quarta-feira, 13 de fevereiro de 2013

Pope: Pray for me and the future Pope, the Lord will guide us!

In Newsva

(Vatican Radio) Even though only 3500 tickets had been distributed for this Wednesday’s general audience, thousands more flocked to the Paul VI hall hoping to gain access for Pope Benedict XVI’s penultimate audience with pilgrims.

As soon as the Holy Father emerged onto the stage from the side door the crowds erupted in greeting. “Dear brothers and sisters, as you know I decided", he began only to be interrupted with prolonged applause. “Thank you for your kindness” he responded and began again. “I decided to resign from the ministry that the Lord had entrusted me on April 19, 2005. I did this in full freedom” the Pope added forcefully, “for the good of the Church after having prayed at length and examined my conscience before God, well aware of the gravity of this act”.
 
But continued Pope Benedict, “I was also well aware that I was no longer able to fulfil the Petrine Ministry with that strength that it demands. What sustains and illuminates me is the certainty that the Church belongs to Christ whose care and guidance will never be lacking. I thank you all for the love and prayer with which you have accompanied me”. 

Again the Pope was interrupted by lengthy applause, and visibly moved he continued: “I have felt, almost physically, your prayers in these days which are not easy for me, the strength which the love of the Church and your prayers brings to me. Continue to pray for me and for the future Pope, the Lord will guide us!".
As the cheers and applause subsided, Pope Benedict then turned to this Wednesday’s catechesis which focused on the season of Lent when we are called to make “more room for God in our lives” as he tweeted to his followers. Just like the great American Convert, Dorothy Day who of whom the Pope also spoke in his audience.

Below a Vatican Radio translation of Pope Benedict XVI’s catechesis [original text Italian]

Dear Brothers and Sisters,

Today, Ash Wednesday, we begin the liturgical time of Lent, forty days that prepare us for the celebration of Holy Easter, it is a time of particular commitment in our spiritual journey. The number forty occurs several times in the Bible. In particular, it recalls the forty years that the Israelites wandered in the wilderness: a long period of formation to become the people of God, but also a long period in which the temptation to be unfaithful to the covenant with the Lord was always present. Forty were also the days of the Prophet Elijah’s journey to reach the Mount of God, Horeb; as well as the time that Jesus spent in the desert before beginning his public life and where he was tempted by the devil. In this Catechesis I would like to dwell on this moment of earthly life of the Son of God, which we will read of in the Gospel this Sunday.

First of all, the desert, where Jesus withdrew to, is the place of silence, of poverty, where man is deprived of material support and is placed in front of the fundamental questions of life, where he is pushed to towards the essentials in life and for this very reason it becomes easier for him to find God. But the desert is also a place of death, because where there is no water there is no life, and it is a place of solitude where man feels temptation more intensely. Jesus goes into the desert, and there is tempted to leave the path indicated by God the Father to follow other easier and worldly paths (cf. Lk 4:1-13). So he takes on our temptations and carries our misery, to conquer evil and open up the path to God, the path of conversion.

In reflecting on the temptations Jesus is subjected to in the desert we are invited, each one of us, to respond to one fundamental question: what is truly important in our lives? In the first temptation the devil offers to change a stone into bread to sate Jesus’ hunger. Jesus replies that the man also lives by bread but not by bread alone: ​​without a response to the hunger for truth, hunger for God, man can not be saved (cf. vv. 3-4). In the second, the devil offers Jesus the path of power: he leads him up on high and gives him dominion over the world, but this is not the path of God: Jesus clearly understands that it is not earthly power that saves the world, but the power of the Cross, humility, love (cf. vv. 5-8). In the third, the devil suggests Jesus throw himself down from the pinnacle of the Temple of Jerusalem and be saved by God through his angels, that is, to do something sensational to test God, but the answer is that God is not an object on which to impose our conditions: He is the Lord of all (cf. vv. 9-12). What is the core of the three temptations that Jesus is subjected to? It is the proposal to exploit God, to use Him for his own interests, for his own glory and success. So, in essence, to put himself in the place of God, removing Him from his own existence and making him seem superfluous. Everyone should then ask: what is the role God in my life? Is He the Lord or am I?

Overcoming the temptation to place God in submission to oneself and one’s own interests or to put Him in a corner and converting oneself to the proper order of priorities, giving God the first place, is a journey that every Christian must undergo. "Conversion", an invitation that we will hear many times in Lent, means following Jesus in so that his Gospel is a real life guide, it means allowing God transform us, no longer thinking that we are the only protagonists of our existence, recognizing that we are creatures who depend on God, His love, and that only by “losing" our life in Him can we truly have it. This means making our choices in the light of the Word of God. Today we can no longer be Christians as a simple consequence of the fact that we live in a society that has Christian roots: even those born to a Christian family and formed in the faith must, each and every day, renew the choice to be a Christian, to give God first place, before the temptations continuously suggested by a secularized culture, before the criticism of many of our contemporaries.

The tests which modern society subjects Christians to, in fact, are many, and affect the personal and social life. It is not easy to be faithful to Christian marriage, practice mercy in everyday life, leave space for prayer and inner silence, it is not easy to publicly oppose choices that many take for granted, such as abortion in the event of an unwanted pregnancy, euthanasia in case of serious illness, or the selection of embryos to prevent hereditary diseases. The temptation to set aside one’s faith is always present and conversion becomes a response to God which must be confirmed several times throughout one’s life.

The major conversions like that of St. Paul on the road to Damascus, or St. Augustine, are an example and stimulus, but also in our time when the sense of the sacred is eclipsed, God's grace is at work and works wonders in life of many people. The Lord never gets tired of knocking at the door of man in social and cultural contexts that seem engulfed by secularization, as was the case for the Russian Orthodox Pavel Florensky. After acompletely agnostic education, to the point he felt an outright hostility towards religious teachings taught in school, the scientist Florensky came to exclaim: "No, you can not live without God", and to change his life completely, so much so he became a monk.

I also think the figure of Etty Hillesum, a young Dutch woman of Jewish origin who died in Auschwitz. Initially far from God, she found Him looking deep inside herself and wrote: "There is a well very deep inside of me. And God is in that well. Sometimes I can reach Him, more often He is covered by stone and sand: then God is buried. We must dig Him up again "(Diary, 97). In her scattered and restless life, she finds God in the middle of the great tragedy of the twentieth century, the Shoah. This young fragile and dissatisfied woman, transfigured by faith, becomes a woman full of love and inner peace, able to say: "I live in constant intimacy with God."

The ability to oppose the ideological blandishments of her time to choose the search for truth and open herself up to the discovery of faith is evidenced by another woman of our time, the American Dorothy Day. In her autobiography, she confesses openly to having given in to the temptation that everything could be solved with politics, adhering to the Marxist proposal: "I wanted to be with the protesters, go to jail, write, influence others and leave my dreams to the world. How much ambition and how much searching for myself in all this!". The journey towards faith in such a secularized environment was particularly difficult, but Grace acts nonetheless, as she points out: "It is certain that I felt the need to go to church more often, to kneel, to bow my head in prayer. A blind instinct, one might say, because I was not conscious of praying. But I went, I slipped into the atmosphere of prayer ... ". God guided her to a conscious adherence to the Church, in a lifetime spent dedicated to the underprivileged.
 
In our time there are no few conversions understood as the return of those who, after a Christian education, perhaps a superficial one, moved away from the faith for years and then rediscovered Christ and his Gospel. In the Book of Revelation we read: "Behold, I stand at the door and knock. If anyone hears my voice and opens the door, [then] I will enter his house and dine with him, and he with me"(3, 20). Our inner person must prepare to be visited by God, and for this reason we should allow ourselves be invaded by illusions, by appearances, by material things.
 
In this time of Lent, in the Year of the faith, we renew our commitment to the process of conversion, to overcoming the tendency to close in on ourselves and instead, to making room for God, looking at our daily reality with His eyes. The alternative between being wrapped up in our egoism and being open to the love of God and others, we could say corresponds to the alternatives to the temptations of Jesus: the alternative, that is, between human power and love of the Cross, between a redemption seen only in material well-being and redemption as the work of God, to whom we give primacy in our lives. Conversion means not closing in on ourselves in the pursuit of success, prestige, position, but making sure that each and every day, in the small things, truth, faith in God and love become most important.

segunda-feira, 11 de fevereiro de 2013

Bento XVI: a tristeza imensa de uma alegria ilimitada - por Nuno Serras Pereira



Levei várias horas a recompor-me da notícia inesperada da resignação do Papa Bento XVI. A tristeza, como que um luto abissal, que me invadiu não há palavras que a descrevam. Desde o meu noviciado, se a memória não me atraiçoa, em 1981 que os seus escritos alimentaram, confirmaram, robusteceram a minha Fé. A sua cooperação leal, corajosa e sintónica com o Santo Padre João Paulo II foi um prodigioso milagre providencial que salvou e fortaleceu a Fé e a Igreja no mundo inteiro, em especial no ocidente.

A sua admirável inteligência, a sua profundidade espiritual, a sua grandíssima coragem, a invulgar, mesmo genial, penetração teológica, o seu singular amor e fidelidade à Verdade, a extraordinária capacidade de diálogo, sem a mínima renúncia ao anúncio do Evangelho, a excepcional humildade, o seu amor inaudito por Jesus Cristo, a Sua Igreja e por todos os homens, tudo isto, e muito mais, garantem-lhe um lugar destacado na história da Igreja e, assim o creio firmemente, a futura canonização. Não há dúvidas que temos de dar muitíssimas Graças a Deus por nos ter concedido este Papa.

Mas apesar do meu intenso sentimento de orfandade, tenho a certeza firme que Bento XVI nunca teria resignado se não tivesse uma iluminação particular de Deus que o movesse a tal, para maior bem do mundo e da Igreja. Daí que a minha ilimitada melancolia se tenha transformado numa alegria imensa. 

É Deus que guia a Sua Igreja. Ele providenciará para que daqui advenha um maior bem para todos.

O que agora a Igreja quer, e seguramente o Papa Bento XVI o deseja com todas as veras, é que todos os católicos rezemos ao Espírito Santo implorando-Lhe que ilumine os Cardeais eleitores para que seja escolhido aquele que Ele quer como sucessor de Pedro e Vigário de Jesus Cristo na terra.

Uma última palavra sobre este Papa e o dia que hoje vivemos. Faz hoje, dia de Nossa Senhora de Lurdes - a Imaculada Conceição -, 6 anos que a maioria dos portugueses, que foram às urnas, votou criminosa e ignobilmente a liberalização do homicídio, em forma de aborto provocado, dos mais inocentes, vulneráveis e indefesos. Desde então só ao abrigo desta “lei” infame e abominável, sem ter em conta os clandestinos que continuam a proliferar, já se dizimaram oitenta mil portugueses. Esta tragédia inominável revela com uma clareza meridiana o elevadíssimo grau de demência suicido-parricida a que chegamos. Depois espantam-se com o aumento exponencial quer de suicídios de mulheres, quer de mães que assassinam brutalmente seus filhos já nascidos para logo em seguida se matarem.

Ora neste breve Pontificado de Bento XVI - coisa que é, sabe-se lá porquê, habitualmente silenciada nas conferências, palestras e debates sobre o seu Magistério - a quantidade e alta qualidade das suas intervenções sobre a defesa da vida é verdadeiramente impressionante.

De importância semelhante são as numerosas intervenções que fez quer como Cardeal quer como Papa em defesa do Crucifixo (Crucificado) no espaço público. Por isso parece boa-ideia homenagearmos o ainda Papa Bento XVI dependurando das janelas e varandas das nossas casas o estandarte de Cristo para o Ano da Fé.


11. 02. 2013
 

Destruir Portugal - por João César das Neves

In DN

Somos a geração que está a destruir Portugal. Daqui a décadas, aqueles que viverem nos escombros do que foi Portugal olharão para trás e culpar-nos-ão da sua situação. Apesar do nosso hábito pedante de condenar épocas antigas por males que lhes assacamos, as acusações que um dia ouviremos nunca as pudemos atribuir aos antigos.

Na sua amargura, os futuros terão dificuldade em acreditar que, apesar do desvario, tivéssemos momentos de lucidez e vislumbre da futura destruição. Hoje, no meio da crise, muitos dizem que Portugal está destruído. Só que, até admitindo o mal, a tacanhez que arruína o País está activa e distorce a compreensão. Os disparates que acompanham queixas e acusações manifestam, nelas próprias, o terrível vício que destrói Portugal.

Aqueles que agora contemplam a desgraça que cairá sobre nós começam logo por se considerar totalmente inocentes. São sempre outros os culpados. Como se um punhado de vilões, mesmo em posição de poder, conseguisse uma devastação destas. Muitos até dizem identificar os bandidos, lançando-se afanosamente em intensa e mesquinha campanha de denúncia e insulto. Assim manifestam a mesma desgraçada grosseria.

Pior é que o diagnóstico da situação, os males considerados e as curas recomendadas são tão laterais, incipientes e tolas que, em si mesmas, manifestam o vício que destrói Portugal. A razão por que tantos bramam que se arruína o País tem a ver com... dinheiros. É espantoso, mas muitos estão mesmo convencidos de que a recessão será irremediável e as dificuldades económicas fatais. O nosso problema é, afinal, falência de lojas e restaurantes, desemprego alto, dívida pública.

Isto permite compreender a desgraçada atitude que arrasa um povo. Pondo a nossa esperança a esse nível, colocando a nossa ânsia nesses temas, tendo a razão de ser em coisas dessas, não admira que se devaste uma nação. "Onde estiver o teu tesouro, aí estará também o teu coração." (Mt 6,21)

De facto, a destruição de Portugal não tem nada a ver com isso. Esta crise estará esquecida dentro de anos, como tantas para trás, a maioria bastante pior. Aquilo que o tempo não pode apagar, aquilo que chega para aniquilar o País é a destruição da família e a extinção da natalidade. Com a taxa de fertilidade mais baixa da Europa Ocidental e das mais baixas do mundo, o casamento em vias de extinção, o divórcio em níveis nunca vistos e a educação na quinta década sucessiva de crise, não admira que as próximas gerações acusem este tempo dos seus males.

Em 2010, último ano com dados para a amostra completa, éramos o terceiro país dos 15 da Europa com mais divórcios e o quarto com menos casamentos. Com apenas mais 1.3 casamentos do que divórcios por mil habitantes, o nosso País mostra uma precariedade familiar que é difícil de replicar na história do mundo, e raramente se encontra fora de situações de calamidade nacional. Não podemos ter dúvidas de que estamos a destruir Portugal.

Nos cinco anos desde 2007 já houve mais de 80 mil abortos, cerca de dez vezes os soldados portugueses mortos nos 14 anos de Guerra Colonial. Muitos se queixaram das cicatrizes que esse conflito deixou na geração que a suportou. Mas ninguém ouve sequer a voz da geração que hoje é sacrificada a "razões socioeconómicas" e à "opção da mulher". E o genocídio não demora apenas 14 anos. Sem fim à vista, continua galopante.

Entretanto, muita gente acha Portugal perdido pela concorrência chinesa, reforma do Estado ou participação no euro. O disparate chega para revelar a infantilidade. Quando souberem que pensamos assim, os futuros habitantes desta terra perceberão a mesquinhez da nossa atitude. Os nossos poucos descendentes e todos aqueles que vierem de longe tapar o buraco populacional que deixámos vão entender como foi possível que fizéssemos esta desgraça.

Afinal, a atitude egoísta e interesseira que endividou o País, trazendo-o à crise, é a mesma que hoje motiva as lamúrias e os insultos e que promove o divórcio, despreza a fertilidade e prefere o aborto. Sem filhos não há futuro.





domingo, 10 de fevereiro de 2013

Bishops have a 'duty' to deny pro-abortion politicians Communion, Vatican Cardinal says

In Catholic Voice

To decriminalise abortion is a contradiction of the most fundamental principle of the legal system

...
The 40th anniversary of Roe vs Wade has just passed which legalised abortion in America under the auspices of "health care". Could you comment on the devastation and misery which this has brought to thousands of women and also why abortion is a crime which should never be decriminalised?

The celebration of the 40th anniversary of Roe vs. Wade underlines for the United States of America the incalculable harm which has been done by the legalization of abortion. Abortion has nothing to do with healthcare, the infant in the womb is not a disease but a gift of new human life. Over 50 million lives have been taken since the handing down of Roe vs. Wade, a decision which practically permits the taking of the life of the infant in the womb up to the very moment of birth. It is not possible to comprehend all of the devastation worked by procured abortion on demand during these past forty years. There is, first of all, the devastation of the loss of innocent and defenceless human life in such staggering numbers. At the same time, there is the tremendous suffering of the women who have undergone an abortion and who have come to understand that they have violently taken a new human life conceived in their wombs. To commit abortion is contrary to the deepest being of a woman. The taking of an innocent and defenceless human life can never be right, can never be justified. Therefore, to decriminalize abortion is a contradiction of the most fundamental principle of the legal system, the principle that human life is to be safeguarded and defended at all times. It is clear that, in the United States of America, the decriminalization of abortion has resulted in millions of deaths, in the loss of respect for woman and in the ever greater violence which sadly marks American society today.

The tragic death of Savita Halappanavar has triggered a frenzy amongst abortion activists in a similar way to which deception and lies were used in the case of Norma Jean McCorvey's pregnancy in 1973. What lessons can the Irish government learn from the McCorvey case to prevent the Savita Case becoming Ireland's Roe vs Wade?

The death of Savita Halappanavar is indeed tragic. It is, however, contrary to right reason to hold that an innocent and defenceless human life can be justifiably destroyed in order to save the life of the mother. The Irish people, and especially the Irish government, should be very alert to the kind of argumentation which will be used by the secular media and by secular ideologues, in general, claiming that the destruction of the new human life in her womb could have saved the life of Savita Halappanavar and, therefore, would have been justified. Such an argument is absurd in itself. Even though, if the reports are correct, Savita Halappanavar requested an abortion, her request would not have made it right for the law to permit such an act which is always and everywhere wrong.

Catholic bishops have been criticised for saying that abortion introduces a "culture of death", also some politicians have complained that Pro Life groups have sent them information including images detailing the horror of abortion. They appeal for what they call a "civilised" and calm debate. Is there anything civilised about abortion and does the use of graphic imagery help create awareness of the gravity of the evil which occurs when an abortion is committed?

With regard to the complaint of some about the language of “culture of death,” and also about certain images which portray the horror of abortion, one must observe that we have a habit in society today to use language which helps us to avoid the reality about which we are speaking. Blessed John Paul II, in his Encyclical Letter The Gospel of Life, insisted that such evils as abortion and euthanasia must be called by their proper names and not by euphemisms which tend to keep from our consciousness the objective reality of the evil involved (cf. no. 58). Therefore, the use of the language of “culture of death,” is not only accurate, but it is also most helpful, for it draws our attention to the pervasive effect of abortion on demand on society in general. In other words, the practice of abortion on demand leads to multiple forms of violence in the family and also against our fellow citizens who have grown weak, either under advanced years or because of special needs which they have or because of a grave illness.

With regard to the use of graphic images, in the context of the plea for a civilized debate with regard to abortion, certainly one must be careful not to use graphic images for the sake of being graphic. On the other hand, our fellow citizens should know what an abortion actually is. Images of the act of abortion or the results of abortion, when carefully presented to the public, can help the public, in general, to recognize the grave evil which besets us and to take appropriate action.

What is the duty of a Catholic politician when faced with this type of legislation and can there ever be a situation where he may vote for abortion even if he believes it to be restricted?

The duty of a Catholic politician when he is faced with anti-life or anti-family legislation is to support all of those measures which will most reduce the evils which attack human life and the integrity of marriage. Sometimes it is not possible to eliminate at once completely the evil. The Catholic politician cannot vote for any legislation which would confirm the evil or even advance it, but, at the same time, if there is some legislation which will reduce the practice of the evil, he would be justified in supporting that legislation, as long as he also acknowledges the intrinsic evil of the practice involved and the need for his constituency to take appropriate action to eliminate the practice altogether.

It is clear from Canon 915 that abortion is a mortal sin and a collaboration with evil, can those who claim to be Catholic vote for it and remain full members of the Church? Also what is the role of the local bishop with regard to this matter?

With regard to Canon 915, it states that those who obstinately persist in manifest grave sin should not be admitted to receive Holy Communion. There can be no question that the practice of abortion is among the gravest of manifest sins and therefore once a Catholic politician has been admonished that he should not come forward to receive Holy Communion, as long as he continues to support legislation which fosters abortion or other intrinsic evils, then he should be refused Holy Communion. In my own experience, when I have informed Catholic politicians who were supporting anti-life or anti-family legislation not to approach to receive Holy Communion, they have understood and have followed the discipline of the Church as it is set forth in Canon 915.

Depending on the situation, the Diocesan Bishop may be involved directly in admonishing the politician, but it is also within the pastoral care of the parish priest to admonish anyone in his congregation who is persisting obstinately in manifest grave sin not to approach to receive Holy Communion. The local Bishop should teach clearly in the matter and also encourage his priests to make sure that the Church’s discipline is observed, in order to avoid the grave sin of sacrilege on the part of the Catholic politician who approaches to receive Holy Communion when he is persisting obstinately in grave moral evil, and to prevent the scandal which is caused when such individuals receive Holy Communion, because their reception of Holy Communion gives the impression that the Church’s teaching on the intrinsic evil of abortion is not firm.

In your book, Divine Love Made Flesh, you explain that Catholics who support abortion legislation should refrain from receiving Holy Communion not only because of the public scandal but also out of love for Our Lord. Could you explain?

In response to the last question, surely the consideration of public scandal must be in the mind of those who approach to receive Holy Communion unworthily. However, at a much deeper level of faith and of personal relationship with our Lord Jesus Christ, a person obstinately persisting in manifest grave sin will refrain from approaching to receive Holy Communion because of his love of our Lord and his sorrow for the grave sin which he is commiting against our Lord and His Holy Church. In fact, it is the recognition of the grave offense against the Lord which will most inspire a conversion of heart in the Catholic politician who publicly supports anti-life or anti-family legislation. One recalls here the words of Saint Paul in chapter 11 of the First Letter to the Corinthians, in which he addressed a situation of the sacrilegious receiving of Holy Communion among the faithful at Corinth, Saint Paul wrote that the person who receives Holy Communion unworthily sins against the Lord and therefore brings about his own condemnation. The passage from the First Letter to the Corinthians reads: “Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of profaning the body and blood of the Lord. Let a man examine himself, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For any one who eats and drinks without discerning the body, eats and drinks judgment upon himself” (1 Cor. 11:27-29).

What causes homosexuality, Peter Tatchell? It depends on which view is most politically convenient - by Peter Saunders


Last week in Parliament I attended a meeting where four leading figures engaged in a lively debate on therapy for those with unwanted feelings of same-sex attraction. 

The debate focussed on the legitimacy of, and freedom to offer, ‘change therapy’ (more accurately SOCEs - sexual orientation change efforts), which is aimed at altering the strength and direction of sexual feelings. 

 

Dr Michael Davidson of CORE Issues (who is about to undergo a disciplinary procedure for using it) and Canadian psychiatrist Dr Joseph Berger (who uses it regularly) were supporting change therapy. 
 

Psychiatrist Professor Michael King (who is its most vehement critic) and gay rights campaigner Peter Tatchell were against it.
 

Although members of the mainstream press were present the debate has so far been reported only by Christian Concern, Pink News and Gay Star News. 

Tatchell and King essentially argued that homosexual orientation was biologically caused and fixed, that change was impossible and that change therapies were damaging and unethical. 


I will come back to King in another blog but I was particularly intrigued by the hard line position taken by Tatchell. 


Tatchell (pictured) summed up his position on the causes of homosexuality by dismissing cultural and environmental factors: ‘The overwhelming mass of scientific and medical evidence shows that homosexual orientation is the product of inheritance and hormonal influences in the womb.’


King, the scientist, wasn’t anywhere as dogmatic about this and suggested that no one really knew the cause. Tatchell, however, firmly stood his ground.


To those who are acquainted with Tatchell’s writings this announcement marked a huge departure from his previous stance. Rather than accept the view that people are born gay, he has actually been one of its chief opponents. 


On his own website in an article titled ‘Born or Made Gay?’ he argues as follows:

‘Something as complex and pivotal as human emotional and sexual life is bound to evolve from a multiplicity of factors, rather than from any single, simple origin… biological determinist models of gayness suggest that same-sex attraction is largely or entirely determined by our genes and hormonal influences in the womb. It is an innate desire, fixed at birth….

This was the central thesis of the recent book, Born Gay, by Glenn Wilson, a Reader at the Institute of Psychiatry in London , and Qazi Rahman, a lecturer in psychobiology at the University of East London . Their book is easily the best summary of evidence from dozens of biological studies into the causes and correlates of homosexuality.

They conclude that sexual orientation is overwhelmingly innate. Social or family influences have little or no impact. Blaming parents and childhood upbringing for a child's gayness is mistaken and unfair. The idea that people become gay by seduction or choice is, they say, not supported by scientific research and empirical evidence…


The authors are right to say that biological factors play a role. Studies of identical twin brothers show that in 52% of cases where one twin is gay the other twin is also gay (Note - later studies suggest this figure is closer to 20%). This is a much higher concordance than the 2% to 10% distribution of gay people in the general population, as recorded by various sex surveys. It suggests a significant genetic component in the causality of homosexuality - and, presumably, in the origins of heterosexuality as well.


Wilson and Rahman argue the other determinant of sexual orientation is hormonal exposure during pregnancy. They document studies showing differences between gay and straight people with respect to a number of physiological traits that are associated with hormonal influences...


This is convincing stuff, but not entirely so. If genes determine our sexual orientation we would expect that in cases of identical twins where one was gay the other would be gay too – in every case. But, in fact, in only just over half the cases are both twins gay. The same lack of complete concordance is found in hormone-associated physical attributes. 


These exceptions lead me to conclude that while genes and hormones may, like male birth order, predispose a person to a particular sexual orientation, they do not determine it. They are significant influences, not the sole cause. Other factors are also at work. Social expectations, cultural values and peer pressure, for instance, help push many of us towards heterosexuality...


Wilson's and Rahman's biological determinist thesis has another major flaw. If we are all born either gay or straight, how do they explain people who switch in mid-life from fulfilled heterosexuality to fulfilled homosexuality (and vice versa)?


The authors have no credible explanation for bisexuality; claiming it barely exists… Much as I would love to go along with the fashionable ‘born gay' consensus (it would be very politically convenient), I can't. The evidence does not support the idea that sexuality is a fixed biological given.’

In another article on his website he takes an even stronger position:
‘Sexual orientation is largely or entirely determined by our genes and hormonal influences in the womb. It is an innate given, fixed at birth. Forget Freudian theory and all the other psycho babble. Biology is destiny.
This is the central thesis of Born Gay. I disagree…. If sexuality was predetermined at birth by genes and hormones, it would be impossible for young Sambian males to switch to homosexuality and then back to heterosexuality with such apparent ease. This suggests there is an element of flexibility in sexual orientation, and that cultural traditions and social mores are also influential factors. 

Born gay? No. Human sexuality is too varied and complex to be reduced to a simple equation of genes plus hormones.’ 
When asked at the debate whether his views had changed Tatchell said that they had. When asked why, he said it was a result of reading ‘Born gay?’ 

But ‘Born gay?’ was written in 2008 and yet just last year in January 2012 Tatchell wrote an article for the Huffington Post titled ‘Future Sex: Beyond Gay and straight’ in which he takes exactly the same position as that expressed on his website: 
‘We already know, thanks to a host of sex surveys, that bisexuality is an fact of life and that even in narrow-minded, homophobic cultures, many people have a sexuality that is, to varying degrees, capable of both heterosexual and homosexual attraction.
It is also apparent that same-sex relations flourish, albeit often temporarily, in single-sex institutions like schools, prisons and the armed forces - which suggests that sexuality might be more flexible than many people assume.

(Kinsey) found that human sexuality is, in fact, a continuum of desires and behaviours, ranging from exclusive heterosexuality to exclusive homosexuality. A substantial proportion of the population shares an amalgam of same-sex and opposite-sex feelings - even if they do not act on them…

…The evidence from these two research disciplines - sociology and anthropology - is that the incidence and form of heterosexuality and homosexuality is not fixed and universal, and that the two sexual orientations are not mutually exclusive. There is a good deal of fluidity and overlap.

What's more, although scientific evidence shows that human sexuality is significantly affected by biological predispositions - such as genes and hormones - other influences appear to be cultural, including social expectations, peer pressure and the availability and opportunity for sexual release. These influences channel erotic impulses in certain directions and not others. An individual's sexual orientation is thus influenced culturally, as well as biologically.

… This picture of human sexuality is much more complex, diverse and blurred than the traditional simplistic binary image of hetero and homo, so loved by straight moralists and - equally significantly - by many lesbians and gay men.

If sexual orientation has a culturally-influenced element of indeterminacy and flexibility, then the present forms of homosexuality and heterosexuality are conditional. They are unlikely to remain the same in perpetuity. As culture changes, so will expressions of sexuality.

… Gay and lesbian identities are largely the product of homophobic prejudice and repression. They are a self-defence mechanism against homophobia. Faced with persecution for having same-sex relations, the right to have those relationships has to be defended - hence gay identity and the gay rights movement.’
So what exactly is Tatchell's position? 

Does he really expect us to believe that in the last twelve months he has suddenly adopted the central thesis of a book he has consistently rejected for over four years? 

 

If so why has he not said so up until this week?
 

Or is there another explanation altogether? Does Tatchell actually choose which view to hold depending on who he is talking to? 
 

Tatchell is at very heart a campaigner and has already hinted above that the ‘fashionable “born gay” consensus’ would be ‘very politically convenient’ for him. 
 

So maybe when he is arguing, as in Huffington Post, that in the future there will be no such thing as gay and straight but just fluidity, it is actually politically convenient to say that the main cause of sexual orientation is cultural and environmental. 
 

But when he is making a case for disciplining people who are practising therapy aimed at changing the strength and direction of sexual attraction, it is more politically convenient for him to argue that sexual orientation is biologically fixed at birth as a result of genes and hormones. 
 

And if he is trying to establish that gay people are a persecuted minority (very useful if you are pushing for a change in the law) then it is expedient to argue that gay and lesbian identities are largely the product of homophobic prejudice and repression. 
 

I wonder which argument Peter Tatchell will use next? 
 

I guess it will depend on who is listening and what his political agenda at the time happens to be.

Querido “Diário de Notícias” - P. Gonçalo Portocarrero de Almada

In i

Obrigado por me fazeres sentir a alegria de ser discípulo de Cristo, na sua Igreja e nesta obra de Deus, que tem a glória humana de não ter como Jesus, nenhuma glória humana
Que sina a minha: mal nasci, saí no jornal! Não tive culpa. Só que me aconteceu o insólito facto de ser o primeiro de três gémeos portugueses, dados à luz em Haia, a capital dos Países Baixos.
Menino e moço, recordo que em casa se lia o “Diário de Notícias”, sobretudo a sua necrologia, uma parte indiscutivelmente verídica do órgão oficioso do regime que, por isso, só podia ser objectivo na medida em que a censura o permitisse.
Depois do 25 de Abril, o mesmo diário, para se redimir do seu passado colaboracionista, entregou-se com fervor ao novo poder. Foi por estas alturas o consulado do Nobel literato que, em pleno PREC, alinhou pelas “boas práticas” da ditadura do proletariado.
Em casa, claro, continuava-se a receber o jornal, cujo obituário merecia a melhor atenção dos mais velhos da família, que aí encontravam sempre pessoas das suas relações. Para as outras verdades, as do país e do mundo, era preciso ir ao “Le Monde”, à “Time”, à BBC ou à “Deutsche Welle”.
Lembrei-me de tudo isto agora, que o “Diário de Notícias” se lembrou de devassar uma pacata obra de Deus – logo por azar a instituição eclesial em que sirvo há já alguns anos – atribuindo-lhe estranhas gestas, para além de secretos mundos e muitos fundos. Fá--lo com meias verdades, repetindo velhos tópicos, mas sem nenhuma especial originalidade.
Nada de novo, portanto. Contudo, surpreendi-me: afinal, é tão fácil fabricar um escândalo! Quer-se acusar de opulência a diocese de Lisboa? Basta recordar que as igrejas da Baixa valem muitos milhões e, portanto, o patriarcado é, na realidade, multimilionário. Pretende-se denegrir as carmelitas descalças? Escandalizem-se os leitores com a sua obrigatória reclusão e as suas arrepiantes autoflagelações. Precisa-se de caricaturar as missionárias da caridade? É dizer que as desgraçadas não têm televisão, não leram, nem podem ler, O Memorial do Convento. Interessa difamar a Companhia de Jesus? Reedite- -se o que dela disseram os que, em 1910, a expulsaram do país, sob a acusação dos jesuítas envenenarem as águas dos fontanários públicos…
A bem dizer, não há pessoa ou instituição, por mais santa que seja, que resista a uma “grande investigação sobre o seu lado secreto”. Nem mesmo o próprio Cristo. Bastaria dizer, por exemplo, que, com trinta anos, não tinha residência fixa e vivia apenas com homens, um dos quais, por certo, ladrão. Que se deixava tocar por prostitutas e, enquanto havia quem morresse de fome, aceitava ser perfumado com bálsamos caríssimos. Que pregou o amor, mas chicoteou os seus semelhantes. Que chamava a si as criancinhas e tinha, como seu amigo predilecto, um jovem adolescente, que se reclinou sobre o seu peito… Tudo verdades, a concluir numa sacrílega mentira, a que o incauto leitor seria induzido por um inquérito “rigoroso” e “objectivo”.
É lógico que seja assim. É lógico que o poder laico não possa tolerar uma Igreja livre. É lógico que os discípulos do Mestre crucificado sejam objecto do escárnio e da maledicência dos seguidores do príncipe deste mundo. É lógico que uma entidade indiscutivelmente fiel à Igreja e unida ao Papa e aos bispos, seja maltratada onde recentemente se negou o dogma católico da virgindade de Maria e se criticou o último livro de Bento XVI. É lógico que a viúva do Nobel, erigida – sabe--se lá porquê!? – em alta autoridade para os fenómenos eclesiais, seja fiel à memória anticristã do seu defunto marido que, segundo a própria, “detestava profundamente as religiões”. É lógico. Aliás, como o mundo, também o inferno deve estar cheio de gente com carradas de razão… Mas sem amor.
Querido “Diário de Notícias” da minha vida: obrigado por esta companhia, desde o meu nascimento e, presumivelmente, até à minha morte. Obrigado por me fazeres sentir a alegria de ser discípulo de Cristo, na sua Igreja e nesta obra de Deus, que tem a glória humana de não ter, nem querer ter, como Jesus, nenhuma glória humana.
Não te peço que deixes de ser o que sempre foste e, seguramente, continuarás a ser, por muitos e bons anos. Mas, se noticiares a minha morte na tua infalível necrologia, por favor, diz apenas que morreu alguém profundamente feliz.

quarta-feira, 6 de fevereiro de 2013

U. K: - “Alteração de definição de casamento coloca católicos sob pressão”

In RR 

A Câmara dos Comuns aprovou ontem, por maioria, o chamado casamento entre homossexuais. Um bispo católico diz que os efeitos para católicos poderão ser graves.

O bispo de Portsmouth, Inglaterra, disse ontem que a aprovação do “casamento” entre homossexuais coloca os católicos sob uma pressão moral intolerável.

Phillip Egan disse aos jornalistas que católicos que trabalham no registo civil, por exemplo, poderão ser obrigados a escolher entre as suas consciências e a profissão.

Egan tece comparações com o efeito da lei que permitiu a adopção por homossexuais e que levou ao encerramento de todas as agências de adopção católica, uma vez que o Governo e os tribunais não admitiram uma excepção para organizações religiosas.

“Tal como a Igreja teve de abandonar os seus serviços de adopção, também alguns católicos que trabalham na área da saúde e serviços sociais poderão encontrar-se sob pressões morais intoleráveis. Pressões que se poderão fazer sentir também nas escolas católicas, por professores, funcionários e pais”.

No Reino Unido, como em Portugal, os casamentos na Igreja Católica também servem para efeitos civis. Mas com esta alteração isso pode mudar, sugere o bispo: “Torna-se claro que a visão católica do matrimónio será, no futuro, marcadamente diferente daquilo a que a sociedade chamará casamento. Uma consequência possível disto é que a Igreja seja forçada a retirar-se do registo civil de casamentos”.

Mas o bispo também fez algumas críticas internas. Segundo ele a culpa da redefinição da definição de casamento também deve ser partilhada pela Igreja que desde os anos 60 não soube “explicar de forma atractiva” a visão cristã desta instituição.

A lei que legaliza o “casamento” entre homossexuais foi aprovada na Câmara de Comuns por maioria. Contudo, o Partido Conservador, cujo líder e primeiro-ministro David Cameron apoiou fortemente a medida, ficou claramente dividido, com uma maioria dos seus representantes a votar contra a proposta. A lei foi aprovada com o apoio dos Liberais Democratas e do Partido Trabalhista, com algumas excepções.

Antes de se tornar lei do país a medida deve agora ser aprovada pela Câmara dos Lordes antes de entrar em vigor.

As preocupações da Igreja Católica são sentidas também, mas em maior grau, pela Igreja de Inglaterra. Os bispos anglicanos opuseram-se à proposta e não se deixam convencer pelas garantias do Governo de que nenhuma confissão possa ser obrigada a realizar “casamentos” entre homossexuais. Os bispos alertam para a possibilidade de recurso ao Tribunal Europeu dos Direitos do Homem, que poderá entender que tal garantia é discriminatória, sobretudo tendo em conta que a Igreja Anglicana é a confissão oficial do Estado.