segunda-feira, 9 de julho de 2012

Le diagnosticaron cáncer pero rechazó el tratamiento para salvar la vida de su bebé: acaba de morir

In Religión en Libertad

Su vida corre casi paralela a la de Chiara Corbella -a quien ya muchos italianos conocen como la beata Chiara. Las dos son madres, a las dos les descubrieron un tumor maligno en la lengua durante su embarazo y las dos eligieron proteger a su hijo aunque ello supusiera retrasar el tratamiento que podía vencer a su enfermedad. Chiara -28 años- fue enterrada hace dos semanas. El funeral de la española Bárbara Castro García ha sido el sábado 7 de julio en Córdoba.

Apenas un día después de la muerte de su mujer, Ignacio Cabezas atiende sereno la llamada de Gaceta.es, y no porque la profesión de Bárbara Castro -periodista en la delegación de medios del obispado de Córdoba- le haya hecho ser comprensivo con la prensa, sino porque siente que la temprana muerte de Bárbara -31 años- ha sido en cierto sentido “para esto. Para dar testimonio”.

Y merece la pena conocer la historia de este matrimonio que nació el 19 de septiembre de 2009, después de once años de noviazgo. “Estábamos locos por casarnos y, una vez casados, deseábamos muchísimo ser padres. Recuerdo el día que supimos que Bárbara estaba embarazada; estábamos los dos desayunando en una cafetería con una sonrisa boba imposible de borrar”.

Tenían la vida que siempre habían deseado y así vivieron, “en un sueño”, hasta que el 15 de julio de 2010 el diagnóstico médico cayó sobre ellos como una losa. “Bárbara llevaba un tiempo quejándose de una llaga en la boca. Por fin fue al dentista, que nos mandó al maxilofacial. Allí le dijeron que no tenía muy buena pinta”.

Era necesario hacer pruebas, iniciar tratamientos... y todo ponía en peligro a Barbarita, la niña que venía en camino. “Mi mujer dijo desde el principio que nuestra hija nacería el día que Dios quisiera, ni uno antes”. Solo se le pudo practicar una pequeña intervención en la lengua que le provocó, además, “dolores que ni siquiera imaginaba que existían”.

Ni un vaso de agua
La llegada al mundo de su hija, el 1 de noviembre de 2010, fue un oasis de alegría y paz en medio del desierto de la enfermedad. Pero solo una semana después los dolores se hicieron más fuertes. La pequeña se quedó con sus abuelos y Bárbara viajó a Madrid junto a su inseparable marido. El cirujano maxilofacial que les atendió no les dio muchas esperanzas. “No sé cómo has podido llegar hasta aquí. Voy a hacer todo lo que pueda, pero la situación es muy seria”.

Llegaron la operación - “se quedó casi sin lengua y sin una parte de la mandíbula. Desde entonces no pudo tragar ni un vaso de agua y se alimentaba por una sonda en el estómago”-, las sesiones de quimioterapia, los dolores...

Cuenta Ignacio que Bárbara y él intuían ya que su historia, su sufrimiento, serviría para dar testimonio, para hacer ver a los demás la fuerza que da el amor de Dios. Rezaban mañana y noche y soñaban con el final del desierto de sufrimiento. Pero juntos.

Ahora Ignacio recuerda aquellos duros momentos en una carta dirigida a su esposa: “Presentía que íbamos a sufrir mucho, que sería muy duro y probablemente muy largo, pero también te garantizaba que, por muy duro que fuese, más tarde yo me iba a encargar de que fueras la persona más feliz del mundo, que todo esfuerzo merecería la pena, que disfrutaríamos de nuestra hija y que nos teníamos que preparar para un tiempo indefinido y horrible. ¡Ganaremos vida mía, ganaremos! Hoy nos queda lo más difícil: buscarle sentido a todo esto que nos ha pasado”.

Invencible
Y, por difícil que pueda parecer, Ignacio lo ha encontrado. “He sentido una fuerza de fe que no había sentido nunca. Me siento invencible”, asegura con la serenidad que le da saberse sujeto por Dios - “me tiene agarrado y no me quiere soltar”- y con el dulce recuerdo de haber compartido su vida con una mujer “que ya sabía que era especial”.

Dice que ella dio su vida por amor. “Hacia su hija, hacia mí y hacia Dios”. Ahora, confiesa, solo le preocupa poder “honrarla como ella merece”.

Bárbara Castro García (1981-2012), madre coraje. Descanse en paz.

«LA IGLESIA SOBREVIVIRÁ»: IMPRESIONANTES CUATRO MINUTOS DEL OBISPO DE PEORIA



Daniel Jenky, obispo de Peoria (Illinois, Estados Unidos), desgrana con una claridad y valentía extraordinarias la necesidad de heroísmo en los católicos de nuestro tiempo, y señala con nombres y apellidos a los enemigos de la Iglesia.

The Duty to Throw off Such Government - by James Schall, S. J.

In CRISIS

“Mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the Forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of Abuses and Usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object, evinces a Design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their Right, it is their Duty to throw off such Government and to provide new Guards for their future Security.”
—The U. S. Declaration of Independence, 1776.

David Goldman, in a recent article in the Asia Times (June 26), was struck by the fierce loyalty that his countrymen showed to Napoleon, even after several spectacular defeats. Goldman attributed this reaction to Napoleon’s ability to break the bonds of society and to concentrate all hope and loyalty into himself. The people no longer had sufficient interior virtues and standards whereby they themselves could form judgments about what was right and wrong. That function was subsumed into dependence and confidence in the emperor’s force of personality and external mission.

Readers of Plato and Aristotle know their recurring thesis: a tyrant arises out of a democracy when the citizens have little or no inner principle of order other than what they will for themselves. The tyrant becomes the “leader of the people” and, finally, their master. He can impose on them his cure for their well-being. But he is seen as a savior because the people, no longer in contact with the rationale of their own tradition, have little else in their souls with which to judge him. Hence, the loyalty and enthusiasm follow the “leader.” What struck Goldman about both Napoleon and Hitler was not so much that they failed, but how close they came to succeeding. The wonder is whether we will always be so lucky.

When we read the powerful words of the Declaration, we are struck by the truth of its observation that mankind is disposed to suffer evils, if it can, rather than to take the effort to throw them off. Custom, for all its good contributions to stability, makes us slow to see things as they go wrong. A people are accustomed to its own political “Form,” even if they retain the capacity to “right themselves” from its abuses. A point can come where they no longer retain such a capacity or a will to exercise it.

The Declaration of Independence is mostly remembered for its ringing words of principle, the “We hold these truths.” But as a document, the greater part is a bill of particulars that recounts the abuses of the British Crown as seen by the colonists, themselves nurtured in this same English tradition. The reason why the abuses are so diligently listed is to make a rational case before mankind that a “design” was being followed to reduce the people to “absolute despotism.”

The British Crown, no doubt, would have denied that such was its real intention. It merely wanted to restore order to its hot-headed colonial subjects. And no doubt with some considerable prudence on its part, the Crown might well have prevented the Revolution. As we watch the British Empire after both the French and American Revolutions, it did learn many lessons that were more benignly applied to other colonial outposts, some of which are still in existence today.

The American founders saw that the kind of limited government that they formed was likely to be strong enough to withstand most external enemies. What some of them also recognized was that the most dangerous threats to the country’s future would come from within and not without. The American system was put together to prevent despotism. Hence, all its offices were constrained. They were to be limited, checked, and balanced so that the enthusiasm which we associate with Napoleon did not arise among us. This nation, under God, was to be a country of citizens not of masses.

What we see today, I think, is the awareness that we must form a careful list of abuses, analogous to those composed by the writers of the Declaration. This time, the abuses are not against any colonial power but against our own rulers. Who would ever have imagined that freedom of religion would come to be on the government’s agenda as an item to be restricted? We see that marriage itself is no longer understood and its supposed alternatives promoted by official policy. The list is getting longer every day.

Though the courts have often been contributors to this list, we see that the Supreme Court may still function as a check on governmental despotism. But what seems clear is that the very idea of a Constitution, of a form of order according to which we should govern ourselves, is called into question when it conflicts with what the democracy or its leader wants. The American Republic was established so that a people who could rule themselves did rule themselves also in the public order. But it was also a Republic based on the idea that such a thing as virtue of soul and order in human affairs existed. They were not simply created in any form we wanted.

Reflecting now on the Fourth of July 2012, we have to wonder about a regime now manifesting a growing list of abuses to the fundamental nature of human worth. These abuses are put into effect by elected rulers themselves. They are accepted by many citizens who themselves are “democratic” in the classic Greek sense, that in their soul they have little principle of order.

Hence, they have no reason to object to anything on any other basis than that of personal whim or want. The term “unconstitutional” is meaningless. This situation is not a far cry from that list found in the Declaration. In describing these abuses, it read: “He (the King) has made Judges dependent on his Will alone.” “He has refused to assent to Laws.” And “He has combined with others to subject us to a Jurisdiction foreign to our Constitution.”

Constitutional rule derives from a people who understand the nature and demands of the virtues and their relation to our final end. It is aware of an order transcendent to politics. Arbitrary rule arises when a leader, seeing that the people have no real order of soul, sees himself able to impose whatever form of rule that he thinks good for the people. Unless they acquiesce in this rule and its decrees, they are no longer citizens, whatever a written Constitution might say.

In 2012, when we read the Declaration of Independence and its appeal to the judgment of mankind, it seems more addressed to our own government rather than to the British Crown.

Pornography, Respect, and Responsibility: A Letter to the Hotel Industry - by Robert P. George and Shaykh Hamza Yusuf



A letter on pornography and business ethics written by two prominent public intellectuals—one a Christian, one a Muslim—sent to hotel industry executives last week. 
 
We write to ask you to stop offering pornographic movies in your company’s hotels. We make no proposal here to limit your legal freedom, nor do we threaten protests, boycotts, or anything of the sort. We simply ask you to do what is right as a matter of conscience.

We are, respectively, a Christian and a Muslim, but we appeal to you not on the basis of truths revealed in our scriptures but on the basis of a commitment that should be shared by all people of reason and goodwill: a commitment to human dignity and the common good. As teachers and as parents, we seek a society in which young people are encouraged to respect others and themselves—treating no one as an impersonal object or thing. We hope that you share our desire to build such a society.

Pornography is degrading, dehumanizing, and corrupting. It undermines self-respect and respect for others. It reduces persons—creatures bearing profound, inherent, and equal dignity—to the status of objects. It robs a central aspect of our humanity—our sexuality—of its dignity and beauty. It ensnares some in addiction. It deprives others of their sense of self-worth. It teaches our young people to settle for the cheap satisfactions of lust, rather than to do the hard, yet ultimately liberating and fulfilling, work of love.

We recognize that we are asking you to abandon a profitable aspect of your business, but we hope that you will muster the conviction and strength of will to make that sacrifice and to explain it to your stockholders. We urge you to do away with pornography in your hotels because it is morally wrong to seek to profit from the suffering, degradation, or corruption of others. Some might say that you are simply honoring the free choices of your customers. However, you are doing much more than that. You are placing temptation in their path—temptation for the sake of profit. That is unjust. Moreover, the fact that something is chosen freely does not make it right; nor does it ensure that the choice will not be damaging to those who make it or to the larger community where degrading practices and materials flourish.

We beg you to consider the young woman who is depicted as a sexual object in these movies, as nothing but a bundle of raw animal appetites whose sex organs are displayed to the voyeurs of the world and whose body is used in loveless and utterly depersonalized sex acts. Surely we should regard that young woman as we would regard a sister, daughter, or mother. She is a precious member of the human family. You may say that she freely chooses to compromise her dignity in this way, and in some cases that would be true, but that gives you no right to avail yourself of her self-degradation for the sake of financial gain. Would you be willing to profit from her self-degradation if she were your sister? Would you be willing to profit from her self-degradation if she were your own beloved daughter?

Furthermore, we trust that you need no reminding of the fact that something’s being legal does not make it right. For example, denying black men and women and their families access to hotel rooms—and tables in restaurants, as well as other amenities and opportunities—was, for countless shameful years, perfectly legal. In some circumstances, it even made financial sense for hotel owners and operators in racist cultures to engage in segregationist practices even when not compelled by law to do so. However, this was deeply morally wrong. Shame on those who denied their brothers and sisters of color the equal treatment to which they were morally entitled. Shame on you if you hide behind legality to peddle immorality in the pursuit of money.

Our purpose is not to condemn you and your company but to call you to your highest and best self. We have no desire to hurt your business. On the contrary, we want you and your business to succeed financially—for your sake; for the sake of your stockholders, employees, and contract partners; and for the sake of the communities that your hotels serve. We believe that the properly regulated market economy serves the good of all by providing products and services at reasonable prices and by generating prosperity and social mobility. But the market itself cannot provide the moral values that make it a truly humane and just institution. We—owners, managers, employees, customers—must bring those values to the market. There are some things—inhuman things, unjust things, de-humanizing things—that should not be sold. There must be some things that, for the sake of human dignity and the common good, we must refuse to sell—even it if means forgoing profit.

Robert P. George is McCormick Professor of Jurisprudence at Princeton University. Shaykh Hamza Yusuf is co-founder and a member of the faculty of Zaytuna College. Affiliations are provided for identification purposes and do not imply institutional endorsements.

Amor na gestão - por João César das Neves

In DN

Nestes dias quentes de Verão somos por vezes surpreendidos pela proverbial lufada de ar fresco. Sensação paralela encontra-se na leitura de alguns textos, como o recente livro de António Pinto Leite "O Amor como Critério de Gestão" (Princípia, 2012).

Com um título destes seria de esperar um chorrilho de disparates benévolos ou filosofias irrealistas. Por isso o raciocínio lúcido e operacional do volume surge inesperadamente refrigerante. O autor consegue sempre manter a integridade dos dois lados da insólita equação do título, resolvendo o que muitos consideram paradoxos impossíveis.

O estilo é sempre leve e interpelante, conciso e cortante, sem perder o rigor ou ceder no equilíbrio. Parte de um princípio simples: "o centro vital da ética cristã é o amor" (p. 23), ideia que repetidamente revolucionou o mundo e não perdeu eficácia ou vigor em 2000 anos. Só que Pinto Leite está a escrever para gestores actuais, que não podem perder tempo com poesias. O seu desafio é levar o princípio à prática sem negar nada dessa prática ou desvirtuar a inspiração. Até o laconismo das 84 páginas cumpre as exigências de administradores ocupados.

A questão é tratada como uma investigação, com sucessivas descidas ao "laboratório" para testar peças da demonstração. Os "instrumentos" usados para concretizar o conceito de amor na gestão (porque a gestão não precisa de concretização) são simples e evidentes. O primeiro é o amor próprio, tirando daí um critério operacional: "Amor ao próximo como critério de gestão significa tratar os outros como gostaríamos de ser tratados por eles com a informação de que dispomos" (28-29). Outras ferramentas usadas são o amor paternal (31, 48, 74) e a história da Europa (55).

O autor tem o dom de criar provocantes frases lapidares, do título à última página: "Modificação genética do conceito de lucro" (43); "valor económico do amor" (48); "A ética dos negócios arruma, o amor como critério de gestão desarruma" (71); "a empresa pode ser o terceiro anel de segurança" (65); "o amor é o mais poderoso critério racional de liderança de uma organização" (51); "para a construção ética da produção de riqueza, é essencial ir, metodicamente, ao encontro do sofrimento" (65); "Deus ama as nossas empresas" (39); "Um cristão não deve confundir Cristo com o princípio da boa-fé, nem o Evangelho com o Código Civil" (72).

A profundidade de reflexão conceptual e operacional por baixo da elegância e simplicidade transforma o texto num valioso pequeno guia espiritual para empresários. Mas isso não esgota o seu valor. Tratando-o como livro de gestão ressalta outro aspecto, a mudança de perspectiva. Os tratados da área costumam olhar as empresas como um mecanismo, gizando soluções funcionais para melhorar os resultados. Mesmo a crescente influência dos estudos psicológicos neste tema científico surge como uma engenharia do espírito, igualmente técnica e operativa. Neste livro a gestão é tomada como uma relação humana, livre, autónoma, não pré-determinada, componente de uma vida e personalidade muito mais ricas. Várias teorias recentes, obsessivas e simplistas, ganhariam bastante se adoptassem os métodos heterodoxos e intuitivos de Pinto Leite.

O centro do livro está no raciocínio que, em cinco passos, leva de "líderes humanizados" à "sociedade justa" (53-54). Uma cadeia vale tanto quanto o seu elo mais fraco, que neste caso é o terceiro teorema: "pessoas felizes fazem empresas produtivas". Sendo aceitável que a felicidade aumente a produtividade, fica por provar que chegue para dar eficácia a aselhas. Dito de outro modo, o livro baseia-se na tese da não contradição entre amor e lucro, contemplando um "win-win" (62), ganhando em toda a linha. Mas são inegáveis os frequentes conflitos entre os dois objectivos. Que fazer nesses casos? Até aí o livro é claro: "A riqueza é uma consequência provável do amor (...). Mas amamos porque amamos, não porque o amor é vantajoso. Perder esta integridade significa perdermo-nos do sentido da eternidade" (62).

CARTA ABERTA A TODOS OS QUE NASCERAM EM 1962 - COMUNICADO da APFN

 In APFN

“Nascidos em 1962 com futuro comprometido”

Caros cidadãos nascidos em 1962: são os bebés nascidos este ano que irão pagar a vossa reforma. É com enorme preocupação que tomámos conhecimento de que o número de nascimentos vai este ano voltar a bater um recorde em baixa.
 
Tendo em conta estes dados o Governo vai ter que rever novamente em baixa o Relatório de Sustentabilidade da Segurança Social. Na versão atual deste documento, o Governo antecipava um crescimento do número de nascimentos para este ano. Como tal não se verifica, devido à forte baixa do número de nascimentos, os cenários de sustentabilidade estão irremediavelmente comprometidos - situação que deve motivar uma revisão do documento e, consequentemente, a adoção de medidas que estimulem a natalidade.
 
A APFN recorda que há apenas três anos, em 2009, pela primeira vez ficámos abaixo dos 100.000 nascimentos. Este ano ficaremos abaixo dos 90.000!
 
Em 1962, ano do vosso nascimento, nasceram um pouco mais de 200 mil pessoas que, em 2027, atingem os 65 anos. Este ano - 2012 - é o ano em que nascem as pessoas que, através do seu trabalho, irão pagar as vossas reformas. Este ano, faltam 110 mil!
 
Preocupamo-nos convosco. Tudo faremos para que a situação se altere, mas precisamos da vossa ajuda. Precisamos da vossa ajuda para acordar o Governo!
 
Solidariamente,
Associação Portuguesa de Famílias Numerosas

Lisboa, 9 de Julho de 2012
 

domingo, 8 de julho de 2012

Carrying Out End-of-Life Refusal Orders in a 'Culture of Refusal' - by by E. Christian Brugger, D.Phil., Senior Fellow and Director, Fellows Program


2 Criteria to Determine Licitness of Rejecting Life Sustaining Treatment

WASHINGTON, D.C., JULY 4, 2012 (Zenit.org ).- Here is a response to a question on bioethics, answered by the fellows of the Culture of Life Foundation.

Q: I am a nurse in a surgical intensive care unit. It is not uncommon for family members to announce that their incapacitated loved one would not want all of the invasive equipment such as ventilators, feeding tubes, vasopressive medications, etc.  We are not infrequently directed to remove tubes and medications and to start a morphine infusion and to titrate it upward to make the patient comfortable.  Is it licit for me to carry out these orders?  


E. Christian Brugger responds:


The answer to this question depends on at least two things: first, whether or not the directive is expressive of the wishes (i.e, the will) of the patient; and second, whether the directive is morally legitimate. Permit me to consider both.
 
The decision whether or not to accept or continue some treatment is first and foremost the patient's. The wishes of family members can play an important role in assisting patients to make good decisions. But these wishes are secondary. This is consistent with the "principle of autonomy." Autonomy is simply a technical term (derived from the Greek words for "self," autos, and "law," nomos) for the truth that God entrusts to each person the moral responsibility for self-direction. Autonomy designates both the right and the duty of each person to seek out and find the truth and when it's found to adhere to it. The medical ethical principle of "free and informed consent" derives from autonomy.

If a patient has an Advance Directive (AD), health care workers should appeal to it for information about patient wishes. Unless there is good reason to believe that the information on the AD is false or fraudulent (i.e., not expressive of the rightful will of the patient), or directs some kind of immoral behavior (e.g., suicide), medical personnel can carry out the directives in good faith, including orders for the removal of life-sustaining treatments (cf. USCCB, Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services (ERD), 5th ed., no. 59).

If the patient has designated a proxy decision-maker through the execution of a Health Care Power of Attorney (HCPoA), then the proxy is legally authorized to act as the patient's health care agent to make any necessary care decisions on the patient's behalf. The proxy has a grave moral responsibility to make decisions according to the will of the patient, and if the patient's will is unknown, to make decisions that are in the best interests of the patient.

If the patient has neither an AD nor a HCPoA, next of kin are often consulted in order to clarify the mind of the patient for end-of-life care. Because family members sometimes have mixed interests in these end-of-life decisions, health care workers should always perform due diligence to ensure that the oral directives of family members are consistent with the wishes of the patient. If, for example, an elderly widow or widower has three children, the doctor or nurse if possible should consult with all three before any consequential decisions are executed. Because of the irreversible character of decisions to remove life-sustaining treatments, an even greater measure of due diligence is required before executing them than before executing decisions to continue treatments that are medically indicated to preserve life.

If a health care worker has doubts as to whether some serious directive stems from the legitimate will of a patient, he or she should resolve the doubts before proceeding with any activity, especially activity that will result in the patient's death.

"Culture of removal"

I said above that rightfully executing medical directives also depends on whether the order is morally legitimate. Several factors bear upon the question of legitimacy. I will speak about one in particular.

The last 25 years in end-of-life care in the US has witnessed the rise of an increasingly rigid "refusal mentality" toward the use of life-sustaining procedures, especially for the elderly. It characterizes not only the culture of health care institutions and elder-care facilities, but also of elderly persons themselves and their families. "I don't want to be a burden." "Being hooked up to tubes is dehumanizing." "I would never want to live like that!", (meaning on life-support). "I'd rather die than sacrifice my independence." In our attempt to prize independence and high-functioning, we are unwittingly becoming a culture that's intolerant of that stage of radical dependency that inevitably accompanies old age.

Catholic teaching holds that a life-sustaining treatment is rightly refused -- and only rightly refused -- if it's futile (i.e., it does not promise a reasonable hope of benefit) or it's excessively burdensome (cf. ERD 57). Otherwise, it should be accepted. Why? For the simple reason that life is always good, even when incapacitated. Because of its intrinsic goodness, the effort to preserve it ordinarily holds a presumption over letting die. This is simply another way of saying that sustaining life, though not always required, is never pointless. The proposition that asserts: "this or that life is not worth living" is literally never true. No human life, no matter how diminished in its capacities, is without intrinsic worth. So strictly speaking, every life at every stage under every condition is worth living.

But morality does not require us in every instance to do everything possible to sustain life. The presumption to act on behalf of its preservation (but never to act against it) can be overridden when very serious burdens promise to accompany its preservation. No one who knows Catholic teaching on end-of-life care in the last 60 years can rightly accuse the Church of imposing, advancing, or even implicitly holding an unreasonable "preservationist" mentality.

Whereas the pendulum in the 1950s-1970s may have tilted excessively in the direction of adopting life-preserving measures, no such excess exists today. The "duty to refuse" has become the mantra of the 21stcentury. And health care workers must do what they can to resist it.

Given the widespread refusal mentality today and the pressure it places especially on elderly persons, there is an increasing probability that refusal directives, whether given orally or codified onto forms such as Living Wills (or the dangerous new document known as the POLST form), will be wrongly decided. Patients who have a duty to accept antibiotic infusions, or intubation for assisted feeding or respiration, or CPR, or dialysis, precisely because those treatments would not be futile and do not pose an excessive burden, may be wrongly motivated to direct that they be removed or withheld.

Having said this, I do not think that health care workers are morally bound to scrutinize the motives of every patient who directs the refusal of life-sustaining treatments. This would unnecessarily burden the delivery of health care by imposing on physicians, nurses and physician assistants a task that at least in some instances could not be carried through to completion (an unconscious patient with a refusal order can no longer express his or her intentions).

But those who advise and assist patients in completing ADs have the duty to facilitate good moral decision making. Patients inclined to refuse life-support should only do so for upright reasons (e.g., when proposed treatments are disproportionate to the benefits promised). Likewise they should be encouraged (without coercion) not to act on disordered motives (e.g., because they feel their life has lost its value, because others want them to refuse, because they are afraid of being a burden on their caregivers, etc.). Advisers should, I believe, inform patients completing AD's of the work of the Patients Rights Council .

Finally, immoral orders should not be carried out. In some instances, assessing the wrongness of an order is straightforward, for example, the order to remove nutrition and hydration from a patient for whom they are necessary to sustain life (cf. ERD 58). But some refusal orders are more difficult to assess.

In principle, any order that directs the withholding or removal of life-sustaining procedures judged to be ordinary and proportionate is unethical and contrary to Catholic teaching (cf. ERDs 56-57). Making this judgment is not always so simple. And so, following ERD 59 , health care workers may presume that refusal orders are rightly decided unless there are good reasons for concluding otherwise. If there are good reasons, then health care workers should undertake due diligence in order to resolve their doubts before carrying out the order.