sexta-feira, 24 de agosto de 2012

The Church and Secularism - part 2 - by Peter Kreeft

In CERC 

The Nature of Diagnosis 
 
All right.  The symptoms are obvious.  We know the symptoms.  The diagnosis is the most important point.  If you don't go through step two — diagnosis — you can't go into step three or four, cure and prescription.  And in fact, of the three steps, the diagnosis is the thing you pay the doctors big bucks for, because they're experts.  They've gone to medical school, they've gone through all this training that makes them experts — you couldn't diagnose your own disease very well.  You observe your own symptoms, of course.  And once the disease is diagnosed, you can peruse the medical books and say, "Well, this is the likely outcome." The prognosis is almost automatic and the prescription is fairly routine.  But the diagnosis is the thing.

There's a story of one of the world's first computers, an enormous thing at MIT, during World War II.  It was all cathode ray tubes; it didn't have chips then.  And it was coordinating the war efforts and went on the blink.  And they asked the main inventor of the computer to come and repair it.  And he said, "I'd be glad to, but I'm going to charge you big bucks." It was a multi-million dollar computer, and it was worthless without repair.  So he said, "I might charge up to a million dollars to diagnose the problem.  But I won't charge you anything if I don't succeed." They said okay.  So he went up there with a screwdriver, and walked up and down the different halls of the computer, which was as large as a building, and listened, and at a certain point, when he heard something wrong, he tapped with the screwdriver — bom bom bom — and said, "The computer's fixed now." They turned it on, and sure enough, it was fixed.  It took him about five minutes.  So they said, "Send us your bill." So he sent them the bill; it was a million dollars.  For tapping the screwdriver.  So they said, "Please itemize your bill." He said, "Gladly." Item one: tapping with a screwdriver, one dollar.  Item two: knowing where to tap, nine hundred and ninety-nine thousand, nine hundred and ninety-nine dollars.  That's diagnosis.
 
Nihilism 
  What's the essential diagnosis of the ills of Western Civilization? It's rather painfully obvious: atheism.  But not just in terms of polls; in terms of real presence in people's lives.  When Nietzsche, back in the 19th Century, said, "God is dead," he didn't mean simply that God is a myth and a superstition and never did live.  He meant that this superstition, this thing that never was literally alive, was the energy of Western Civilization.  Nietzsche, like the saints, understood that there is no Western Civilization without God.  Although he believed that we created Him in our image, rather than that he created us in His image, he realized that the image and the model go together.  When there's a mirror on the wall in a room, and you walk out of that room, due to the finite speed of light, though you can't see it, your image remains in the mirror for a split second after you leave the room.  Well, if we're made in God's image, and God is dead, it may take a split second, or a century, for man, His image, to die.  But man cannot live without God.  An image cannot live without its model.  If God leaves, man leaves.  Nietzsche knew that.  Half of him rejoiced in it; half of him was agonized over it, but he called for the new man, the man without religion and without morality.  We're seeing it gradually happen.  

If you want to read the two most prophetic books of modern times, read The Abolition of Man by C. S. Lewis, and remember, his title is to be taken seriously, it's not an exaggeration; and Brave New World by Aldous Huxley.  Brave New World is what de Tocqueville called "soft totalitarianism." 

One of the biggest traumas in my life when I was a young and naïve teacher — I'm still young, I don't know what I want to be when I grow up, and I'm still naïve — but I gave them Brave New World, a class, and I didn't prepare them for it.  I thought they'd understand it.  So I said nothing about it, I said we'll discuss it next week, and we started discussing it in the class and I discovered to my consternation that they misunderstood Brave New World.  They thought Huxley was for it.  Worse, they agreed with him! They were astonished when I told them that this was a dystopia, not a utopia, and that Huxley was a prophet who was counselling us against Brave New World.  "What?  Against Brave New World?  Everybody's happy there!  Everybody's comfortable!  They solve all problems.  There's no poverty, there's no prejudice, there's no war.  There's free sex, there's free entertainment, there's free drugs — it's ideal!  It's like Boston College campus!"

Well, if we're in love with it, that's where we're going.  If there's no God, then there's no being.  Wait a minute, that's very abstract.  What do you mean, "being"? Well, being isn't just the fact that something exists.  Being is real-ness.  Nihilism is the ism or ideology that says there is no being.  Well obviously we exist, and this piece of paper exists, and the planet Mars exists — what do you mean, there is no being? Well, nothing's really real.  Everything's fake.  Nothing is to rely on.  Everything's empty.  Read the Book of Ecclesiastes.  Don't read the last six verses, which is the answer.  Read the rest of the book, which is the problem.  "Vanity of vanities, all is vanity." What does that mean? There is no being.  Nothing's real.  Everything's like a bubble.  Touch it, and it bursts.  People are like bubbles; they're fakes.  Everything's a fake.  Everything's a facade.  Nothing's behind the facade.  It's empty.  The difference between the full and the empty is more important even than the difference between life and death, or good and evil.
 Lack of Meaning 
  Viktor Frankl wrote a wonderful book called Man's Search for Meaning.  It's the best book to come out of the Nazi era.  He was a disciple of Freud, a psychiatrist from Vienna, who, as a Jew, was put into Auschwitz.  And he observed his fellow prisoners with the eye of a scientist, and was struck by the fact that his predictions didn't come true about who would survive and who didn't.  Some of the weakest prisoners who had no privileges did survive, and some of the strongest and healthiest prisoners, including those who had privileges with the Nazis because they sucked up to them, didn't survive.  And he questioned Freud's basic principle, which is the pleasure principle, that the desire for pleasure is the deepest need of human beings, and he said, "That principle didn't enable me to predict the facts that I observed at Auschwitz.  There must be some deeper need that everybody has that the survivors fulfilled and the non-survivors didn't.  What could that be?"

And he came to the conclusion that it was the need for meaning, the need for something real in your life that was an absolute, that you'd give yourself to, that wasn't humanly invented, that was real.  And he tested the hypothesis and it came out.  All these survivors, weak or strong, had some reason to suffer.  They said, "Life has meaning, and suffering is a part of life, therefore suffering has meaning." That's the common feature. 

For some of them, the meaning was simply to get back at the Nazis after the war, to get revenge.  For some of them, the meaning was to find a family again.  For some of them, their meaning was to complete their work, to finish their book or whatever.  For some of them, their meaning was to prove that they were strong and able to survive.  For some of them, the meaning was religious.  But for some of them it wasn't.  But all of them turned a corner.  All the survivors turned this corner and the non-survivors didn't.  Everybody, survivors and non-survivors, asked the same question: why? Why are we here? This is meaningless.  This is nonsense.  This is unjust.  This is ridiculous.  This is insane.  It is utterly irrational.  Of course.  And some of them just stuck in that forever, and they didn't survive.  

But some of them turned a corner and realized that whereas they had been asking life, "Life, what is your meaning now," they were wrong.  Not because they didn't get an answer to the question, but because they were asking the wrong question.  In fact, the fact that they were asking the question was the mistake.  Life was asking them the question.  They were being asked, "What is your meaning?" And they had to respond.  That's the essence of responsibility.  The ability to give a response to life's challenges, to life's questions: What is your meaning? And those who had any kind of answer to that question survived.  Those who didn't didn't. 

Many of the prisoners believed that behind life there was a personal God.  So it was God that was asking them, "What is your meaning?" But even those that didn't believe in God knew that life was asking them, "What is your meaning?" And those that responded, survived, those that didn't, didn't.  So he wrote this wonderful book called Man's Search for Meaning and founded a whole new school of psychology called Logotherapy, based on the principle that man's fundamental need is the need for meaning.  

Meaning means, ultimately, purpose: teleology, from the Greek word telos, which means "end" or "purpose." That's a concept which modern science has discarded.  And in order to do hard science you have to discard it.  You can't bring that into equations.  And since science has been our most spectacular success, we tend to make the mistake of thinking that the closer you can get to the scientific method, the stronger and more certain your knowledge is and therefore we tend to discount anything that doesn't fit the scientific method.  But purpose doesn't fit the scientific method.  You can't measure purpose.  

That, by the way, is why I personally think that the intelligent design people, who are very good and well intentioned and reasonable people, are making a strategic mistake when they say, "This is science." It's not.  It's philosophy.  Science requires quantification and empirical verification, and you can't do that with purpose.  It's very good philosophy — it's basically Aquinas' fifth way, the argument from design, which is probably the most popular argument for the existence of God in the world — but to present it as science is not going to convince people, because the scientific method is tougher than that, harder than that, narrower than that. 

But if you run your life by the scientific method, nothing's left.  Not only do you throw out God, you throw out persons.  Science doesn't know what a person is.  If you're a doctor and you're operating on a patient, you have to treat that patient as a machine in order to be an efficient doctor.  If you think, "That patient has a soul," or "That patient is my grandmother," or "That patient is someone I'm in love with," your hands are going to shake, and you're going to botch the operation.  So you have to deliberately suppress the most valuable stuff in you in order to be an effective surgeon or an effective scientist.  That brain is a computer that is not working; let me figure out why.  But to take that over into life as such is devastating.  But, more or less, our society has done that.  And therefore there's no purpose: "Oh, everybody needs a purpose, but it's just a fiction.  It's something you make up.  It's not real.  It's not true.  It's just a little game you play with yourself in order to motivate yourself.  You're the donkey and you invent a carrot and you put it on a stick in front of your own head to make you move." That's not going to really motivate you.  

The True, the Good, and the Beautiful 
 
Well, I've expressed my diagnosis in three different terms, which are equivalent: God, being, and meaning.  But those are pretty abstract terms.  Can I make this more concrete? Can I break it down into something more specific? Yes, I can. Every religion in the world that has, if not a God, something above man, something god-like, also has a meaning, a purpose, a fundamental absolute to give to all human beings as the main purpose of human life.  And every religion in the world, according to social scientists and anthropologists and sociologists, has three visible ingredients.  It manifests itself in three ways.  They are often called creed, code, and cult — or words, works, and worship.  Every religion says there's something to believe in as true.  Every religion says there's some lifestyle to practice as good.  And every religion says there's some work to do, some liturgy, some worship, some prayer or meditation.  Thomas Aquinas says we only need to know three things.  And the Apostles' Creed, the Ten Commandments, and the Lord's Prayer tell us everything we need to know.  The Apostles' Creed, the simplest and earliest and shortest creed, summarizes what is true.  And the Ten Commandments summarize what is good.  And the Lord's Prayer summarizes what is desirable or beautiful.  So the Creed tells us what we must believe — that's the object of faith: truth.  The Commandments tell us what we must love — that's the object of the will, that's good.  And the Lord's Prayer tells us what we must hope for — that's what gives us joy.  If we use beauty as a correlate to hope, we have the true, the good, and the beautiful as the three absolutes.  The three things every human being wants infinitely, and is not satisfied with only a little bit of.  We're satisfied with a little bit of food; we're satisfied with a little bit of power; we're satisfied with a little bit of sex; but not a little bit of truth.  "I'll be ignorant about fifty percent of truth and knowledgeable about fifty percent" — nobody says that.  I've got a couple of things that are good for me, but I want some things that are not good for me — nobody says that.  I like to enjoy beauty on Monday, but ugliness is okay on Tuesday — nobody says that.  And therefore these are the three things that don't get boring and therefore they are the three foretastes of heaven, because they are three attributes of Almighty God himself.  

But without God, there really is no truth, because there's no being.  God, being, and truth are a kind of progression.  Truth means truth about what is real, and if there's no ultimate being, no ultimate reality, then reality is just what we call it.  It falls apart, ultimately.  Deep down, everything is empty.  So if there's no truth, there's nothing for either reason or faith to grab onto, so you're a sceptic.  And that's certainly one of the deep distresses of modern society — scepticism.  Second, without truth there's no goodness.  Nothing's truly good.  Goodness too is kind of a fake, or purely subjective.  So another aspect of the diagnosis of our society is amoralism.  And without goodness, there's really no beauty.  Gothic cathedrals were not made by moral sceptics; they were made by saints.

quinta-feira, 23 de agosto de 2012

Economics, reproductive health and the integrity of the family - by Arland Nichols, PhD and Donald DeMarco, PhD

In Zenit

The term “economic” is derived from the Greek oikonomia, pertaining to the management of the household. In this sense, the term has considerable breadth inasmuch as it deals not only with finances, but all the human complexities involved in managing and caring for all the members of the family.

Today’s economist is, in general, not particularly concerned with the family. He is not interested in those realities that are beyond the reach of data. At a macro level an economy is said to be “healthy” when GDP, interest rates, and unemployment stabilize at acceptable levels. In our modern use of the term, it is possible to have a healthy economy in a sick society. Thus, a “healthy” economy at the macro level can coexist with the use of contraception or abortion by families seeking to avoid another mouth to feed.

The modern economist who restricts his professional interest to financial data displays a much narrower view of economics than has been characteristic of the Christian tradition. As Pope Pius IX stated in Quadragesimo Anno, “Economic life must be inspired by Christian principles.” This includes the reproductive realm. In writing Humanae Vitae, Pope Paul VI was guided by an ever-present concern for a “integral vision of man.” In section 7 of the encyclical, Paul VI writes:
The problem of birth, like every other problem regarding human life, is to be considered…in the light of an integral vision of man and of his vocation, not only his natural and earthly, but also his supernatural and eternal vocation.
From this perspective, Pope Paul accurately predicted what would happen if the use of contraception became widespread. He warned of a general lowering of moral standards throughout society, an increase in marital infidelity, a lessening of respect for women by men, and the coercive use of contraceptive technologies by governments.

Leaving aside the obvious connection between this fourth prediction and the current “contraceptive mandate” in the United States, Paul VI could not possibly have predicted the radical impact “reproductive health” initiatives would have in changing the demographic and economic landscape through the world. For years the world has wrung its collective hands at the disastrous economic situation in Greece. Few know, however, that Greece is also demographically insolvent. Fertilityrates in this country have dropped from 2.2 children per couple in the 1980s to less than 1 child today. As Mark Steyn recently characterized the problem: “In Greece, 100 grandparents have 42 grandchildren – i.e., an upside-down family tree…if 100 geezers run up a bazillion dollars worth of debt, is it likely that 42 youngsters will ever be able to pay it off?” No amount of aid, restructuring of debt or infusion of financial capital can offer a long-term solution to the situation in Greece. Only human capital can remedy—perhaps “could have remedied” would be more accurate—the impending collapse. A vibrant economy is only possible through an “integral vision” of economy as oikonomia. In other words, Greece must address the family and demographic collapse if its financial crisis is to be ameliorated.

Another country with looming debt problems seems insistent on pursuing a similar course as Greece: According to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) of the United States the economy is projected to shut down in 2027 as the nation will be unable to meet its trillions of dollars in debt obligations. By the middle of the 21st century the CBO notes that interest payments on the debt will exceed federal revenues. The specter of collapse looms large.

Clearly guided by a truncated anthropology and economic vision, political leaders in the United States have chosen to throw gas on this proverbial fire. Though the United States already gives birth to children at a rate (1.9) below replacement level (2.1), prominent political figures have decided that the solution to economic woes is more “reproductive health” i.e., more abortion and contraception. Nancy Pelosi gave voice to this approach when justifying the “economic stimulus plan” of 2008 that included hundreds of millions of dollars toward provision of contraception to the poor.

In an interview with George Stephanopolis, Pelosi argued: “Well the family planning services reduce costs, it reduced [sic] costs. The states are in terrible fiscal budget crisis now.” Categorizing “family planning,” provision of children’s health, education, food stamps, and unemployment insurance together, Pelosi noted that these initiatives “are to help the states meet their financial needs…the contraception will reduce costs to the State and to the federal government too. No apologies, no…We have to deal with the consequences of the down turn in our economy…there is more bang for the buck [with such initiatives].” To put it simply, poor children cost the government money, and since we have the goal of saving money, we need the poor to have less children.

Contraception as economic stimulus was eventually removed from the economic stimulus that would pass in the United States Congress, but the prevailing economic and sexual ideology expressed by Pelosi has continued to hold sway in the debates concerning the economically strained health care industry. This ideology was apparent in the Institute of Medicine’s recommendation that contraception, sterilization and abortion-inducing drugs should be part of free “preventive health care” for all women.

Their mandate explicitly forbade the use of costs as a justification for a recommendation. “Cost was explicitly excluded as a factor that the committee could use in forming recommendations, the committee process could not evaluate preventive services on the basis of cost.” It is of no little coincidence that the committee went on to argue the following to justify “free” provision of all sterilization and contraception: “contraception is highly cost-effective. The direct medical cost of unintended pregnancy in the United States was estimated to be nearly $5 billion in 2002, with the cost savings due to contraceptive use estimated to be 19.3 billion.” In other words, on a macro-level, children are an economic liability and the government has a vested interest in ensuring that on a micro level women (especially poor women) use contraception.

Continuing in this vein, the argument that the HHS mandate is justified by economic benefits has been repeated on a number of occasions. President Obama noted it in his announcement of his “accommodation” that was anything but, and Kathleen Sebelius has asserted that “the reduction in the number of pregnancies is [sic] compensates for the cost of contraception.”

As we have seen in countries facing demographic collapse, preventing more births does not, in fact, buoy an economy. Aside from what has already been noted, contraception adds further strains on a country and the health care system in particular. Allow us to note just a few examples.

Out of wedlock pregnancies and divorce rates in the United States are positively correlated to the increased use of contraception and availability of abortion. Yet we continue to hear the tired refrain that contraception brings about “stronger marriages.”

Further, the negative side effects of combined oral contraceptives creates a host of unnecessary costs. These negative effects include increased risk of breast, cervical and liver cancer, stroke, heart attack, and blood clots. As noted in a recent “LifeWatch” column, it is estimated that in one year 50,000 women experience blood clots because of the use of combined oral contraceptives. That’s one year alone and only one health issue! And aside from the obvious human cost, the economic toll is clearly staggering.

Consider also numerous studies that indicate that contraceptives are correlated with the risk of sexually transmitted diseases, such as the study published in The Lancet Infectious Diseases that indicated that women who use contraception and men whose partners use it were twice as likely to contract HIV/AIDS than non-users.

The destructive impact that contraception has on marriages, the family and the health of women is well documented—if not well known.

The ideology of certain members of the media and politicians has prevailed where it pertains to the importance of children for society, the economy, and families. Children are viewed as a liability to a thriving economy or robust family life, and contraception presented as the remedy. This is both misleading and dangerous. To strengthen the integrity of the family and economy we would do well to hold an integral vision of economics as oikonomia. The modern economist may not be expected to share this broad vision, but he is surely under no obligation to oppose it. Contraception is hardly a panacea. On the contrary, a culture of contraception carries a significant array of problems that warrant attention. Most fundamentally, however, we must cease to view children as an economic liability. Unless we relish the prospect of going the way of Greece and other EU nations reaping contraception’s demographic desserts, we must recognize children as the most precious good of the family and greatest treasure of a healthy economy.

Arland K. Nichols is the National Director of HLI America, an educational initiative of Human Life International. Donald DeMarco, Ph.D., is a Senior Fellow of HLI America. He is Professor Emeritus at St. Jerome’s University in Waterloo, Ontario and adjunct professor at Holy Apostles College and Seminary. Some of their recent writings may be found on HLI America’s Truth and Charity Forum.

Editorial: Delegates Beware on Sexual Orientation - by Austin Ruse


NEW YORK, August 24 (C-FAM) The UN is in the midst of a multi-year campaign to regularize homosexuality and other behaviors in the scheme of international law.

The skirmishes began many years ago with attempts by Brazil to place sexual orientation within a resolution at the Human Rights Commission in Geneva. This failed more than once but it was a testing motion to see where they stood. Read More

Philippine Senator Denounces Global Abortion Lobby - By Stefano Gennarini, J.D.


MANILA, August 24 (C-FAM) Senator Vicente C. Sotto III, one of the most popular and beloved politicians in the Philippines, is using all his clout to fight the latest attempt of the global abortion lobby to change his countries' laws to open the door for unfettered abortion. He has made it his "mission."

A bill, commonly known as the Reproductive Rights Bill or RH Bill, is currently undergoing an amendment process in the Philippine Legislature. The same bill has been rejected five times under different names, and as recently as 2010. The bill has made it to the amendments stage this time. President Aquino is backing the bill and the odds seemed to be stacked against the life of the unborn. Read More

Nada te assuste… - Nuno Serras Pereira

Eu sei que nestas missivas que vou enviando não deveria falar de mim, no entanto, por vezes, e esta é uma delas, sinto o dever de o fazer para salvaguarda e defensa dos meus amigos. Sabereis que todo eu sou uma enfermidade, tantas são as doenças que me acometem que um confrade meu já exclamou assombrado: Puxa!, é preciso muita saúde para aguentar tanta doença!

Ora uma dessas obriga-me, de há uns anos a esta parte, a tomar umas cápsulas que não só me engordam como me abrem grandemente o apetite. Devereis saber que todo eu sou uma farmácia ambulante, e um verdadeiro índice terapêutico - não há droga legal que não ingira ou que não conheça, com todos os seus efeitos, contra-indicações e interacções medicamentosas: se a teologia fosse farmacêutica eu seria um eminente catedrático. Sucedeu porém, como periodicamente me acontece, que entretanto contraí uma nova maleita, pelo que um médico feroz ao verificar a minha obesidade, as incomensuráveis toneladas de gordura que fui acumulando como um imenso javardo, um enorme tonel de banha, um oceano de toucinho, peremptória e implacavelmente vociferou crueldades ásperas, bárbaras e medonhas traduzidas neste conciso mas pavoroso verbo: Irra, emagreça!!! Caramba!

Tolhido de paúra recolhi-me ou arrastei-me cabisbaixo, com grande pesar, imaginando futuros negros e tremendos, até ao convento. Cheio de receança, timidamente, comecei por abster-me de alguns cozinhados que me asseguraram serem insalubres porque geradores enxúndia. Depois, aos poucos, à medida que ia fraquejando fui ganhando forças para a luta. Travaram-se então combates tremendos, batalhas épicas, escaramuças heróicas. Cada prato, era um inimigo a derrubar; cada copo, um comando a abater; cada sobremesa, um fuzileiro a eliminar; cada cedência, uma traição; cada gelado, um submarino a afundar; cada bolo, um porta-aviões a destruir. 

Preocupados por me verem a definhar os meus confrades começaram por me avisar: olhe que tu qualquer dia desapareces. No entanto, com o decorrer do tempo, quando me lobrigavam ao fundo do corredor, e como são infindáveis os corredores nos conventos!, viam um esqueleto, eu, a caminhar e cuidavam ser uma alma do outro mundo. Pelo que o Guardião mandou que no coro se fizessem preces e cada irmão trouxesse consigo água benta, e, ademais, alcançou do Bispo diocesano que a todos os sacerdotes fosse concedida a devida autorização para fazerem exorcismos. Fui desde então sujeito a consecutivos chuveiros de água benta e a incessantes exorcismos até que se concluiu que este cadáver ambulante, este esqueleto barbudo era mesmo eu, irremediavelmente enfermo, amumiado e escanzelado até que a próxima doença me obrigue de novo a anafar. 

Fique pois, isto que aqui deixo escrito, como aviso para que quem se depare comigo não se assuste cuidando espavorido que topa com um espírito ou com um esqueleto reanimado. Sou eu mesmo. E assim serei até que nova ruindade me force, de novo, a tornar-me um paquiderme banhudo.

23. 08. 2012

quarta-feira, 22 de agosto de 2012

El valor de denunciar a los Adminiculus Antichristi, sin respetos humanos ni "corporativos"


Beato, el monje de Liébana, y Eterio, el obispo exiliado de Osma, ocupada por los moros, cuando combaten en su Apologética (a.d. 785) las deviaciones adopcionistas del hereje Elipando, a la sazón ocupando el Arzobispado de Toledo bajo los sarracenos, le llamarán "testículo del Anticristo" ["adminiculus Antichristi"],:

"Estos (los herejes) son los testículos del Anticristo, de cuyo semen es engendrada la pervesa prole que es copulada en la boca del Anticristo... Este Anticristo tiene tantos testículos cuantos son los predicadores de su iniquidad"
[Heterii et Sancti Beati ad Elipandum Epistola (Apologeticum) Obras, I, II, n. 96 ]



Y en función de su actitud de servicio a los cristianos Beato y Eterio explican lo grave que son los heresiarcas en los puestos de pastor y maestro, pues son los que generan las semillas de la herejía y los herejes ("testículos del Anticristo, de cuyo semen es engendrada la pervesa prole")

No existía "corporativismo" y los clérigos y las jerarquías sabían que su deber con Dios era proteger a los fieles, denunciando a los heresiarcas, incluso aunque éstos okuparan las diócesis más importantes.

No es de extrañar que los españoles de la alta Edad Media, disponiendo de estas armas espirituales e intelectuales, frente a toda lógica militar y logística, fueran capaces de liberarse de la ocupación islámica y sus aliados y cómplices herejes (se considera que una de las causas de la facilidad de la ocupación musulmana fue la herejía arriana y su antitrinitarismo que consideraba la doctrina agarena como análoga)

A todos nos vienen a la cabeza los  Elipandos de hoy, que desde sus posiciones privilegiadas, por acción o por omisión (la mayoría), siguen siendo generadores de "perversas proles" en el clero, el laicado, los centros de enseñanza y los media "católicos", etc...

Lo que es preocupante es que tenemos más dificultad cuando queremos recordar émulos actuales de Beato y Eterio, lo suficientemente valientes para pener negro sobre blanco (o en la ondas) denuncias sobre los actuales Elipandos.
















Life is valuable…even for the severely disabled - by Michael Cook


There can be no more difficult case for dispassionate discussion than the fate of Tony Nicklinson, a totally paralysed British man who wants to end his life. Last week the UK High Court denied his request for euthanasia. 

After a catastrophic stroke in 2005, Mr Nicklinson is paralysed below the neck and unable to speak. He can move only his head and eyes. He communicates by blinking. Swallowing is laborious. He often coughs and needs to have saliva wiped from his face. Once a sports-event manager and rugby player based in Dubai, nowadays he writes his memoirs and watches a lot of television.

He describes his life in the bleakest terms imaginable: “dull, miserable, demeaning, undignified and intolerable. …it is misery created by the accumulation of lots of things which are minor in themselves but, taken together, ruin what’s left of my life.” Since 2007 his mind has been set on euthanasia.

Each of the three justices on the High Court took pains to express their sympathy for his plight (and the similar case of a man named Martin). But they reluctantly agreed that that the existing law on murder had to be affirmed. In England, euthanasia is still a crime. Even passionate supporters of legalised assisted suicide supported the Court’s decision. The head of Dying with Dignity in the UK, Sarah Wootton, commented: “his case goes way beyond what Dignity in Dying is calling for. We campaign for dying people to have the choice of an assisted death if they’re mentally competent and there are legal, upfront safeguards, and of course Tony is disabled, he’s not dying.”

But is death really the only solution to the dependence and limited possibilities of Mr Nicklinson’s existence? Perhaps it takes an extraordinary person, but even with locked-in syndrome, most people want to live. If the media didn’t suffer from congenital short-term memory loss, journalists would remember a French colleague who was even more locked-in than Tony Nicklinson. Jean-Dominique Bauby was the editor of the French edition of Elle when he suffered a massive stroke. He retained his capacity to think and blink (only with his left eye, though).

Crippled as he was, he wrote an international best-seller, The Diving Bell and the Butterfly. It was a poetic reflection on his dependency which was drenched with mordant humour and utterly devoid of self-pity. Here is he is describing his meals:
“By means of a tube threaded into my stomach, two or three bags of a brownish fluid provide my daily caloric needs. For pleasure I have to turn to the vivid memory of tastes and smells, an inexhaustible reservoir of sensations. Once I was a master of recycling leftovers. Now I cultivate the art of simmering memories. You can sit down to a meal at any hour, with no fuss or ceremony. If it’s a restaurant, no need to call ahead. If I do the cooking, it’s always a success.”
He never mentions euthanasia and barely mentions death.
Bauby’s is far from being an extraordinary case. The largest-ever survey of chronic locked-in syndrome patients found last year that only 28 percent were unhappy. Very few of them were interested in euthanasia – only 7 percent—or had suicidal thoughts.

The author of the study, Steven Laureys of the Coma Science Group at the University Hospital of Liege in Belgium, admitted that his sample size was small – only 65 patients in France. But it confirmed other research into how people adapt to calamities. It also suggested ways to care for these patients. For instance, nearly all of them felt that they were not engaged in worthwhile activities. Many of them wanted more social interaction.

Dr Laureys believes that the situation of locked-in syndrome patients will improve substantially as more sophisticated technology becomes available. “I predict that in coming years, our view of this disease is really going to change,” he said. “It makes a huge difference to be able to read a book or go onto the internet at will.”

In the light of stories like these, perhaps we should recalibrate our notions of “worthwhile” and “dignified”. In fact, commented a Canadian neuroscientist unconnected to the Belgian study, “We cannot and should not presume to know what it must be like to be in one of these conditions. Many patients can find happiness in ways that we simply cannot imagine.”

Not that patients delight in their disability. A year may pass before they reach a steady level of subjective well-being, said Dr Laureys. Hence requests for euthanasia soon after a stroke or accident are not well-informed: “Recently affected [locked-in syndrome] patients who wish to die should be assured that there is a high chance they will regain a happy meaningful life.”

A couple of years ago, a woman who has lived with locked-in syndrome for more than 30 years, Maryannick Pavageau, was awarded the Légion d’honneur, France’s highest civil honour, precisely for leading the charge against euthanasia. (See last year’s article in MercatorNet here.) Mme Pavageau flatly denied that her life was miserable:
“All life is worth living. It can be beautiful, regardless of the state we are in. And change is always possible. That is the message of hope that I wish to convey. I am firmly against euthanasia because it is not physical suffering that guides the desire to die but a moment of discouragement, feeling like a burden… All those who ask to die are mostly looking for love.”
Might that be the case with Tony Nicklinson? Perhaps the money used to promote his case and to pay for his legal fees should have been spent on a trip to Brittany to seek counselling from Mme Pavageau.

Besides, there is a significant detail in his application for voluntary euthanasia. He doesn’t want to die; he only want to be able to die. The judgement pointed out that:
“At the moment he thinks that he would probably wish to end [his life] in a year or two, but he wants to establish the right to die with dignity at a time of his choosing.”
Even though his life is “dull, miserable, demeaning, undignified and intolerable” he still wants to hang on to it. This suggests that he could respond if he were given more affection and stimulation.

None of us – least of all me – would want to be in Tony Nicklinson’s predicament. I fear that I would react more like him than Mme Pavageau. But it would be a heartless society which prefers to respect his “autonomy” by giving him a lethal injection rather than giving him and his family more support, affection and friendship.

In the end, making our own happiness is the supreme choice we have to make in life. As a New Zealand rugby player with locked-in syndrome wrote in the BMJ a few years ago: “It is definitely a crazy, mixed-up world. I’m just glad to still be alive—most of the time anyway… Shit definitely happens; I just have to make the most of each day in my journey towards recovery.”