Letter from Birmingham Jail" in 1963, Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. boldly said, "The goal of America is freedom." As a Christian pastor, he argued that to call America to the full measure of that freedom was the specific contribution Christians are obliged to make. He rooted his legal and constitutional arguments about justice in the long Christian tradition:
I would agree with Saint Augustine that "An unjust law is no law at all." Now what is the difference between the two? How does one determine when a law is just or unjust? A just law is a man-made code that squares with the moral law or the law of God. An unjust law is a code that is out of harmony with the moral law. To put it in the terms of Saint Thomas Aquinas, an unjust law is a human law that is not rooted in eternal law and natural law.11
It is a sobering thing to contemplate our government enacting an unjust law. An unjust law cannot be obeyed. In the face of an unjust law, an accommodation is not to be sought, especially by resorting to equivocal words and deceptive practices. If we face today the prospect of unjust laws, then Catholics in America, in solidarity with our fellow citizens, must have the courage not to obey them. No American desires this. No Catholic welcomes it. But if it should fall upon us, we must discharge it as a duty of citizenship and an obligation of faith.

It is essential to understand the distinction between conscientious objection and an unjust law. Conscientious objection permits some relief to those who object to a just law for reasons of conscience—conscription being the most well-known example. An unjust law is "no law at all." It cannot be obeyed, and therefore one does not seek relief from it, but rather its repeal.

The Christian church does not ask for special treatment, simply the rights of religious freedom for all citizens. Rev. King also explained that the church is neither the master nor the servant of the state, but its conscience, guide, and critic.
As Catholics, we know that our history has shadows too in terms of religious liberty, when we did not extend to others the proper respect for this first freedom. But the teaching of the Church is absolutely clear about religious liberty:
The human person has a right to religious freedom. This freedom means that all men are to be immune from coercion on the part of individuals or of social groups and of any human power, in such wise that in matters religious no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs … whether privately or publicly, whether alone or in association with others, within due limits. . . . This right of the human person to religious freedom is to be recognized in the constitutional law whereby society is governed. Thus it is to become a civil right.12
As Catholics, we are obliged to defend the right to religious liberty for ourselves and for others. We are happily joined in this by our fellow Christians and believers of other faiths.
A recent letter to President Obama from some sixty religious leaders, including Christians of many denominations and Jews, argued that "it is emphatically not only Catholics who deeply object to the requirement that health plans they purchase must provide coverage of contraceptives that include some that are abortifacients."13

More comprehensively, a theologically rich and politically prudent declaration from Evangelicals and Catholics Together made a powerful case for greater vigilance in defense of religious freedom, precisely as a united witness animated by the Gospel of Jesus Christ.14 Their declaration makes it clear that as Christians of various traditions we object to a "naked public square," stripped of religious arguments and religious believers. We do not seek a "sacred public square" either, which gives special privileges and benefits to religious citizens. Rather, we seek a civil public square, where all citizens can make their contribution to the common good. At our best, we might call this an American public square.

The Lord Jesus came to liberate us from the dominion of sin. Political liberties are one part of that liberation, and religious liberty is the first of those liberties. Together with our fellow Christians, joined by our Jewish brethren, and in partnership with Americans of other religious traditions, we affirm that our faith requires us to defend the religious liberty granted us by God, and protected in our Constitution.

Martyrs Around the World

In this statement, as bishops of the United States, we are addressing ourselves to the situation we find here at home. At the same time, we are sadly aware that religious liberty in many other parts of the world is in much greater peril. Our obligation at home is to defend religious liberty robustly, but we cannot overlook the much graver plight that religious believers, most of them Christian, face around the world. The age of martyrdom has not passed. Assassinations, bombings of churches, torching of orphanages—these are only the most violent attacks Christians have suffered because of their faith in Jesus Christ. More systematic denials of basic human rights are found in the laws of several countries, and also in acts of persecution by adherents of other faiths.

If religious liberty is eroded here at home, American defense of religious liberty abroad is less credible. And one common threat, spanning both the international and domestic arenas, is the tendency to reduce the freedom of religion to the mere freedom of worship. Therefore, it is our task to strengthen religious liberty at home, in this and other respects, so that we might defend it more vigorously abroad. To that end, American foreign policy, as well as the vast international network of Catholic agencies, should make the promotion of religious liberty an ongoing and urgent priority.

"All the Energies the Catholic Community Can Muster"

What we ask is nothing more than that our God-given right to religious liberty be respected. We ask nothing less than that the Constitution and laws of the United States, which recognize that right, be respected.

In insisting that our liberties as Americans be respected, we know as bishops that what our Holy Father said is true. This work belongs to "an engaged, articulate and well-formed Catholic laity endowed with a strong critical sense vis-à-vis the dominant culture."

As bishops we seek to bring the light of the Gospel to our public life, but the work of politics is properly that of committed and courageous lay Catholics. We exhort them to be both engaged and articulate in insisting that as Catholics and as Americans we do not have to choose between the two. There is an urgent need for the lay faithful, in cooperation with Christians, Jews, and others, to impress upon our elected representatives the importance of continued protection of religious liberty in a free society.

We address a particular word to those holding public office. It is your noble task to govern for the common good. It does not serve the common good to treat the good works of religious believers as a threat to our common life; to the contrary, they are essential to its proper functioning. It is also your task to protect and defend those fundamental liberties guaranteed by the Bill of Rights. This ought not to be a partisan issue. The Constitution is not for Democrats or Republicans or Independents. It is for all of us, and a great nonpartisan effort should be led by our elected representatives to ensure that it remains so.

We recognize that a special responsibility belongs to those Catholics who are responsible for our impressive array of hospitals, clinics, universities, colleges, schools, adoption agencies, overseas development projects, and social service agencies that provide assistance to the poor, the hungry, immigrants, and those faced with crisis pregnancies. You do the work that the Gospel mandates that we do. It is you who may be forced to choose between the good works we do by faith, and fidelity to that faith itself. We encourage you to hold firm, to stand fast, and to insist upon what belongs to you by right as Catholics and Americans. Our country deserves the best we have to offer, including our resistance to violations of our first freedom.

To our priests, especially those who have responsibility for parishes, university chaplaincies, and high schools, we ask for a catechesis on religious liberty suited to the souls in your care. As bishops we can provide guidance to assist you, but the courage and zeal for this task cannot be obtained from another—it must be rooted in your own concern for your flock and nourished by the graces you received at your ordination.

Catechesis on religious liberty is not the work of priests alone. The Catholic Church in America is blessed with an immense number of writers, producers, artists, publishers, filmmakers, and bloggers employing all the means of communications—both old and new media—to expound and teach the faith. They too have a critical role in this great struggle for religious liberty. We call upon them to use their skills and talents in defense of our first freedom.

Finally to our brother bishops, let us exhort each other with fraternal charity to be bold, clear, and insistent in warning against threats to the rights of our people. Let us attempt to be the "conscience of the state," to use Rev. King's words. In the aftermath of the decision on contraceptive and sterilization mandates, many spoke out forcefully. As one example, the words of one of our most senior brothers, Cardinal Roger Mahony, thirty-five years a bishop and recently retired after twenty-five years as archbishop of Los Angeles, provide a model for us here: "I cannot imagine a more direct and frontal attack on freedom of conscience than this ruling today. This decision must be fought against with all the energies the Catholic community can muster."15

A Fortnight for Freedom

In particular, we recommend to our brother bishops that we focus "all the energies the Catholic community can muster" in a special way this coming summer. As pastors of the flock, our privileged task is to lead the Christian faithful in prayer.
Both our civil year and liturgical year point us on various occasions to our heritage of freedom. This year, we propose a special "fortnight for freedom," in which bishops in their own dioceses might arrange special events to highlight the importance of defending our first freedom. Our Catholic institutions also could be encouraged to do the same, especially in cooperation with other Christians, Jews, people of other faiths, and indeed, all who wish to defend our most cherished freedom.

We suggest that the fourteen days from June 21—the vigil of the Feasts of St. John Fisher and St. Thomas More—to July 4, Independence Day, be dedicated to this "fortnight for freedom"—a great hymn of prayer for our country. Our liturgical calendar celebrates a series of great martyrs who remained faithful in the face of persecution by political power—St. John Fisher and St. Thomas More, St. John the Baptist, SS. Peter and Paul, and the First Martyrs of the Church of Rome. Culminating on Independence Day, this special period of prayer, study, catechesis, and public action would emphasize both our Christian and American heritage of liberty. Dioceses and parishes around the country could choose a date in that period for special events that would constitute a great national campaign of teaching and witness for religious liberty.

In addition to this summer's observance, we also urge that the Solemnity of Christ the King—a feast born out of resistance to totalitarian incursions against religious liberty—be a day specifically employed by bishops and priests to preach about religious liberty, both here and abroad.

To all our fellow Catholics, we urge an intensification of your prayers and fasting for a new birth of freedom in our beloved country. We invite you to join us in an urgent prayer for religious liberty.

Almighty God, Father of all nations,
For freedom you have set us free in Christ Jesus (Gal 5:1).
We praise and bless you for the gift of religious liberty,
the foundation of human rights, justice, and the common good.
Grant to our leaders the wisdom to protect and promote our liberties;
By your grace may we have the courage to defend them, for ourselves and for all those who live in this blessed land.
We ask this through the intercession of Mary Immaculate, our patroness,
and in the name of your Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, in the unity of the Holy Spirit,
with whom you live and reign, one God, for ever and ever. Amen.

Acknowledgements

Excerpts from The Documents of Vatican II, Walter M. Abbott, SJ, General Editor, copyright © 1966 by America Press, Inc. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
Excerpt from Pope Benedict XVI, Ad limina address to bishops of the United States, January 19, 2012, copyright © 2012, Libreria Editrice Vaticana, Vatican City. Used with permission. All rights reserved.

Copyright © 2012, United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Washington, DC. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the copyright holder.

The document Our First, Most Cherished Liberty: A Statement on Religious Liberty, was developed by the Ad Hoc Committee for Religious Liberty of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB). It was approved by the Administrative Committee of the USCCB at its March 2012 meeting as a statement of the Committee and has been authorized for publication by the undersigned.

Msgr. Ronny E. Jenkins, JCD
General Secretary, USCCB

Ad Hoc Committee for Religious Liberty

Chairman
Most Rev. William E. Lori, Archbishop-designate of Baltimore
Bishop Members
Cardinal Donald Wuerl, Archbishop of Washington
Most Rev. Charles J. Chaput, OFM Cap, Archbishop of Philadelphia
Most Rev. Wilton D. Gregory, Archbishop of Atlanta
Most Rev. John C. Nienstedt, Archbishop of St. Paul–Minneapolis
Most Rev. Thomas J. Rodi, Archbishop of Mobile
Most Rev. J. Peter Sartain, Archbishop of Seattle
Most Rev. John O. Barres, Bishop of Allentown
Most Rev. Daniel E. Flores, Bishop of Brownsville
Most Rev. Thomas J. Olmsted, Bishop of Phoenix
Most Rev. Thomas J. Paprocki, Bishop of Springfield, IL
Bishop Consultants
Most Rev. José H. Gomez, Archbishop of Los Angeles
Most Rev. Stephen E. Blaire, Bishop of Stockton
Most Rev. Joseph P. McFadden, Bishop of Harrisburg
Most Rev. Richard E. Pates, Bishop of Des Moines
Most Rev. Kevin C. Rhoades, Bishop of Fort Wayne–South Bend

ENDNotes

  1. Cardinal James Gibbons, Address upon taking possession of Santa Maria in Trastevere, March 25, 1887.
  2. Benedict XVI, Ad limina address to bishops of the United States, January 19, 2012.
  3. Most Rev. William E. Lori, Chairman, USCCB Ad Hoc Committee on Religious Liberty, Oral Testimony Before the Judiciary Committee of the United States House of Representatives, February 28, 2012.
  4. Most Rev. Thomas J. Rodi, Archbishop of Mobile, August 1, 2011.
  5. Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations, Statement, January 24, 2012.
  6. James Madison, "Property," March 29, 1792, in The Founding Fathers, eds. Philip B. Kurland and Ralph Lerner (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1987), accessed March 27, 2012. http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/v1ch16s23.html. . . .
  7. James Madison, "Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessment," June 20, 1785, in The Founding Fathers, accessed March 27, 2012. http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/amendI_religions43.html. . . .
  8. Michael Novak and Jana Novak, Washington's God, 2006.
  9. Anson Phelps Stokes, Church and State in the United States (Harper & Brothers Publishers, 1950), 678.
  10. Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School v. EEOC, 565 U.S. ___, 132 S. Ct. 694, 703 (2012).
  11. Martin Luther King Jr., "Letter from Birmingham Jail," April 16, 1963.
  12. Second Vatican Council, Declaration on Religious Liberty (Dignitatis Humanae), no. 2, in The Documents of Vatican II, ed. Walter M. Abbott (New York: Guild Press, 1966).
  13. Letter from Leith Anderson et al. to President Obama, December 21, 2011 (available at www.becketfund.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/To-President-NonCatholics-RelExemptionSigned.pdf. . . ).
  14. Evangelicals and Catholics Together, "In Defense of Religious Freedom," First Things, March 2012.
  15. Cardinal Roger Mahony, "Federal Government Mandate for Contraceptive/Sterilization Coverage," Cardinal Roger Mahony Blogs L.A. (blog), January 20, 2012, cardinalrogermahonyblogsla.blogspot.com/2012/01/federal-government-mandate-for.html. . . .