sábado, 24 de agosto de 2013

Periodista responde a pedido de sentenciado por Wikileaks: "No, Bradley Manning, no eres una mujer"

LONDRES, 23 Ago. 13 / 01:22 pm (ACI).- El periodista Brendan O’Neill criticó a los medios de comunicación que han aceptado el pedido de Bradley Manning, el exagente de inteligencia de Estados Unidos sentenciado por haber filtrado los llamados "WikiLeaks", de ser nombrado en femenino tras anunciar que deseo de vivir como mujer y ser llamado Chelsea.

En una columna publicada en Spiked Online, O’Neill -quien se define como ateo y de izquierda- explicó que "solo porque el Señor Manning diga que es una mujer, no significa que lo sea".

Manning fue condenado el 22 de agosto a 35 años de prisión por filtrar documentos secretos. Ese mismo día informó que se sometería a una terapia hormonal para cambiar de sexo. "Soy Chelsea Manning. Soy una mujer", escribió.

"No, Bradley Manning, no eres una mujer", escribió el periodista editor del sitio web Spiked Online, calificando de "surrealista" que el agente de inteligencia se declarara mujer "cuando eres, de hecho, un hombre".

"Señor Manning, ningún hombre (o mujer) es una isla; usted existe en un mundo donde tenemos nombres para las cosas, donde el lenguaje existe para el propósito de expresar ideas sobre la realidad material, que significa que así como seguramente arriba es arriba, y abajo es abajo, así usted es un hombre", escribió el periodista.

O’Neill indicó que el cambio de nombre de Bradley Manning a Chelsea Manning "es asunto suyo", sin embargo no es aceptable que él diga "que de ahora en adelante quiere que se le trate como una mujer, y se le mencione solo pronombres femeninos".

"Disculpe, pero no", dijo el periodista ateo, "usted no se vuelve una mujer simplemente por decir ‘soy una mujer’. Ese intento de huir de la realidad objetiva, en este caso de la realidad objetiva de ser hombre, es bizarro".

"El nombre de Manning es un asunto solo suyo, pero su sexo no es tan personal, o tan maleable", puntualizó.

El editor de Spiked Online señaló que el sexo de todas las personas "está gobernado por hechos básicos científicos y sociales", por lo que "es el colmo de la arrogancia narcisista esperar que la sociedad se refiera a usted como una mujer simplemente porque usted dice que es una".

"Si yo dijera ‘soy negro, así que de ahora en adelante por favor refiéranse a mí como ‘afro-británico’, la gente se burlaría de mí. ¿Por qué? Porque no soy negro. Y de la misma forma, el Señor Manning no es una mujer".

O’Neill criticó que el diario británico The Guardian haya "accedido ya a este pedido que niega la realidad, diciendo constantemente ‘ella’ en su artículo sobre el cambio de sexo fantasma del Señor Manning".

"A su favor, la BBC no ha cumplido (con el pedido de Manning), mostrando que aún tiene al menos un pie puesto sobre el mundo real, tangible, consciente, al referirse bastante correctamente al Señor Manning como ‘él’".

Para el periodista, "sería anómalamente relativista para los medios de comunicación referirse ahora sobre el Señor Manning como ‘ella’", pues "se supone que los periodistas deben encontrar hechos, reportar al mundo como existe, no comunicar la versión de la realidad de un hombre, tal como fuera esbozada en un comunicado remitido desde la cárcel".

"El pedido de Manning es una muestra de nuestros tiempos terapéuticos, en los que se nos dice constantemente que cómo nos sentimos sobre nosotros mismos es más importante que lo que realmente somos, o lo que realmente hacemos", criticó.

"A los jóvenes se les enseña a adorar su autoestima, a enfocarse en hacerse sentir bien, en vez de lograr algo significativo en el mundo exterior".

Esto, alertó O’Neill, "motiva a la gente a ignorar la realidad, a forjar una obsesión miope con el yo, con el propio ombligo y la imagen y la etiqueta, en vez de relacionarse con el amplio mundo y sus habitantes".

In Germania puoi essere maschio, femmina o X - di Tommaso Scandroglio

In NBQ

Una legge del Parlamento tedesco ha stabilito che da novembre sarà facoltativo indicare nell’atto di nascita il sesso del neonato. Quindi si potrà scrivere Maschio, Femmina oppure lasciare vuota la rispettiva casella. Non solo. Nel caso in cui il piccolo fosse affetto da ermafroditismo – una rarissima patologia a causa della quale un individuo presenta contemporaneamente gonadi maschili e femminili – si potrà segnare nell’apposita casella una X ad indicare, così hanno spiegato i relatori del testo di legge, la condizione di intersessualità. Costui, una volta diventato maggiorenne, potrà scegliere a quale sesso appartenere oppure rimanere sessualmente indeterminato, sospeso in un limbo sessuale a vita.

Si tratta, come appare evidente, di un altro passo della cultura di genere verso l’abisso antropologico. Un passo che assume più significati. In primo luogo il fronte omosessualista ha compreso che il dato biologico – essere geneticamente maschi o femmine – è ineludibile. Dal momento che l’appartenenza ad un sesso rispetto all’altro rappresenta un dato di fatto incancellabile dalle nostre carni come superare l’ostacolo? Semplice: dimentichiamoci che esiste. Ecco perché indicare il sesso del neonato diventerà facoltativo. Il dato genetico può essere omesso, tralasciato: non è al fin fine aspetto così importante da obbligarci a scriverlo su un documento pubblico come l’atto di nascita. Ciò che importa è la percezione di sé come maschio o femmina e questo potrà deciderlo solo il bambino una volta che sarà diventato adulto. L’importante è il genere non il sesso.

Seconda riflessione. C’è un altro modo per aggirare il problema dello status genetico dell’uomo. Stabilire per legge che l’appartenenza al sesso genetico è facoltativa vuole dire relegare la realtà biologica, che è sempre sessuata, ad opzione soggettiva. Non più un elemento empirico da riconoscere, ma un dato da disconoscere se si vuole. Insomma è come dire: non è madre natura a stabilire che io sia biologicamente maschio o femmina, ma la mia volontà. Fino a ieri la cultura di genere sosteneva che siamo biologicamente maschi e femmine, ma nonostante ciò il maschio genetico può percepirsi femmina e viceversa. Qui si compie un passo in più. È la stessa realtà cromosomica che soggiace all’arbitrio dell’uomo. Se ti va puoi far rimanere tuo figlio in uno status indefinito dal punto di vista sessuale non indicando il sesso genetico.

Questa riflessione ci traghetta ad un’altra considerazione che attiene alla possibilità, nel caso in cui venga alla luce un bambino affetto da ermafroditismo, di siglare il suo atto di nascita con una bella X.

L’ermafroditismo è una condizione rarissima, ma al movimento gay poco importa che la fessura nella diga sia sottilissima: l’importante è che esista perché da lì si può far crollare agevolmente tutta la diga. Infatti dietro questa proposta si può intravedere la nuova frontiera della cultura di genere. Come abbiamo recentemente illustrato (“Cambiare sesso. Basta il pensiero”), l’ideologia gender predica che i sessi sono infiniti come i desideri delle persone. Al di là del dato genetico ti puoi sentire maschio, femmina, un po’ maschio e un po’ femmina con quote differenti di mascolinità e femminilità, oppure puoi crearti il tuo sesso particolare che nulla a che vedere con la mascolinità e la femminilità.

Quella X nell’atto di nascita confermerà con tanto di timbro dello Stato che non è vero che esiste solo il sesso maschile e femminile, ma un terzo sesso che è l’insieme dei due precedenti. Questo significa almeno due cose. In primo luogo, come abbiamo accennato, che il dato biologico maschile/femminile può essere superato. E può essere superato non grazie ad elucubrazioni filosofiche: è la stessa natura che ci dice – così potrebbero sostenere i fautori di questa legge – che non esiste solo il sesso femminile e maschile ma anche un “terzo genere”. Quella natura che i cattolici continuamente tirano in ballo per opporsi all’omosessualità, conferma nei fatti i presupposti della cultura di genere.

In secondo luogo oggi la X possiamo metterla solo nel caso appunto di ermafroditismo o di altri casi altrettanto rari di mosaicismo umano e domani invece diventerà obbligatoria, cioè diventerà obbligatorio non scrivere nulla. Infatti mettere una X o nulla è operazione equivalente in fin dei conti dato che la X è un’incognita, cioè un qualcosa su cui nulla si sa. Un nichilismo sessuale. Questo principio è già evidente nel testo di legge presente. Maschio e femmina sono già diventati un optional: un domani il piccolo Gustav potrà decidere di sentirsi Hanna, quindi perché costringerlo sin da piccolo in una condizione che non sarà la sua? La X quindi oggi è eccezione e domani sarà la norma. Tutti alla nascita siamo X e solo dopo decidiamo il nostro orientamento sessuale. Un orientamento sessuale che non riguarda più solo l’aspetto psicologico – la percezione di sé – ma addirittura e in modo utopico ha la pretesa di cambiare la realtà genetica.

Questo è il succo della legge made in Germany. Infatti i sostenitori di questa nuova disciplina hanno tenuto a precisare che la X sta ad indicare la condizione di “intersessualità”. Non si riferiscono quindi ai transessuali – e come potrebbe essere transessuale un neonato? – ma a tutti quei sessi che semplicemente non sono “maschio” e “femmina”, ad iniziare dagli ermafroditi per aprirsi un domani a chissà a quali e a quanti varianti inventate dall’uomo. L’ermafroditismo è quindi quel grimaldello per affermare che il “genere” e non il “sesso” è una realtà biologica e non semplicemente più ideologica: il “genere” non esiste solo nella testa di alcuni fanatici gay, bensì è una realtà genetica. Si tratta quindi di una svolta di ampia portata, non limitata ai casi rarissimi di ermafroditismo. Infatti il ministro della Giustizia, Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger ha affermato che è necessaria una ''ampia riforma'' che investirà molti ambiti da quello anagrafico al diritto di famiglia.

Come rispondere a tutte queste argomentazioni? In realtà aggrapparsi all’ermafroditismo per far passare la cultura di genere si risolve in autogol. Infatti i rarissimi casi di ermafroditismo non mandano a gambe all’aria il dato di realtà che esiste solo il sesso maschile e quello femminile, bensì lo comprova, ne è un’attestazione indiretta. L’ermafroditismo infatti non è un terzo sesso perché anche nel caso di ermafroditismo completo, il soggetto porta in sé cromosomi sia maschili (XY) che femminili (XX). Non porta in sé una inedita coppia di cromosomi, ad esempio ZZ o WZ: questo sì che rappresenterebbe un terzo sesso. La persona ermafrodita è la prova in carne ed ossa che il sesso genetico o è maschile o femminile. Tertium (genus) non datur.

In secondo luogo i firmatari della legge tedesca hanno, forse volutamente, dimenticato che non tutto ciò che è innato è secondo natura. Anche i bambini down nascono con un’alterazione genetica, ma nessuno ha così poco senno da sostenere che, dato che vengono alla luce con questa anomalia, la sindrome di down è un qualcosa di fisiologico, di normale, di naturale. Bensì è una patologia. Così come è una patologia l’ermafroditismo. La X sull’atto di nascita vorrebbe quindi trasformare una malattia in una condizione di normalità, elevare un’anomalia genetica ad una condizione giuridica.


terça-feira, 20 de agosto de 2013

3.8 million human embryos created to produce 122,000 live births – success rate of 3.2% - by Peter Saunders

August 18, 2013 ( PJ Saunders) - The Daily Telegraph this weekend reports on a new expert study which has raised fears that some clinics may be offering techniques that put the embryo at risk for their own profit.
 
The review, carried out by Dr Justin McCracken, the former head of the Health Protection Agency, highlighted a new technique, known as Pre-Implantation Genetic Screening (PGS), as one which is possibly being offered inappropriately for commercial reasons.
 
For a fee, which can run into thousands of pounds, clinics can check embryos created by a successful IVF cycle for certain genetic abnormalities and only implant those that appear normal.
 
The process is becoming especially popular for older couples seeking IVF, because embryos created from their sperm and eggs have a higher chance of abnormalities. As it involves the removal of a cell from an embryo (see picture) it carries some risk for the embryo being tested.
 
Dr McCracken said the jury was still out on whether PGS improves the chances of having a baby and warned there is a risk of harm to the foetus. He said it was vital that the regulator checks that clinics are not simply recommending it to boost profits.
 ‘I understand that there is no clinical consensus regarding its efficacy, but there is a real risk to the embryo in carrying it out.’ (emphasis mine)
This is a somewhat curious statement. Dr McCracken seems (appropriately) concerned about the risk of damage to a few hundred embryos each year undergoing PGS.
 
But he is curiously silent (or perhaps unaware) that over three million embryos have perished or been deliberately destroyed since 1990 as a result of procedures made legal by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act.
 
Liberal Democrat Peer Lord Alton recently asked in parliament how many embryos have been created in each year since the commencement of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990, and how many of these have resulted in live births.
 
Figures given in reply by the Under-Secretary of State at the Department of Health Earl Howe showed that 3,806,699 embryos have been created since 1990. Between 1992 and 2006 a total of 122,043 live births occurred according to figures from the HFEA given alongside his reply (see also here).
 
122,043 live births from 3,806,699 embryos represent a success rate of 3.21%. Or, to put it another way, 3,684,656 embryos never made it to birth.
 
These figures make McCracken’s concern about PGS embryos alone look like what Jesus called ‘straining a gnat whilst swallowing a camel’ (Matthew 23:23-24).
 
In a letter to the Telegraph, as yet unpublished, disability rights advocate Ann Farmer has highlighted the fact that, in addition to the vast wastage of embryos, some women have also died from complications of infertility treatments such as OHSS. She comments:
‘The whole point of the infertility industry is to manufacture babies out of embryos… A car factory that managed to accumulate 3,684,656 surplus models between 1990 and 2012 and in addition killed some of its customers would surely have gone out of business long ago.’
In 1948 the World Medical Association adopted the Declaration of Geneva which included the affirmation, ‘I will maintain the utmost respect for human life from the time of conception, even against threat’.
 
Today’s doctors, it seems, take a contrary view.
 
If you agree with today’s doctors that early human life can be treated as a disposable commodity then the figures that Lord Alton has uncovered (not much short of the current population of New Zealand!) will probably not bother you much at all.
 
But if, like me, you believe that they are special creations made in God’s image, which should be granted respect, wonder, empathy and protection you will no doubt be very concerned indeed.

segunda-feira, 19 de agosto de 2013

Cattolici in tanti partiti, un modello già fallito - di Stefano Fontana

In NBQ

I ventisei parlamentari che hanno scritto ad Avvenire e di cui si è già occupata La Nuova BQ nei giorni scorsi ripropongono lo schema "militare divisi per colpire uniti". Essi hanno rivendicato il merito di aver migliorato il testo della legge sull'omofobia con una trattativa efficace e di averlo fatto come cattolici. In questo modo ripropongono lo schema della collocazione dei cattolici in tutti i partiti per poi convergere uniti in parlamento per contrastare leggi contrarie ai principi non negoziabili. Una riedizione dello storico programma: "marciare divisi per colpire uniti".

Questo schema ha avuto nel recente passato i suoi momenti di gloria. Dopo la fine del partito cattolico di riferimento, mentre si assisteva ad un attacco legislativo alla natura umana mai capitato prima, si consolidò l'idea che i cattolici potessero ormai entrare in ogni partito, basta che poi unissero trasversalmente le loro forze in parlamento. A dire il vero non esisteva una dottrina che legittimasse questa plurima presenza (che un tempo si chiamava diaspora), anzi, la Nota Ratzinger del 2002 diceva chiaramente che il cattolico non può collocarsi indifferentemente in tutti i partiti. Però nella prassi e nel sentire comune questo schema divenne dominante. Tanto è vero, per fare un esempio, che i settimanali cattolici ad ogni appuntamento elettorale intervistano i candidati cattolici presenti in tutti i partiti, da Sel alla Lega.

Se però osserviamo bene, proprio in occasione della legge sull'omofobia, diversamente da quanto sostenuto dai 26 autori della lettera ad Avvenire, l'unità dei diversi, la convergenza in aula di parlamentari cattolici variamente collocati, non si è verificata. Anzi, si è concretizzata una radicale diversità nella valutazione della legge stessa. Secondo una prima interpretazione, la legge Scalfarotto poteva diventare accettabile se il testo fosse stato corretto nel senso di permettere l'espressione per motivi religiosi o morali di valutazioni contrarie all'omosessualità (la cosiddetta clausola di garanzia). In altre parole, il difetto della legge consisterebbe solo nell'impedire la libertà di espressione. Una volta che quest'ultima venisse tutelata da un miglioramento del testo, la legge risulterebbe positiva e accettabile.

Una seconda valutazione, invece,  afferma che la legge comporta il riconoscimento pubblico da parte dello Stato della normalità dell'omosessualità. Con ciò lo Stato si arroga il diritto di cambiare lo statuto della natura umana. In questo modo si distrugge la legge naturale considerando "naturale" l'omosessualità.  Da questo punto di vista, la legge in questione rimane inaccettabile e non votabile in aula da parte di una coscienza cattolica retta.

Come si vede i deputati cattolici sono arrivati alla legge con posizioni molto diverse e quindi non hanno potuto predisporre un piano di intervento unitario. Anche l'essere giunti in ritardo e alla spicciolata, senza un collegamento con chi, nel Paese, si stava mobilitando, è spiegabile con questa diversità di vedute circa la gravità della legge.  Ciò va detto anche in positivo: i deputati che si sono subito mobilitati - e che non figurano nei 26 - lo hanno fatto in virtù di una comprensione diversa del significato negativo della legge in questione.

Si è marciato divisi ma non si è colpito uniti se perdurano divisioni nella stessa valutazione della legge. 

Questa conclusione ci costringe a riconoscere che lo schema della convergenza in aula non regge e che è di corto respiro continuare ad insistervi.  Uno dei motivi di fondo di questo insuccesso consiste nel fatto che la collocazione partitica comporta anche una scelta culturale che finisce per avere alla fine il sopravvento rispetto alle modulazioni della cultura cattolica e della stessa fede.

Appartenere ad un partito non è solo un fatto tecnico, non è come affittare una stanza, ma alla lunga comporta una ricaduta di ritorno che inquina la purezza dell'ottica della fede cattolica nel punto e nel momento in cui si fa cultura.

Queste vicende ci insegnano che bisogna cambiare percorso. Dalla dispersione non verrà mai nessuna unità. Un quadro culturale e politico unitario non emergerà mai dal confronto tra le diverse anime del cattolicesimo, dato che la dispersione della identità cattolica ha raggiunto livelli molto acuti. Bisognerà invertire la direzione, ricominciare da una proposta unitaria e attorno ad essa coagulare convinte e culturalmente strutturate appartenenze.

domingo, 18 de agosto de 2013

Boosters of same-sex parenting rely heavily on sociologists’ surveys. But do these really prove their case? - by Walter R. Schumm

In MercatorNet 



As a sociologist my life is all about creating, taking and interpreting surveys of attitudes and opinions. So I sometimes feel a bit depressed at how knuckle-headed the media can be when reporting about research on same-sex marriage. Let’s look at a slogan which is being repeated over and over: Same-sex parents are just as good at parenting as heterosexuals. This looks simple -- but its simplicity is deceptive. Let me unpack it for you.

What is meant by “same-sex”? 

Two sisters living together to save money, raising children from former husbands who died at a young age? Two bisexual women with children from previous marriages to men? Two lesbians who have each conceived a child by sperm donation? Two gay men who have adopted a child jointly?

Different situations can impact children very differently; thus, it is risky to subsume them all under the one label of “same-sex parent”. Does it mean that one parent had some same-sex experience as a teenager but now is heterosexual? Does it mean that one parent identifies as heterosexual but engages in gay affairs just for the sex? Sexual orientation is defined by attraction, behavior, and identity, with all combinations in between. Does it mean a woman who was raped at age six and became lesbian out of a hatred for her rapist? Does it mean a woman who feels she can be a better mother with another woman at her side rather than a man? Or, are we talking about someone who identifies as a “gay” man because he has found he has no sexual attraction to women or to men?

What is meant by “good”?

Does it mean they are provided adequate nutrition? Does it mean they are growing up with no plans on having sex until they marry? Does it mean they plan on cohabiting before they marry? Are they being raised to believe that they can marry a man or a woman when they marry? To what extent do the children believe in and practice delayed gratification? Are their gender roles distinct from those of the opposite sex? Are they growing up to love and serve God, putting that before personal pleasure or satisfaction? Does it mean they are academically prepared to succeed at the university?

What is meant by “just as”?

Does it mean that in a comparison of two biased non-random convenience samples, small in size, that there was an effect size difference that was moderate in magnitude but not statistically significant? Does it mean that there was a national random sample from which groups were compared with adequate statistical power to detect even small effect sizes? Were appropriate statistics used to make the comparisons?

What is meant by “parenting”?

Does it mean the parent is biologically related to the child? Does it mean that the parent spends only one day every two weeks with the child because of custody disputes? Does it mean that the father is the child’s biological father but the father has long ago disappeared and has not seen the child in the past ten years? Does it mean that the parent is “around” but for all practical purposes the child is being raised by a nanny? Does it mean that the parent has so much money that paid employees are, for all practical purposes, raising the child?

What is meant by “heterosexuals”?

Are these folks legally married? Cohabiting? In a civil union? Is the parent heterosexual but parenting alone because of the death or separation from the other person? Are the parents heterosexuals with a per capita family income (two parents earning $40,000 a year with six children) of a tenth of what the per capita family income of the comparison group (eg, one lesbian parent earning $100,000 a year with one child) happens to be?

What does the research say?

What may look simple on the surface can be pretty complicated. Research has been very limited in the past but is getting better. So what do we know?

First, despite continued denials, it appears that children of gay-lesbian-bisexual (GLB) parents are more likely to grow up to engage in same-sex sexual behavior, at least on an experimental basis, or to identify as GLB, than children of heterosexual parents.

This may be related to the evidence that GLB parents are much more flexible about or tolerant of their children adopting a non-heterosexual orientation than are most heterosexual parents. There is some evidence that sexual behavior by heterosexual children of same-sex parents is less traditional (cohabit sooner, more likely to have sex before marriage).

Second, if same-sex parents have long-term stable relationships, their children may do as well in some areas (psychological adjustment, school success), at least as reported by the parent (we have less information in terms of child reports or independent observers). However, same-sex parents (in contrast to same-sex couples, whose relationships may be as stable) appear to have far less stable relationships than heterosexual married, even cohabiting couples. That is, instability may be a problem for children, for both same-sex and heterosexual families. But the risk is greater for the former and their children on average may be disadvantaged.

Third, there is growing evidence that the gender roles of the children of same-sex couples, including adoptive same-sex couples, are more “flexible”. What that means in practice is that among the children of heterosexuals, the most masculine girl scores well below the average score for boys while the most feminine of boys scores well above the average score for girls. Among the children of same-sex parents, it is not uncommon for the most masculine girls to score above the average for boys and for the most feminine of boys to score below the average for girls (ie, much greater overlap of the distributions, which are also closer to each other).

Fourth, there is growing evidence that the children of same-sex couples may be more likely to use or abuse illegal drugs. This may reflect greater such drug usage by homosexuals in general or may reflect less parental training in delayed gratification by same-sex parents. Evidence is mounting that same-sex persons are more likely to have a background of childhood sexual abuse, which might or might not play into how they parent, if they become parents.

Because of selective reporting by most media, it is likely that most readers have never heard of much of this information.

If parents have a DNA relationship to a child, they take better care of the child. (I am referring to research that live-in boyfriends tend to abuse their girlfriend’s children more than do biological fathers.) In the traditional marriage, both parents have a DNA relationship to all of their children. This creates a quandary in that while we want to be supportive of all families and may need to be more supportive of non-DNA families, we really want as a society overall to encourage parenting by stable-relationship parents who are the biological parents of the child.

Who is doing the heavy lifting?

From another angle, we want to reward those in society who do the most difficult “emotional work”. Anyone who has ever tried living with a member of the opposite sex knows that it is emotional work and that it is not always easy.

There are numerous ways in which gender makes for conflict in heterosexual relationships. In terms of happiness in heterosexual relationships, if there are differences, it is most often that the woman is less happy.

It is clear that one result of no-fault divorce has been the feminization of poverty in which women lose much of their socioeconomic status after a divorce, even though they are more often responsible for the care of the children. If we begin to treat same-sex lesbian marriages as the same as heterosexual ones, what are we really telling young women? Go ahead and marry a man because this is good for society (both of you will have a DNA relationship to the child and your relationship will be more stable, which is good for the child) but you will have to accept the risk of a greater likelihood of being unhappy and of being ruined financially if your unhappiness leads to divorce, not to mention all the gender-related or sexuality-related conflicts you will have to endure even if you do not divorce.

But, we will grant the same benefits and respect to other women who bypass all those risks and dangers by hooking up with another woman. Will not this make women who marry men look and feel a bit like fools?

And what about men?

Research is clear that gay men usually feel OK about sex outside a civil union or marriage, often by mutual consent. How often will a heterosexual married man get “mutual” consent from his wife to have an affair? Some recent research with lesbians has found that some of them look forward to marriage precisely because marriage would make having sex outside the marriage easier on the relationship. This is the exact opposite of what occurs for most heterosexual couples. That is, how many heterosexual women look forward to marriage so their husband can start having sex with other women or so they can start having sex with other men?

In other words, one cost of marriage for heterosexuals is sexual restriction, which may involve personal sacrifice. With same-sex marriage, that social norm will decline further in strength, in my estimation.

Thus, heterosexual men and women are doing what society calls for -- but we will be punishing them for it. It’s like telling a soldier: we need you to go and fight the enemy face-to-face 24 hours a day and to risk maiming and death. But we, in order to be “fair”, are going to grant the same respect, rank, promotions, or veterans benefits and privileges to soldiers who stayed home and worked only eight hours a day out of air conditioned buildings.

The challenge of proving the “harm”

The evidence, including my own research, suggests that same-sex couples are happier than opposite-sex couples. And why not? Sociology can only capture part of the spectrum of human happiness. If a survey defines it as fewer hassles, less conflict over gender-related issues or sexuality issues, more disposable income and less fretting about children, what would you expect?

But if we grant same-sex couples equality, we will create a grander inequality for the far larger proportion of society who accept the “challenges” (ie, the greater risks and costs) of living heterosexually while providing society with greater benefits in terms of greater stability and care for their own biologically-related children.

If you say “prove the harm”, I say, OK, how would you prove harm if all combat pay and decorations were eliminated in order to be “fair” and to create equality for non-combat soldiers? After all, some soldiers may not feel they were “born for” combat, may not feel attracted to it, may feel unsuited for it, yet they are soldiers. Surely they deserve the same respect, honor, and compensation?

If all benefits were “equalized”, and the military found it more difficult to get volunteers for battle, it could always be blamed on something else. If re-enlistment rates went down, it would be blamed on inadequate retention pay. The military could demand that all soldiers face combat. If the soldiers who were forced into combat against their will didn’t perform well, it could be blamed on bad leadership at the unit level.

I am not sure you could ever prove harm to the satisfaction of those who demanded the elimination of all differential pay and benefits for combat veterans versus non-combat veterans.

Proving the “harm” of same-sex marriage is similar. No matter what you find in the research, it will be denigrated and dismissed by those in favor of same-sex marriage. The reality is that US states are aligned on a sexual freedom continuum that includes a number of matters (sex before marriage, cohabitation, same-sex marriage, acceptance of divorce, etc.) related to the so-called Second Demographic Transition. Trying to separate the effects of same-sex marriage from the entire cluster of changes is like asking which bee of the five that stung you did the most damage. No matter what, the other four bees can almost always be blamed more than the fifth bee.

It is my opinion that for a social system to work optimally, everyone should play by the same rules, with a few exceptions (eg, disabilities). Marriage has traditionally meant sexual fidelity, at least in principle. It has meant two people of different genders working through gender conflicts. It has meant two people committing themselves to each other for a lifetime. It has meant having children that are biologically related to both parents or being supportive of others who have such children. It has meant raising children who are not ashamed of being a boy or a girl.

If we are to begin saying that sexual fidelity is not really all that important, that having children is not all that important, that accepting gender role conflicts is something to bypass if possible, that gender roles are not all that important for children, or that long-term relationship stability is not all that important, we are really saying this: people can pick and choose which rules to play by with the right to reject any rules, restrictions, or limits that they don’t like.

Allowing everyone to make up their own rules may sound like a wonderful freedom, but consider what would happen if football was played with no rules or no referees? What if the Geneva Conventions for warfare were handled that way (it’s up to each soldier to follow or not follow them, with no consequences either way)? What if children could choose what homework assignments to do or not do? Even those who are pro-gay recognize this principle latently when they criticize how some places allow same-sex marriage and others do not (ie, the rules/laws change from place to place and are not the same for everybody).

If folks want the same benefits of marriage, they should be willing to play by the same rules. Research tells us that this is not the case at present and logic suggests it may never be. If the rules do not matter any longer or if everyone can make up their own rules as they go along, the meaning of marriage changes substantially from what it has been traditionally.


As a sociologist my life is all about creating, taking and interpreting surveys of attitudes and opinions. So I sometimes feel a bit depressed at how knuckle-headed the media can be when reporting about research on same-sex marriage. Let’s look at a slogan which is being repeated over and over: Same-sex parents are just as good at parenting as heterosexuals. This looks simple -- but its simplicity is deceptive. Let me unpack it for you.
What is meant by “same-sex”?
Two sisters living together to save money, raising children from former husbands who died at a young age? Two bisexual women with children from previous marriages to men? Two lesbians who have each conceived a child by sperm donation? Two gay men who have adopted a child jointly?
Different situations can impact children very differently; thus, it is risky to subsume them all under the one label of “same-sex parent”. Does it mean that one parent had some same-sex experience as a teenager but now is heterosexual? Does it mean that one parent identifies as heterosexual but engages in gay affairs just for the sex? Sexual orientation is defined by attraction, behavior, and identity, with all combinations in between. Does it mean a woman who was raped at age six and became lesbian out of a hatred for her rapist? Does it mean a woman who feels she can be a better mother with another woman at her side rather than a man? Or, are we talking about someone who identifies as a “gay” man because he has found he has no sexual attraction to women or to men?
What is meant by “good”?
Does it mean they are provided adequate nutrition? Does it mean they are growing up with no plans on having sex until they marry? Does it mean they plan on cohabiting before they marry? Are they being raised to believe that they can marry a man or a woman when they marry? To what extent do the children believe in and practice delayed gratification? Are their gender roles distinct from those of the opposite sex? Are they growing up to love and serve God, putting that before personal pleasure or satisfaction? Does it mean they are academically prepared to succeed at the university?
What is meant by “just as”?
Does it mean that in a comparison of two biased non-random convenience samples, small in size, that there was an effect size difference that was moderate in magnitude but not statistically significant? Does it mean that there was a national random sample from which groups were compared with adequate statistical power to detect even small effect sizes? Were appropriate statistics used to make the comparisons?
What is meant by “parenting”?
Does it mean the parent is biologically related to the child? Does it mean that the parent spends only one day every two weeks with the child because of custody disputes? Does it mean that the father is the child’s biological father but the father has long ago disappeared and has not seen the child in the past ten years? Does it mean that the parent is “around” but for all practical purposes the child is being raised by a nanny? Does it mean that the parent has so much money that paid employees are, for all practical purposes, raising the child?
What is meant by “heterosexuals”?
Are these folks legally married? Cohabiting? In a civil union? Is the parent heterosexual but parenting alone because of the death or separation from the other person? Are the parents heterosexuals with a per capita family income (two parents earning $40,000 a year with six children) of a tenth of what the per capita family income of the comparison group (eg, one lesbian parent earning $100,000 a year with one child) happens to be?
What does the research say?
What may look simple on the surface can be pretty complicated. Research has been very limited in the past but is getting better. So what do we know?
First, despite continued denials, it appears that children of gay-lesbian-bisexual (GLB) parents are more likely to grow up to engage in same-sex sexual behavior, at least on an experimental basis, or to identify as GLB, than children of heterosexual parents.
This may be related to the evidence that GLB parents are much more flexible about or tolerant of their children adopting a non-heterosexual orientation than are most heterosexual parents. There is some evidence that sexual behavior by heterosexual children of same-sex parents is less traditional (cohabit sooner, more likely to have sex before marriage).
Second, if same-sex parents have long-term stable relationships, their children may do as well in some areas (psychological adjustment, school success), at least as reported by the parent (we have less information in terms of child reports or independent observers). However, same-sex parents (in contrast to same-sex couples, whose relationships may be as stable) appear to have far less stable relationships than heterosexual married, even cohabiting couples. That is, instability may be a problem for children, for both same-sex and heterosexual families. But the risk is greater for the former and their children on average may be disadvantaged.
Third, there is growing evidence that the gender roles of the children of same-sex couples, including adoptive same-sex couples, are more “flexible”. What that means in practice is that among the children of heterosexuals, the most masculine girl scores well below the average score for boys while the most feminine of boys scores well above the average score for girls. Among the children of same-sex parents, it is not uncommon for the most masculine girls to score above the average for boys and for the most feminine of boys to score below the average for girls (ie, much greater overlap of the distributions, which are also closer to each other).
Fourth, there is growing evidence that the children of same-sex couples may be more likely to use or abuse illegal drugs. This may reflect greater such drug usage by homosexuals in general or may reflect less parental training in delayed gratification by same-sex parents. Evidence is mounting that same-sex persons are more likely to have a background of childhood sexual abuse, which might or might not play into how they parent, if they become parents.
Because of selective reporting by most media, it is likely that most readers have never heard of much of this information.
If parents have a DNA relationship to a child, they take better care of the child. (I am referring to research that live-in boyfriends tend to abuse their girlfriend’s children more than do biological fathers.) In the traditional marriage, both parents have a DNA relationship to all of their children. This creates a quandary in that while we want to be supportive of all families and may need to be more supportive of non-DNA families, we really want as a society overall to encourage parenting by stable-relationship parents who are the biological parents of the child.
Who is doing the heavy lifting?
From another angle, we want to reward those in society who do the most difficult “emotional work”. Anyone who has ever tried living with a member of the opposite sex knows that it is emotional work and that it is not always easy.
There are numerous ways in which gender makes for conflict in heterosexual relationships. In terms of happiness in heterosexual relationships, if there are differences, it is most often that the woman is less happy.
It is clear that one result of no-fault divorce has been the feminization of poverty in which women lose much of their socioeconomic status after a divorce, even though they are more often responsible for the care of the children. If we begin to treat same-sex lesbian marriages as the same as heterosexual ones, what are we really telling young women? Go ahead and marry a man because this is good for society (both of you will have a DNA relationship to the child and your relationship will be more stable, which is good for the child) but you will have to accept the risk of a greater likelihood of being unhappy and of being ruined financially if your unhappiness leads to divorce, not to mention all the gender-related or sexuality-related conflicts you will have to endure even if you do not divorce.
But, we will grant the same benefits and respect to other women who bypass all those risks and dangers by hooking up with another woman. Will not this make women who marry men look and feel a bit like fools?
And what about men?
Research is clear that gay men usually feel OK about sex outside a civil union or marriage, often by mutual consent. How often will a heterosexual married man get “mutual” consent from his wife to have an affair? Some recent research with lesbians has found that some of them look forward to marriage precisely because marriage would make having sex outside the marriage easier on the relationship. This is the exact opposite of what occurs for most heterosexual couples. That is, how many heterosexual women look forward to marriage so their husband can start having sex with other women or so they can start having sex with other men?
In other words, one cost of marriage for heterosexuals is sexual restriction, which may involve personal sacrifice. With same-sex marriage, that social norm will decline further in strength, in my estimation.
Thus, heterosexual men and women are doing what society calls for -- but we will be punishing them for it. It’s like telling a soldier: we need you to go and fight the enemy face-to-face 24 hours a day and to risk maiming and death. But we, in order to be “fair”, are going to grant the same respect, rank, promotions, or veterans benefits and privileges to soldiers who stayed home and worked only eight hours a day out of air conditioned buildings.
The challenge of proving the “harm”
The evidence, including my own research, suggests that same-sex couples are happier than opposite-sex couples. And why not? Sociology can only capture part of the spectrum of human happiness. If a survey defines it as fewer hassles, less conflict over gender-related issues or sexuality issues, more disposable income and less fretting about children, what would you expect?
But if we grant same-sex couples equality, we will create a grander inequality for the far larger proportion of society who accept the “challenges” (ie, the greater risks and costs) of living heterosexually while providing society with greater benefits in terms of greater stability and care for their own biologically-related children.
If you say “prove the harm”, I say, OK, how would you prove harm if all combat pay and decorations were eliminated in order to be “fair” and to create equality for non-combat soldiers? After all, some soldiers may not feel they were “born for” combat, may not feel attracted to it, may feel unsuited for it, yet they are soldiers. Surely they deserve the same respect, honor, and compensation?
If all benefits were “equalized”, and the military found it more difficult to get volunteers for battle, it could always be blamed on something else. If re-enlistment rates went down, it would be blamed on inadequate retention pay. The military could demand that all soldiers face combat. If the soldiers who were forced into combat against their will didn’t perform well, it could be blamed on bad leadership at the unit level.
I am not sure you could ever prove harm to the satisfaction of those who demanded the elimination of all differential pay and benefits for combat veterans versus non-combat veterans.
Proving the “harm” of same-sex marriage is similar. No matter what you find in the research, it will be denigrated and dismissed by those in favor of same-sex marriage. The reality is that US states are aligned on a sexual freedom continuum that includes a number of matters (sex before marriage, cohabitation, same-sex marriage, acceptance of divorce, etc.) related to the so-called Second Demographic Transition. Trying to separate the effects of same-sex marriage from the entire cluster of changes is like asking which bee of the five that stung you did the most damage. No matter what, the other four bees can almost always be blamed more than the fifth bee.
It is my opinion that for a social system to work optimally, everyone should play by the same rules, with a few exceptions (eg, disabilities). Marriage has traditionally meant sexual fidelity, at least in principle. It has meant two people of different genders working through gender conflicts. It has meant two people committing themselves to each other for a lifetime. It has meant having children that are biologically related to both parents or being supportive of others who have such children. It has meant raising children who are not ashamed of being a boy or a girl.
If we are to begin saying that sexual fidelity is not really all that important, that having children is not all that important, that accepting gender role conflicts is something to bypass if possible, that gender roles are not all that important for children, or that long-term relationship stability is not all that important, we are really saying this: people can pick and choose which rules to play by with the right to reject any rules, restrictions, or limits that they don’t like.
Allowing everyone to make up their own rules may sound like a wonderful freedom, but consider what would happen if football was played with no rules or no referees? What if the Geneva Conventions for warfare were handled that way (it’s up to each soldier to follow or not follow them, with no consequences either way)? What if children could choose what homework assignments to do or not do? Even those who are pro-gay recognize this principle latently when they criticize how some places allow same-sex marriage and others do not (ie, the rules/laws change from place to place and are not the same for everybody).
If folks want the same benefits of marriage, they should be willing to play by the same rules. Research tells us that this is not the case at present and logic suggests it may never be. If the rules do not matter any longer or if everyone can make up their own rules as they go along, the meaning of marriage changes substantially from what it has been traditionally.
- See more at: http://www.mercatornet.com/articles/view/unpacking_the_slogans#sthash.ZutCXwtB.dpuf