Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Cristianismo. Mostrar todas as mensagens
Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Cristianismo. Mostrar todas as mensagens

quarta-feira, 26 de março de 2014

Jerusalem's Rational God - by Rodney Stark

In CERC

Modernity developed only in the West — in Europe and North America.  Nowhere else did science and democracy arise; nowhere else was slavery outlawed.  The question is, Why?  The answer — at least the most important answer to that question — is Christianity.

The intellectual revolution that took place in Greece had no impact on most of its neighboring societies — the Persians were no more interested than were the Egyptians.  But Greek philosophy had profound impact among the Jews.  Unlike priests of the religions that dominated most of the world, from early days Jewish theologians were struck by the fact that what their scripture said about God was quite compatible with some aspects of Greek conceptions of a supreme god.  In addition, since they were committed to reasoning about God, the Jews were quick to embrace the Greek concern for valid reasoning.  What emerged was an image of God as not only eternal and immutable but also as conscious, concerned, and rational.  The early Christians fully accepted this image of God.  They also added and emphasized the proposition that our knowledge of God and of his creation is progressive.  Faith in both reason and progress were essential to the rise of the West.

Hellenism and Judaism

At present there is bitter and misguided debate over whether or not Greek thought influenced Jewish theology.  On one side are obvious examples of an extensive intermingling of the two traditions.  On the other side are a host of Jewish scholars who claim that the rabbis who produced the Talmud had very little knowledge of Greek philosophy and despised it:  "Cursed be the man who would breed swine and cursed be the man who would teach his son Greek wisdom."
Whatever the Talmudic rabbis did or didn't know about Greek philosophy seems irrelevant.  Their writings did not begin until the third century AD, and it is certain that in earlier times there was extensive Hellenic influence on Jewish life and theology.  As the twentieth-century historian Morton Smith put it, "The Hellenization extended even to the basic structure of Rabbinic thought."  It was this Hellenized Judaism that influenced early Christian theologians; they had virtually no contact with the Talmudic rabbis, nor any interest in their teachings.
It is important to realize that as early as 200 BC, most Jews lived not in Palestine but in Roman cities — especially the cities dominated by Greek culture.  These communities are known as the Jewish Diaspora (literally: dispersion), and they were home to at least six million Jews, compared with only a million Jews still living in Palestine.  (Several million more Jews lived to the east of Palestine, including a substantial community in Babylon, but little record of them survives and they played little or no role in the rise of the West.) The majority of Jews living in the Hellenized western cities were quite assimilated.  Intermarriage with Gentiles was widespread.  Moreover, the Diasporan Jews read, wrote, spoke, thought, and worshiped in Greek.  Of inscriptions found in the Jewish catacombs in Rome, fewer than 2 percent are in Hebrew or Aramaic, while 74 percent are in Greek and the remainder in Latin.  Most of the Diasporan Jews had Greek names; many of them, Israeli scholar Victor Tcherikover noted, "did not even hesitate to [adopt] names derived from those of Greek deities, such as Apollonius."  As early as the third century BC the religious services held in Diasporan synagogues were conducted in Greek, and so few Diasporan Jews could read Hebrew that it was necessary to translate the Torah into Greek — the Septuagint.
The Hellenization of the Jews was not limited to the Diaspora.  Beginning with Alexander the Great's conquest of the Middle East, Palestine came under the control of Ptolemaic (Greek) Egypt.  This soon led to the founding of twenty-nine Greek cities in Palestine — some of them in Galilee, the two largest of these being Tiberius (on the Sea of Galilee) and Sepphoris, which was only about four miles from Nazareth.  By early in the second century BC, Jerusalem was so transformed into a Greek city that it was known as Antioch-at-Jerusalem.  According to the eminent scholar-theologian Sir Henry Chadwick, "Greek influence reached its height under King Herod (73-04 BC) . . . who built a Greek theatre, amphitheatre, and hippodrome in or near Jerusalem."
In these highly Hellenized social settings it was inevitable that Greek philosophy would influence religious perspectives.  As Chadwick put it:  "As early as Philo, we see that the current intellectual coin of the more literate classes of society is this blend of Stoic ethics with Platonic metaphysics and some Aristotelian logic.  Like the form of Greek spoken in the hellenistic world . . . Philo simply takes it for granted."  Thus, the most revered and influential Jewish leader and writer of the era, Philo of Alexandria (20 BC-AD 50), attempted to interpret the law "through the mirror of Greek philosophy," and he described God in ways that Plato would have found familiar:  "the perfectly pure unsullied Mind of the universe, transcending virtue, transcending knowledge, transcending good itself and the beautiful itself."  According to scholar Erwin R. Goodenough, Philo "read Plato in terms of Moses, and Moses in terms of Plato, to the point he was convinced that each said essentially the same things."
But Philo was wrong.  Although it is true that the Jewish conception of God is consistent with some aspects of the supreme God proposed by Plato, Aristotle, and the other Greek philosophers, the Jewish God is different in important ways.  Like Plato and Aristotle's God, Yahweh is believed to be perfect, eternal, and immutable.  But he is no remote ideal.  He is the loving Creator who is intensely conscious of humankind.  He sees and hears; he communicates; he intervenes.  And it was the fully developed Jewish conception of God, not the remote and inert God of the Greeks or even the God of Philo, that shaped Christian theology and underlay the rise of the West.

Early Christianity and Greek Philosophy

From the start, the early Christian fathers were familiar with Greek philosophy — Paul correctly quoted the Stoic Greek poet Aratus (ca. 315-240 BC) in his impromptu sermon to local philosophers on Mars Hill in Athens (Acts 17:28).  In fact, some early and influential Christian theologians had been trained as philosophers before they converted to Christianity.  And as their conversions testified, the many points of agreement between the philosophers and Christian theology were widely acknowledged.  Clement of Alexandria (ca. 150-ca. 215), who probably was born in Athens and who studied with several philosophical masters before converting, wrote:
Before the advent of the Lord, philosophy was necessary to the Greeks for righteousness . . . being a kind of preparatory training. . . . Perchance, too, philosophy was given to the Greeks directly and primarily, till the Lord should call the Greeks.  For this was a schoolmaster to bring "the Hellenic mind," as the law, the Hebrews, "to Christ."  Philosophy, therefore, was a preparation, paving the way for him who is perfected in Christ.
Perhaps no early church father held Greek philosophy in higher regard than did Justin Martyr (ca. 100-165).  Justin was born into a Greek-speaking pagan family in Samaria, was formally trained in philosophy, and continued to wear his philosopher's cloak even after his conversion to Christianity in about 130.  Eventually he opened a school in Rome where two future church fathers, Irenaeus and Tatian, may have been his students.  Justin was given the surname "Martyr" for having been flogged and beheaded during an outbreak of anti-Christian persecution during the reign of Marcus Aurelius.
Justin held that "the gospel and the best elements in Plato and the Stoics are almost identical ways of apprehending the same truth."  One reason for this close correspondence, according to Justin, was that the Greeks depended immensely on Moses — a view ratified by Philo as well as by Neoplatonist contemporaries of Justin, including Plotinus, who asked, "What is Plato, but Moses in Attic Greek?" In this sense, Justin identified the Jewish prophets and Greek philosophers as "Christians before Christ."  Of course, he and other early Christian thinkers were wrong about the early Greeks having learned from Moses, as Saint Augustine wryly admitted in his City of God.  But that doesn't alter the fact of extensive similarities between Christianity and Platonism.
Justin gave a second reason for the great similarity between Christian theology and Greek philosophy:  both rested on the divine gift of reason, which, he said, "has sown the seeds of truth in all men as beings created in God's image."  And since God's greatest gift to humanity was the power to reason, Christian revelation must be entirely compatible with "the highest Reason."  Consequently, Justin viewed Jesus as a philosopher as well as the son of God, as the personification of "right reason."
To Justin, then, Plato was correct when he conceived of God as outside the universe, timeless, and immutable, and when he said that humans possessed free will.  But Justin, Clement, and other early Christian writers also pointed out many shortcomings in Greek philosophy.  For example, they denied Greek claims that God was remote and impersonal, that souls took up life in a new body, and that lesser gods existed.  And where Greek philosophy and Christianity disagreed, according to Justin, the latter was authoritative, for philosophy was merely human, whereas Christianity was divine — revelation was the ultimate basis of truth.
One problem early Christian writers identified was that none of the numerous divinities in the Greek pantheon was adequate to serve as a conscious creator of a lawful universe, not even Zeus.  Like humans, the Greek gods were subject to the inexorable workings of the natural cycles of all things.  Some Greek scholars, including Aristotle, did posit a god of infinite scope having charge of the universe, but they conceived of this god as essentially an impersonal essence, much like the Chinese Tao.  Such a god lent a certain spiritual aura to a cyclical universe and its ideal, abstract properties, but being an essence, "God" did nothing and never had.
Even when Plato posited a demiurge — an inferior god who served as creator of the world, the supreme God being too remote and spiritual for such an enterprise — this creator paled in contrast with an omnipotent God who made the universe out of nothing.  Moreover, for Plato the universe had been created in accord not with firm operating principles but with ideals.  These primarily consisted of ideal shapes.  Thus the universe must be a sphere because that is the symmetrical and perfect shape, and heavenly bodies must rotate in a circle because that is the motion that is most perfect.  As a priori assumptions, Platonic idealism long impeded discovery:  many centuries later, Copernicus's unshakable belief in ideal shapes prevented him from entertaining the thought that planetary orbits might be elliptical, not circular.
A second problem in Greek philosophy, according to early Christian writers, related to the Greek conception of the universe as not only eternal and uncreated but also locked into endless cycles of progress and decay.  In On the Heavens, Aristotle noted that "the same ideas recur to men not once or twice but over and over again," and in his Politics he pointed out that everything has "been invented several times over in the course of ages, or rather times without number."  Since he was living in a Golden Age, he concluded, the levels of technology of his time were at the maximum attainable level, precluding further progress.  As for inventions, so too for individuals — the same persons would be born again and again as the blind cycles of the universe rolled along.  According to Chrysippus in his now-lost On the Cosmos, the Stoics taught that the "difference between former and actual existences of the same people will be only extrinsic and accidental; such differences do not produce another man as contrasted with his counterpart from a previous world-age."  As for the universe itself, Parmenides held that all perceptions of change are illusions, for the universe is in a static state of perfection, "uncreated and indestructible; for it is complete, immovable, and without end."  Other influential Greeks, such as the Ionians, taught that although the universe is infinite and eternal, it also is subject to endless cycles of succession.  Although Plato saw things a bit differently, he too firmly believed in cycles, that eternal laws caused each Golden Age to be followed by chaos and collapse.
Finally, the early Christians saw that the Greeks insisted on turning the cosmos, and inanimate objects more generally, into living things.  Plato taught that the demiurge had created the cosmos as "a single visible living creature."  Hence the world had a soul, and although "solitary," it was "able by reason of its excellence to bear itself company, needing no other acquaintance or friend but sufficient to itself."  The problem with transforming inanimate objects into living creatures capable of aims, emotions, and desires was that it short-circuited the search for physical theories.  The causes of the motion of objects, for example, were ascribed to motives, not to natural forces.  According to Aristotle, celestial bodies moved in circles because of their affection for this action, and objects fell to the ground "because of their innate love for the centre of the world."
For these reasons, the early Christian fathers did not fully embrace Greek philosophy.  They were content to demonstrate where it supported Christian doctrines and, where there was disagreement, to show how much more rational and satisfying were the Christian views.  Thus the primary effect of Greek philosophy on Christianity had far less to do with doctrines per se than with the commitment of even the earliest Christian theologians to reason and logic.

The Rational Creator of the Cosmos

Justin Martyr was not alone in stressing the authority of reason.  That has been the most fundamental assumption of influential Christian theologians from earliest times.  From the very start the church fathers were forced to reason out the implications of Jesus's teachings, which Jesus did not leave as written scripture.  The precedent for a theology of deduction and inference began with Paul:  "For our knowledge is imperfect and our prophesy is imperfect."
As Tertullian (ca. 160-ca. 225) put it, "Reason is a thing of God, inasmuch as there is nothing which God the Maker of all has not provided, disposed, ordained by reason — nothing which he has not willed should be handled and understood by reason."  This was echoed in The Recognitions, which tradition attributed to Clement of Rome:  "Do not think that we say that these things are only to be received by faith, but also that they are to be asserted by reason.  For indeed it is not safe to commit these things to bare faith without reason, since assuredly truth cannot be without reason."
Hence the immensely influential Saint Augustine (354-430) merely expressed the prevailing wisdom when he held that reason was indispensable to faith:  "Heaven forbid that God should hate in us that by which he made us superior to the animals! Heaven forbid that we should believe in such a way as not to accept or seek reasons, since we could not even believe if we did not possess rational souls."  Augustine added that although it was necessary "for faith to precede reason in certain matters of great moment that cannot yet be grasped, surely the very small portion of reason that persuades us of this must precede faith."
Augustine devoted all of book 8 in his City of God to explicating and assessing the bonds between Greek philosophy and Christianity, placing the primary emphasis on reason as a basis of truth.  He noted that Plato "perfected philosophy" by using reason to prove the existence of God and to deduce many of his aspects from the many observations of order in the universe — such as the predictable movements of the heavenly bodies, the succession of the seasons, and the rise and fall of the tides.
But Augustine recognized something else inherent in Plato's commitment to reason:  Socrates had surpassed his predecessors, Plato had advanced knowledge beyond Socrates, and Christianity was far advanced beyond all the Greeks — clearly philosophy was progressive.  Indeed, some Greek philosophers were inclined to think that history was itself a progressive phenomenon.  Augustine shared that view, stressing that the general trajectory of history is progressive as knowledge accumulates and technology improves.  Scholars have identified this belief as the idea of progress.
By this I do not mean that human progress is inevitable, as Gottfried Leibniz (1646–1716) may have believed, but merely that, at least in the West, there has been a progressive trend, especially in the sphere of technology, and in the widespread agreement that things can be and ought to be made better.  Because humans lead their lives "under the spell of ideas," the idea of progress has marked the path to modernity.

Faith in Progress

A remarkable amount of nonsense has been taught about the idea of progress.  The prolific Cambridge professor J. B. Bury's 1920 book The Idea of Progress dominated opinion for several generations with the message that belief in progress is a recent development, having originated during the eighteenth-century era sometimes called the Enlightenment.  This claim is as mistaken as the notion that science developed despite the barriers religion erected.  The truth is that science arose only because the doctrine of the rational creator of a rational universe made scientific inquiry plausible.  Similarly, the idea of progress was inherent in Jewish conceptions of history and was central to Christian thought from very early days.
The Jews believed that history was progressing toward a golden Messianic Age, when, in the words of the distinguished historian Marjorie Reeves, "a Holy People was expected to reign in Palestine in an era of peace, justice, and plenty, in which the earth would flower in unheard of abundance. . . . The Messianic age is conceived as within history, not beyond it."  Early Christianity fully incorporated Jewish millenarianism and hence a progressive view of history.  There was another aspect to Christian faith in progress as well:  almost without exception, Christian theologians have assumed that the application of reason can yield an increasingly more accurate understanding of God's will.
Augustine noted that there were "certain matters pertaining to the doctrine of salvation that we cannot yet grasp" — but "one day," he added, "we shall be able to do so."  Progress in general was inevitable as well, he supposed.  Augustine wrote:  "Has not the genius of man invented and applied countless astonishing arts, partly the result of necessity, partly the result of exuberant invention, so that this vigour of mind . . . betokens an inexhaustible wealth in the nature which can invent, learn, or employ such arts.  What wonderful — one might say stupefying — advances has human industry made in the arts of weaving and building, of agriculture and navigation!" He likewise celebrated the "skill [that] has been attained in measures and numbers! With what sagacity have the movements and connections of the stars been discovered!" Augustine concluded that all of these advances resulted from the "unspeakable boon" that God conferred on his creation — a "rational nature."
Many other Christian thinkers echoed Augustine's optimism about progress.  In the thirteenth century Gilbert de Tournai wrote, "Never will we find truth if we content ourselves with what is already known. . . . Those things that have been written before us are not laws but guides.  The truth is open to all, for it is not yet totally possessed."  In 1306 Fra Giordano preached in Florence:  "Not all the arts have been found; we shall never see an end to finding them.  Every day one could discover a new art."  But the most notable statement came from Saint Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274) in the Summa Theologica, which stands as a monument to the theology of reason and set the standard for all subsequent Christian theologians.  Because humans could not see into the very essence of things, Aquinas argued, they must reason their way to knowledge, step by step — using the tools of philosophy, especially the principles of logic, to construct theology.
For Augustine, Aquinas, and the others, such views reflected the fundamental Christian premise that God's revelations are always limited to the capacity of humans at that time to comprehend.  In the fourth century Saint John Chrysostom stated that even the seraphim do not see God as he is.  Instead, they see "a condescension accommodated to their nature.  What is this condescension? It is when God appears and makes himself known, not as he is, but in the way one incapable of beholding him is able to look upon him.  In this way God reveals himself proportionately to the weakness of those who behold him."
In addition, with all these thinkers we see the Christian belief in man's rational nature — what Augustine called that "unspeakable boon" — and also in God himself as the epitome of reason.48 Had they seen God as an inexplicable essence, as had the Greek philosophers, the very idea of rational theology — and, more broadly, of progress itself — would have been unthinkable.
The twentieth-century classical scholar Moses I. Finley was quite aware that the European embrace of progress was "unique in human history."  But he seems not to have realized that the idea of progress is profoundly Christian.  The philosopher John Macmurray put it best when he said, "That we think of progress at all shows the extent of the influence of Christianity upon us."

The West and the Rest

To this discussion a qualification must be added:  faith in progress was fundamental to western Christianity.  As for Orthodox Christianity in the Byzantine East, it prohibited both clocks and pipe organs from its churches.
Nor was it only the Orthodox Church that did not embrace the idea of progress.  By looking at other major traditions from the East, we can appreciate the uniqueness of the Western approach.
Consider life under Islam, which arose as a religion and cultural force several centuries after Christianity did.  In 1485 Bayezid II, sultan of the Ottoman Empire and caliph of Islam, outlawed the printing press.  That ban remained in effect throughout the Muslim world for at least the next three centuries.
The sultan's action represented far more than the power of tyrants.  It reflected Muslim commitment to the idea of decline in contrast to the idea of progress.  In addition to the Qur'an, Muslims give great authority to a collection of writings known as Hadith.  These consist of sayings attributed to Muhammad and accounts of his actions.  In the first Hadith Muhammad is quoted as saying:  "Time has come full circle back to where it was on the day when first the heavens and earth were created."  The second Hadith quotes the prophet thus:  "The best generation is my generation, then the ones who follow and then those who follow them."  The Palestinian historian Tarif Khalidi interpreted these passages — which were "both frequently cited and commented upon" by Muslim scholars — to "suggest a universe running down, an imminent end to man and all his works."  They also imply the superior virtue of the past.  In this context, prohibiting the printing press was not surprising, for books written by hand — the standard from the past — would seem inherently better.
Even more important, Islam holds that the universe is inherently irrational — that there is no cause and effect — because everything happens as the direct result of Allah's will at that particular time.  Anything is possible.  Attempts at science, then, are not only foolish but also blasphemous, in that they imply limits to Allah's power and authority.  Therefore, Muslim scholars study law (what does Allah require?), not science.
But what of the "Golden Era" of Muslim science and learning that flourished while Europe languished in the "Dark Ages"? Chapter 4 makes it clear that the "Dark Ages" are a myth.  The "Golden Era" of Islamic science and learning is too.  Some Muslim-occupied societies gave the appearance of sophistication only because of the culture sustained by their subject peoples — Jews and various brands of Christianity (see chapter 14).
Islam's conception of the universe and its resulting opposition to reason, science, and philosophical inquiry have had a profound impact down to the present day.  Muslim societies today are manifestly backward in comparison with those of the West.  As Robert Reilly points out in The Closing of the Muslim Mind, "The Arab world stands near the bottom of every measure of human development; . . . scientific inquiry is nearly moribund in the Islamic world; . . . Spain translates more books in a single year than the entire Arab world has in the past thousand years; . . . some people in Saudi Arabia still refuse to believe man has been to the moon; and . . . some Muslim media present natural disasters like Hurricane Katrina as God's direct retribution."
It is also useful to look at China.  Many historians claim that, until modern times, almost every significant invention was first made in China.  If so, then it also must be admitted that nearly every one of these Chinese inventions was either disregarded or very little exploited; some even were prohibited.  As Jean Gimpel, the French historian of medieval inventions, put it:  "it is a feature of Chinese technology that its great inventions . . . never played a major evolutionary role in Chinese history.
Consider the case of gunpowder.  Whether gunpowder was independently invented in Europe or imported from China is irrelevant.  It is well known that the Chinese had gunpowder by the thirteenth century and even cast a few cannons.  But when Western voyagers reached China in the sixteenth century the Chinese lacked both artillery and firearms, whereas the Europeans had an abundance of both.  The Chinese also invented a mechanical clock, but the court Mandarins soon ordered all of them destroyed.  As a result, when Westerners arrived, nobody in China really knew what time it was.
The reason so many innovations and inventions were abandoned or even outlawed in China had to do with Confucian opposition to change on grounds that the past was greatly superior.  The twelfth-century Mandarin Li Yen-chang captured this viewpoint when he said, "If scholars are made to concentrate their attention solely on the classics and are prevented from slipping into study of the vulgar practices of later generations, then the empire will be fortunate indeed!"
Nothing sums up the importance of the idea of progress better than the story of the great Chinese admiral Zheng He (also Cheng Ho).  In 1405 Zheng He commanded a large Chinese fleet that sailed across the Indian Ocean and reached the coast of East Africa.  His purpose was to display the power of China and to collect exotica — especially unusual animals — for the imperial court.  The voyage was entirely successful, making its way to and from Africa without major mishaps and bringing back a cargo of exotic goods and strange animals, including several giraffes.  In all, Zheng He led seven of these voyages, each of them successfully completed, the last one in 1433 (during which he may have died and been buried at sea).  It is believed that Zheng He's Chinese fleet included several hundred ships and that the major ships dwarfed anything being sailed in the West at this time.
The Chinese flotilla must have awed the occupants of the Indian and African ports it visited, and had the Chinese been so inclined, they could easily have imposed their rule over coastal areas all along their route, just as Westerners were soon to do following Vasco da Gama's Portuguese expedition that reached India in 1498.  Moreover, had Chinese voyaging continued, they might well have sailed around Africa to Europe or across the Pacific to the "New World."
But after 1433 the voyages ceased.  What happened?
The death of Zheng He would not have been enough to halt the voyages completely, given the obvious successes of the previous expeditions and the opportunities at hand.  Instead, a decree came down from the emperor forbidding the construction of any oceangoing ships.  The emperor also had Zheng He's fleet dragged ashore and stripped of useful timbers; the remains were allowed to rot.  Even the plans for such ships were destroyed, and the Chinese attempted to erase all records of Zheng He's voyages.  Soon it was a capital offense to build a seagoing ship (as opposed to junks for sailing along the coast and on the inland waterways).  For good measure, all the exotic animals Zheng He had brought back to the imperial zoo were killed.
Why?  The court Mandarins believed that there was nothing in the outer world of value to China and that any contacts were potentially unsettling to the Confucian social order.  Progress be damned.
Contrast this with the medieval West's eager adoption of technologies that had been invented elsewhere.  As Samuel Lilley wrote in his history of technological progress, "The European Middle Ages collected innovations from all over the world, especially from China, and built them into a new unity which formed the basis of our modern civilization."
These counterexamples to the history of the West expose the weakness of the widely accepted claim that technological progress is pretty much an inevitable product of the times — that, for example, when conditions were right the incandescent bulb and the phonograph would have been invented whether or not Thomas Edison ever existed.  Inventions don't just happen.  Someone has to bring them about, and the likelihood that anyone will attempt to do so is influenced by the extent to which they believe that inventions are possible — that is, the extent to which the culture accepts the idea of progress.
Perhaps of even greater significance is that inventions not only must be made but also must be sufficiently valued to be used.  That is not inevitable either.  What if the phonograph had been outlawed, as the printing press was in the Ottoman Empire?  What if the state had declared a monopoly on the incandescent lightbulb and destroyed all privately produced bulbs, as the Chinese did with iron production in the eleventh century?

The Road to Modernity

Throughout the remainder of the book, we shall see how the Christian conception of God as the rational creator of a comprehensible universe, who therefore expects that humans will become increasingly sophisticated and informed, continually prodded the West along the road to modernity.

terça-feira, 11 de fevereiro de 2014

Spiritual Healing After Sexual Abuse - Dawn Eden interview by John Burger

 In CWR

Dawn Eden sees herself as a missionary. Herself a victim of sexual abuse as a child, abuse that was healed in part through her journey of faith, she now envisions bringing God's healing to other victims, particularly those who are underserved, such as prisoners. 
Eden, a Catholic convert who grew up Jewish, weaves her story of abuse with those of saints who suffered abuse of various kinds. In My Peace I Give You: Healing Sexual Wounds with the Help of the Saints, she offers advice on how victims can heal through learning some of those stories, through prayer, and through forgiveness. 
In an interview with Catholic World Report, the author of the 2006 best-seller The Thrill of the Chaste offers suggestions on how the Church can reach out more effectively to victims of abuse, whether that abuse took place in the Church or in the victim’s very own home. 

CWR: What led you to write this book?
Dawn Eden: I myself am a victim of childhood sexual abuse. For me, when I received the grace of faith in Christ at the age of 31, I was instantly healed of the depression and temptations to suicide that had dogged me since my teens and which I later learned were the effects of post-traumatic stress disorder brought on by the abuse. But what I discovered during my first years as a Christian, during which I was a Protestant, was that although I had experienced this dramatic healing from the worst aftereffects of the abuse, I still had other effects to contend with, including anxiety, flashbacks, and hyper-sensitivity. And my thought as a new Christian was that the fact that I had not yet received healing from these effects meant that I wasn’t fully surrendered, that I didn’t have enough faith. So I blamed myself for my own seeming failure to be living completely within the light of the risen Christ.
Five years after becoming a Christian I made the decision to become Catholic, and I was received into the Church in 2006, at the age of 37. Once I was a Catholic I knew there was nowhere else to go; I was home. And I also instinctively felt from what I understood of the Catholic faith that somehow the wounds I retained from the abuse, these effects had some kind of meaning in Christ, that they weren’t my fault. But I struggled to understand what meaning these wounds might have.
Two things happened in 2010 that led me to a new and deeper healing. The first was an experience I had on an Ignatian retreat, where for the first time I really began to see my own wounds in light of the wounds of Christ. And I realized, with Christ now being glorified and yet retaining his wounds, that if I united my own wounded heart to the wounded and glorified heart of Jesus, then somehow my wounds could become the crack that Christ’s light could get in. This was a revelation for me because all this time I’d been thinking that my wounds separated me from the love of Christ, that they were simply an obstacle. But this insight made me realize that in fact I could actually find healing in Christ not in spite of my wounds but through my wounds. My wounds could lead me to greater intimacy with God through realizing my dependence upon him for everything, and through personally participating in the victory over sin that Jesus won for me through his passion.
The second insight I received in 2010 was when I picked up a book called Modern Saints by Ann Ball, and that’s where I discovered the story of Blessed Laura Vicuña. Ann Ball describes Bl. Laura, as many people do, as another Maria Goretti. Certainly her story is very similar in that she died while still quite young, in the early 20th century. And she died following being brutalized by a man who sought to sexually victimize her. But in reading Bl. Laura’s story, I noticed a difference in that while Maria was brought up in a devout Catholic home so that the abuse she suffered was truly an intrusion upon her sheltered life, Bl. Laura lived with an abuser for three years. She was abused by her mother’s lover.
And this was very similar to my own experiences as a child. After my mother’s divorce, I was raised by my mother; I was made to live in what was truly a sexually porous environment where I was not protected from adult nudity, from pornography, from graphic sex talk, and where I too was molested by one of my mother’s boyfriends.
What’s more, whereas Maria Goretti, on her deathbed, heroically forgave her abuser, Laura did something additional that was particularly meaningful for me because besides forgiving her abuser, she forgave her mother, who enabled the abuse. She actually offered her life for her mother’s conversion. When I read that, I broke down crying because I realized how relevant it was for me, as I was still needing to forgive my mother for not protecting me. Then I thought if Laura’s story was so healing for me, imagine how it would be for others. And I realized how relevant it would be for others because statistics show that if a child is living in a household where the father is not present and where there is a man in the household who is not the child’s father, that child is 33 times more likely to suffer sexual abuse than in a household where the father is present. So in that sense, Bl. Laura’s story was really modern, with modern relevance, and that was the direct inspiration for my wanting to write a book on healing from childhood sexual abuse through the lives of saints who have suffered such abuse. 

CWR: How can saints help a person overcome the effects of abuse?
Eden: I would say the most common toxic effect of childhood sexual abuse is the misplaced guilt that the child is likely to carry throughout life unless the victim makes a concrete and persevering effort to counter it. Children tend to blame themselves for the evil that others perpetrate upon them. In some ways this misplaced shame and guilt is a survival mechanism, because if the child is abused by a parent or guardian, or if a parent or guardian in some way is enabling the abuse by not protecting the child, then the child may still think, “As bad as my situation is, if this guardian goes away, I will have nobody to protect me.” So, subconsciously, the child thinks, “Therefore I can’t blame my parents or guardian; I have to just blame myself and say I must have wanted it.”
When the adult who has internalized this misplaced guilt learns there is a saint who suffered similar wounds and whom the Church now acknowledges to be in heaven, then the adult can begin to feel free of this guilt and realize “I couldn’t have been responsible for this abuse. This abuse could not have been my sin.” 

CWR: How did you choose which saints to focus on?
Eden: The first thing I did was look for saints who had suffered childhood sexual abuse, and in doing so I looked for saints whose stories were well documented. For that reason I left out St. Dymphna, although she is a very popular saint and I have met people who experienced healing through her intercession. But anyone who tries to find literature on St. Dymphna will discover that all we have are legends.
Now, legends don’t mean that this person didn’t live or wasn’t heroic. But what it does mean is that this person’s story was likely in some way embellished over time—to the point that we can’t say with certainty that these events happened in a particular way, or we can’t verify particular details.
I wanted, rather, for people reading these stories to know that these things really happened. And that’s important too because victims are often told by people who were around at the time of the abuse, “Oh that didn’t really happen. Nobody remembers it in that way.” So to be able to point to saints’ lives and say, “This thing happened to this saint,” and this was independently verified, it helps to validate victims’ own experiences.
Second of all, I looked for saints who had experienced any kind of trauma because most people who have suffered childhood sexual abuse will experience some effect of trauma. It’s important to note that not everyone who has suffered childhood sexual abuse will experience post-traumatic stress disorder. PTSD is a constellation of symptoms, and only a minority will have that full-blown disorder. But if you meet anyone who has suffered childhood sexual abuse it is likely that he or she will have experienced at least one PTSD symptom, such as anxiety, depression, temptation to self-harm, flashbacks, hyper-sensitivity.
So saints who have suffered any kind of trauma often provide for us models of coping with the effects of the abuse. In this sense, even saints who didn’t suffer sexual abuse, such as Ignatius of Loyola or Thérèse of Lisieux, can yet teach us a great deal through their lives and spirituality. 

CWR: What do you hope this book will accomplish? How can it be used to help victims?
Eden: The voice that I use in the book is directly speaking to adults who were victimized in childhood, but the overall structure of the book is really designed to provide a model for priests and pastoral caregivers in walking with victims. We live in a “Band-Aid” culture, and what little outreach we have towards victims of abuse tends to be focused on bringing them instant healing. For example, we might have charismatic-type healing Masses or retreat weekends, which are designed to bring victims an infusion of the Holy Spirit that will just turn them around in one night or weekend. Now, I don’t mean, by singling these things out, to say we shouldn’t have such outreach at all. Any effort by Catholics to reach out to the wounded is better than nothing. What’s more, certainly, dramatic healings can happen, and I can vouch for that fact since, as I said, when I first received the grace of Christian faith, I was instantly healed of the temptation to self-harm. And that was huge for me. But after that instant healing there were still effects that remained in me, and without a solid understanding of what the Church teaches on redemptive suffering, the fact that I wasn’t instantly healed of some of my effects actually, unfortunately, led me to blame myself for the effects that remained in me.
And that’s the problem with the “Band-Aid” approach, when we rely too heavily on this idea that grace is going to immediately change the whole person.
What we need to do instead is remember what St. Thomas Aquinas says in the first question of his Summa Theologiae, that grace does not destroy nature. Grace perfects nature, and while we certainly should ask God for healing in faith, we should remember that God does not normally heal every aspect of any illness in a second, in an instant. God’s normal way of working is to plant seeds in us, which unfolds over time. So the priest or pastoral caregiver is to truly, through his or her ministry, participate in the unfolding of God’s grace in the victim’s heart, then this priest or pastoral caregiver needs to himself be patient with God’s grace and to help the victim recognize the incremental steps through which we become conscious of our identity as sons and daughters of God.
It’s those steps that I delineate in the book, and I use the examples of saints to help the victim progress and the pastoral caregiver to walk with the victim to enable God’s healing to unfold over time.
I’m very interested in speaking to prisoners and groups of people who are in recovery. I’ve made a personal consecration of my celibacy to the Sacred Heart of Jesus through the Immaculate Heart of Mary, and I’m in the process of requesting to be called to a diocesan consecration. So my hope is that God is going to use me in a deeper way as a missionary of God’s healing to vulnerable and underserved populations. I have a small fund set up for transportation to prisons and other places where I might be able to do missionary talks. I’ve already spoken to prisoners in Philadelphia and to women convicted of prostitution who are in a rehabilitation program. 

CWR: What can the average Catholic do if he or she encounters someone struggling with a past marked by sexual abuse?
Eden: The first thing is to weep with those who weep. Normally, our first instinct is simply to solve the problem, to push the person to look beyond their pain. But it’s much more helpful to really be present for the person who is suffering, to acknowledge their pain, to affirm that what was done to that person was wrong.
Second, and very importantly, we should pray for that person. And third, when the person is ready, we can do what’s in our power to help that person find both a competent spiritual director who has experience with victims of abuse, and a therapist, preferably a Catholic therapist. In my book, I do recommend both therapy and spiritual direction for victims, and I emphasize the importance of finding a therapist who either is Catholic or at least respects one’s Catholic faith. 

CWR: You became a Catholic in 2006, at the height of the sexual abuse scandal. Was that a hurdle for you, in coming into a Church that was depicted in the media, at least, as full of abusive priests and enabling bishops?
Eden: It did at first make me suspicious of the Church, which is one of the reasons why I delayed entering, because I received Christian faith in 1999, and the scandal broke in 2002. I remember asking Catholics at the time of the scandal about how they could be part of a Church that had these evils within it, and I remember being surprised by the response of my Catholic friends, that they were just as furious about the abuse as anyone. From the way the news reported things, I had just assumed that all Catholics were like Bill Donohue [president of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights], simply circling the wagons and assuming that every single accusation against a priest had to be a malicious lie invented by the media or people out to get money from the Church.
So, learning that Catholics themselves were grieving over the abuse itself—not just grieving that the abuse was exposed but that it had actually taken place—helped me become more open to entering the Church.
What really won me was the Church’s consistent witness for the dignity of human life, because abuse is a very soul-destroying experience. It’s a kind of murder. For someone to abuse another person—especially to abuse a child—the abuser has to, in his or her heart, really deny the humanity of this child and just look at the child as an object. So when I saw the Church’s love for human life at every stage, particularly the Church’s unceasing affirmation of the dignity of life in the womb, that was what made me realize that only the truth proclaimed by the Church was capable of protecting children from abuse. The fact that sinful, fallen human beings who are members of the Church yet disobey God’s law does not take away from the truth of the law as proclaimed by the Church. 

CWR: You said earlier that the structure of your new book is “designed to provide a model for priests and pastoral caregivers in walking with victims.” Do you think victims are able to trust priests in the Catholic Church to help them overcome sexual abuse, after such a barrage in the media following the Boston scandal in 2002?
Eden: The best answer I can give you is what a friend said to me recently about the experience of his mother, who left the Church as a teenager after being treated uncharitably by a priest, and returned as an adult. He said it takes just one bad priest to run someone out of the Church, but it takes just one good priest to bring someone back in. And I think that’s exactly right. But most of all, it takes prayer, from all the members of the Mystical Body, for the return of the lost sheep. 

CWR: What are your thoughts on how the Church has responded to the problem of abusive clergy and the cover-up that took place in various dioceses?
Eden: I think there are certain aspects of the response that are very good; for example, the emphasis that any and all abuse by a representative of the Church needs to be reported, not only to the Church but also to the proper authorities.
I think that also there are certain elements of the Dallas Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People that are very positive and needed, such as that a diocesan commission needs to investigate any and all claims of abuse.
At the same time I believe that so much more needs to be done. For one thing, recent cases such as occurred with Bishop [Robert] Finn [of Kansas City, Mo.] show that we need to follow what rules we have in place. This also came up with the recent case with the archbishop of Minneapolis-St. Paul [local media have reported failures by the archdiocese in dealing with clergy who sexually abused children]. We badly need to follow our own rules because the rules are only as good as the observance of them.
What little outreach we’ve had to victims needs to be dramatically improved. First of all, as was pointed out by a victim at the first Vatican conference on abuse, which was held in 2012, it’s very important that we offer spiritual help to victims. Right now, if someone contacts the victim assistance program of a diocese, the victim will be offered psychological help but very little, if any, spiritual help. If we’re not offering spiritual help, we’re not being Church because anyone who is a victim of evil needs to know that God did not will that evil for them, and that God loves them. And how much truer is this for someone who’s been abused by a representative of the Church. So much improvement needs to be done in the area of spiritual help.
Secondly, what little outreach we have to victims is mostly to victims of clergy abuse. It’s understandable that that should be our first priority, but it shouldn’t be our only priority. Here, Bill Donahue is right, in that while we should not at all minimize the grave evil of clergy abuse, it’s true that only a tiny percentage of child sexual abuse is committed by clergy or religious. About half of all childhood sexual abuse takes place in the child’s own home, and the rest of the abuse takes place usually in the private home of a neighbor or family friend or is committed by a teacher or someone else who has the opportunity to be in close proximity to the child, or by a peer.
So if we’re only reaching out to those people who have been victims of clergy abuse, we’re failing to bring the healing of Christ to a large number of people who need it.
Now the statistics on sexual abuse are very under-reported because of the misplaced guilt and shame associated with such abuse. They’re also under-reported because given the comprehensive sexual education that we now have, children are taught from an early age that it’s natural for them to act out sexually. So many people grow up being abused who don’t even mentally write what was done to them as abuse. So when you hear the statistics, which are still quite high—that one out of four women and one out of six adult men report having been sexually abused in childhood—you have to wonder if those numbers aren’t higher, which, I’m sure they are.
And second, those numbers only refer to what is referred to as contact sexual abuse. There are a far greater number of people who have been victimized in childhood by non-contact sexual abuse, such as exposure to pornography, intentional exposure to adult nudity or to graphic sex talk. These things all can have lasting toxic effects when perpetrated upon a child. Just think about some of the things children see on television, including all the sexual violence that you can see day or night on TV. We’re a culture that has grown up with deep wounds. If the Church is going to be Church, we have to come up with a vocabulary for affirming that people are wounded, and pointing them toward the healing that can only be found in Christ. 

CWR: Your first book dealt with chastity. Have you heard of ways in which it has helped young people lead chaste lives?
Eden: The response to The Thrill of the Chaste has been deeply gratifying for me. I still hear very often from people who have read it whose lives were positively affected by it. Perhaps the most beautiful experience of it was when a reader from Ireland invited me to her wedding. I went, and at the end of the speeches, when the bride was speaking, she said none of this would have been possible were it not for one woman here, who wrote this book, because she had been living away from her Catholic faith. Reading The Thrill of the Chaste brought her back to the practice of the faith, motivated her to become a speaker with an Irish-based group called Pure at Heart, which promotes chastity, and then it was through her chastity and pro-life activism that she met her husband, who is also a prominent supporter of pro-life causes in Ireland. It’s very rare for someone, within her own lifetime, to have the opportunity to see the ripple effects of the good things she has put into this world. So that for me was a special gift and grace. 

CWR: What do you think of the way or ways the Church is responding to our sometimes hyper-sexualized culture?
Eden: There’s a need for more artists and writers and media producers to create entertainment that reflects the Catholic world view. Certainly Barbara Nicolosi Harrington[founder of Act One, a training program for Christian screenwriters in Hollywood] is a leader in this regard, and I highly recommend the Internet sitcom Ordinary, which is a Catholic sitcom about the life of a new priest in a parish. It’s done not like those Hallmark Hall of Fame, syrupy shows but with the same kind of entertainment value as TV shows like The Office or Community but without the obscenities or gratuitous sex or violence of such shows.
But we need much more of this because people can really be converted through good books. I was converted through a novel, when a rock musician I was interviewing recommended the novel The Man Who Was Thursday, by G.K. Chesterton. So the more that we make a concerted effort to produce good art that is informed by our Catholic faith, the more we will find ourselves evangelizing the culture in important and needed ways. 

CWR: Let me ask you about your name, Dawn Eden. Is it a pen name?
Eden: My birth certificate says Dawn Eden Goldstein. I was born in 1968, the time of “flower power” (it was the same year as Humanae Vitae as well). My parents liked the sound of the name Dawn Eden. So with the name Dawn Eden as my first and middle name, as a teenager, I realized that it made a good pen name, and so I’ve been calling myself that ever since. 

CWR: When you became a Catholic, did you add another?
Eden: I took the Confirmation name Lucy, not only after the martyr, St. Lucy, but also after St. Lucy Filippini. I’d been really touched by the holiness of a Filippini sister I’d met who had co-written a biography of St. Lucy Filippini, Forever Yes, and I was inspired reading that biography. 

CWR: Besides writing books, what are you doing these days?
Eden: I’m currently a full-time graduate student in theology at the Pontifical Faculty of the Immaculate Conception at the Dominican House of Studies in Washington. I’m finishing up a Sacred Theology Licentiate, which is a pre-requisite that I need to do a Sacred Theology Doctorate in Rome. My hope is to be a professor at a Catholic college. I’m doing my STL on St. Thomas Aquinas and John Paul II on redemptive suffering and looking at how the suffering that we undergo in this life, when united to Jesus’ passion, helps to dispose us for the life of the resurrection. 

CWR: In the book, you describe growing up in a Jewish family where you had heard arguments against belief in Jesus of Nazareth as the Messiah. Later you became a Christian and still later, a Catholic. What was it that convinced you that the arguments you had heard growing up were not true?
Eden: I was basically Evangelical. I became Christian through a local community church that was Adventist. I asked the pastor if I could just get a generic baptism—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit—and not have to take the Adventist vows.
I really have to thank my mother for sowing the seeds of my conversion. Although my walk with my mother has included the need to forgive her (I should add, by the way, that my mother does not remember all the things that I remember, but those things that she remembers she deeply regrets), by some mystery, it’s also through my mother that I became disposed to faith in Christ—through my mother’s witness—because when I was a teenager and an agnostic it was right at the time that I began to lose my Jewish faith that my mother had a conversion and entered the Catholic Church. She ended up not identifying as Catholic for long, but she retained faith in Christ. Hearing her speak about Jesus as the fulfillment of the promises made to the Jews helped me to overcome obstacles I might have.
Also I really saw that Christian faith effected a transformation in my mother so that she found a certain kind of ground to stand on that she hadn’t had before. She had really been searching all her life and had gone through all of these different New Age beliefs and experimented with different faith traditions before finding the truth of Christ and really accepting Jesus as the Messiah who was promised.
So just seeing the change that faith worked in her made me desire to have that same change in me, even though it took 15 years after my mother’s conversion before I could be fully open to that grace of conversion myself. 

CWR: Are there aspects of your Judaism that survive in your life as a Christian?
Eden: When I first became a Christian I was drawn to the branch of Protestantism that calls itself Messianic Judaism. In this area I was very influenced by my mother, who herself had come to identify as a messianic Jew. Even as a new Catholic I was initially sympathetic to people who were arguing that we needed more Jewish-style prayers in Catholic devotional life and that sort of thing.
Since becoming a Catholic, I’ve learned that there is not just one rite of the liturgy; we have many rites that have been approved, not just the Roman Rite but other rites which are more ancient—the Eastern rites. And what I’ve come to believe is that, with regard to the Catholic prayer life as it has organically developed through the different rites, if you rightly understand what it is that we pray, it is the complete fulfillment of Jewish prayer and it does not need any kind of Jewish prayer to be extrinsically laid upon it. The Catholic Mass, even in its most modern form, as the Mass of Paul VI, when it’s reverently celebrated, fulfills all the aspects of Torah and Temple sacrifice that Moses and the prophets preached about and that God revealed to them. And so I do believe that Catholic prayer life as it stands in the liturgy books is a perfect fulfillment of Jewish faith.
Where I believe the Church has room to improve is in the reception of the Second Vatican Council’s document on relations with non-Christian religions. Nostra Aetate is a tremendously important document that takes in the most essential aspects of Catholic doctrine from the Council of Trent, as well as before and since, and places them in a framework that is relevant to contemporary concerns. Everyone should study this document and really internalize it, in terms of their understanding of the relationship of Jewish faith and Jewish people to Christians, and I think that in this respect Pope Francis is really going to move us forward. 

CWR: You don’t think Nostra Aetate has been fully received by the laity?
Eden: No, it hasn’t. We still suffer from various errors. On the one hand, there’s the extreme replacement theology, a kind of extreme supersessionism, which teaches that because the Church is the New Israel, therefore all God’s promises to the Jews are void, and the Jews are simply enemies of Christ. This is the kind of theology that you see espoused by E. Michael Jones and his supporters, and the Society of St. Pius X, very sadly and tragically. It’s an ideology that has unfortunately been a source of schism in the Church.
On the other side you have ideas like that which were propounded in the early 2000s, in a USCCB document on relationships with the Jewish people, and this document was since corrected, I think, through the intervention of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. This other side makes a dual-covenant claim, which is that the Jews have their covenant and we have ours, and if we just leave the Jews alone, then they’ll be saved. And that’s simply not true, and that’s not what the Council teaches. And here is where a right understanding of what Pope Francis is now teaching in his new apostolic exhortation, would be very helpful. Because when the Pope says we are not to proselytize, he doesn’t mean we are not to evangelize. When the Church speaks about not proselytizing Jews, for example, it’s speaking about not singling out Jewish people the way that Jews for Jesus does, for example—not drawing a bull’s eye on someone and saying, “You need to be saved because you are Jewish.” Rather, we evangelize by saying that everyone needs the Good News.  And we can adapt our style of evangelization to different cultures, to their needs, but we will not just say any one particular people who are outside the Catholic Church are in any more need of salvation than any other people outside the Church.