sexta-feira, 14 de janeiro de 2011

Attorney claims as many as half of priest abuse accusations are ‘fraudulent or entirely false’

by Thaddeus Baklinski

LOS ANGELES, January 13, 2011 (LifeSiteNews.com) - LA attorney Donald H. Steier has filed a declaration with the Los Angeles County Superior Court stating that a large number of sex abuse claims against priests are false or heavily exaggerated, according to a report by TheMediaReport (http://www.themediareport.com/jan2011/special-steier-declaration.htm)

In his declaration Mr. Steier states: “One retired F.B.I. agent who worked with me to investigate many claims in the Clergy Cases told me, in his opinion, about ONE-HALF of the claims made in the Clergy Cases were either entirely false or so greatly exaggerated that the truth would not have supported a prosecutable claim for childhood sexual abuse.” (emphasis is Mr. Steier’s)

“In several cases my investigation has provided objective information that could not be reconciled with the truthfulness of the subjective allegations. In other words, in many cases objective facts showed that accusations were false,” Mr. Steier writes.

Mr. Steier, who reports in the declaration that he has taken part in over 100 investigations involving claims of childhood sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in Los Angeles, says that many plaintiffs had come forward only after hearing about lucrative settlements from an abuse claim.

“I am aware of several plaintiffs who testified that they realized that they had been abused only after learning that some other person - sometimes a relative - had received a financial settlement from the Archdiocese or another Catholic institution,” Mr. Steier states.

He describes plaintiffs’ testimonies changing over time, resulting in increased settlement pay-outs.

“In my investigation of many cases, I have seen the stories of some accusers change significantly over time, sometimes altering years, locations, and what activity was alleged - in every case, the changes seemed to have enabled or enhanced claims against my clients, or drastically increased alleged damages,” the veteran attorney declares.

In addition, Mr. Steier claims that many priests under investigation willingly undertook, and passed, lie-detector tests, while their accusers refused the test.

“I have had accused priest clients take polygraph examinations performed by very experienced former law enforcement experts, including from L.A.P.D., the Sheriff Department, and F.B.I. In many cases the examinations showed my clients’ denial of wrongdoing was ‘truthful,’ and in those cases I offered in writing to the accuser to undergo a similar polygraph examination at my expense. In every case the accuser refused to have his veracity tested by that investigative tool, which is routinely used by intelligence agencies,” Mr. Steier reports.

Mr. Steier implicates the victims’ advocacy group Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) for their part in making it a simple matter, by means of their website, for anyone wanting to make a false claim of clerical sexual abuse to find the information they need.

“They maintain an interactive Internet website with a user ‘Forum’ and ‘Message Board,’ among other features, where people can share detailed information between alleged victims pertaining to identity of specific alleged perpetrators, their alleged ‘modus operandi,’ and other details of alleged molestation,” Mr. Steier says.

“In effect, a person who wanted to make a false claim of sexual abuse by a priest could go to that website and find a ‘blueprint’ of factual allegations to make that would coincide with allegations made by other people. Law enforcement also uses the S.N.A.P. website to attempt to locate new victims and allegations against Catholic priests.”

In a press release, SNAP denounced Steier’s report as “among the most outrageous and hurtful ever made by a church defense lawyer,” and indicates it will file a California Bar Association complaint against him.

Images of Mr. Steier’s declaration, filed with the LA County Superior Court on December 15, 2010, are available through TheMediaReport website here.

Un nuevo Syllabus para el siglo XXI

Se implora un documento que condene los errores de interpretación del Concilio Vaticano II. Lo ha pedido un obispo de Kazakhstan, en un congreso en Roma con otros obispos y cardenales. Y suscita reacciones también el anuncio de Benedicto XVI de un nuevo encuentro interreligioso en Asís

por Sandro Magister

In www.chiesa

ROMA, 14 de enero de 2011 – El anuncio, hecho por Benedicto XVI luego del Angelus de año nuevo, de un viaje a Asís, el próximo octubre, para celebrar un nuevo encuentro interreligioso para orar por la paz, ha estimulado las controversias no sólo sobre el llamado "espíritu de Asís", sino también sobre el Concilio Vaticano II y el postconcilio.

El profesor Roberto de Mattei – flamante autor de una redacción de la historia del Concilio que culmina en el pedido a Benedicto XVI para que promueva "un nuevo examen" de los documentos conciliares, y así disipar la sospecha que éstos últimos habían roto con la doctrina tradicional de la Iglesia – ha firmado junto a otras personalidades católicas un pedido al Papa, para que el nuevo encuentro de Asís "no reencienda las confusiones sincretistas" del primero, convocado el 27 de octubre de 1986 por Juan Pablo II en la ciudad de san Francisco.

En efecto, en el año 1986, el entonces cardenal Joseph Ratzinger no fue a ese primer encuentro, del cual fue crítico. Por el contrario, participó en una réplica celebrada también en Asís el 24 de enero del 2002, a la que adhirió "in extremis" luego de haberse asegurado que los equívocos del encuentro anterior no se volverían a repetir.

El equívoco principal alimentado por el encuentro de Asís del año 1986 fue el de equiparar las religiones como fuentes de salvación para la humanidad. Contra este equívoco la Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe emitió en el año 2000 la Declaración "Dominus Iesus", para reafirmar que todo hombre no tiene otro salvador que Jesús.

Pero también como Papa, Ratzinger ha vuelto a alertar contra las confusiones. En un mensaje al obispo de Asís, del 2 de setiembre del 2006, ha escrito:

"Para que no haya equívocos con respecto al sentido de lo que Juan Pablo II quiso realizar en 1986, y que se ha calificado con una expresión suya como 'espíritu de Asís', es importante no olvidar el cuidado que se puso entonces para que el encuentro interreligioso de oración no se prestara a interpretaciones sincretistas, fundadas en una concepción relativista. [...] Por eso, también cuando nos reunimos para orar por la paz es necesario que la oración se desarrolle según los distintos caminos que son propios de las diversas religiones. Esta fue la opción que se hizo en 1986, y sigue siendo válida también hoy. La convergencia de personas diversas no debe dar la impresión de que se cae en el relativismo que niega el sentido mismo de la verdad y la posibilidad de alcanzarla".

Y en una visita a Asís el 17 de junio del 2007, ha dicho en la homilía:

"La elección de celebrar ese encuentro en Asís fue sugerida precisamente por el testimonio de Francisco como hombre de paz, al cual tantos miran con simpatía incluso desde otras posiciones culturales y religiosas. Al mismo tiempo, la luz del 'Pobrecillo' sobre esa iniciativa era una garantía de autenticidad cristiana, ya que su vida y su mensaje se apoyan de modo tan visible en la opción por Cristo, que rechaza a priori cualquier tentación de indiferentismo religioso, que nada tendría que ver con el auténtico diálogo religioso. [...] No podría ser actitud evangélica, ni franciscana, el no lograr conjugar la acogida, el diálogo y el respeto por todo con la certeza de fe que cada cristiano, a la par que el santo de Asís, se espera que cultive, anunciando a Cristo como camino, verdad y vida del hombre, único Salvador del mundo".

Volviendo a la controversia sobre el Concilio Vaticano II, hay que señalar un congreso importante celebrado el 16-18 de diciembre pasado en Roma, a pocos pasos de la basílica de san Pedro, "para una justa hermenéutica del Concilio a la luz de la Tradición de la Iglesia".

Bajo el juicio crítico de los expositores estaban sobre todo la naturaleza "pastoral" del Vaticano II y los abusos que se han llevado a cabo en su nombre.

Entre los expositores estuvieron el profesor de Mattei y el teólogo Brunero Gherardini, de 85 años de edad, canónico de la basílica de san Pedro, profesor emérito de la Pontifica Universidad Lateranense y director de la revista de teología tomista "Divinitas".

Gherardini es autor de un volumen sobre el Concilio Vaticano II que concluye con una "Súplica al Santo Padre", en la que se pide que se sometan a revisión los documentos del Concilio, para aclarar de una vez por todas "si, en qué sentido y hasta qué punto " el Vaticano II está o no en continuidad con el anterior magisterio de la Iglesia.

El libro de Gherardini tiene el prefacio de Albert Malcolm Ranjith, arzobispo de Colombo y ex secretario de la Congregación vaticana para el Culto Divino, creado cardenal en el consistorio del pasado mes de noviembre.

Ranjith es uno de los dos obispos a los que www.chiesa ha dedicado recientemente un servicio con este título:

> Los mejores alumnos de Ratzinger están en Sri Lanka y Kazajstán

Y también el segundo de estos obispos, el auxiliar de Karaganda, Athanasius Schneider, estuvo presente como expositor en el congreso romano del 16-18 de diciembre.

A continuación se reproduce la parte final de su conferencia, la cual concluye con el pedido al Papa de dos remedios contra los abusos del postconcilio: la redacción y difusión de un "Syllabus" contra los errores doctrinales de interpretación del Vaticano II y el nombramiento de obispos "santos, valientes y profundamente arraigados en la Tradición de la Iglesia".

Hubo cardenales, funcionarios de la curia y teólogos de relieve que escucharon a Schneider. Basta decir que entre los mismos expositores estuvieron el cardenal Velasio de Paolis, el arzobispo Agostino Marchetto, el obispo Luigi Negri y monseñor Florian Kolfhaus, de la Secretaría de Estado del Vaticano.

Entre los oyentes hubo un nutrido grupo de Franciscanos de la Inmaculada, una joven congregación religiosa surgida en el surco de san Francisco, floreciente de vocaciones y de orientación decididamente ortodoxa, situada en las antípodas del llamado "espíritu de Asís", promotora del mismo congreso.

__________



EL DESAFÍO DE LAS INTERPRETACIONES CONTRASTANTES

por Athanasius Schneider



[...] Para una interpretación correcta del Concilio Vaticano II es necesario tener en cuenta la intención manifestada en los mismos documentos conciliares y en las palabras específicas de los Papas que lo han convocado y presidido: Juan XXIII y Pablo VI.

Además es necesario descubrir el hilo conductor de toda la obra del Concilio, es decir, su intención pastoral, que es la "salus animarum", la salvación de las almas. Ésta, a su vez, depende y está subordinada a la promoción del culto divino y de la gloria de Dios, es decir, depende del primado de Dios.

Este primado de Dios en la vida y en toda la actividad de la Iglesia se manifiesta inequívocamente por el hecho que la Constitución sobre la liturgia ocupa intencional y cronológicamente el primer puesto en la vasta obra del Concilio. [...]

*

Lo característico de la ruptura en la interpretación de los textos conciliares se manifiesta, en la forma más estereotipada y difundida, en la tesis de un viraje antropológico, secularizante o naturalista del Concilio Vaticano II respecto a la tradición eclesial anterior.

Una de las manifestaciones más conocidas de tal interpretación errónea ha sido, por ejemplo, la llamada teología de la liberación y su consiguiente devastadora praxis pastoral. Cuál es el contraste que hay entre esta teología de la liberación, su praxis y el Concilio, aparece claramente en la siguiente enseñanza conciliar: “La misión propia que Cristo confió a su Iglesia no es de orden político, económico o social. El fin que le asignó es de orden religioso” (cfr. "Gaudium et Spes", n. 42). [...]

Una interpretación de ruptura de peso doctrinalmente más ligero se ha manifestado en el campo pastoral-litúrgico. Se puede mencionar a tal fin la merma del carácter sagrado y sublime de la liturgia y la introducción de elementos gestuales más antropocéntricos.

Este fenómeno se evidencia en tres prácticas litúrgicas demasiado conocidas y difundidas en la casi totalidad de las parroquias del orbe católico: la desaparición casi total del uso de la lengua latina, la recepción del cuerpo eucarístico de Cristo directamente en la mano y de pie y la celebración del sacrificio eucarístico en la modalidad de un círculo cerrado en el que sacerdote y pueblo se observan recíprocamente cara a cara.

Este modo de rezar – el no estar todos orientados en la misma dirección, lo cual es una expresión corporal y simbólica más natural respecto a la verdad de estar todos espiritualmente orientados hacia Dios en el culto público – contradice la práctica que Jesús mismo y sus apóstoles han observado en la oración pública, tanto en el templo como en la sinagoga. Contradice además el testimonio unánime de los Padres de la Iglesia y de toda la tradición posterior de la Iglesia oriental y occidental.

Estas tres prácticas pastorales y litúrgicas, de clamorosa ruptura con la ley de la oración mantenida por generaciones de fieles católicos durante al menos un milenio, no encuentran ningún apoyo en los textos conciliares, por el contrario, más bien contradicen tanto un texto específico del Concilio (en la lengua latina: cfr. "Sacrosanctum Concilium", nn. 36 y 54), como la "mens", la verdadera intención de los Padres conciliares, tal como se puede verificar en las actas del Concilio.

*

En el alboroto hermenéutico de las interpretaciones contrastantes y en la confusión de las aplicaciones pastorales y litúrgicas, aparece como único intérprete auténtico de los textos conciliares el Concilio mismo, en unidad con el Papa.

Se podría plantear una analogía con el clima hermenéutico confuso de los primeros siglos de la Iglesia, provocado por interpretaciones bíblicas y doctrinales arbitrarias por parte de grupos heterodoxos. En su famosa obra "De praescriptione haereticorum", Tertuliano pudo contraponer a los herejes de distintas orientaciones el hecho que solamente la iglesia posee la "praescriptio", es decir, solamente la Iglesia es la legítima propietaria de la fe, de la palabra de Dios y de la tradición. Con esto, en las disputas sobre la verdadera interpretación la Iglesia puede rechazar a los herejes. Solamente la Iglesia puede decir, según Tertuliano: “Ego sum heres Apostolorum”, yo soy la heredera de los apóstoles. Hablando analógicamente, solamente el magisterio supremo del Papa o de un posible futuro concilio ecuménico podrá decir: “Ego sum heres Concilii Vaticani II”, [yo soy el heredero del Concilio Vaticano II].

En las décadas pasadas existían, y todavía existen, reagrupamientos en el interior de la Iglesia que abusan enormemente del carácter pastoral del Concilio y de sus textos, escritos según esta intención pastoral, ya que el Concilio no quería presentar enseñanzas propias definitivas o irreformables. De la misma naturaleza pastoral de los textos del Concilio se evidencia que sus textos están en principio abiertos a perfeccionamientos y a ulteriores precisiones doctrinales. Teniendo en cuenta la experiencia de varias décadas de interpretaciones doctrinal y pastoralmente equivocadas y contrarias a la continuidad bimilenaria de la doctrina y de la oración de la fe, surge entonces la necesidad y la urgencia de una intervención específica y autorizada del magisterio pontificio para una interpretación auténtica de los textos conciliares, con perfeccionamientos y precisiones doctrinales; una especie de "Syllabus" de los errores respecto a la interpretación del Concilio Vaticano II.

Hay necesidad de un nuevo Syllabus, dirigido esta vez no tanto contra los errores provenientes de afuera de la Iglesia, sino contra los errores difundidos dentro de la Iglesia por parte de los partidarios de la tesis de la discontinuidad y de la ruptura, con su aplicación doctrinal, litúrgica y pastoral.

Tal Syllabus debería constar de dos partes: la parte que señala los errores y la parte positiva con las proposiciones aclaratorias, conclusivas y de precisiones doctrinales.

*

Se ponen en evidencia dos reagrupamientos que sostienen la teoría de la ruptura. Uno de estos reagrupamientos intenta "protestantizar" doctrinal, litúrgica y pastoralmente la vida de la Iglesia. Del lado opuesto están esos grupos tradicionalistas que, en nombre de la tradición, rechazan el Concilio y se apartan de la sumisión al supremo magisterio viviente de la Iglesia, a la cabeza visible de la Iglesia - que es el vicario de Cristo en la tierra -, sometiéndose entre tanto sólo a la cabeza invisible de la Iglesia, esperando tiempos mejores. [...]

Sustancialmente, ha habido dos impedimentos para que la verdadera intención del Concilio y su magisterio pudieran llevar frutos abundantes y duraderos.

Uno se encontraba fuera de la Iglesia, en el violento proceso de revolución cultural y social de los años ´60, que como todo fuerte fenómeno social penetraba en el interior de la Iglesia, contagiando con su espíritu de ruptura amplios ámbitos de personas y de instituciones.

El otro impedimento se manifestaba en la falta de sabios y al mismo tiempo intrépidos pastores de la Iglesia que estuviesen dispuestos a defender la pureza y la integridad de la fe y de la vida litúrgica y pastoral, no dejándose influenciar ni por el elogio ni por el temor.

Ya el Concilio de Trento afirmaba en uno de sus últimos decretos sobre la reforma general de la Iglesia: “Últimamente el mismo santo Concilio, movido por los gravísimos males que padece la Iglesia, no puede no recordar que nada es más necesario a la Iglesia de Dios escoger pastores óptimos e idóneos; y esto con tanta mayor causa, cuanto nuestro Señor Jesucristo pedirá cuenta de la sangre de las ovejas que perecieren a causa del mal gobierno de los Pastores negligentes y olvidados de su deber” (Sesión XXIV, Decreto "Sobre la reforma", cap. 1).

Seguía diciendo el Concilio: “En cuanto a todos los que por algún motivo tienen por parte de la Sede Apostólica algún derecho para intervenir en la promoción de los futuros prelados o de alguna otra forma participan en ello, el santo Concilio los exhorta y los amonesta para que recuerden ante todo que ellos no pueden hacer nada que sea más útil para la gloria de Dios y la salvación de los pueblos que procurar se promuevan pastores buenos e idóneos para gobernar a la Iglesia”.

Hay entonces verdadera necesidad de un Syllabus conciliar con valor doctrinal, y además existe la necesidad del aumento del número de pastores santos, valientes y profundamente arraigados en la Tradición de la Iglesia, despojados de toda especie de mentalidad de ruptura tanto en el campo doctrinal como en el campo litúrgico.

Estos dos elementos constituyen la condición indispensable para que la confusión doctrinal, litúrgica y pastoral disminuya notablemente y la obra pastoral del Concilio Vaticano II pueda proporcionar muchos y duraderos frutos en el espíritu de la Tradición, que nos enlaza con el espíritu que ha reinado en todo tiempo, en todas partes y en todos los verdaderos hijos de la Iglesia Católica, la cual es la única y la verdadera Iglesia de Dios en la tierra.

__________


El texto íntegro de la conferencia del obispo Athanasius Schneider, pronunciada en Roma el 17 de diciembre de 2010:

> Il primato del culto di Dio come fondamento di ogni vera teologia pastorale. Proposte per una corretta lettura del Concilio Vaticano II

__________


La apelación del 11 de enero pasado a Benedicto XVI contra los peligros doctrinales de un nuevo encuentro interreligioso en Asís:

> "Santo Padre Benedetto XVI, siamo alcuni cattolici gratissimi dell'opera da Lei compiuta..."

terça-feira, 11 de janeiro de 2011

A fé dos Demónios

1. Poderá um Sacerdote ou um Bispo aconselhar em quem votar ou desaconselhar de votar. Segundo o Cardeal Pell, que recentemente se pronunciou sobre o assunto, qualquer um deles tem plena legitimidade de o fazer, em circunstancias habituais, pois qualquer um deles é cidadão, como todas as outras pessoas.

Em Maio do ano passado escrevi dois pequenos textos sobre as presidenciais[1] nos quais sugeria que não se votasse em Cavaco Silva, em virtude das “leis” injustas, iníquas e criminosas que promulgou, cooperando desse modo formalmente com o mal intrínseco das mesmas e tornando-se moralmente responsável por todos os males, previstos e imprevistos, cometidos ao abrigo dessa mesmas “leis” [2] . Neles propunha, uma vez que os restantes candidatos padecem do mesmo mal, uma abstenção generalizada, com um propósito determinado. O facto de não sugerir o voto branco não se deveu somente ao facto de ele não contar como voto expresso mas também à circunstância de me parecer praticamente impossível persuadir um número significativo de pessoas a saírem de casa para irem votar desse modo. Continuo pois a favorecer a desmobilização eleitoral, pela abstenção.[3]

2. Desde então, e agora com maior frequência, tem-se advogado a escolha de Cavaco Silva em nome do “mal menor”. Este mal dito menor é defendido fundamentalmente por dois motivos. O primeiro consiste em pensar que Cavaco Silva é uma garantia que muito poderá ajudar na resolução da grave crise económica. Mutatis mutandi essa seria uma razão para votar em Hitler em vez de Estaline, caso a eleição se disputasse entre os dois. Julgue o leitor se seria oportuno e lícito escolher o primeiro. Eu, por mim, recusar-me-ia, evidentemente, a votar em qualquer um deles. O segundo motivo prende-se com a Fé. Cavaco diz que acredita em Deus e que é um católico praticante. Alegre pelo contrário professa o ateísmo. Ora, segundo alguns sempre será melhor eleger alguém que acredita em Deus do que quem n’ Ele não crê. Esta afirmação, porém, parece esquecer duas coisas. A primeira prende-se com o que o Papa Bento XVI e toda a história da Igreja têm ensinado, a saber, que os piores inimigos da mesma se encontram dentro dela e não fora. E a segunda de que há uma fé que é pior do que a ausência dela. Trata-se da fé dos demónios, de que fala S. Tiago na sua Carta. O P. António Vieira, desenvolvendo este tema num dos seus sermões acusa, num tempo dado à perseguição dos judeus, os cristãos de serem piores do que esses nossos irmãos mais velhos, precisamente, por terem uma fé como a dos demónios[4]. Essa fé acredita em todas as verdades acerca de Deus, de Cristo, da Igreja, etc., mas não se conforma com a vontade de Deus, não é operante, ignorando não só a Caridade e a Justiça mas indo mesmo contra elas. É uma fé cadavérica, morta, aquela que não tem obras. E se as que tem são contra o Amor e a Justiça é escabrosa, macabra, pestilencial, diabólica. E essa fé, segundo um filósofo judeu, que era ateu e se converteu ao catolicismo, Fabrice Hadjadj, é pior do que o ateísmo[5].

Alguém tem dúvidas, do tipo de fé que é revelado pelas leis promulgadas pelo actual presidente da república? As árvores conhecem-se pelos seus frutos, diz o Senhor no Evangelho.

3. Dantes, alguns manuais de moral, nos dias de hoje superados pela Encíclica O Esplendor da Verdade, diziam que entre dois males inevitáveis devia-se escolher o menor. Ora ninguém é obrigado a votar em qualquer um dos candidatos pelo que não está perante uma escolha má inevitável. A verdade, porém, é que nunca se pode escolher o mal e mesmo que alguém pense em consciência que deve escolher entre algum deles terá de fazê-lo por um bem e nunca por um mal.

De qualquer modo, parece-me claro que nas últimas décadas os eleitores têm vindo a escolher de “mal menor” em “mal menor” caindo sucessivamente nos piores males.

4. Uma vitória à primeira volta e retumbante do actual presidente-candidato constituiria uma consagração triunfal de todas as infâmias e crueldades de que foi cúmplice, uma sagração das políticas anti-vida, anti-família, anti-liberdade de ensino e de educação, anti-liberdade religiosa, anti, enfim, princípios e valores inegociáveis. Seria uma validação e premiação do maquiavelismo, da mais baixa imoralidade do falso e pernicioso axioma de que os fins justificam os meios. Seria uma proclamação de que tudo é permitido e nada impedido. Se desta vez não é penalizado nem punido nas urnas quem tanto mal fez em tão breve tempo, será imparável e irreversível, por muitos anos, a degradação e estragação dos católicos na política.

Nuno Serras Pereira

11. 01. 2011



[2] Procriação medicamente assistida (2006):
http://dre.pt/pdf1sdip/2006/07/14300/52455250.pdf

Aborto (2007):
http://dre.pt/pdf1sdip/2007/04/07500/24172418.pdf

Divórcio (2008):
http://dre.pt/pdf1sdip/2008/10/21200/0763307638.pdf
Educação sexual (2009):
http://dre.pt/pdf1sdip/2009/08/15100/0509705098.pdf
Casamento homossexual (2010):
http://dre.pt/pdf1sdip/2010/05/10500/0185301853.pdf
(Apoio do Estado aos estabelecimentos do ensino particular e cooperativo (2010):
http://dre.pt/pdf1sdip/2010/12/25001/0001300014.pdf)

[3] Nos artigos em questão explícito a finalidade de tal escolha.

[4] Num outro sermão chega a dizer que os cristãos podem ser piores do que os demónios.

[5] Vale a pena ler: Fabrice Hadjadj, La Fede Deis Demoni, ovvero il superamento dell’ ateísmo, Marietti 1820(Casa Editrice Marietti S.p.A – Genova-Milano), Julho 2010, pp. 255

sábado, 8 de janeiro de 2011

Former porn actress to men: Stop looking at porn or you will destroy your life


by John-Henry Westen

HOLLYWOOD, January 5, 2011 (LifeSiteNews.com) - Jennifer Case left the sex industry three years ago by the grace of God, she says, and her message to men is very clear: “There is a real person on the other side of the images you are seeing, and you are destroying her life and the lives of her children.”

In an interview with The Porn Effect, Case attests from her own personal experience the harm that the porn industry does to the women involved. She says was traumatized, oppressed and abused, and was hooked on drugs and needed the money from porn to continue to afford them. Physically she had to deal with sexually transmitted diseases: “I had so many different infections all of the time. I left Hollywood because I became so ill from Chlamydia. My abdomen hurt so much I had to come back home,” she said.

The porn industry is fueled by its consumers - they and their money drive the destructive business - and hence the damage done to these women can be attributed to the consumers as well as the producers. However, the former porn actress holds no grudge against men for her past life. She possesses a keen insight into the addictive nature of porn and says she realizes it will take God’s help for men to get out of the addiction, as it did for her to leave the business.

“Men, God loves you! I love you too and I will always pray for all of you, for the chains to be broken,” she says. “You are a slave to porn much as much any porn star. If you are viewing porn or addicted to porn, you are trying to fill a void inside of you that only God can fill. Whenever you look at porn, you are making the void bigger, and you will destroy your life.”

She says porn is “evil” and “is a drug and it is poison and a lie.”

“If you think you can keep it in the dark, God will bring it out into the light to stop you and heal you. “

In a heartfelt appeal to men, Case concluded the interview saying: “These women are precious and deserve to be loved just as much as you do. There is a real person on the other side of the images you are seeing, and you are destroying her life and the lives of her children. Every porno has somebody’s daughter in it. What if it were your little girl? You may actually be assisting in someone’s death! Male and female porn actors die all of the time from AIDS, drug overdoses, suicides, etc. Please stop looking at porn.”

See the full interview here.

quinta-feira, 6 de janeiro de 2011

A Very Important Marriage Debate


The authors of “What Is Marriage” have now replied at Public Discourse to a renewed attempt by Prof. Kenji Yoshino of NYU to explode their argument. Yoshino’s second attempt was more serious than his first, but also more revealing of the relativistic radicalism at the heart of the movement to redefine marriage. Turns out you can “redefine” marriage without actually defining it at all!

If you want to start at the beginning of this important debate, here are its parts so far:

1. Sherif Girgis, Robert P. George, and Ryan T. Anderson (hereafter GG&A), “What Is Marriage?” in the latest issue of the Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy, posted at SSRN on 11 December.

2. Kenji Yoshino, “The Best Argument Against Gay Marriage: And Why It Fails,” Slate, 13 December.

3. GG&A, “The Argument Against Gay Marriage: And Why It Doesn’t Fail,” Public Discourse, 17 December.

4. Andrew Koppelman, “What Marriage Isn’t,” Balkinization, 18 December.

5. GG&A, “Marriage: Merely a Social Construct?” Public Discourse, 29 December.

6. Barry Deutsch, “What Is Bodily Union? (A response to What Is Marriage?),” Family Scholars, 21 December.

7. GG&A, “Marriage: Real Bodily Union,” Public Discourse, 30 December.

8. Kenji Yoshino, “Lose the Baseball Analogy,” Slate, 21 December.

9. GG&A, “Marriage: No Avoiding the Central Question,” Public Discourse, 3 January.

I think I can safely say that Girgis, George, and Anderson’s arguments are still standing, while those of their critics have fallen pretty flat.

Can Immunology Corroborate the Two-in-One-Flesh Image in Genesis?

by Donald Demarco
In CERC
Science, which is immune to political or fashionable trends, bears witness to the unique nature of the conjugal bond between a man and a woman.
Our immune system, certainly one of the great marvels of nature, equips us with 100 billion (100,000,000,000) immunological receptors. Each of these tiny receptors has the uncanny natural capacity to distinguish the selfnonself.[1] Consequently, they are able to immunize or protect our bodies against the invasion of foreign substances that could be harmful to us.[2] from the

Marvelous as nature is, it is never extremist. From a purely immunological point of view (from the standpoint of an all out defensive strategy), a woman's body would reject the oncoming sperm, recognizing it as a foreign substance. But this is precisely the point at which nature, we might say, becomes wise. If our immune system regards sperm as a potential enemy, then fertilization would never take place, and the human race would have come to an early demise with the passing of Adam and Eve.

But something extraordinary occurs that makes fertilization and the continuation of the human race possible. Traveling alongside the sperm in the male's seminal fluid is a mild immunosuppressant. Immunologists refer to it as consisting of "immunoregulatory macromolecules." This immunosuppressant is a chemical signal to the woman's body that allows it to recognize the sperm not as a nonself, but as part of her own self. It makes possible, despite the immune system's usual preoccupation with building an airtight defense system, a self-to-self union or, from an immunological perspective, a "two-in-one-flesh" intimacy.

What is well known is that male semen carries spermatozoa that have the capacity to fuse with the nucleus of the woman's egg (fertilization). What is less known is the presence of the mild immunosupressant it carries that allows the woman's immune system to welcome the male sperm as part of her own flesh. Nature is congenial to heterosexual procreativity.

With regard to sodomy, on the other hand (whether hetero-or homosexual), a pertinent question can be raised: What happens when semen is deposited in the rectal area rather than in the vaginal tract? How do the spermatozoa and the immunosuppressant function when they are placed in this particular bodily environment?

  1. Sperm have the capacity to penetrate the nucleus of cells. While the physiological target of a sperm cell is the oocyte (egg), they can penetrate somatic cells as well. When this occurs with a somatic cell, this fusion of sperm with somatic cells may result in oncogenesis (the development of cancerous malignancies). In an article entitled, "Sexual Behaviour and Increased Anal Cancer," authors Richard J. Ablin and Rachel Stein-Werblowsky, report that "anal intercourse is one of the primary factors in the development of cancer."[3] They make the following observations: a) Spermatozoa are capable of penetrating somatic cells and fuse with their nuclei. b) Nuclear fusion, other than in normal fertilization, can result in malignant transformation in the invaded tissue. c) Immunoregulatory macromolecules may directly and/or indirectly contribute to an immunopermssive environment favourable for the perpetuation of spermatozoa (or otherwise)-induced tumours and/or be a factor for tumorigenic-associated infectious agents.[4] Daling et al., writing for the New England Journal of Medicine, state: "Our study lends strong support to the hypothesis that homosexual behaviour in men increases the risk of anal cancer."[5] In addition, Melbye et al., reporting in the International Journal of Cancer find that "Being single and having practiced anal intercourse appears to be associated with anal cancer and case reports have suggested a recent increase in the number of cases of anal cancer."[6] The medical literature on this point is extensive.

  2. Scientists have confirmed that when the male immunosuppressant is deposited in the rectal area an "immunopermissive environment" is created. This environment, in which the immune system is not working as it should, is favorable for the perpetration of spermatozoa-induced tumors and other pathologies. It is as if, in this instance, the immune system becomes confused and welcomes its enemies. Researchers have documented a decreasing immunocompetence in a substantial proportion of HIV-positive homosexual men, particularly those with a history of intraepithelial abnormalities.[7] It has been shown in a number of studies that, unlike all sexually transmitted disease, where both partners are equally susceptible to the disease, in homosexual males, immunosuppression appears in the anal sperm recipients but not in the partners who deposit the sperm.[8]

Nature does not make accommodations to politically based ideologies or individual preferences. This is a point that Dr. Jeffrey Satinover makes throughout his book Homosexuality and the Politics of Truth.[9] Heterosexual intercourse is biologically completely distinct from male homosexual intercourse, and the consequences of these acts are similarly divergent.

Furthermore, the vagina is an effective biological barrier against viruses. By contrast, the distal colon and rectum, which are designed to absorb water and nutrients in the final stages of the digestive process, possess a rich lymphatic network within the rectal mucosa (the lining of the rectum). Therefore, the distal colon and rectal area is designed to facilitate absorption, including absorption of the immunosuppressive components of male semen, if exposed to them.[10]

One researcher states that, "The risk of anal cancer soars for those engaging in anal intercourse. According to one report, it rises by an astounding 4,000 percent, and doubles again for those who are HIV positive."[11] Despite the well-documented adverse medical consequences associated with sodomy, this damaging practice has been strongly supported in certain influential circles. Indeed, even the Supreme Court (in Lawrence et al. vs. Texas) has specifically upheld male to male sodomy. According to Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for the majority, persons in a homosexual relationship may seek autonomy for these purposes ['The right to define one's own concept of existence, of meaning, of the universe'], just as heterosexual persons do."[12] In dissent, Justice Antonin Scalia saw the Lawrence decision as allowing politics to usurp law:

Today's opinion is the product of a Court, which is the product of a law-profession culture, that has largely signed on to the so-called homosexual agenda, by which I mean the agenda promoted by some homosexual activists directed at eliminating the moral opprobrium that has traditionally attached to homosexual conduct.[13]

Science in itself, like nature, is immune to political or fashionable trends. Politicians and lawyers, however, are more vulnerable to the seductions of the Zeitgeist. But in looking closely and carefully at what the science of immunology can tell us about the natural functioning of spermatozoa and the male immunosuppressant, we have even more reason for upholding and honoring the wisdom of marriage as the potentially procreative union of a man and a woman. In this regard, we have added reason to feel awe when we re-read the passage in the first chapter of Genesis that refers to marriage as a union of "two-in-one flesh." Immunology gives us reason to believe that this phrase is not a mere metaphor, but is descriptive of a reality unique to the conjugal bond between a man and a woman.

Immunology, of course, does not tell us what marriage is. But it does underscore the radical importance of the body and the fundamental importance for life of the distinctiveness of the sexes. On the other hand, Al and Tipper Gore's book Joined at the Heart (2002), to take but one example among many that represent a growing trend,[14] by employing a metaphor, fails to appreciate the corporeal solidity of marriage.[15] It is difficult to see how, by missing what is elementary to marriage, one could properly appreciate the subsequent psychological, spiritual, personal, and religious levels of marriage for which the body has prototypic significance.

Immunology, on a scientific level, corroborates the notion of the "two-in-one-flesh" meaning of marriage as recorded in Genesis. It offers yet another example of the compatibility of science and faith.

Endnotes:

  1. Daniel E. Koshland Jr., "Recognizing Self from Nonself," Science 248 (1990): 1273; F.M. Burnet, "Immunological Recognition of Self: Such Recognition Suggests a Relationship with Processes Through Which Functional Integrity Is Maintained," Science 133 (1961): 307-311.
  2. These include prostaglandins of the E series, complement inhibitors, transforming growth factor-beta receptors for Fc fraction of gamma-globulin and the more recently described glycodelin-A. See R.W. Kelly, "Immunosuppressive Mechanisms in Semen: Implications for Contraception," Human Reproduction 10 (1995):1686–1693; W.S. Yeung et al., "Glycodelin: A Molecule with Multi-Functions on Spermatozoa," Society of Reproduction and Fertility Supplement 63 (2007): 143–151.
  3. Richard J. Ablin and Rachel Stein-Werblowsky, "Sexual Behaviour and Increased Anal Cancer," Immunology and Cell Biology 75 (1997): 181–183.
  4. Ibid., 182.
  5. J.R. Daling at al., "Sexual Practices, Sexually Transmitted Diseases, and the In-
    cidence of Anal Cancer," New England Journal of Medicine 16 (1987): 937–973.
  6. M. Melbye et al., "Immune Status as a Determinant of Human Paillomavirus Detection and Its Association with Anal Epithelial Abnormalities," International Journal of Cancer 46 (1990): 203–206.
  7. M. Melbye et al., "Changing Patterns of Anal Cancer Incidence in the United States, 1940–1989," American Journal of Epidemiology 139 (1994): 777–780.
  8. G.M. Maviigit et al., "Chronic Immune Stimulation by Sperm Alloantigens," Journal of the American Medical Association 251 (1984): 237.
  9. Jeffrey Satinover, Homosexuality and the Politics of Truth (Grand Rapids, MI: Hamewith Books, 1996).
  10. T.C. Quinn et al., "The Polymicro Origin of Intestinal Infections in Homosexual Men," New England Journal of Medicine 309 (1983): 573–582; D.C. William et al., "Sexually Transmitted Enteric Pathogens in Male Homosexual Population," New York State Journal of Medicine 77 (1977): 2050–2051.
  11. M.A. Melonakos, R.N., "Why Isn’t Homosexuality Considered a Disorder on the Basis of Its Medical Consequences?" National Association for Research and Therapy of Homosexuality (NARTH) (May 15, 2004), 2, http://www.leaderu. com/orgs/narth/medconsequences.html.
  12. Lawrence et al. v. Texas, 539 U.S. 558 (2003). The purposes Justice Kennedy had defined just prior to this quote by quoting himself from Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 505 U.S. 833 (1992).
  13. Lawrence et al. v. Texas, 539 U.S. 558 (2003).
  14. Two examples are: 1) Mother Outlaws: Theories and Practices of Empowerment Mothering, ed. Andrea O’Reilly (Toronto, ON: Women’s Press, 2004), 126, where the author extols the "new" family in which "gendered demarcation and embodiment is forever displaced"; 2) Margaret A. Farley, Just Love: A Framework for Christian Sexual Ethics (New York: Continuum, 2006), 288: "the justice ethic appropriate to heterosexual relationships is the same justice ethic appropriate to same-sex relationships."
  15. Al and Tipper Gore, Joined at the Heart: The Transformation of the American Family (New York: Henry Holt and Company, 2002).

quarta-feira, 5 de janeiro de 2011

Gender Identity Disorder in Children

by Dr.s Richard P. Fitzgibbons, M.D. & Joseph Nicolosi, Ph.D.

In Culture of Life Foundation

Dr.s Richard P. Fitzgibbons, M.D. & Joseph Nicolosi, Ph.D. explain the early signs of Gender Identity Disorder, the sources of the disorder and counsel parents on strategies that can be counterproductive as well as strategies and therapies that are helpful and effective.

A mother, concerned for some time about her 4-year-old son's effeminate mannerisms, lack of male playmates, and interest in Barbie dolls, finally decides to ask the pediatrician if these are signs of a problem. She is particularly worried that her husband has become increasingly upset and alienated from their son.

The pediatrician is reassuring: "This is just a phase nothing to worry about. He will grow out of it." Unfortunately, the pediatrician is probably wrong. Gender identity problems, including cross-dressing, exclusive cross-gender play, and a lack of same-sex friends should be treated as a symptom that something may be very wrong. Boys who exhibit such symptoms before they enter school are more likely: to be unhappy, lonely and isolated in elementary school; to suffer from separation anxiety, depression, and behavior problems; to be victimized by bullies and targeted by pedophiles; and to experience same-sex attraction in adolescence. If they engage in homosexual activity as adolescents, they are more likely than boys who do not: to be involved in drug and alcohol abuse or prostitution; to attempt suicide; or to contract a sexually transmitted disease, such as HIV/AIDS; or to develop a serious psychological problem as an adult. A small number of these boys will become transvestites or transsexuals.

The good news is that if the gender identity problems are identified and addressed and if both parents cooperate in the solution, especially fathers, many of the negative outcomes can be prevented. According to Dr. Kenneth Zucker and Susan Bradley, experts in the treatment of gender identity problems in children, treatment should begin as soon as possible.

...In general we concur with those who believe that the earlier treatment begins, the better. [1]...It has been our experience that a sizable number of children and their families can achieve a great deal of change. In these cases, the gender identity disorder resolves fully, and nothing in the children's behavior or fantasy suggest that gender identity issues remain problematic.... All things considered, however, we take the position that in such cases clinicians should be optimistic, not nihilistic, about the possibility of helping the children to become more secure in their gender identity[2].

The effeminacy in some boys is so pronounced that parents may assume the problem is genetic or hormonal, but no such factors have been scientifically proven. Experts report that children assumed to have a biological problem responded positively to therapeutic intervention: According to Rekers, Lovaas, and Low:

When we first saw him, the extent of his feminine identification was so profound (his mannerisms, gestures, fantasies, flirtations, etc., as shown in his "swishing" around the home and the clinic, fully dressed as a woman with a long dress, wig, nail polish, high screechy voice, slatternly, seductive eyes) that it suggested irreversible neurological and biochemical determinants. After 26 months follow-up, he looked and acted like any other boy. People who viewed the video taped recordings of him before and after treatment talk of him as "two different boys."[3]

Healthy psychological development requires that a little boy be able to feel acceptance by and identify with his father, experience acceptance by male peers, recognize that there are two sexes and that he is male and will grow up to be a man and possibly a father, not a woman and a mother. Additionally he needs to feel good about his body and about being a boy and becoming a man. He needs to believe that his mother and father are happy that he is a boy and expect him to become a man and he needs to feel accepted as a boy by other boys.

If a boy feels inadequate in his masculine identity due to peer or father rejection or a poor body image, identifies with his mother instead of his father, feels that he would like to be a girl, those around him should not pass this off as non-stereotypical behavior. There is a reason why this boy is not developing a healthy masculine identity and that reason should be discovered and addressed.

One often hears boys with gender identity problems called "girlish", but if one observes their behavior carefully, one sees that they do not resemble healthy little girls of the same age, but imitate adult women. For example, while doll play for healthy girls includes mother/baby play and fashion/dress up play, boys with gender identity problems focus almost exclusively on fashion/dress up. While healthy girls combine outdoor physical activities with more sedate play, boys with gender identity problems are often unreasonably afraid of injury, avoid rough and tumble play, and dislike group sports. Cross-dressing and cross-gender fantasy in boys is often passed off by the family as a sign that the boy is a "great actor" or has a "wonderful imagination." Family members fail to understand that a boy who never takes the part of male character, but identifies with either a benevolent, idealized female, such as a princess or Snow White, or a domineering, angry female is revealing a deep ambivalence toward his own masculinity and toward women. Therapy can help the boy and his family understand why he feels more confident, comfortable, and accepted when he is fantasizing that he is a female.

Today many adults try very hard not to impose rigid gender stereotypes on young children, but this push for gender openness can lead parents to ignore the symptoms of gender identity conflict. Children with gender identity problems don't inhabit a gender neutral world where boys and girls play with the same toys. These troubled children reject certain types of play and clothing precisely because it is associated with their own gender or adopt activities because they are associated in their mind with the opposite sex. Boys with serious gender identity problems may use female clothing to gain acceptance or soothe anxiety become angry and upset when deprived of these objects.

Some parents may ask "What is wrong with a boy playing with dolls?" The answer is that the problem is as much what he is not doing -- learning how to be a boy among boys -- as it is what he is doing -- escaping into a female world.

Parents need to be concerned when a child openly expresses a dissatisfaction with his or her sex. such as when a boy says "I want to be a girl" or when a girl insist she is a boy. One extremely effeminate boy when asked, "Do you want to be like your daddy when grown up?" responded "I don't want to grown up." Such statements should be taken as symptoms that something is very wrong. Although the boy may feel or even express the desire to grow up to be a woman, he is male and will grow up to be a man.

Children are born with a drive to seek love and acceptance by each parent, siblings and peers. If this need is met, children develop an acceptance of their masculinity or femininity. When this developmental task is successfully completed, the child is free to choose gender atypical activities. Boys and girls with gender identity problems are not freely experimenting with gender atypical activities. They constrained by deep insecurities and fears and are reacting against the reality of their own sexual identity, usually as a result of failing to experience love and acceptance from the parent of the same sex or same sex peers. Therapy is not directed toward forcing a sensitive or artistic boy to become a macho-sports fanatic, but helping a boy to grow in confidence and be happy he is a boy.

Effeminacy, cross-gender play, and cross dressing are not the only signs that there may be a problem. Some boys suffer from a chronic sense of being inadequate in their masculinity , but do not imitate female behavior. These boys may exhibit an almost phobic reaction to rough and tumble play and an intense dislike of team sports because of poor eye-hand coordination. This inability to bond with other boys through sports boys leads to isolation, profound loneliness, a weak sense of masculinity, deep resentment and often depression.

Gender identity problems also occur among girls, although the problem is less common. In some cases a father may be pleased with his daughter's success in athletics and ignore her phobic reaction to dresses or anything feminine. Girls with gender identity problems may believe that being a boy will make them safe from abuse. Other girls, like the majority of boys with GID, have struggled with low self-esteem and a poor body image and have never appreciated their God-given female gifts and beauty.

What should a parent do if they think that there might be a problem. First, they should take any repeated problematic behaviors as a cry for help. If their pediatrician ignores their concerns, they should find a therapist who is trained in the treatment of gender identity problems. Parents can read up on the subject. in Zucker and Bradley's book Gender Identity and Psychosexual Problems in Children and Adolescence, which offers a complete review of the problem.

Consistent cross-gender behaviors are a sign that the child believes he or she would be better off' as the opposite sex. According to Bradley and Zucker, "This fantasy solution' provides relief but at a cost." These are unhappy children who are using these behaviors defensively to deal with their distress.[4]

Parents sometimes try on their own to stop the overt behavior, but forcing a frightened child to engage in behaviors in which he feels inadequate or fearful is not the solution. The therapist can work with the child and the parents to uncover the root cause of the emotional conflicts, so that the problem can be addressed and resolved.

In our experience a challenging aspect of treatment is helping the father realize how crucial his role is in the healing process and then engaging him to become more involved with strengthening his son’s masculine identity. This difficuly is often the result of the father’s modeling after a father (the boy’s grandfather) who did not communicate praise and love regularly to the father.

It is true that without treatment certain manifestations of gender identity conflicts, such as fantasy fashion doll play in boys or open cross-dressing may disappear by the time the child is 8 or 9, but these coping mechanisms are often replaced by other less overt expressions of an underlying gender identity problem. Once the problem goes "underground" it will be more difficult to treat.

Some people may avoid treatment because they believe that gender identity problems are a sign that the child was born "homosexual" and that the parents should simply accept this outcome as inevitable and encourage the child to accept a homosexual identity. Given the positive results of early intervention, the profound unhappiness of these children during elementary school, and the massive problems which accompany same-sex attraction in adolescence, parents should do everything possible to help their child resolve even minor gender identity problems.

Catholic parents need to be particularly concerned. The Church's teaching on homosexual activity is clearly stated in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, "homosexuals acts are intrinciscally disordered... Under no circumstances can they be approved" (CCC 2357). For a Catholic trying to be obedient to God, temptations to same-sex activity are a source of deep pain. Treatment of adolescents or adults is possible, but difficult and the outcome is not assured. It is far better to prevent the problem or treat it in early childhood. Those who would like to understand more about same-sex attractions can find information on the website of the Catholic Medical Association (www.cathmed.org) in a report entitled Homosexuality and Hope.

If a boy grows up at ease and confident about his masculine identity as a result of a close loving relationship with his father, with same-sex friends in childhood, with a mother who supports his manly development and is protected from vicious bullying and sexual predators, the chances are minimal that he will experience same-sex attraction in adolescence. Even if one or two items on the above list are missing, the chances are still small that the boy will become homosexually involved as an adult. Generally, the histories of men engaging in same-sex behaviors reveal a history of cumulative problems: significant peer rejection, a distant father, a poor body image, low self-esteem, an overprotective or controlling mother, victimization by bullies, or sexual abuse. Fortunately these conflicts can be resolved, and the masculine identity can be strengthened and then embraced

[1] Zucker and Bradley (p.281)

[2] .(p.282)

[3] Rekers, G., Lovaas, O., Low, B. (1974) Behavioral treatment of deviant sex role behaviors in a male child. Journal of Applied Behavioral Analysis. 7: 134 - 151.

[4] Bradley, S., Zucker, K. (1998) Drs. Bradley and Zucker reply. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. 37, 3: 244-245.