quinta-feira, 2 de agosto de 2012

Expertise and Ethics - by Anthony Esolen

In CRISIS

One of the more puzzling things about contemporary arguments regarding what things a good or free society ought to allow and what things it ought to forbid is our turn toward the “expert,” the ethicist, the person who has made a professional career of teasing out deductions from moral premises. But what really qualifies such a person to be regarded as a beacon of wisdom? Aristotle famously said that the best way to learn about justice would be to observe a just man. The dictum is not tautological. In the life of a Mother Teresa, for example, we may learn literally countless—that is, not reducible to numbers—lessons in love and magnanimity, whence we may confirm true principles already held, and reveal others whose existence we had not suspected. We would be confronting the just life not as an academic exercise, but as an intensely personal challenge.

The same aridity and insubstantiality can be found in “professional” conclusions that a certain act is ethical or unethical. Such terms are pallid substitutes for older, harder words, like right and wrong, or good and evil, or straight and crooked, or upright and depraved. They relieve us of the necessity of existential analysis. It is as if one were playing a game, with moves that would either promote or hinder our objective, but would remain comfortably extrinsic to us. But those older words are ineluctably existential. An act that is wrong is, etymologically, twisted: cf. wry, wrinkle, writhe, the contortions of the face of a man seized by wrath, a mind warped by evil; also Latin perversus, turned inside out. It is what gave Dante the happy idea of portraying Purgatory as a corkscrew mountain, whose turnings would unwind the bends in those whom the world had made crooked.

Now the thing about crookedness is that it is inherently unstable. Hammer a crooked nail head-on and you will bend it all the more. A car that is out of alignment will grow worse with every jolt of a pothole. So too with the lived reality of evil. It is disintegrative. “Sin will pluck on sin,” says Macbeth, knowing that the evil of his murder of King Duncan is not “the be-all and end-all.”  “For he that once hath missed the right way,” says Spenser’s Despair to the Red Cross Knight, speaking truly, “the further he doth go, the further he doth stray.”  “While they adore me on the throne of Hell,” says Milton’s Satan, referring scornfully to his fellows in crime, “the lower still I fall.”

To recognize the disintegrative character of evil is not to commit the fallacy of the slippery slope. Granted, a step in one morally neutral direction does not imply a further step in the same direction. To raise taxes by 5 percent is not to raise taxes by 10 percent. Nor does the affirmation of a certain kind of action in certain circumstances imply an affirmation of a superficially similar kind of action in other circumstances. To spank a child for drawing with a crayon on the walls is not to whip him for painting them. But evil is like a progressive and deadly disease. To engage in an evil act, again and again, is more than the acquisition of a habit, which will make the same act easier and easier to commit, but which has no effect upon the person otherwise. If we accept the insight of the ancient Platonists—that evil as a thing-in-itself does not exist, but is instead a privation or a corruption of a good that should be there—then the turn toward evil is a turn toward non-being. To embrace evil at the core is, as it were, to riddle oneself with unreason, with nonexistence. It is to warp, to rot.

We should recall, then, that the ancients never equated wisdom with a great facility for ratiocination or calculation. To be in one’s wits, to be wise is, literally, to see (cf. Latin videre, Greek idea). But evil twists the mind. A bad man is worse than a bad dog, not just because he can put his evil to greater effect, but because the evil causes him to see things wrong-side-out, so that he will apply his reasoning powers to unreason. If he is possessed of great natural intelligence, he may become a genius in depravity.  Alfred Kinsey, the teenager, was not yet hiring pederasts to molest infant boys in his laboratory; he was not yet collecting warped data from prison populations, and stretching it to “reveal” things about ordinary people. But by the time he was corrupting a nation with lies, I doubt that the greatest topologist in the world could have mapped the tangles of his heart to distinguish what was left of the genuine Kinsey and what was the serpentine and all-eating cancer.

In this sense all murderers are suicides, all liars are dupes. When, in Milton’s Paradise Lost, the Father offers grace to fallen mankind, it is described in terms of vision:

And I will place within them as a guide My umpire Conscience, whom if they will hear, Light after light well used they shall attain, And to the end persisting, safe arrive.
But those who reject that grace will walk in darkness:

This my long suffering and my day of grace they who neglect and scorn, shall never taste, But hard be hardened, blind be blinded more, That they may stumble on, and deeper fall.

Quite aside from the theology, the view of what happens to evil men is correct and is ratified by history and experience—the rogues’ gallery of twentieth-century despots alone provides evidence enough. With all his prodigious intellect, and even by way of that intellect, Lenin was a blind man; and they who followed the cruel mastermind were blinded too.

Then the first question we might ask of an ethicist who tries to persuade us, with diagrams and statistics and syllogisms, that what we had thought was evil is actually all right, is not “What degrees do you have?” or “What articles have you published in peer-reviewed journals?” but “Who are you?” It isn’t an easy question, nor is it decisive. An otherwise decent person may be, for a long while, better than his evil philosophy, and then we may thank God for foolishness and inconsistency. But it ought to be asked.

Who are these medical ethicists who recently have concluded, with wonderful logic, that parents have a right to murder their infant children—and who call it, with telling duplicity, “after-birth abortion?”  We would not turn to Larry Flynt or Hugh Hefner for a definition of decency; why should we turn to these people to advise us on which children we may kill and when? Are they crooked? Why should we follow the crooked, when we want to walk straight?

I am not recommending ad hominem attacks, or the ignoring of rational (or irrational) arguments. I wish merely to assert that when an ethicist, or anyone else for that matter, recommends that an action previously considered wrong be permitted, the burden of proof is particularly heavy, and we are justified in examining the virtue of the recommender. A warped heart, a warped mind— the one will eventually follow upon the other. Similarly, when a person of acknowledged moral courage, a Mother Teresa, warns us that an action which we have permitted is evil, we would be wrong not to pause and reconsider. Yes, we may admit the confusion of motives in any human being, and the rarity of pure saints or pure demons. But the virtuous life is an art; and one learns art not from theorists but from the artists themselves.

quarta-feira, 1 de agosto de 2012

Casi cuatro mil pastores negros advierten a Obama: no le votarán por el matrimonio gay

In Religión en Libertad

"Está ignorando a la gente que le puso en la Casa Blanca": más claro no lo pudo decir William Owens, presidente de la Coalición de Pastores Afroamericanos. Este grupo que ha advertido al presidente de que harán una campaña nacional para que los votantes negros se piensen el apoyo mayoritario que dieron hace cuatro años a Barack Obama.

"Es la hora de un ataque amplio contra los poderes que quieren cambiar nuestra cultura para un hombre pueda casarse con un hombre, y una mujer con una mujer. Me avergüenza que sea el primer presidente negro quien elija esa desgraciada vía", dijo este jueves durante un acto en el Club Nacional de Prensa.

Esta campaña, anunció, "es un esfuerzo para salvar la familia" de ese asalto. Le respaldaban en el estrado otros cinco pastores, en representación de los 3.742 pastores negros que se han unido a ella, y cuya influencia sobre sus respectivas comunidades puede ser decisiva ante unas elecciones presidenciales que se anuncian muy reñidas.

Obama se manifestó durante la campaña electoral de 2008 contra el matrimonio homosexual, pero el pasado mes de mayo hizo un viraje radical en su posición: "Las parejas del mismo sexo deberían poder casarse", dijo en ABC News.

Según recoge la CNN, Owens advirtió al actual inquilino de la Casa Blanca de que no dé por garantizado el voto negro, y de que no hay ninguna similitud entre la lucha por los derechos civiles y el movimiento en favor de la equiparación de las parejas homosexuales con el matrimonio.

Según una encuesta de abril del Pew Research Center, el 49% de los negros norteamericanos rechazan el matrimonio homosexual, diez puntos más que quienes lo aprueban. Un sondeo del Public Religion Research Institute apuntó también a que para un 18% de los negros este punto será "decisivo" a la hora de orientar su voto.

Truth and Lies, Nature and Convention: The Debate Over Same-Sex Marriage - by Matthew J. Franck


The case for same-sex marriage, as articulated in a new book that debates the issue, still refuses to recognize that civil society needs real marriage, as it has always existed, to preserve itself. 
 
Why do the advocates of same-sex marriage want what they want? And why do defenders of traditional marriage, as uniting men with women to form families, resist such a change? One cannot do better for achieving clarity on such questions than by reading Debating Same-Sex Marriage, co-authored by John Corvino and Maggie Gallagher. Corvino, who teaches philosophy at Wayne State University in Michigan, and Gallagher, a co-founder of the National Organization for Marriage, have achieved something of real value in this book, confronting one another with (in general) an admirable degree of civility. Given the space to build arguments for their own views, and to respond to each other at length, Corvino and Gallagher provide what are probably the best and the most complete arguments on either side of this momentous debate.

And this is why Debating Same-Sex Marriage so admirably exposes the weakness of the case in its favor.

Gallagher sums up the aims of the two sides this way:

For gay marriage advocates, the ultimate end is equality: the recognition of gay unions as marriages in all fifty states and ultimately around the world as part of the process of creating a world in which sexual orientation is treated like race.
For opponents of gay marriage, stopping gay marriage is not victory, it is only a necessary step to the ultimate victory: the strengthening of a culture of marriage that successfully connects sex, love, children, and mothers and fathers.

Corvino no doubt agrees with Gallagher’s characterization of his side’s argument. What he gives no credence is her account of her own side. Indeed, he signally fails even to grasp the kinds of arguments Gallagher makes, and then concludes, from his own failure, that her arguments must be incoherent. But the shoe is on the other foot.

The trouble for Corvino begins with the tissue-thin brevity of the positive case he makes for “marriage equality,” as he calls it. In a mere eight pages or so—constituting just a tenth of his opening “case for same-sex marriage”—Corvino tells us that marriage, more than any other arrangement or institution in which two people can take part, “promotes mutual lifelong caregiving.” This, he would have us believe, is the core, the irreducible purpose of marriage, its true raison d’être. Some homosexual couples really want to enter into such an arrangement, and to have it called “marriage” under the law with all the attendant rights and recognition that accompany the label. For Corvino, their desire for this recognized arrangement supplies them with a presumptive right to it, in the name of equality. And so for the remainder of his main statement, and his reply to Gallagher’s statement, Corvino devotes all his space to attempted rebuttals of the opposing view.

That is, he proceeds as though the common understanding of marriage advanced by every known civilization must justify itself before the tribunal of a wholly new and unproven understanding. And this sets the pattern: Corvino alternates between ineffectual logic-chopping that evades the real issues regarding the nature and purpose of marriage, and making the argumentum ad misericordiam, the appeal to our sympathy for gay and lesbian couples. If only we understood how important it is to this or that couple to be able to marry, we would drop our objections. We would understand that “to deny marriage to a group of people” who want it very badly is to tell them that “you are less than a full citizen.”

But as Gallagher shows, the reason marriage exists in the first place is not to satisfy the longings of any two (or more) persons for social recognition of their desire to care for one another for the long haul, or to make anyone feel better about his place in society. The reason marriage exists is because (in the briefest version of her argument), “sex makes babies, society needs babies, children need mothers and fathers.” These are, she rightly notes, social problems for which marriage is the institutional solution. Our private relationships are generally none of the state’s proper business. But society’s manifest need to regulate procreation and the responsibility for children elevates marriage—and the legitimate family relations that flow from it—from the plane of private law to the plane of public law. As the family of mother, father, and children is more basic and natural than the state, so marriage, as the relationship that founds the family, needs and deserves all the status the state can bestow upon it.

What problem, by contrast, does same-sex marriage solve? No two persons of the same sex can, without the aid of others, generate children. Again, the best Corvino can offer is that “it’s good for people to have a special someone” and that “commitment matters.” True enough. But these are not, even remotely, social problems requiring an institutional solution. Marriage, for same-sex couples, is a solution in search of a problem.

Yet it is more than that, for, as Gallagher also demonstrates, same-sex marriage promises to create all sorts of new problems, and to exacerbate others we already know. Marriage in the modern age is a wounded institution, and the advent of same-sex marriage would injure it further. We already have trouble remembering that marriage is about procreation—and that procreation ought to take place within marriage. Same-sex marriage would make remembering this harder. We already have trouble honoring fidelity, exclusivity, and permanence in marriage; same-sex marriage would make this harder too. We already have trouble articulating why our society rejects polygamy, or even incest; same-sex marriage would render us speechless. We already have trouble recalling that marriage unites men and women so that children have both mothers and fathers, preferably the ones nature gave them; same-sex marriage means actively rejecting this idea. And this rejection begins with the necessity of telling ourselves a lie about what marriage is, a falsehood that is wrong in itself and that has terrible fallout.

To all of Gallagher’s deep reflections on the nature of fundamental human relationships, Corvino can only reply with shallow recourse to mere conventionalism. Marriage, he argues, is an evolving social institution, which has picked up new baggage and shed old baggage over the centuries. It is simply a name we give to our most highly prized relationships of mutual care and commitment. Therefore, if we decide to include same-sex unions among such relationships, all we are doing is changing the “established usage” of the word. Marriage is, for Corvino, like other entirely conventional institutions with meanings that utterly “depend on shared understanding across a community,” like “corporation” or “baseball.” In a world in which the word “mother” has as much connection to nature as the phrase “designated hitter,” the purblind philosopher is king. As Gallagher writes, “an institution with deep roots in human nature and human necessity becomes contingent and arbitrary, a product of will and politics, as the rational connections between its component parts are severed.”

There is much more coverage of the controversy over marriage in this book than a brief review can recapitulate, including a discussion of the social science on same-sex parenting that has been overtaken by the recent research of sociologist Mark Regnerus and the New Family Structures Study (about which, see recent Public Discourse articles here and here). But there is one respect in which Corvino’s contribution to Debating Same-Sex Marriage is truly hair-raising. When Gallagher argues that one of the essential meanings of same-sex marriage is that it will result in the privatization and stigmatization of beliefs about marriage that have prevailed in every age and culture, and the active suppression of such beliefs in the public square, Corvino concedes that this is so. He replies, with an honesty that is both commendable and chilling: “Whichever side prevails in this debate, the other’s views will be marginalized. There’s no getting around that.”

In other words, Corvino does indeed look forward to a future in which those who believe men can only marry women and women can only marry men will be treated as bigots, just as racists are treated today. In this future, already working itself out in states and countries with same-sex marriage (and even some that so far have only same-sex civil unions), these bigots will be denied advancement in their professions; their rights to conduct private businesses according to their view of the reality of marriage will be regulated out of existence; their children will be inculcated with a view of marriage that is anathema to them; and in general they can look forward to being told they are in the grip of an “irrational hatred” they must relinquish as an obsolete social pathology. The fact that considered moral views, and not animosity, are at the root of their beliefs, will matter not at all. The fact that, for most people believing what human civilizations have always believed about marriage, this belief is intimately bound up with religious faith and vouchsafed to them by revelation itself, will avail them nothing.

A future in which same-sex marriage is enshrined in the law is a future without meaningful religious liberty, freedom of speech, or economic freedom for millions of Americans. Yes, they can “privatize” their view, and go about their business incognito, as it were. But that is a surrender of their freedom, not a preservation of it. As Gallagher astutely notes:

Using the power of law and culture to suppress alternative conceptions of marriage and sex (because gay people find these ideas hurtful and insulting to the newly internalized equality norm) is not a bug in the gay marriage system, it’s a feature. It’s part of, if not the main point.

Corvino is right. One side or the other will have its view “marginalized.” Until just a few years ago, the notion that persons of the same sex could marry one another was the very definition of a “marginal” view. Practically no one took it seriously, even among gays and lesbians (who do not universally embrace it even now). The case in its favor is so undeniably weak, as Corvino’s contributions to this book demonstrate, that the progress the same-sex marriage “movement” has made is an amazing tale of the incantatory power of the word “equality.” When the incantation fades, and sense returns to those who have been bewitched by it, the idea of same-sex marriage will once again retreat to the margins of society. That will be a victory of justice over tyranny. The only question is, will we resist the disastrous error of an experiment with a lie, or will we try to live the lie and then have to recover from it? Human societies have experimented with lies before. It is better to avoid them in the first place.

‘Dehumanizing’ and ‘insulting’: Kenya Bishops slam Melinda Gates’ contraception plan for Africa - by Peter Baklinski

NAIROBI, Kenya, July 31, 2012 (LifeSiteNews.com) - The Catholic Bishops of Kenya have collectively slammed a pro-contraception article that appeared in the country’s Africa Review earlier this month as “dangerous” saying that it could “lead to destruction of the human society and by extension the human race.”

“We cannot allow our country to be part of an international agenda, driven by foreign funds and by so doing, losing our independence and our African values of the family and society,” wrote John Cardinal Njue, chairman of the Kenya Episcopal Conference of Bishops in a letter titled Let us Uphold Human Dignity. 

The article that the Bishops wrote against, titled “Kenya joins global birth control push”,  mentioned that Kenya is among the countries that have “signed up to a new $4.2 billion (Sh356 billion) drive to promote family planning services”, adding that leaders of more than 20 developing countries made “bold commitments” to address “financing and delivery barriers” that women face who seek contraceptive services and supplies.

The article also mentioned that Planning minister Wycliffe Oparanya attended a summit in the U.K. as part of the World Population Day where the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, co-hosts of the event, “underscored the importance of access to contraceptives as both a right and a transformational health and development priority.”

But the country’s Catholic Bishops made it clear that they would have nothing to do with the “artificial family planning programme” by “foreign forces”.

“[T]he use of contraceptives […] is both dehumanizing and goes against the teaching of the church, especially in a country like Kenya where a majority of the people are Christians and God fearing. It already threatens the moral fabric of the society and is an insult to the dignity and integrity of the human person.”

The Catholic Bishops urged all Kenyans and the country’s government leaders that “any development which does not protect the human person is meaningless and in vain.”

The Bishops slammed the program for targeting millions of girls and women in Africa with contraception while “many women are dying daily due to lack of proper medical care, food and housing.”

The Bishops point out that there are other “efficient ways of proactive and Responsible Parenthood through the practice of Natural Family Planning” that do not contradict the “centrality of the human person”.

“This of course demands discipline through abstinence, which is a necessary value in married life. This should not be rubbished as impossible,” they wrote

“Nobody should be forced to abuse his/her dignity through contraceptives”, the Bishops conclude.

Melinda Gates’ recently-launched campaign to distribute contraceptives to African women has come under attack by critics who say that it is based on “an unfounded and second-rate understanding” of the issue.

Italian journalist Giulia Galeotti called (http://www.lifesitenews.com/resources/birth-control-and-disinformation-the-risks-of-philanthropy) the Gates’ plan “off-target” and suggested that the people running it were “confused by bad information and by the stereotypes that persist regarding this topic [of family planning].”

Galeotti suggested that Gates must be unaware of the reliability of existing family planning methods that are entirely natural, such as the Billings Ovulation Method, which is not only moral in the mind of the Catholic Church, but is also completely free in that in involves no plastics or costly drugs. 

“Using this method, women can know if they are fertile or not, and based on that, can choose their sexual behavior,” wrote Galeotti, adding that the communist government of Peking promoted the method of regulating births that “cost nothing and didn’t damage the health of the woman, a method considered 98% reliable.”

Vatican newspaper blasts Gates for ‘disinformation’ campaign on contraceptives - by Matthew Cullinan Hoffman

July 31, 2012 (LifeSiteNews.com) - The Vatican’s L’Osservatore Romano newspaper has published an article attacking Melinda Gates’ recently-launched campaign to distribute contraceptives to African women, saying that it is based on “an unfounded and second-rate understanding” of the issue.
Click here for full translation of article.

The article, written by Italian journalist Giulia Galeotti, and titled “Birth control and disinformation: The risks of philanthropy,” notes that Melinda Gates has expressed “anguish” over her new initiative, due to the conflict it creates with the Catholic hierarchy. It adds that Gates is apparently unaware of the reliability of the Billings Ovulation Method (BOM) - a moral and completely free family planning method - for spacing births.

Unlike contraception, the Billings method allows women to avoid conception by abstaining from sexual intercourse during the more fertile part of the month, and has no adverse health effects. The method is endorsed by the Catholic Church when used to avoid children for serious reasons. Galeotti notes that the method is so reliable that the Chinese government is encouraging its citizens to use it.

CLICK ‘LIKE’ IF YOU ARE PRO-LIFE!
 
“An example, little known but striking, of the success of BOM has been its adoption in China,” writes Galeotti. “The communist government of Peking was very interested in a method of regulation that cost nothing and didn’t damage the health of the woman, a method considered 98% reliable.”
However, the “original and unpardonable sin,” of BOM is that ” it is completely free, an aspect that, evidently, makes it very unpopular with the pharmaceutical industry, which, through chemical contraceptives, obtains enormous profits, as will others thanks to the philanthropy of Mrs. Gates.”

Galeotti warns that if Gates persists in “disinformation, presenting things in a false manner,” she “runs the risk” of falling into the kind of corporate exploitation carried out by Nestlé, which distributes powdered milk to pregnant women free, then charges them for it once they cease to produce breast milk, and pressures them with advertising portraying breastfeeding as “barbaric.”

The truth about ‘Morning-after pills’ - by Anna Maria Hoffman


On June 5, 2012, New York Times writer Pam Belluck wrote an article called “Abortion Qualms on Morning-After Pill May Be Unfounded.” In her article, Belluck mistakenly lumps Plan B and Ella—two very different drugs—together, ignorantly proclaims that these drugs do not prevent implantation, and does not account for Ella’s abortion-inducing actions. 

Unsurprisingly, Belluck claims that the pro-life view of morning-after pills “is probably rooted in outdated or incorrect scientific guesses about how [they] work.” As she presents her empty argument, Belluck argues that no studies have confirmed “that emergency contraceptive pills prevent fertilized eggs from implanting in the womb” and that these pills only “delay ovulation.”  She heavily refers to a New York Times review, along with “scientists” and “experts” she forgets to cite, to support her view that Plan B does not prevent implantation and that “the one-shot dose in morning-after pills does not have time to affect the uterine lining.”

Disheartened by Belluck’s reporting? Luckily, several renowned pro-life advocates have written articles against Belluck’s dishonest claims:





terça-feira, 31 de julho de 2012

Primera derrota judicial del «mandato» de Obama contrario a la libertad religiosa

In Religión en Libertad

John L. Kane, juez federal del tribunal de distrito de Colorado, le ha dado la razón al presidente de Hercules Industries (una empresa que trabaja en el ámbito de la eficiencia energética y las energías renovables), William Newland, en su demanda contra el "mandato" anticonceptivo y abortista de la Administración norteamericana.

El magistrado, nombrado en tiempos de Jimmy Carter, ha suspendido la aplicación de la orden ministerial HHS (Health and Human Services [Servicios Humanos y de Salud]), también conocido como "mandato anticonceptivo", en el caso de Hercules Industries, atendiendo a que dicha disposición legal viola la libertad religiosa de los dueños de la empresa, que son católicos y presentaron en su momento la correspondiente demanda.

El "mandato" de Barack Obama, que ha provocado la mayor reacción colectiva de los católicos norteamericanos en la historia del país (culminada con una Quincena por la Libertad que terminó el 4 de Julio), pretende obligar a todas las empresas e instituciones religiosas a asegurar a sus empleados con seguros médicos que incluyan planes anticonceptivos y en algún caso abortivos.

Un instrumento para cerrar empresas católicas
Según Kane, si esto se aplicara en Hercules Industries se produciría a sus propietarios un "daño irreparable" desde el punto de vista de su libertad religiosa, derecho fundamental reconocido en la Constitución como clave fundacional de Estados Unidos.

Los dueños de Hercules Industries (William Newland, Paul Newland, James Newland y Christine Ketterhagen), una empresa familiar, contrataron los servicios de Matt Bowman, abogado de Alliance Defence Fund [Fondo para la Defensa de la Alianza], un despacho que defiende este tipo de causas. La demanda pretendía conseguir "que los burócratas de Washington no puedan forzar a las familias a abandonar su fe para ganarse la vida", explica Bowman: "Los americanos no quieren que los políticos y los burócratas decidan quién, dónde y cómo puede vivir su fe".

El juez les da la razón: los demandantes sólo "buscan dirigir Hercules en una forma que refleje sus sinceras creencias religiosas". Y alega la jurisprudencia en el sentido de que "es de gran interés público el libre ejercicio de la religión incluso si ese interés puede entrar en conflicto con otros".

La decisión judicial permite a Hercules Industries sustraerse temporalmente -hasta que instancias superiores decidan sobre la constitucionalidad del mandato- a las cuantiosas multas que afrontarían os Newland por no asegurar a sus 265 empleados para planes anticonceptivos (incluida la píldora abortiva) o esterilizaciones.

La multa se eleva a 100 dólares por empleado y día sin asegurar, lo que elevaría la sanción a 10 millones de dólares al año. Son cifras que, como han señalado los opositores al "mandato", apuntan a la voluntad del gobierno de Barack Obama de cerrar todo tipo de instituciones y empresas de la Iglesia o dirigidas por católicos.

Actualmente, 56 instituciones católicas acumulan un total de 23 demandas en todo el país, que auguran un futuro legal muy problemático y una campaña electoral donde esta cuestión pueden tener un peso decisivo. En 2008, el 54% de los católicos votaron por el actual inquilino de la Casa Blanca.