Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta morte. Mostrar todas as mensagens
Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta morte. Mostrar todas as mensagens

segunda-feira, 18 de novembro de 2013

Ano da Fé - por João César das Neves

In DN
 
Não há felicidade maior do que saber que Deus, o Deus supremo, sublime, transcendente, que fez o céu e a terra, se entregou à morte para me salvar. A mim pessoalmente. Nas nossas cidades e aldeias, nas casas e capelas de Portugal, em especial neste Ano da Fé que agora termina, tudo lembra este facto radical. Apesar disso, ele é esquecido a cada passo. Por isso as nossas vidas não são felizes. Ele está pendurado por minha causa. Nas paredes das salas, nas frontarias das igrejas, nos quadros dos museus, até no meu peito, em todo o lado a imagem da cruz lembra que Aquele ali, coberto de sangue, foi condenado à morte por minha causa. Eu vivo a minha vida, em cada momento, sob o olhar do que está num patíbulo em vez de mim.

As razões da condenação acumulo-as a cada momento. Pequenas e grandes traições, mentiras e violências, egoísmo e mesquinhez; sobretudo a terrível tibieza e mediocridade em que mergulham os meus dias. De fora não se vê a podridão que tenho dentro. Nem os meus inimigos, que têm tanta razão nos insultos, nem eles sabem do mal a metade. Sou todos os dias muito justamente condenado à morte.

Todos estamos condenados à morte e um dia, cedo ou tarde, a sentença será executada. Aliás, a morte não é só um justo castigo dos nossos males, mas também um alívio terapêutico dos mesmos males. Que seria viver para sempre em tanta maldade? "Deus não institui a morte ao princípio, mas deu-a como remédio. Condenada pelo pecado a um trabalho contínuo e a lamentações insuportáveis, a vida dos homens começou a ser miserável. Deus teve de pôr fim a estes males, para que a morte restituísse o que a vida tinha perdido. Com efeito, a imortalidade seria mais penosa que benéfica, se não fosse promovida pela graça" (S. Ambrósio Na Morte do Irmão Sátiro, II, 47).

Isto posso compreendê-lo bem olhando com honestidade para a minha vida. Se tirar a máscara de respeitabilidade e elegância, se esquecer as justificações retóricas e os enganos convenientes, se for ao fundo das minhas razões, vejo com clareza que um juiz justo e imparcial teria de me condenar. Exalto o pouco bem que vou fazendo, mas essa ilusão de óptica não impede a sentença inevitável.

Mas não sou eu que estou ali pendurado. É Ele. Ele, a única pessoa a poder dizer com verdade não merecer a morte, é Ele que está ali. "Jesus estará em agonia até ao fim do mundo" (Pascal , 1670, Pensées, ed. Brunschvicg n.º 553, ed.Lafuma n.º 919). Ele está em agonia, e a culpa é minha. E graças à morte d"Ele a minha tem remédio. A morte, em si mesma, é definitiva. Quem morre fica morto. Mas porque Ele quis morrer por mim, a minha morte tem saída. A minha morte pode ir para a vida. Se me agarrar a Ele, o único que voltou da morte.

Porque essa morte, que Ele sofreu por minha causa, durou apenas três dias. Porque Ele, o único a poder dizer que não merece a morte, destruiu a morte com a morte que sofreu por minha causa. Assim não há mais morte, não há mais culpa. Tudo foi levado na enxurrada da ressurreição de Cristo.

Eu, no medíocre quotidiano, continuo a mesma mesquinha criatura que sempre fui. Os meus pecados não desapareceram por Ele ter morrido e ressuscitado. Aliás, todos os meus pecados foram já cometidos depois de Ele ter morrido e ressuscitado por mim. Mas, porque Ele morreu e ressuscitou, eu sei que existe algo que cobre a multidão dos meus erros, misérias, podridões. Existe a Sua eterna misericórdia. E essa, por ser infinita, ganha ao meu mal. Se eu a procurar.

Agora posso viver a minha vida debaixo do olhar que Ele me lança da cruz. Daquela cruz que vejo a cada passo nas cidades e aldeias. Daquela cruz onde Ele está pendurado por minha causa. E isso muda a minha vida. Até muda a desgraça, a tacanhez, a maldade da minha vida. Assim, até ela fica quase boa. Por me lembrar do facto de Ele estar ali pendurado por minha causa. E não se ir embora, por grandes que sejam os meus crimes. Por ficar ali pendurado, esperando sempre que eu O veja. Que caia em mim. Que volta para Ele. Que tenha fé. E isso é a vida eterna.

domingo, 25 de novembro de 2012

Os mais Infelizes e Miseráveis - Nuno Serras Pereira

O povo na sua rudeza diz verdades como punhos embora, não poucas vezes, de um modo desajeitado. É o caso, por exemplo, quando sentencia: se a vida eterna não existe, Deus para que é que serve? Literalmente esta interrogação poderá parecer um disparate ou uma blasfémia. Mas se atentarmos bem, o que ela significa é que se Deus não é eterno então não é Deus; e se não é Deus é então um ídolo vão que podemos e devemos repudiar. Porém, se Deus existe, então não só é eterno como nos pode fazer participantes dessa Sua vida. Não só livrando-nos da mortalidade definitiva, mas redimindo-nos da morte segunda, isto é, da condenação, ou perdição, eterna. Esse resgate que o mundo antigo ansiava com ardor aconteceu de um modo que superou qualitativamente tudo quanto os povos e os sábios poderiam esperar. Esse acontecimento impensável deu-Se quando o Imenso, o Omnipotente, o Infinito, Se fez um de nós, minúsculo, mínimo, no seio de uma Virgem, para, uma vez Dela nascido, passar fazendo o bem, combatendo os demónios, e finalmente, carregando com os nossos pecados e misérias, dar a Sua vida, passando para nós a sua Inocência, numa Cruz, ser sepultado e Ressuscitar ao terceiro dia.


Isto que todo o cristão teoricamente sabe, de facto, na vida prática parece ignorá-lo inteiramente. Sinais eloquentes desta necedade consistem, a meu ver, numa profusão de documentos episcopais cuja atenção sistemática parece concentrar-se nos problemas político-sociais da vida presente, à margem de considerações, de fundo, de ordem teológico-espirituais, que tenham em conta as consequências eternas das atitudes e decisões, conscientes e livres, dos cristãos a quem se dirigem. Dá a impressão que muitos membros da Igreja vêem a sua missão como meramente política e social, esquecendo ou relegando para segundo plano, a Evangelização explícita de Jesus Cristo Redentor, o Ressuscitado, que morrendo aniquilou a morte e ressuscitando restaurou a vida.

Fruto venenoso desta mentalidade meramente mundana é claramente a indiferença e a culpabilidade com que se distribui a Sagrada Comunhão a políticos e outros personagens públicos que manifestamente vivem em pecado grave. Estes sacrilégios consentidos se não mesmo promovidos são fruto de um calculismo e de uma negociação, ainda que implícita, em vista de proveitos eclesiais de índole temporal. Mas chegados aqui importa perguntar: que aproveita à Igreja ganhar o mundo inteiro se vier perder-se a si mesma? Ou então lembrar o que afirma S. Paulo: Se nós temos esperança em Cristo apenas para esta vida, somos os mais miseráveis de todos os homens. 

Enquanto, todos nós, pensarmos que a nossa Fé não é mais do que uma sabedoria para viver neste mundo em vista de um maior bem-estar estaremos a atraiçoá-la e a cavar a nossa infelicidade e miséria.

Importa, pois, viver permanentemente à luz da eternidade que nos espera, para não sermos contados entre os mais infelizes e miseráveis. Todos os que fomos justificados pela Fé seremos julgados pelo Amor verdadeiro e efectivo que praticámos.

25. 11. 2012

terça-feira, 2 de outubro de 2012

Ciências da (dí)Vida - por José Luís Nunes Martins

In i

Nesta semana, o Conselho Nacional de Ética para as Ciências da Vida pronunciou-se no sentido de que o Estado português pode e deve racionar o acesso aos medicamentos mais caros para tratar o cancro, a sida e a artrite reumatóide. Tendo o médico que preside ao referido Conselho dito que se trata de “uma luta contra o desperdício e a ineficiência, que é enorme em saúde”. Mais, que “não é só legítimo, mas desejável”. Chegando- -se a referir ao facto de que 50 mil euros por 2 meses de vida não se justificam.

Uma vida não tem preço. Nem qualquer pedaço dela.

Como pode um homem, médico, chegar à conclusão de que há um valor justo para um mês de vida... todos já tivemos muitos meses maus, anos até... eu também, poderia ter passado por cima deles, mas, ainda assim, integram a minha história, fazem parte do meu caminho até aqui... Mas, apesar de tudo, amputar passados é diferente de abortar futuros.

Matar de forma absoluta o amanhã de alguém é crime. Chama-se homicídio. Trate-se de um bebé em embrião que se desenvolve à velocidade da vida ou um doente em coma, com cancro em fase terminal... é sempre homicídio. Sempre. Porque morre alguém por vontade de outrem.

Na vida, há momentos, um olhar, um sorriso, um beijo que duram segundos mas que valem (mais que) uma vida...

A vida é essencialmente futuro. Ainda que numa cama de hospital, em lágrimas, num mar de sofrimento... a Vida também é isso. Não é só alegria, também é dor.

Será que os médicos deixarão de fazer juramento de Hipócrates para, hipocritamente, jurar defender com aprumo, brio, disciplina e coragem militares o Orçamento? Na conclusão 6 do parecer, o Conselho refere que os médicos deviam obrigatoriamente ter mais formação ética para tomarem decisões mais justas e mais, imagine-se, responsáveis!

Argumentarão que não há recursos e perguntarão quem escolheria eu de entre dois doentes com diagnósticos e prognósticos diferentes... Mas a falta de recursos deve-se não a quem está doente, mas a quem andou a desperdiçá-los. Em casa onde não há razão, todos ralham, mas nunca há pão. Talvez porque alguém o come todo assim que chega... O problema não é o custo das terapias, mas o dinheiro que devia existir para as pagar e que foi canalizado para outras vi(d)as.

Haverá, por esta altura, uma multidão de gente à procura de uma fórmula matemática que decida, ela própria, o “sim” ou “não” em relação ao futuro dos doentes em avançado estado de despesa pública... No entanto, parecia-me bem mais humano que, em casos extremos, fosse alguém a fazê-lo, alguém com valores a assumi-lo, mas nunca um algoritmo que se aplica de forma impessoal... e atrás do qual, depois, muitos se esconderão.

Em breve, a capacidade de o Estado pagar reformas acabará... O que argumentarão, perante esse cenário, os então senhores das Ciências da (dí)Vida? Talvez alguém ligado a um qualquer conselho de ética (!) venha dizer que a vida, para além dos 70 anos, já não é vida, que a qualidade de vida dos mais novos é posta em causa por esses egoístas que já viveram mais do que o suficiente... ou talvez que se devia ter investido mais em aborto... ou outra enormidade que não me é dado imaginar...

Está completamente errado quem contribui com a sua sabedoria sobre Ética e sobre a Vida para a aplicação de medidas políticas inumanas, num país que pode ter pouco dinheiro, mas que não deixa por isso de ter muito valor. Apesar dos concidadãos que trocam vidas por dinheiro.

Resta um apelo: que se perdoem estes senhores da Ética pois, seguramente, não sabem o que dizem nem o que fazem... Na melhor das hipóteses, porque talvez nunca tenham conseguido um olhar que de um sorriso se fez beijo... mas, sabem, nunca é tarde! E vale sempre muito mais que 50 mil euros – asseguro eu.

Investigador

sexta-feira, 13 de julho de 2012

Video Game Adiction - How video games kill the soul & body

In TFP

About the author

Elizabeth Woolley founded Online Gamers Anonymous to people addicted to video games. Mrs. Woolley has been interviewed by the Catholic Herald Citizen, CBC, CBS, and the BBC. She has travelled internationally to speak at conferences on the dangers of gaming. In 2002, she started a website to warn society about the “dark” side of gaming and to provide help and counseling for those who are already addicted to video games.

Crusade: Could you please explain why you founded Online Gamers Anonymous?

Mrs. Woolley: In 2000, my son Shawn became addicted to an online video game called Everquest. Within three months he quit his job, got evicted from his home, and was up all night playing. Despite our efforts to help him get his life back together, he committed suicide only a year and a half after being introduced to the game.

Shortly after Shawn’s suicide, I did an interview with the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel and that’s when I realized how many families are being broken up and suffering like us. In 2002, I founded the Online Gamers Anonymous site so these people would have a place to go and know they are not alone.

I want to warn people that these games can take control of their lives just like drugs or alcohol. Some gamers told me one can become addicted in less than 24 hours. Once a gamer has gone from social gaming to addicted gaming, he can’t go back. Games can be a drug of choice and need to be looked at that way.

Our website, www.olganon.org spreads research on how gaming affects children, stunting their mental growth and social development, and helps to warn parents. We host several meetings a week where addicted gamers can talk and support one another to turn their lives around and also have a very active forum where different topics are discussed.

Crusade: Do you have any tips for parents who have video games in the house?

Mrs. Woolley: The biggest key is to make sure that your child’s life is balanced. Children cannot be raised on just one activity otherwise they will run into difficulties. Even if the child protests. It is your job as parents to say “no” and guide him towards other activities.

Being a parent isn’t easy, but trust me, there was life before video games, and as parents we have to find or make activities to give our children besides sitting them in front of a screen. That means getting them into sports, social events, and educational activities. Alternatives need to be presented. If the child says he doesn’t want to leave the game, you have to set limits, otherwise he will develop problems.

Crusade: Who can get addicted and what are the consequences?

Mrs. Woolley: Anyone can get addicted. Colleges recognize that video games cause a huge percentage of their dropouts. Many now bring in counselors to deal with excessive gaming. Some are asking students if they play games before offering a scholarship. They know they might be wasting a scholarship on a gamer. I know several parents who lost their college funds to their gaming children this way.

Many teenagers being pulled into these games are actually geniuses. They are very intelligent and highly motivated. Proof of this is that many games require hours of tedious effort, concentration and patience. It is very sad to see how all this brilliant mind power is being wasted.

Besides considering how these games are affecting their personal lives and education, we should imagine what could be happening if these very capable people were solving the real problems of society. Instead, video games have become a big part of the dumbing-down of our society.

Fully grown, hard-working adults also get addicted. I know several who had a job and house but lost it all to the games. An extreme case is of a man in Florida who lost his job and had to start living on the street. Now he has a restaurant job and makes just enough to get himself to the gaming café, where he spends the rest of the day. When the café closes he sleeps on the street and does the same the next day.

Many fathers leave their families to spend more time gaming. They don’t care about their children, because all they feel they can do is play.

Grown women tend to play social games like Farmville, SIMS and Second Life because they like to do things with others. This often leads to problems because married women end up leaving husband and family, neglecting their real children, to be with someone in the game. There are many examples of this. An extreme case is the Korean couple who let their real child die of malnutrition because they spent all their time taking care of a virtual baby.

Crusade: Most video games give children a sense of worth and accomplishment. What’s wrong with that?

Mrs. Woolley: One of the main dangers is precisely that it is so very easy to get worth and accomplishment from a game. And if you don’t succeed or like what you did you can just restart until you get it right. Well, real life isn’t like that. Real life isn’t easy and you don’t often get do-overs. So the child grows disappointed with real life and ends up by quitting in real life. He says, “This is too hard,” and runs back to the games.

This poses a huge danger to the child’s social life. Instead of satisfying his desire for things like worth and accomplishment through social interaction, he obtains it through the game. Then he fails to get the experience he needs in real life, especially by suffering and learning how to deal with the bad as well as the good times. Real life isn’t easy for anybody, but allowing a child to use games as a drug to escape reality is not going to teach him how to cope with real life.

I could see this in my son. In the game he could easily do whatever he wanted and feel like he was accomplishing something. In the mean time, he was not spending time nurturing his real life, so there was nothing there to sustain him.  He no longer cared about the future and advancing in his real life. If most of your time is spent in games there isn’t enough time to enhance real life education, skills or friendships. Anyone who wants real accomplishment needs to get out of gaming and get working in real life.

Crusade: What would you tell parents who use video games to help entertain their children?

Mrs. Woolley: I have seen a lot of reckless behavior by parents because they want to use games as baby sitters. Unfortunately, a lot of it is because many are gamers themselves.

Firstly, giving children a game to get them out of your hair is not being a good parent. Be with your children in real life! I know of a father who taught his 3-year-old child to play World of Warcraft with him because he felt that if he could get his child addicted to it then he could interact with him through the game. I let parents know that gaming with your child is not interacting because almost no words are being exchanged; the child’s only communication with anything is through the controls.

Secondly, I recommend parents not allow any child under 16 to play games connected to the Internet, period. You never know who they are playing against, and pedophiles are figuring out ways to connect with children through these games. Somehow, because it is inside the home, parents think it is safe; but it isn’t. Giving them Internet games is like putting them in a public bar by themselves.

Also, many times parents tell me they can’t help but give what their children want and they don’t seriously look at what is in the game. These games can have sexually explicit material, cursing, drug use, senseless violence and destruction. If this stuff was in a movie, the violence alone would make it R-rated. Most of the Christian families I talk to would never hand their children an R rated movie, but they allow them to interact with violent games. This is very damaging.

Crusade: What if the games are non-violent and not online?

Mrs. Woolley: Just because it’s non-violent and not online doesn’t mean it cannot be harmful. That would be like saying it’s alright for kids to be handed non-violent drugs. Again, video games should be viewed as possible drugs and no one should be allowed to become addicted to them.

We really find that when a gamer crosses the line from having the choice of playing to being compelled to play, his mind has actually been rewired by the gaming. He is no longer playing because he wants to but because he has to. Then he starts hating the games but cannot stop. And then, as his life breaks down, he goes into a vicious circle of feeling guilty and having highs on the games, only to plunge back down and return to the game where it all starts again. And while tapping away at controls he becomes dehumanized, giving less importance to his senses, not going outside, getting exercise or sunshine eating good food; he turns into a human shell.

I also believe that more research has to be done but there is already enough information on how gaming affects especially the young, stunting their mental growth and social development. That’s one thing that startled me about my son. He stopped talking to people, including to me, his own mother.

Before getting into this game he was just like the rest of us. He had a future, plans, friends, and a job. After he became addicted it was like a light in his mind was switched off. He no longer cared about how he would spend his real life; he no longer saw a real future; and he had no more goals or principles. He just stopped thinking about reality and became depressed. His whole personality changed and he became anti-social. That’s why I always say these games can rewire the brain and a gamer can change and become a different person. My son’s friends were astounded by how much he actually changed.

Crusade: Could you give an example of how some parents intervene too late?

Mrs. Woolley: One of the boys I knew was a 15-year-old from Canada called Brandon. He was playing a game called Call of Duty and his parents were struggling with him to quit, as they knew it was causing problems. Brandon attached far too much importance to being a very powerful person in this game and wanted to stay in it because of all the fake power and attention he was getting. In 2008, his parents finally decided to put their foot down and took the game from him. Brandon ran away from home and a few weeks later some hunters found his dead body about seven miles from the house. It seems he jumped from a tree.  

Crusade: Have addicts talked to you about the gaming buzz causing emptiness in real life?

Mrs. Woolley: Yes, absolutely, and it makes perfect sense because in the games there are always more “missions” and more interesting challenges. The gamers get an adrenaline rush to be able to attain the next level and figure out what to do next. Going on quests and planning cities is all very exciting, and when you go back to real life there’s what? Parents telling you to go sweep the floor, do your homework, do the dishes, and eat at the table; talk with your sister. And then parents are surprised when their children say “life is so depressing,” “everything is boring,” “I have no friends.” It is all because they are spending all their time on games and not experiencing real life; if children had activities, their own groups and friends, real life would be interesting for them.

 Crusade: Could you share some more stories from your son’s addiction?

Mrs. Woolley: Yes. After my son became addicted to Everquest and was diagnosed with mental problems, he was admitted to a long-term support program. He was living in a group home five miles from my house. During the night I woke up and couldn’t sleep, which is very rare, so I went downstairs to check my e-mail and heard the front door opening. This was shortly past midnight. Thinking it was a burglar, I got a bat to challenge the thief. Then in walks my son, who was addicted to a game. He had walked five miles from the group home to play it. Who knows how many times he was getting up at night to play the game? Children admit it all the time on my forum that they are spending all night in front of these games without their parents knowing.

Another time my son was at his brother’s wedding, the first wedding in the family. He left during the ceremony to play and didn’t return for the rest of the day. People noticed that he wasn’t at the reception and I discovered he had left in the middle of the wedding and walked home to continue playing his game. My son would have never have done that before his addiction. He loved parties and socializing.

sexta-feira, 27 de abril de 2012

Dad rescues ‘brain dead’ son from doctors wishing to harvest his organs – boy recovers completely

by Matthew Cullinan Hoffman

LEICESTER, England, April 25, 2012 (LifeSiteNews.com) - According to the Daily Mail newspaper, a young British man owes his life to an insistent father who would not allow his son’s organs to be removed from his body, despite assurances from four doctors that his son could not recover from the wounds he had suffered in a recent car accident.

The Mail reports that Stephen Thorpe, then 17, was placed in a medically-induced coma following a multi-car pileup that had already taken the life of his friend Matthew, who was driving the vehicle.
Although a team of four physicians insisted that his son was “brain-dead” following the wreck, Thorpe’s father enlisted the help of a general practitioner and a neurologist, who demonstrated that his son still had brain wave activity. The doctors agreed to bring him out of the coma, and five weeks later Thorpe left the hospital, having almost completely recovered.

Today, the 21-year-old with “brain damage” is studying accounting at a local university. “‘My impression is maybe the hospital weren’t very happy that my father wanted a second opinion,” he told the Mail.

The case is similar to dozens of others LifeSiteNews has reported in recent years, in which comatose or otherwise unconscious patients are declared to be “brain dead,” or hopelessly incurable. In many cases, aggressive doctors seek the organs of the patient for harvesting.

In 2011, the Quebec Hospital Sainte Croix de Drummondville sought permission to extract the eyes of a patient who had choked on hospital food in the absence of a nurse, claiming she was “brain dead.” After the family demanded proof from physicians of her alleged condition, she regained consciousness, and recovered most of her faculties. The family declared its intention to sue the hospital.

In 2008, a 45-year-old Frenchman revived on the operating table as doctors prepared to “harvest” his organs for donation, following cardiac arrest. In the subsequent investigation by the hospital’s ethics committee, a number of doctors admitted that such cases, while rare, were well known to them.
That same year, a “brain dead” 21-year-old American, Zack Dunlap, was about to have his organs harvested when his two sisters, both nurses, decided to test the hospital’s theory that his brain was no longer functioning. Family members poked his feet with a knife and dug their fingernails under his nails, provoking strong reactions by Dunlap and proving he was conscious. He recovered completely. He later related that he was conscious and aware as doctors discussed harvesting his organs in his presence.

The term “brain death” was invented in 1968 to accommodate the need to acquire vital organs in their “freshest” state from a donor who some argue is still very much alive.

While death had previously been defined as lack of respiration and heart activity, “brain death” was judged as compatible with an otherwise living patient. “Brain death” has never been rigorously defined, and there are no standardized tests to determine if the condition exists.

Dr. John Shea, a medical advisor to LifeSiteNews.com, points out that patients diagnosed as “brain dead” often continue to exhibit brain functions.

In “Organ Donation: The Inconvenient Truth”, Shea states that the criteria for “brain death” only “test for the absence of some specific brain reflexes. Functions of the brain that are not considered are temperature control, blood pressure, cardiac rate and salt and water balance. When a patient is declared brain dead, these functions are not only still present, but also frequently active.”

A list of articles by LifeSiteNews on comotose and “brain dead” patients who unexpectedly recovered follows:
* Brain dead’ woman recovers after husband refuses to withdraw life support
* Woman Diagnosed as “Brain Dead” Walks and Talks after Awakening
* ‘Brain dead’ Quebec woman wakes up after family refuses organ donation
* Doctor Says about “Brain Dead” Man Saved from Organ Harvesting - “Brain Death is Never Really Death”
* Doctors Who Almost Dissected Living Patient Confess Ignorance about Actual Moment of Death
* New study questions “brain-death” criterion for organ donation
* Coma Recovery After 19 Years Poses Questions About Terri Schiavo
* Polish Man Wakes from 19-Year “Coma”, Talks and Expected to Walk Soon
* Man Wakes from Two-Year Coma – was Aware and Remembers Everything
* Boy in “Hopeless” Vegetative State Awakens and Steadily Improves
* Commentary: The Significance of that Case of the Man Trapped in a “Coma” for 23 Years
* Girl Once Comatose and Scheduled for Euthanasia Will Testify against Attacker
* ‘Comatose’ UK Man Chooses Life by Moving Eyes
* Woman’s Waking After Brain Death Raises Many Questions About Organ Donation
* Russian Surgeons Removing Organs Saying Patients Almost Dead Anyway
* Denver Coroner Rules “Homicide” in Organ-Donor Case
Related links:

quarta-feira, 9 de novembro de 2011

New York Times columnist shown wrong on multiple facts about population - by Susan E. Wills

Nicholas Kristof and Toddlers: When You Really Need a Fact Checker

Think overpopulation, poverty, climate change, and abortion can all be solved by more birth control? Think again.

Who knew that the intractable global problems of “overpopulation,” poverty, carbon emissions, climate change, deforestation, civil wars, unplanned pregnancies, and abortions could all be solved by the simple expedient of more birth control? Nicholas Kristof, for one.

He proposed this solution in a New York Times column that will likely be studied by journalism students for decades—as an example of what happens when the last Fact Checker at a “newspaper of record” is asleep on the job.

It took only a 30-second Google search to demolish Kristof’s principal thesis—that the birth of the world’s 7 billionth person is the result of too much unprotected sex that contributes to all these ills.

The 30-second search confirms that population growth is not fueled by an excess of babies, as Kristof contends; it is fueled by more folks living longer than ever. The demographic evidence comes straight from the United Nations Population Division (UNPD). Using UNPD data, a Population Reference Bureau demographer compared population trends in the 0-4 age group and the 65-and-over age group. For simplicity, I’ll refer to these groups as Toddlers and Elders. Here’s what the UN’s data show.

In 1950 there were 335 million Toddlers worldwide and only 131 million Elders. Due to very low birthrates in developed countries and declining birthrates in most developing countries, today Elders are rapidly closing the gap. After Toddlers peak at about 650 million, sometime between 2015 and 2020, “for the first time in history, the [number of Toddlers] will decline” while Elders keep growing in number, reaching 714 million in 2020. By 2050, there will be 2.5 times more Elders than Toddlers—a complete reversal of the 1950 demographics.

Greater longevity is a good thing—the result of scientific and technological breakthroughs in agriculture and nutrition, in medicine, in water purification, and in improved sanitation.

But it’s the Toddlers on whom the future of humanity depends. When they reach adulthood, they will join the workforce, contributing to the nation’s wealth and tax revenues for roughly four decades, revenues sorely needed to fund Social Security and Medicare. It’s the cohort of former Toddlers who’ll be buying the cars, homes, and pricey electronics that keep an economy humming.

It is only right to provide a safety net for the elderly poor, from pure compassion, as well as in recognition of their contributions and sacrifices. But countries in the European Union are already reeling from the crisis of having too few workers to sustain the cradle-to-grave welfare state, even as the number of retirees explodes. Demographically, America is not far behind.

A good Fact Checker might also have questioned Mr. Kristof’s faith in the theoretical modeling exercises of the Guttmacher Institute, which purport to show that an X increase in access to and use of contraception will reduce unplanned pregnancies by Y, and abortions by Z.

The evidence simply doesn’t back this up. Empirical data of the last fifty years overwhelmingly show that with increased access to and use of contraception, unplanned pregnancies and abortions very often rise, or at best, stay about the same (an exception being found among women in former Soviet bloc countries, whose lifetime abortions often numbered well into double digits). Guttmacher and others have published numerous papers describing this apparent paradox.

Spain provides a recent example of this phenomenon: Between 1997 and 2007, contraceptive use among women rose 63 percent, while the rate of elective abortion in Spain more than doubled (108 percent).

In Sweden, teen abortion rates dropped 40 percent between 1975 and 1985, and teen childbearing also fell. Later the government increased pregnancy prevention efforts—providing free contraceptive counseling, subsidized oral contraceptives (OCs) and condoms, and over-the-counter emergency contraceptives. Between 1995 and 2001, teen abortion rates in Sweden increased by almost one-third—from 17 to 22.5 per 1000.

Duke University economics professor Peter Arcidiacono writes: “Our results suggest that increasing access to contraception may actually increase long run pregnancy rates. … On the other hand, policies that decrease access to contraception, and hence sexual activity, may lower pregnancy rates in the long run.”

Key studies with full citations are summarized in a fact sheet titled “Greater Access to Contraception Does Not Reduce Abortions.”

Why do contraceptives fail to live up to their name and their advertising? Many factors contribute to lack of effectiveness in preventing pregnancies (and STDs), especially among teens: method and user errors, the phenomenon of “risk compensation,” age-related fertility, and frequency of intercourse. Guttmacher’s Family Planning Perspectives reports the following 12-month pregnancy rates for sexually active OC users: 3.3 percent for middle-income married women age 30 and above; 13 percent for low-income single teens; and 48.4 percent for low-income cohabiting teens.

Among sexually active women whose partners use condoms as their primary method of birth control, 12-month pregnancy rates are as follows: 6.2 percent for middle-income married women age 30 and above; 23.2 percent for low-income single teens; and 72 percent for low-income cohabiting teens.

If it were just a matter of hormonal birth control not being 100-percent foolproof, and putting aside the moral questions involved in casual and contraceptive sex, some might argue for its use by disciplined, meticulous adults, in a stable relationship, willing and financially able to raise the potential “unplanned” baby.

Hormonal contraceptives are not benign, however, as any Fact Checker would learn from drug labels on the FDA’s website (even without perusing the voluminous Adverse Events data).

The link between hormonal contraceptives and breast cancer has been known for over thirty years. The World Health Organization (WHO) classifies the synthetic estrogen and progestin in contraceptives as carcinogenic to humans. The largest metanalysis (54 studies with over 150,000 women) found that women who use OCs before age 20 have almost double the risk of developing breast cancer before age 30, compared to women who did not use OCs as teens.

Until 2002, hormone replacement therapy (HRT), using hormones similar to those in combined OCs, but in lower doses, was standard treatment for menopausal symptoms. As HRT use increased, breast cancer rates rose by over 40 percent from the early 1980s through 2001. In 2002, the Women’s Health Initiative HRT trials were abruptly halted due to findings of increased risks of breast cancer, heart disease, blood clots, and stroke. As prescriptions plummeted, breast cancer rates in women over age 50 dropped 8.6 percent between 2001 and 2004. WHO now classifies HRT as carcinogenic in humans.

A Fact Checker could have told Mr. Kristof that there is, in fact, a way to slightly reduce population growth through contraceptive use, but not what he had in mind: Contraceptives can kill adults and teens.

In addition to having an increased risk of dying from breast cancer, women using hormonal contraceptives and their partners are dying at higher rates from incurable STDs, like HIV/AIDS, because hormonal contraceptives can double the risk of STD acquisition.

Women continue to die from high levels of synthetic hormones. For example, about 130 deaths have been linked to the Ortho Evra patch from blood clots resulting in heart attack, stroke, or pulmonary embolism.

Three new studies show a higher risk of lethal blood clots or gallbladder disease in women using birth control pills like Yaz. The manufacturer, Bayer, is already facing “6,850 lawsuits alleging that Yaz’s drospirenone ingredient is more dangerous than those used in competing pills. About 190 deaths from heart attack, stroke or pulmonary embolism have been associated with Yaz and similar pills.”

The manufacturer of NuvaRing® now faces 730 lawsuits in the U.S. for blood clot-related injuries and deaths associated with its use. About 40 deaths linked to NuvaRing® use have been identified to date in the FDA adverse event database.

A good Fact Checker could have given Mr. Kristof these hard truths and spared him from looking foolish. But where are all the good Fact Checkers when you need them? Not at The New York Times.

Susan E. Wills, Esq., is assistant director for education and outreach at the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Secretariat of Pro-Life Activities.

domingo, 24 de outubro de 2010

Anti-Depressants and the Dying: Depression Can Be a Factor for the Terminally Ill


by E. Christian Brugger, Senior Fellow in Ethics


WASHINGTON, D.C., OCT. 20, 2010 (Zenit.org).- Here is a question on bioethics asked by a ZENIT reader and answered by the fellows of the Culture of Life Foundation.

Q: What are some ethical issues surrounding the taking of anti-depressants? Does their mood-altering affect raise moral problems for people preparing their consciences for death? -- K.N., Augusta, USA.

E. Christian Brugger offers the following response.

A: There are many brands of antidepressants on the market today divided over several drug categories (or classes). An older class known as tricyclics came into widespread use in the 1950s and 60s. Common brand names include Elavil and Pamelor. A newer class known as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) came into common use in the late 1980s and 1990s and are still widely prescribed (including the famous drugs Prosac and Zoloft). One of the newest classes of the last 10 years, called selective serotonin norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SSNRIs), includes the popular brands Cymbalta and Effexor. In addition to depression, antidepressant drugs are also prescribed for anxiety, bipolar disease, eating disorders and chronic pain.

All three classes work at the cellular level of the brain blocking the absorption of brain chemicals known as neurotransmitters, believed to be involved in mood. The two most common neurotransmitters targeted by these meds are serotonin and norepinephrine.

Some fear that because they are involved in the altering of a person's mood, taking antidepressants is morally analogous to the taking of illicit mood-altering drugs.

I believe this is incorrect. Neurotransmitter medications, at least for depression and anxiety, when effective -- and they often are ineffective even when medically indicated -- ordinarily do not induce a "high," but work rather by restoring mood to a measure of statistical normality in one whose mood has grown flat and darkened, or has been shadowed by anxiety.

Whether or not antidepressants are advisable or promise symptomatic relief for certain individuals is a clinical question; and nobody reading this article should take what I say as clinical advice. My purpose here is to address moral questions surrounding the legitimacy of taking antidepressants for clinically indicated conditions.

The principal purpose of legitimately prescribed medications is therapeutic, that is, ordered toward the restoration of health. People suffering from major depression, dysthymia (low level chronic depression), chronic anxiety, panic attacks or bipolar disease are suffering from real health disorders. Medicine has demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt that these conditions have a distinct biological dimension. Data indicates that that dimension can be positively benefited by antidepressant medications.

These conditions might also have what clinical psychology calls a behavioral dimension. And I firmly believe that one's voluntary choosing and thinking can contribute to the exacerbation or minimization of the effects of many psychic disorders. It is unquestionably the case that for persons diagnosed with these types of disorders, some behavioral changes will be necessary to restoring long-term therapeutic health. But antidepressants can and should sometimes be part of a comprehensive therapeutic plan.

That said, antidepressants can cause significant side effects that burden one's life, affect one's relationships and limit one's range of activity. Moreover, similar to wearing glasses, one's neurochemistry after taking antidepressants for extended periods can establish new levels of normality on the medication. And so people who cease taking the meds will sometimes feel worse than before going on them. Finally, the newer classes of antidepressants are very expensive and can burden one's budget especially during economic downturns such as our own.

In making a good morally informed decision about beginning or continuing treatment with one of these drugs, consideration of these possible burdens should be factored in.

The question above asks specifically about the use of anti-depressants for persons preparing for death. The only uses of the meds for which I am familiar in end-of-life care are for treating the psychic states of those with terminal conditions. Those conditions, involving as they do bodily deterioration, can precipitate or exacerbate the types of neurochemical imbalances that correspond to states such as depression. In other words, as one's biology deteriorates, the biological basis for depression will often increase. Fear of dying might also play a role in one's mental state.

If such persons exhibit signs of depression, not only is it legitimate to treat them with antidepressant medications, it can be, in my opinion, a requisite part of palliative care (i.e., relieving distress involved in the dying process). Studies consistently illustrate that those patients most vulnerable to euthanasia are suffering from (among other things) treatable depression. For persons consigned to a bed because of incapacitating illness, behavioral options may be limited, so medications may be one of the few options available.

If health care workers appear unconcerned about the mood of the dying, then family members and other caregivers should insist that the patient's mood be taken seriously.

If the administration of antidepressants causes severe side effects that inhibit a person from conscientiously preparing himself or herself for death, then patients might rightly forgo their use as "excessively burdensome."

But if a patient is suffering from psychological distress of some sort as a (biological and/or environmental) result of a terminal condition, or if they have a history of mood disorders, and antidepressant medications can promise some relief, then treating them with these medications is no more morally suspect than treating them for chronic pain.