Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Paternidade. Mostrar todas as mensagens
Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Paternidade. Mostrar todas as mensagens

quinta-feira, 16 de janeiro de 2014

Homossexuais contra co-adopção: «Soy homosexual, no gay»: testimonio de Jean-Pier en la manifestación pro-familia de Roma

In ReL

El sábado 11 de enero en Roma tuvo lugar una manifestación en defensa de la familia, la primera organizada por La Manif Pour Tous Italia (www.lamanifpourtous.it) en la que participaron más de 4.000 personas.

Publicamos a continuación de forma íntegra el discurso de Jean-Pier Delaume-Myard, francés, un hombre con sentimientos homosexuales y que se define como homosexual, pero que está en contra de redefinir el matrimonio y de que se entreguen niños a parejas del mismo sexo, privándoles de la posibilidad de crecer con un padre y una madre.

Discurso de Jean-Pier Delaume-Myard,
Roma, 11 de enero de 2014

Queridos amigos, ¡buenas tardes a todos! Desgraciadamente no tengo la suerte de hablar vuestro bello idioma, por lo que os ruego que me permitáis hablar en francés. Soy muy feliz y es para mí un honor estar aquí en Italia, junto a vosotros, con La Manif pour Tous Italia.

Lo que nos reúne hoy aquí es el valor fundamental de la familia. Nosotros mismos formamos una bonita y gran familia que va más allá de las fronteras nacionales, porque la familia es una y universal.

Que se hable de esto aquí, en vuestro país Italia, como en el nuestro Francia, o en otros países europeos o en todo el mundo, no importa. De hecho, me gustaría recordar a mi amigo Bobby que lucha como nosotros en los Estados Unidos contra los lobbies gais porque no queremos que la mujer sea considerada una mercancía, no queremos que los niños sean privados voluntariamente de un padre o de una madre, o de ambos.

Conozco un poco Italia. He tenido ocasión de venir varias veces, en circunstancias distintas. La primera vez fue en 1981, después de una grave enfermedad que me había trastornado durante mi adolescencia. Para dar gracias al Señor por haberla superado fui a San Damiano, dónde aún vivía Mama Rosa que había visto a la Virgen María. Después tuve la suerte de venir a Roma para participar en una audiencia privada con el Papa Juan Pablo II. Pero he venido también en otras ocasiones. El vínculo que me une a Italia es también de tipo afectivo; de hecho, viví 8 años con un amigo italiano.

En el mes de noviembre de 2012, en Francia los medios de comunicación anunciaron que todas las personas homosexuales estaban a favor del matrimonio entre personas del mismo sexo y que todos los homosexuales querían hijos.

En realidad me estaban robando mi voz, estaban robando nuestra voz, de nosotros homosexuales que no habíamos pedido nada de todo esto.

Por este motivo decidí coger papel y bolígrafo como un simple ciudadano y escribir en el sitio web de una conocida publicación semanal francesa: Le Nouvel Observateur.

Ese artículo, titulado “Soy homosexual, no gay: ¡detened esta confusión!” dio la vuelta rápidamente en la red con más de 110.000 visitas.

En el artículo escribo, entre otras cosas, que “no estoy orgulloso de mi orientación sexual, no más de lo que un hetero lo esté de la suya».

Quiero recordar claramente que “los gais hacen referencia a una cultura, a un estilo de vida. Necesitan que su carnicero, su panadero, su kiosquero sean gais. Quieren vivir con otros gais… Yo, como homosexual y como individuo de una nación, he elegido siempre habitar y actuar sin preocuparme de la orientación sexual de mis vecinos o de mis compañeros de trabajo”.

En el artículo planteo también una pregunta importante: “¿Por qué quieren una ley en favor del matrimonio entre personas del mismo sexo? ¿Para las personas homosexuales o para los centenares de “gais” que viven en las zonas chic de París?”.

Después de esto hemos fundado un colectivo llamado HomoVox (www.homovox.com) que reúne a centenares y centenares de homosexuales que se oponen a la ley sobre el matrimonio gay.

He tenido la posibilidad de dar un testimonio en video y la he aceptado de buen grado. Después de tantos artículos y testimonios, el 25 de enero de 2012 me reuní con el Presidente de la República Francesa.

Cuando le dije que la ley sobre los matrimonios gais era en realidad el árbol detrás del cual se escondía el bosque de la maternidad subrogada y de la reproducción medicamente asistida, él me respondió: “No soy para nada favorable a esto y me expresaré en contra”.

En Francia tenemos serias dudas sobre esta cuestión. Sabemos que en ocasión de la presentación de la proxima ley sobre la familia, en marzo, algunos diputados de la actual mayoría depositarán enmiendas en favor de la reproducción medicamente asistida y de la maternidad subrogada.

Como homosexual, desde el principio de mi compromiso, no trabajo en favor de un partido político y menos aún en favor de una comunidad; a mí no me gusta el comunitarismo. Combato en conciencia y con todas mis fuerzas para que cada niño tenga un padre y una madre.

Si yo fuera heterosexual, habría perseguido el mismo fin, es decir, ¡el de la racionalidad!

Mi compromiso no tiene nada que ver con mi orientación sexual.

Me he comprometido porque si uno tiene un mínimo de compasión por los seres humanos, ciertamente no se puede aceptar que un niño se quede sin puntos de referencia sociales.

Me he comprometido porque si dentro de veinte años me encontrase con un chico o una chica, hijo de una pareja del mismo sexo, no quiero que me reproche por haberle privado de la posibilidad de tener un padre o una madre, como cada niño, hijo de una pareja divorciada, de una pareja de hecho o casada. ¡Para todos son necesarios un padre y una madre!

Me he comprometido porque mi deseo de tener hijos no tiene que tener como consecuencia la llegada al mundo de un niño sin el afecto materno.

Me he comprometido porque, como persona responsable, no quiero tener que responder un día a mi hijo, cuando me pregunte quién era su madre, que su identidad no es distinta al número de un cheque.

En Francia, La Manif Pour Tous no sólo es víctima de discriminación, sino que es objeto también de graves violencias por parte de la policía o de duras condenas judiciales. Estoy pensando en Nicolas, un joven de 23 años detenido el 19 de junio de 2013 por llevar puesta una sudadera de La Manif Pour Tous en los Campos Elíseos y condenado a ¡dos meses de cárcel!

Las Autoridades de mi país no han querido oir la voz de una petición que había recogido ¡700.000 firmas!

En Francia la ley que abre al matrimonio de las parejas del mismo sexo ha sido votada deprisa a mano alzada en su segunda lectura ¡con el fin de preservar la paz social!

En Francia las más altas autoridades han declarado que éramos 300.000 personas, cuando en realidad se han manifestado más de ¡un millón de ciudadanos!

Quisiera también aprovechar esta ocasión para dar las gracias de parte de La Manif Pour Tous a uno de vuestros connacionales, Luca Volontè, antes Presidente del PPE en Estrasburgo.

Gracias a uno de vosotros, queridos amigos italianos, el comité de los ministros del Consejo de Europa ha planteado con fecha 23 de abril de 2013 una pregunta al Gobierno francés acerca de la gestión de las manifestaciones en favor de la familia y ha pedido con insistencia al Gobierno que dé explicaciones. Cosa inédita en la patria de los derechos del hombre. Gracias Sr. Luca Volontè.

Si mañana en Francia o en Italia se aprobaran la maternidad subrogada o la reproducción asistida, desgraciadamente no seremos nosotros quienes pagaremos las consecuencias. Las pagarán, ante todo, los mismos niños, privados del derecho legítimo a la filiación directa. Les privaremos del derecho a tener un padre y una madre.

Pagarán las consecuencias los mismos homosexuales, porque son estas mismas leyes las que están creando la homofobia, no los que se manifiestan.

Hoy no tenemos necesidad de llevar puesto una vestido de novia para tener los mismos derechos.

El deseo de tener un hijo es una realidad singular y dolorosa. Yo lo sé. Pero nosotros homosexuales no pedimos a la sociedad un bricolaje legislativo para cambiar la realidad.

La política del gobierno francés no tiene otro objetivo más que el de matar a la Familia. El gobierno “familiafóbico” mata a la familia.

La Manif Pour Tous en Francia sigue pidiendo la abrogación de la ley que autoriza el matrimonio entre personas del mismo sexo.

Además de la necesaria abrogación de dicha ley, proponemos que se reconozca la filiación en el seno de la familia. Un niño no es una mercancía de trueque ni carne de cañón; es un ser humano que tiene el derecho de conocer el origen cultural, geográfico, social y religioso de sus padres.

En lo que respecta las próximas elecciones europeas, recordaremos a los candidatos la importancia de las decisiones que están llamados a tomar. Los candidatos deberían firmar una carta en la que declaran proteger a la familia y respetar a las personas.

Os invitamos a hacer lo mismo en Italia porque estamos convencidos de que la familia es el lugar mejor para crecer y ser educados.

Estamos convencidos de que la familia es la célula base de la sociedad y que la familia asegura el futuro y el progreso del país.

El 21 de octubre pasado publiqué un libro titulado HOMOSEXUAL contra el matrimonio “para todos”. Esta publicación ha sido censurada por los medios de comunicación por la presión ejercida por el lobby LGBT.

Este lobby me acusa de ser un traidor porque no pienso igual que los dos mil gais de París. Es una actitud completamente homofóbica por su parte. Significa que un homosexual no puede ni pensar ni actuar autónomamente.

Más grave es el hecho de que he recibido amenazas de muerte en la web. ¿Quién es homófobo, La Manif Pour Tous o ellos?

Nosotros ciudadanos italianos o franceses, hombres y mujeres razonables, homosexuales o heterosexuales, proseguiremos nuestro camino de hombres responsables que quieren dejar tras de sí un planeta donde los hombres con H mayúscula no sean un bien comercial.

La denominada libertad, querida por algunos, no debe condenar al hombre y su diversidad. El derecho a la diferencia debe seguir siendo la única libertad del ser humano. ¡La naturaleza es la única que puede vigilar!

Por eso, La Manif Pour Tous os da las gracias por haber creado La Manif Pour Tous Italia. Os agradezco de corazón vuestra calorosa acogida. Gracias a todos, nos volveremos a ver pronto, con ocasión de una gran manifestación europea. ¡No renunciaremos nunca!

(Traducción de Helena Faccia Serrano, Alcalá de Henares)
 
 
 







segunda-feira, 9 de setembro de 2013

El deterioro de los hombres que «abortan»: un padre llora a la hija a quien nunca encontró

In RL 

Muchos hombres son responsables directos del aborto -ante el silencio feminista-, por no querer hacerse cargo de sus responsabilidades e inducir a la madre a matar al hijo común. Otros -como el caso que recogía ReL recientemente- se ven impotentes cuando querrían tenerlos, pero la ley no les concede ningún derecho si la decisión de la mujer se inclina por la supresión del embarazo.

Una historia de sufrimiento

El caso que recoge la bloguera católica Rebecca Frech parece responder a una tercera tipología: cuando el aborto se produce por consentimiento común de la pareja. Y también en este caso los efectos sobre la conciencia son devastadores.

Rebecca estaba hablando con un "viejo y querido amigo" sobre la pérdida de su hija Bernadette, cuando ese amigo se vino abajo: "Empezó a llorar y a hablarme sobre su propia pequeña. La niña que nunca conoció y a quien ama sin reservas".

Frech pidió al hombre que escribiese su testimonio de vida en silencio como "padre postaborto", y reproduce en uno de sus últimos posts la historia de esa tragedia.

Un día de agosto de 1988
"Amo a la niña que nunca encontré. Jamás la llevé de la mano, ni le revolví el pelo, ni le canté canción alguna. Pero la amo igualmente": así comienza la historia, anónima, del amigo de Rebecca. Quien lamenta: "No sé si es alta o baja, y los rasgos de su rostro existen sólo en mi imaginación. Estoy seguro de que el tono de su voz y la alegría de su risa rivalizan con el coro de los ángeles. Sus ojos, brillantes, serán marrones, tal vez color avellana. Pero todo eso me lo he perdido. Todo lo que tengo son memorias irreales de cuanto pudo haber sido".

Explica que hace veinticinco años, en el mes de agosto, esa niña a la que hoy ama "fue abortada": "Mi pequeña. Mi única hija. Una niña que agarra mi dedo hasta hoy, pero que nunca me llamará papá. Una niña que nunca sintió el abrazo protector de su padre, porque su padre le falló en el momento en el que más le necesitaba".

Arrepentido y reconciliado con Dios
El hombre que escribe esta historia habla brevemente de sí mismo, aunque afirma ya no ser el que era entonces, ese niño que asistió a un colegio católico, ese adolescente convertido "en un idiota que acudía a las fiestas a emborracharse".

Ya ha dejado atrás los "Si al menos hubiera..." o los "Debería haber hecho...": "Admito que lo que hice, lo que permití que pasara, fue un error. Me he arrepentido y cumplido mi penitencia. Estoy reconciliado con la Iglesia".

Pero "la reconciliación, aunque borra el pecado, no quita la pena": "En mi corazón hay un agujero con forma de niña, y ese agujero nunca será colmado en esta vida".

Diferente actitud de la madre
Dos años después del aborto, el hombre contrajo matrimonio con la chica: "Me casé con la madre de mi hija. Tal vez penséis que me habría ahorrado mucho sufrimiento casándome con otra persona, y no os lo discuto, pero en aquellos días yo estaba convencido de que el aborto no era cosa mía, que yo no era el responsable. No tenía nada que ver conmigo. Fue al pasar el tiempo cuando me enfrenté al  hecho de que yo sí era responsable, de que yo era padre, y necesitaba redención".

El aborto que cometieron sigue siendo, sin embargo, "un tema tabú" entre ellos, "una pared invisible e infranqueable, que sólo se rompió dos veces en los últimos veinticinco años".

"No voy a profundizar en lo que pasó", continúa, "salvo para decir que la única persona que podria ayudarme a soportar el dolor y la pena es la misma persona que rechaza admitir que tengo razones para el dolor y la pena. Ella no quiere o no puede admitir que mató a su hija. Pero es algo de lo que yo tengo que hablar. Seguir adelante sin hablarlo con nadie es más de lo que puedo soportar".

Síndrome postaborto, también en los padres
El amigo de Rebecca afirma que "hay muchos padres que lamentan el aborto y son incapaces de hablar de ello: la culpa, la vergüenza, la inadaptación, el haber fallado en proteger a los débiles, la soledad, el desapego, la incapacidad de establecer relaciones estables, la tensión de la que no se habla, las heridas emocionales... son pesos invisibles que acongojan sus almas. Aman a niños que existen sólo en su corazón, un amor desolado y no correspondido. Lo sé porque lo he vivido".

Y explica cómo y cuándo: "He derramado muchas lágrimas en la soledad de una habitación vacía, en Navidad, cuando todo el mundo se había ido a la cama. Algunas canciones me evocan fuertes emociones, como cuando Fantine canta en Los Miserables "I dreamed a dream" y dice: "Soñé que mi vida podía ser tan diferente del infierno que estoy viviendo".

Algunas escenas de película son devastadoras, como cuando en Salvad al soldado Ryan el capitán John Miller, al morir sobre el puente de la ciudad francesa, le dice al soldado Ryan: "Earn this! ¡Haz que esto valga la pena!".

Y él hizo que valiera la pena, pero yo me quedo preguntándome si valió la pena la decisión que tomé en mi vida. He visto a mis hermanos con sus hijas el día de sus bodas, y pienso que yo nunca seré padre.

Me he postrado en adoración en el suelo de las iglesias ante Dios bendito, rogándole Su paz, pidiéndoLe ayuda para librarme del dolor. Y Él siempre me da paz, pero el agujero en mi vida con forma de niña continúa".

Rezar por intercesión de la pequeña

"Pero no quiero que desaparezca", advierte: "Sé que suena raro, pero es la verdad. En otro tiempo intenté llenar esa ausencia con otras cosas, y sin embargo ahí permanecía. Durante años intenté dar a otros propósitos (algunos buenos, otros no tanto) el amor que era para mi hija, pero ahora comprendo que eso no podía funcionar. Me di cuenta de que el amor nunca quedará satisfecho. Ahora rezo con ella, y pido cosas por su intercesión. Eso es lo que me ha quedado".

Concluye explicando que no busca alivio en la autocompasión: "Lamento con cada fibra de mi ser lo que sucedió aquel día de agosto de 1988, pero no fantaseo sobre lo que pudo haber sido. Hice la elección [choice] del aborto, y sufro las consecuencias de esa elección [choice]. Como también mi esposa, aunque su rechazo a admitir que se equivocó gravemente impide una sanación completa entre los dos. La quiero,  y la he perdonado. No guardo ningún resentimiento hacia ella, y ruego a Dios que ablande su corazón para que pueda empezar a redimirse. Puesto que es la madre de todos mis hijos, he decidido mantener el compromiso hasta el final, sea cual sea el final".

"Por último", concluye, "creo que mi hija nos ha perdonado, y eso me ha ayudado mucho. E incluso espero, por la inexplicable misericordia y bondad de Dios, que Él mismo es también Padre, que finalmente nos encontraremos. Un encuentro entre extraños que siempre se han amado mutuamente, y en el que por fin podré escucharla decir ¡Papá!".


quinta-feira, 5 de setembro de 2013

There is no such thing as ‘gay marriage,’ just marriage, period - by William B. May

September 4, 2013 (MercatorNet) - We have all, or nearly all, done it -- talked about "gay marriage" or "same-sex marriage". But according to William B. May, who has been in the thick of the marriage debate in the United States, that's a mistake. MercatorNet asked him to explain.

* * * * *
 
MercatorNet: People trying to defend marriage know that “same-sex marriage” is a contradiction in terms, nonsense in fact, but isn’t it just shorthand for referring to an issue? What’s the harm?
 
William B May: The only reason there is a debate about the legal definition of marriage is because of confusion about its true meaning and purpose. Without truth about marriage, people take positions based on emotion and sentimentality. To restore the truth about marriage we must witness it in a way people can understand.

The first thing to consider is that no one is really proposing to put something called “same-sex marriage” in the law. They take “a man and a woman” and replace it with “two people.” That has consequences that people are not considering. So be careful not to oppose something that is not there.

When they eliminate “a man and a woman” from marriage laws it eliminates the only civil institution that is specifically geared to unite children with their moms and dads – the sole reason for marriage being a privileged institution in the first place. That exposes the hidden agenda and the truth about what is at stake.

Opponents argue that they don’t want to change marriage, and men and woman can still get married, so what is the big deal. The problem is that men and women are not getting married, and  this has created a crisis with increasing fatherlessness and associated consequences, and an increasing number of children living in poverty. Removing this child-centric institution from the law removes authority to actively promote the unique value of men and women marrying before having children. It makes it illegal for public institutions to do so and makes it legally discriminatory for anyone else.
 
What should we say instead of “same-sex marriage”?

Using the term “same-sex marriage” is one of the traps we fall into. It implies the issue is about participation in it by same-sex couples and makes us sound like our only motive is to oppose their aspirations. It is critical to educate people that the issue is redefinition, not participation and that redefining marriage has consequences. Redefining eliminates the only civil institution that is geared to uniting children with their moms and dads. The issue should be whether or not we need such an institution.
 
Why do the terms we use matter so much? Are there implications we are not seeing?

We live in a relativistic culture in which words mean different things to different people. For example when you talk about children needing a mother and father, or say that a married mother and father is good for children, that statement may be true, but different people have different understandings of what children need and what is good. This invariably leads to a debate about outcomes for children and competency in parenting, and who can do a better job, which escalates emotions. Ironically this has little to do with the meaning and purpose of marriage.

Being born into a family with mom and dad united in marriage is a human right, as the Catholic Church teaches, and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child implies (in Articles 7 and 9 ). Our moms and dads are part of our identity and we carry their flesh for all of eternity. With every right there is a corresponding duty to promote respect for that right and in this case to promote civil marriage as the foundation of the family of common ancestry.

It is also important for people to be able to distinguish between a real human right, that can only be recognized by law and never created, and a claimed individual right or license. A human right applies to each and every person without exception. The human right of children to know and, as far as possible, to be loved and cared for their moms and dads is a right that can be known by both reason and our own desire for connection with the man and woman from whom we originated. This is also an experience of God’s plan for creation, but is not dependent in belief in God.
 
What definition of marriage do you recommend we should use in debating this issue?

“Marriage unites a man and a woman with each other and any children born from their union.” That is what marriage is; that is what it does. The trouble is that children and family have been disconnected from marriage.

Factors include no fault divorce making it adult-centric, the separation of sex from procreation and marriage, having children becoming a life-style choice for personal fulfillment, and the increasingly accepted practice of intentionally depriving children of their moms or dads or both through assisted reproductive technology (sperm and egg donation, and surrogacy).

Considering these factors, it is difficult for people to understand marriage by discussing complementarity, procreation, motherhood and fatherhood, etc. It must be expressed in its totality. In reality, marriage unites a man and a woman with each other and any children born from their union. It is a fact, something that the law can only recognise, not change. If the word is redefined in the law, marriage will still exist, but will be no longer recognized in law as such. It becomes discriminatory to advocate that is has any unique value to society, at least under the name of marriage.
 
What do you think of the term “traditional marriage”? Is it useful?

I just use the word “marriage”, but I am careful to use it in a context so people know what I mean. “Traditional marriage” communicates what we mean but nothing about its true meaning and purpose in a way people can understand. Traditional has a connotation of connection with and holding onto the past. However, marriage is about the future.
 
How does this work out at the ballot box? How are referendums worded?

I have felt that defining marriage between a man and a woman in law does not go far enough. The law in some way needs to imply its public interest; clarifying that its purpose is more than recognizing loving, committed relationships between men and women. Perhaps it should state something like, “Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognize. All public institutions must promote its unique value as the only civil institution that unites children with their mothers and fathers.”
 
Click "like" if you support TRADITIONAL marriage.
 
Opponents will object because it reveals the real meaning and purpose of marriage. They argue that children raised by same-sex couples have a right to married parents, but this changes the subject because every child in this situation has lost their mom, dad or both. Arguments that this could provide stability for such children implies that marriage is merely a human creation for some sociological objective. Marriage is about the free choice of a man and woman to make themselves irreplaceable to each other in preparation to receive life as a gift. Marriage is the foundation of the communion of irreplaceability we call the family.

Opponents cause further confusion by saying marriage can’t be about procreation because not all married man and woman have children. That may be so, but every child has a mother and father and has a right, as far as possible, to be born into a family with them united in marriage. All married men and women engage in the same conjugal act, which is a commemoration and renewal of the marriage vows. Even sociologists from across the political spectrum agree that it is important to reestablish a norm for men and women to marry before having children.
 
How can we stay on the front foot in debates on this issue? Can we ever avoid being labeled “bigot”?

When we use the term “same-sex marriage,” it immediately tells people we are against someone and the so-called “rights” they are advocating. It’s an unfortunate tactic of our opponents to attribute motives to those defending marriage in an effort to seek sympathy, discredit, and intimidate. Avoiding the use of the term and instead focusing on what we are for will help greatly.

We can understand the sincere desire of some people to have same-sex relationships recognized, but marriage would have to be redefined in the law in a way that eliminates the only civil institution that unites kids with their moms and dads. How can anyone justify that? This issue is not about homosexuality at all. It is about whether marriage is a reality that not only unites a man and a woman with each other, but with any children born from their union.

What opponents are really proposing is that marriage be redefined in the law to be merely an institution for recognizing committed relationships for the benefit of the adults. What is the public interest in that? We love talking about other people’s sins, so it takes discipline to avoid getting drawn into a conversation about sexual ethics and personal behavior and stay focused on the reality of marriage.
 
Actually, the marriage redefiners seem to agree with you. They don’t use “gay marriage” or “same-sex marriage” either, but talk about “marriage equality”. Why do you think that is?

Their research shows that 58% of people in the US already believe that the purpose of marriage is to recognize committed relationships for adults. So all they have to do is to say same-sex couples want to marry for the same reason anyone else does.

The current understanding of marriage is one of the factors contributing to the fact fewer people are marrying and more than half of children born to women under 30 are outside of marriage. This is a crisis that is touching almost every family. The focus must be on changing current ideas about what marriage is for the benefit of society and our own families instead of focusing on why same-sex couples don’t qualify.

I imagine that marriage redefiners don’t want to use the term “same-sex or gay marriage” because their current approach is more effective, and the terms conjure up “anti-gay” feelings.
 
William B May is president of the United States organization Catholics for the Common Good and played a prominent role in the Proposition 8 effort that successfully restored the definition of marriage between a man and a woman in California – since overturned by the courts. He is the author of Getting the Marriage Conversation Right, a Guide for Effective Dialogue .

segunda-feira, 2 de setembro de 2013

‘Gay’ lawmaker to Christians: ‘We’ll take your children’ - by Matt Barber

Aug. 27, 2013 (LifeSiteNews.com) - Few people doubt that New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie hopes to become president in 2016. Unfortunately for him, he may have just signed away any chance of that.

On Monday, Christie signed A3371, a draconian piece of legislation that bars licensed therapists from helping children overcome unwanted same-sex attractions, behavior or identity. This law bans help for minors even when – as is so often the case – those same-sex attractions arise from childhood sexual abuse by the likes of a Jerry Sandusky.

This law will prohibit minors and their parents from receiving counseling they desire and will force counselors to violate ethical codes because they will not be able to help clients reach their own counseling goals. This law would enslave children – whether abused or not – to a subjectively determined sexual identity that they reject.

The connection between homosexual abuse and “gay identity” is undeniable. Consider this: Researchers from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) have found that homosexual men are “at least three times more likely to report CSA (childhood sexual abuse)” than heterosexual men.

Moreover, the Archives of Sexual Behavior – no bastion of conservatism – determined in a 2001 study that nearly half of all gay-identified men were molested by a homosexual pedophile: “46 percent of homosexual men and 22 percent of homosexual women reported having been molested by a person of the same gender. This contrasts to only 7 percent of heterosexual men and 1 percent of heterosexual women reporting having been molested by a person of the same gender” noted the study.

For obvious reasons, this politically motivated law has been dubbed the “Jerry Sandusky Victimization Act.” Liberty Counsel, one of the fastest growing civil rights law firms in the country, has stepped in to protect New Jersey children, parents and licensed therapists. We’ve filed suit to block the law, as we’ve already blocked a similar law in California.

In his signing statement, Gov. Christie wrote: “Government should tread carefully into this area and I do so here reluctantly. I have scrutinized this piece of legislation with that concern in mind. However, I also believe that on issues of medical treatment for children we must look to experts in the field to determine the relative risks and rewards.”

Beyond the fact that Christie and the New Jersey Legislature have just violated the First Amendment rights of New Jersey parents, children and counselors, there remains another problem with his assertion. It’s not true. As with any form of therapy, the “experts” are all over the board on the issue of change therapy.

Click "like" if you support TRADITIONAL marriage.
 
For instance, both New Jersey Democrats and Christie cited the American Psychological Association, or APA, as justification for this gross infringement on the right of self-determination. Although, no doubt, the highly liberal APA supports this and similar Sandusky Laws for political reasons, the group’s own task force on change therapy – led entirely by members who themselves are “gay”-identified or known political activists – has had to admit, nonetheless, that homosexuality itself “refers to feelings and self-concept.”

The taskforce confessed that such therapy has shown “varying degrees of satisfaction and varying perceptions of success.” It acknowledged within its own skewed, very limited “study” that some people had “altered their sexual orientation. … [P]articipants had multiple endpoints, including LGB identity, ex-gay identity, no sexual orientation identity, and a unique self-identity. … Individuals report a range of effects from their efforts to change their sexual orientation, including both benefits and harm.”

Reports of “both benefits and harm”? Exactly what might be expected from any form of therapy.

But that’s for adults. Here’s the kicker: The APA also acknowledged that there is no evidence whatsoever that change therapy harms minors. Mat Staver, founder and chairman of Liberty Counsel, addressed this, the most outrageous aspect of the law: “The very report that the governor cited for signing this law also admitted that there is absolutely zero research – none – regarding the effect of change therapy with minors.”

Get that? Gov. Christie just signed into law a bill purporting to prevent harm to minors from change therapy, citing, as the reason, an APA report that admits there is neither research nor empirical evidence to suggest that change therapy harms minors.
Is your head swimming? It should be.

The governor is one of three things. He is either: 1) ill-informed, 2) politically motivated or 3) stupid.

I don’t know, I guess he could be 4) all of the above.
Meanwhile, there are many experts outraged over this gross overreach by Christie and other New Jersey liberals. Dr. Nicholas Cummings, former president of the APA, wrote in USA Today: “Contending that all same-sex attraction is immutable is a distortion of reality. Attempting to characterize all sexual reorientation therapy as ‘unethical’ violates patient choice and gives an outside party a veto over patients’ goals for their own treatment. A political agenda shouldn’t prevent gays and lesbians who desire to change from making their own decisions.”

Dr. Cummings has testified to personally helping hundreds of formerly homosexual clients achieve the change they desired.

Things get more sinister yet. On Wednesday, New Jersey Assemblyman Tim Eustace, who sponsored the bill and is openly homosexual, bombastically compared change therapy to “beating a child” and suggested that the government take children seeking change away from their parents. He told Talk Radio 1210 WPHT, “What this does is prevent things that are harmful to people. If a parent were beating their child on a regular basis we would step in and remove that child from the house. If you pay somebody to beat your child or abuse your child, what’s the difference?”

Mat Staver responded on the same program: “It is shocking to hear the law’s sponsor threaten parents that the state will remove their children from them if they provide the counsel they need and which helps them. This is the ultimate nanny state,” he said.

I’ll take it a step further, and I think I speak for many Christian fathers. None of my three children suffer from unwanted same-sex attraction, but if any of them did and they decided to seek change therapy to reconcile their feelings with their faith, Mr. Eustace and the rest of his Gaystapo would be extremely ill-advised to crest my front porch with designs on taking my children.

Is this George Washington’s America, or Joseph Stalin’s Russia?

domingo, 18 de agosto de 2013

Boosters of same-sex parenting rely heavily on sociologists’ surveys. But do these really prove their case? - by Walter R. Schumm

In MercatorNet 



As a sociologist my life is all about creating, taking and interpreting surveys of attitudes and opinions. So I sometimes feel a bit depressed at how knuckle-headed the media can be when reporting about research on same-sex marriage. Let’s look at a slogan which is being repeated over and over: Same-sex parents are just as good at parenting as heterosexuals. This looks simple -- but its simplicity is deceptive. Let me unpack it for you.

What is meant by “same-sex”? 

Two sisters living together to save money, raising children from former husbands who died at a young age? Two bisexual women with children from previous marriages to men? Two lesbians who have each conceived a child by sperm donation? Two gay men who have adopted a child jointly?

Different situations can impact children very differently; thus, it is risky to subsume them all under the one label of “same-sex parent”. Does it mean that one parent had some same-sex experience as a teenager but now is heterosexual? Does it mean that one parent identifies as heterosexual but engages in gay affairs just for the sex? Sexual orientation is defined by attraction, behavior, and identity, with all combinations in between. Does it mean a woman who was raped at age six and became lesbian out of a hatred for her rapist? Does it mean a woman who feels she can be a better mother with another woman at her side rather than a man? Or, are we talking about someone who identifies as a “gay” man because he has found he has no sexual attraction to women or to men?

What is meant by “good”?

Does it mean they are provided adequate nutrition? Does it mean they are growing up with no plans on having sex until they marry? Does it mean they plan on cohabiting before they marry? Are they being raised to believe that they can marry a man or a woman when they marry? To what extent do the children believe in and practice delayed gratification? Are their gender roles distinct from those of the opposite sex? Are they growing up to love and serve God, putting that before personal pleasure or satisfaction? Does it mean they are academically prepared to succeed at the university?

What is meant by “just as”?

Does it mean that in a comparison of two biased non-random convenience samples, small in size, that there was an effect size difference that was moderate in magnitude but not statistically significant? Does it mean that there was a national random sample from which groups were compared with adequate statistical power to detect even small effect sizes? Were appropriate statistics used to make the comparisons?

What is meant by “parenting”?

Does it mean the parent is biologically related to the child? Does it mean that the parent spends only one day every two weeks with the child because of custody disputes? Does it mean that the father is the child’s biological father but the father has long ago disappeared and has not seen the child in the past ten years? Does it mean that the parent is “around” but for all practical purposes the child is being raised by a nanny? Does it mean that the parent has so much money that paid employees are, for all practical purposes, raising the child?

What is meant by “heterosexuals”?

Are these folks legally married? Cohabiting? In a civil union? Is the parent heterosexual but parenting alone because of the death or separation from the other person? Are the parents heterosexuals with a per capita family income (two parents earning $40,000 a year with six children) of a tenth of what the per capita family income of the comparison group (eg, one lesbian parent earning $100,000 a year with one child) happens to be?

What does the research say?

What may look simple on the surface can be pretty complicated. Research has been very limited in the past but is getting better. So what do we know?

First, despite continued denials, it appears that children of gay-lesbian-bisexual (GLB) parents are more likely to grow up to engage in same-sex sexual behavior, at least on an experimental basis, or to identify as GLB, than children of heterosexual parents.

This may be related to the evidence that GLB parents are much more flexible about or tolerant of their children adopting a non-heterosexual orientation than are most heterosexual parents. There is some evidence that sexual behavior by heterosexual children of same-sex parents is less traditional (cohabit sooner, more likely to have sex before marriage).

Second, if same-sex parents have long-term stable relationships, their children may do as well in some areas (psychological adjustment, school success), at least as reported by the parent (we have less information in terms of child reports or independent observers). However, same-sex parents (in contrast to same-sex couples, whose relationships may be as stable) appear to have far less stable relationships than heterosexual married, even cohabiting couples. That is, instability may be a problem for children, for both same-sex and heterosexual families. But the risk is greater for the former and their children on average may be disadvantaged.

Third, there is growing evidence that the gender roles of the children of same-sex couples, including adoptive same-sex couples, are more “flexible”. What that means in practice is that among the children of heterosexuals, the most masculine girl scores well below the average score for boys while the most feminine of boys scores well above the average score for girls. Among the children of same-sex parents, it is not uncommon for the most masculine girls to score above the average for boys and for the most feminine of boys to score below the average for girls (ie, much greater overlap of the distributions, which are also closer to each other).

Fourth, there is growing evidence that the children of same-sex couples may be more likely to use or abuse illegal drugs. This may reflect greater such drug usage by homosexuals in general or may reflect less parental training in delayed gratification by same-sex parents. Evidence is mounting that same-sex persons are more likely to have a background of childhood sexual abuse, which might or might not play into how they parent, if they become parents.

Because of selective reporting by most media, it is likely that most readers have never heard of much of this information.

If parents have a DNA relationship to a child, they take better care of the child. (I am referring to research that live-in boyfriends tend to abuse their girlfriend’s children more than do biological fathers.) In the traditional marriage, both parents have a DNA relationship to all of their children. This creates a quandary in that while we want to be supportive of all families and may need to be more supportive of non-DNA families, we really want as a society overall to encourage parenting by stable-relationship parents who are the biological parents of the child.

Who is doing the heavy lifting?

From another angle, we want to reward those in society who do the most difficult “emotional work”. Anyone who has ever tried living with a member of the opposite sex knows that it is emotional work and that it is not always easy.

There are numerous ways in which gender makes for conflict in heterosexual relationships. In terms of happiness in heterosexual relationships, if there are differences, it is most often that the woman is less happy.

It is clear that one result of no-fault divorce has been the feminization of poverty in which women lose much of their socioeconomic status after a divorce, even though they are more often responsible for the care of the children. If we begin to treat same-sex lesbian marriages as the same as heterosexual ones, what are we really telling young women? Go ahead and marry a man because this is good for society (both of you will have a DNA relationship to the child and your relationship will be more stable, which is good for the child) but you will have to accept the risk of a greater likelihood of being unhappy and of being ruined financially if your unhappiness leads to divorce, not to mention all the gender-related or sexuality-related conflicts you will have to endure even if you do not divorce.

But, we will grant the same benefits and respect to other women who bypass all those risks and dangers by hooking up with another woman. Will not this make women who marry men look and feel a bit like fools?

And what about men?

Research is clear that gay men usually feel OK about sex outside a civil union or marriage, often by mutual consent. How often will a heterosexual married man get “mutual” consent from his wife to have an affair? Some recent research with lesbians has found that some of them look forward to marriage precisely because marriage would make having sex outside the marriage easier on the relationship. This is the exact opposite of what occurs for most heterosexual couples. That is, how many heterosexual women look forward to marriage so their husband can start having sex with other women or so they can start having sex with other men?

In other words, one cost of marriage for heterosexuals is sexual restriction, which may involve personal sacrifice. With same-sex marriage, that social norm will decline further in strength, in my estimation.

Thus, heterosexual men and women are doing what society calls for -- but we will be punishing them for it. It’s like telling a soldier: we need you to go and fight the enemy face-to-face 24 hours a day and to risk maiming and death. But we, in order to be “fair”, are going to grant the same respect, rank, promotions, or veterans benefits and privileges to soldiers who stayed home and worked only eight hours a day out of air conditioned buildings.

The challenge of proving the “harm”

The evidence, including my own research, suggests that same-sex couples are happier than opposite-sex couples. And why not? Sociology can only capture part of the spectrum of human happiness. If a survey defines it as fewer hassles, less conflict over gender-related issues or sexuality issues, more disposable income and less fretting about children, what would you expect?

But if we grant same-sex couples equality, we will create a grander inequality for the far larger proportion of society who accept the “challenges” (ie, the greater risks and costs) of living heterosexually while providing society with greater benefits in terms of greater stability and care for their own biologically-related children.

If you say “prove the harm”, I say, OK, how would you prove harm if all combat pay and decorations were eliminated in order to be “fair” and to create equality for non-combat soldiers? After all, some soldiers may not feel they were “born for” combat, may not feel attracted to it, may feel unsuited for it, yet they are soldiers. Surely they deserve the same respect, honor, and compensation?

If all benefits were “equalized”, and the military found it more difficult to get volunteers for battle, it could always be blamed on something else. If re-enlistment rates went down, it would be blamed on inadequate retention pay. The military could demand that all soldiers face combat. If the soldiers who were forced into combat against their will didn’t perform well, it could be blamed on bad leadership at the unit level.

I am not sure you could ever prove harm to the satisfaction of those who demanded the elimination of all differential pay and benefits for combat veterans versus non-combat veterans.

Proving the “harm” of same-sex marriage is similar. No matter what you find in the research, it will be denigrated and dismissed by those in favor of same-sex marriage. The reality is that US states are aligned on a sexual freedom continuum that includes a number of matters (sex before marriage, cohabitation, same-sex marriage, acceptance of divorce, etc.) related to the so-called Second Demographic Transition. Trying to separate the effects of same-sex marriage from the entire cluster of changes is like asking which bee of the five that stung you did the most damage. No matter what, the other four bees can almost always be blamed more than the fifth bee.

It is my opinion that for a social system to work optimally, everyone should play by the same rules, with a few exceptions (eg, disabilities). Marriage has traditionally meant sexual fidelity, at least in principle. It has meant two people of different genders working through gender conflicts. It has meant two people committing themselves to each other for a lifetime. It has meant having children that are biologically related to both parents or being supportive of others who have such children. It has meant raising children who are not ashamed of being a boy or a girl.

If we are to begin saying that sexual fidelity is not really all that important, that having children is not all that important, that accepting gender role conflicts is something to bypass if possible, that gender roles are not all that important for children, or that long-term relationship stability is not all that important, we are really saying this: people can pick and choose which rules to play by with the right to reject any rules, restrictions, or limits that they don’t like.

Allowing everyone to make up their own rules may sound like a wonderful freedom, but consider what would happen if football was played with no rules or no referees? What if the Geneva Conventions for warfare were handled that way (it’s up to each soldier to follow or not follow them, with no consequences either way)? What if children could choose what homework assignments to do or not do? Even those who are pro-gay recognize this principle latently when they criticize how some places allow same-sex marriage and others do not (ie, the rules/laws change from place to place and are not the same for everybody).

If folks want the same benefits of marriage, they should be willing to play by the same rules. Research tells us that this is not the case at present and logic suggests it may never be. If the rules do not matter any longer or if everyone can make up their own rules as they go along, the meaning of marriage changes substantially from what it has been traditionally.


As a sociologist my life is all about creating, taking and interpreting surveys of attitudes and opinions. So I sometimes feel a bit depressed at how knuckle-headed the media can be when reporting about research on same-sex marriage. Let’s look at a slogan which is being repeated over and over: Same-sex parents are just as good at parenting as heterosexuals. This looks simple -- but its simplicity is deceptive. Let me unpack it for you.
What is meant by “same-sex”?
Two sisters living together to save money, raising children from former husbands who died at a young age? Two bisexual women with children from previous marriages to men? Two lesbians who have each conceived a child by sperm donation? Two gay men who have adopted a child jointly?
Different situations can impact children very differently; thus, it is risky to subsume them all under the one label of “same-sex parent”. Does it mean that one parent had some same-sex experience as a teenager but now is heterosexual? Does it mean that one parent identifies as heterosexual but engages in gay affairs just for the sex? Sexual orientation is defined by attraction, behavior, and identity, with all combinations in between. Does it mean a woman who was raped at age six and became lesbian out of a hatred for her rapist? Does it mean a woman who feels she can be a better mother with another woman at her side rather than a man? Or, are we talking about someone who identifies as a “gay” man because he has found he has no sexual attraction to women or to men?
What is meant by “good”?
Does it mean they are provided adequate nutrition? Does it mean they are growing up with no plans on having sex until they marry? Does it mean they plan on cohabiting before they marry? Are they being raised to believe that they can marry a man or a woman when they marry? To what extent do the children believe in and practice delayed gratification? Are their gender roles distinct from those of the opposite sex? Are they growing up to love and serve God, putting that before personal pleasure or satisfaction? Does it mean they are academically prepared to succeed at the university?
What is meant by “just as”?
Does it mean that in a comparison of two biased non-random convenience samples, small in size, that there was an effect size difference that was moderate in magnitude but not statistically significant? Does it mean that there was a national random sample from which groups were compared with adequate statistical power to detect even small effect sizes? Were appropriate statistics used to make the comparisons?
What is meant by “parenting”?
Does it mean the parent is biologically related to the child? Does it mean that the parent spends only one day every two weeks with the child because of custody disputes? Does it mean that the father is the child’s biological father but the father has long ago disappeared and has not seen the child in the past ten years? Does it mean that the parent is “around” but for all practical purposes the child is being raised by a nanny? Does it mean that the parent has so much money that paid employees are, for all practical purposes, raising the child?
What is meant by “heterosexuals”?
Are these folks legally married? Cohabiting? In a civil union? Is the parent heterosexual but parenting alone because of the death or separation from the other person? Are the parents heterosexuals with a per capita family income (two parents earning $40,000 a year with six children) of a tenth of what the per capita family income of the comparison group (eg, one lesbian parent earning $100,000 a year with one child) happens to be?
What does the research say?
What may look simple on the surface can be pretty complicated. Research has been very limited in the past but is getting better. So what do we know?
First, despite continued denials, it appears that children of gay-lesbian-bisexual (GLB) parents are more likely to grow up to engage in same-sex sexual behavior, at least on an experimental basis, or to identify as GLB, than children of heterosexual parents.
This may be related to the evidence that GLB parents are much more flexible about or tolerant of their children adopting a non-heterosexual orientation than are most heterosexual parents. There is some evidence that sexual behavior by heterosexual children of same-sex parents is less traditional (cohabit sooner, more likely to have sex before marriage).
Second, if same-sex parents have long-term stable relationships, their children may do as well in some areas (psychological adjustment, school success), at least as reported by the parent (we have less information in terms of child reports or independent observers). However, same-sex parents (in contrast to same-sex couples, whose relationships may be as stable) appear to have far less stable relationships than heterosexual married, even cohabiting couples. That is, instability may be a problem for children, for both same-sex and heterosexual families. But the risk is greater for the former and their children on average may be disadvantaged.
Third, there is growing evidence that the gender roles of the children of same-sex couples, including adoptive same-sex couples, are more “flexible”. What that means in practice is that among the children of heterosexuals, the most masculine girl scores well below the average score for boys while the most feminine of boys scores well above the average score for girls. Among the children of same-sex parents, it is not uncommon for the most masculine girls to score above the average for boys and for the most feminine of boys to score below the average for girls (ie, much greater overlap of the distributions, which are also closer to each other).
Fourth, there is growing evidence that the children of same-sex couples may be more likely to use or abuse illegal drugs. This may reflect greater such drug usage by homosexuals in general or may reflect less parental training in delayed gratification by same-sex parents. Evidence is mounting that same-sex persons are more likely to have a background of childhood sexual abuse, which might or might not play into how they parent, if they become parents.
Because of selective reporting by most media, it is likely that most readers have never heard of much of this information.
If parents have a DNA relationship to a child, they take better care of the child. (I am referring to research that live-in boyfriends tend to abuse their girlfriend’s children more than do biological fathers.) In the traditional marriage, both parents have a DNA relationship to all of their children. This creates a quandary in that while we want to be supportive of all families and may need to be more supportive of non-DNA families, we really want as a society overall to encourage parenting by stable-relationship parents who are the biological parents of the child.
Who is doing the heavy lifting?
From another angle, we want to reward those in society who do the most difficult “emotional work”. Anyone who has ever tried living with a member of the opposite sex knows that it is emotional work and that it is not always easy.
There are numerous ways in which gender makes for conflict in heterosexual relationships. In terms of happiness in heterosexual relationships, if there are differences, it is most often that the woman is less happy.
It is clear that one result of no-fault divorce has been the feminization of poverty in which women lose much of their socioeconomic status after a divorce, even though they are more often responsible for the care of the children. If we begin to treat same-sex lesbian marriages as the same as heterosexual ones, what are we really telling young women? Go ahead and marry a man because this is good for society (both of you will have a DNA relationship to the child and your relationship will be more stable, which is good for the child) but you will have to accept the risk of a greater likelihood of being unhappy and of being ruined financially if your unhappiness leads to divorce, not to mention all the gender-related or sexuality-related conflicts you will have to endure even if you do not divorce.
But, we will grant the same benefits and respect to other women who bypass all those risks and dangers by hooking up with another woman. Will not this make women who marry men look and feel a bit like fools?
And what about men?
Research is clear that gay men usually feel OK about sex outside a civil union or marriage, often by mutual consent. How often will a heterosexual married man get “mutual” consent from his wife to have an affair? Some recent research with lesbians has found that some of them look forward to marriage precisely because marriage would make having sex outside the marriage easier on the relationship. This is the exact opposite of what occurs for most heterosexual couples. That is, how many heterosexual women look forward to marriage so their husband can start having sex with other women or so they can start having sex with other men?
In other words, one cost of marriage for heterosexuals is sexual restriction, which may involve personal sacrifice. With same-sex marriage, that social norm will decline further in strength, in my estimation.
Thus, heterosexual men and women are doing what society calls for -- but we will be punishing them for it. It’s like telling a soldier: we need you to go and fight the enemy face-to-face 24 hours a day and to risk maiming and death. But we, in order to be “fair”, are going to grant the same respect, rank, promotions, or veterans benefits and privileges to soldiers who stayed home and worked only eight hours a day out of air conditioned buildings.
The challenge of proving the “harm”
The evidence, including my own research, suggests that same-sex couples are happier than opposite-sex couples. And why not? Sociology can only capture part of the spectrum of human happiness. If a survey defines it as fewer hassles, less conflict over gender-related issues or sexuality issues, more disposable income and less fretting about children, what would you expect?
But if we grant same-sex couples equality, we will create a grander inequality for the far larger proportion of society who accept the “challenges” (ie, the greater risks and costs) of living heterosexually while providing society with greater benefits in terms of greater stability and care for their own biologically-related children.
If you say “prove the harm”, I say, OK, how would you prove harm if all combat pay and decorations were eliminated in order to be “fair” and to create equality for non-combat soldiers? After all, some soldiers may not feel they were “born for” combat, may not feel attracted to it, may feel unsuited for it, yet they are soldiers. Surely they deserve the same respect, honor, and compensation?
If all benefits were “equalized”, and the military found it more difficult to get volunteers for battle, it could always be blamed on something else. If re-enlistment rates went down, it would be blamed on inadequate retention pay. The military could demand that all soldiers face combat. If the soldiers who were forced into combat against their will didn’t perform well, it could be blamed on bad leadership at the unit level.
I am not sure you could ever prove harm to the satisfaction of those who demanded the elimination of all differential pay and benefits for combat veterans versus non-combat veterans.
Proving the “harm” of same-sex marriage is similar. No matter what you find in the research, it will be denigrated and dismissed by those in favor of same-sex marriage. The reality is that US states are aligned on a sexual freedom continuum that includes a number of matters (sex before marriage, cohabitation, same-sex marriage, acceptance of divorce, etc.) related to the so-called Second Demographic Transition. Trying to separate the effects of same-sex marriage from the entire cluster of changes is like asking which bee of the five that stung you did the most damage. No matter what, the other four bees can almost always be blamed more than the fifth bee.
It is my opinion that for a social system to work optimally, everyone should play by the same rules, with a few exceptions (eg, disabilities). Marriage has traditionally meant sexual fidelity, at least in principle. It has meant two people of different genders working through gender conflicts. It has meant two people committing themselves to each other for a lifetime. It has meant having children that are biologically related to both parents or being supportive of others who have such children. It has meant raising children who are not ashamed of being a boy or a girl.
If we are to begin saying that sexual fidelity is not really all that important, that having children is not all that important, that accepting gender role conflicts is something to bypass if possible, that gender roles are not all that important for children, or that long-term relationship stability is not all that important, we are really saying this: people can pick and choose which rules to play by with the right to reject any rules, restrictions, or limits that they don’t like.
Allowing everyone to make up their own rules may sound like a wonderful freedom, but consider what would happen if football was played with no rules or no referees? What if the Geneva Conventions for warfare were handled that way (it’s up to each soldier to follow or not follow them, with no consequences either way)? What if children could choose what homework assignments to do or not do? Even those who are pro-gay recognize this principle latently when they criticize how some places allow same-sex marriage and others do not (ie, the rules/laws change from place to place and are not the same for everybody).
If folks want the same benefits of marriage, they should be willing to play by the same rules. Research tells us that this is not the case at present and logic suggests it may never be. If the rules do not matter any longer or if everyone can make up their own rules as they go along, the meaning of marriage changes substantially from what it has been traditionally.
- See more at: http://www.mercatornet.com/articles/view/unpacking_the_slogans#sthash.ZutCXwtB.dpuf