segunda-feira, 4 de junho de 2012

Vaticano condena obra de religiosa que promueve masturbación, homosexualidad y divorcio

VATICANO, 04 Jun. 12 / 10:17 am (ACI/EWTN Noticias).- La Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe en el Vaticano, con la aprobación del Papa Benedicto XVI, condenó el libro "Just Love. A Framework for Christian Sexual Ethics" (Solo Amor: Un marco para la ética sexual cristiana) de la religiosa Sor Margaret A. Farley en el que se promueve la masturbación, los actos homosexuales, las uniones homosexuales y el divorcio.

Por su importancia, ACI Prensa reproduce en su integridad la notificación dada a conocer hoy por el mencionado dicasterio:

CONGREGACIÓN PARA LA DOCTRINA DE LA FE
Notificación acerca del libro
Just Love. A Framework for Christian Sexual Ethics
de Sor Margaret A. Farley, R.S.M.

Introducción

La Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, después de haber concluido un primer examen del libro Just Love. A Framework for Christian Sexual Ethics (New York: Continuum, 2006), de Sor Margaret A. Farley, R.S.M., con carta del 29 de marzo de 2010 se dirigió a la Autora a través de Sor Mary Waskowiak, entonces Presidenta de las Hermanas de la Misericordia de las Américas, para transmitirle una evaluación preliminar de su libro e indicarle sus problemas doctrinales. 

La respuesta de Sor Farley, del 28 de octubre de 2010, no clarificó de manera satisfactoria tales problemas. En consideración del hecho de que se trataba de errores doctrinales cuya publicación había sido causa de confusión entre los fieles, la Congregación decidió emprender un "Examen con procedimiento urgente" según el Reglamento para el Examen de las Doctrinas (cf. cap. IV, art. 23-27).

Después de la evaluación realizada por una Comisión de expertos (cf. art. 24), la Sesión Ordinaria de la Congregación, reunida el 8 de junio de 2011, confirmó que el libro en cuestión contenía proposiciones erróneas cuya divulgación podía causar grave daño a los fieles. Por tanto, con carta del 5 de julio de 2011, se transmitió a Sor Waskowiak el elenco de las proposiciones erróneas, pidiéndole que invitara a Sor Farley a corregir las tesis inaceptables presentes en su libro (cf. art. 25-26).

El 3 de octubre de 2011, Sor Patricia McDermott, sucesora de Sor Mary Waskowiak, de acuerdo con el Artículo 27 del citado Reglamento, envió a la Congregación la respuesta de Sor Farley acompañada de su propia opinión y a la de Sor Waskowiak. Esta respuesta, después de haber sido examinada por una Comisión de expertos, el 14 de diciembre de 2011 fue sometida a la atención de la Sesión Ordinaria. En esta ocasión, los miembros de la Congregación, considerando que la respuesta de Sor Farley no clarificaba adecuadamente los problemas contenidos en su libro, decidieron proceder con la publicación de la presente Notificación.

I. Problemas generales
La Autora no entiende correctamente el papel del Magisterio de la Iglesia, que es expresión de la autoridad de los Obispos para enseñar en comunión con el Sucesor de Pedro, que guía a la Iglesia a una comprensión siempre más profunda de la Palabra de Dios, que se encuentra en la Sagrada Escritura y que es transmitida fielmente por la Tradición viva de la Iglesia. 

Sor Farley trata argumentos de carácter moral ignorando la enseñanza constante del Magisterio y cuando ocasionalmente lo menciona, lo trata como a una opinión más. Tal actitud no se puede justificar, aun dentro de la perspectiva ecuménica que ella quiere promover. Sor Farley revela también una comprensión defectuosa del carácter objetivo de la ley moral natural, prefiriendo argumentar en base a conclusiones sacadas de ciertas corrientes filosóficas o de su propia comprensión de la "experiencia contemporánea". Tal enfoque no está de acuerdo con la auténtica teología católica.

2. Problemas específicos
Entre los numerosos errores y ambigüedades del libro se encuentran sus opiniones acerca de la masturbación, los actos homosexuales, las uniones homosexuales, la indisolubilidad del matrimonio y el problema del divorcio seguido de nuevas nupcias.

Masturbación
Escribe Sor Farley: «La masturbación […] generalmente no implica ningún problema de carácter moral. […] Por cierto, muchas mujeres […] han experimentado un gran bien en el placer auto procurado –quizá en modo especial en el descubrimiento de sus propias posibilidades para el placer–, algo que muchas no habían experimentado y ni siquiera conocido en sus relaciones sexuales ordinarias con maridos o amantes. En este sentido, se podría afirmar que la masturbación favorece las relaciones más que estorbarlas. Mi observación conclusiva es que los criterios de la justicia, como los he estado presentando, parecieran aplicables a la decisión de probar placer sexual auto-erótico solo en la medida en que esta actividad ayude o dañe, mantenga o limite el bienestar y la libertad de espíritu. Y esta es una cuestión de carácter empírico, no moral» (pág. 236).

Tales afirmaciones no están en conformidad con la doctrina de la Iglesia Católica: «Tanto el Magisterio de la Iglesia, de acuerdo con una tradición constante, como el sentido moral de los fieles, han afirmado sin ninguna duda que la masturbación es un acto intrínseca y gravemente desordenado. El uso deliberado de la facultad sexual fuera de las relaciones conyugales normales contradice a su finalidad, sea cual fuere el motivo que lo determine. Así, el goce sexual es buscado aquí al margen de la relación sexual requerida por el orden moral; aquella relación que realiza el sentido íntegro de la mutua entrega y de la procreación humana en el contexto de un amor verdadero. Para emitir un juicio justo acerca de la responsabilidad moral de los sujetos y para orientar la acción pastoral, ha de tenerse en cuenta la inmadurez afectiva, la fuerza de los hábitos contraídos, el estado de angustia u otros factores psíquicos o sociales que pueden atenuar o tal vez reducir al mínimo la culpabilidad moral»1.

Actos homosexuales
Escribe Sor Farley: «Desde mi punto de vista […], las relaciones y los actos homosexuales pueden ser justificados de acuerdo a la misma ética sexual de las relaciones y los actos heterosexuales. Por lo tanto, las personas con inclinaciones homosexuales, así como sus respectivos actos, pueden y deben ser respetados, sea que ellas tengan o no la alternativa de ser de otra manera» (pág. 295).

Dicha posición no es aceptable. La Iglesia Católica, en efecto, distingue entre personas con tendencias homosexuales y actos homosexuales. En cuanto a las personas con tendencias homosexuales, el Catecismo de la Iglesia Católica enseña que deben ser acogidas «con respeto, compasión y delicadeza. Se evitará, respecto a ellos, todo signo de discriminación injusta»2. En cuanto a los actos homosexuales, en cambio, el Catecismo afirma: «Apoyándose en la Sagrada Escritura que los presenta como depravaciones graves, la Tradición ha declarado siempre que los actos homosexuales son intrínsecamente desordenados. Son contrarios a la ley natural. Cierran el acto sexual al don de la vida. No proceden de una verdadera complementariedad afectiva y sexual. No pueden recibir aprobación en ningún caso»3.

Uniones homosexuales
Escribe Sor Farley: «Las legislaciones contra la discriminación de los homosexuales así como de las parejas de hecho, las uniones civiles y los matrimonios gay, pueden desarrollar un papel importante en la transformación del odio, de la marginación y de la estigmatización de gays y lesbianas, que todavía está siendo reforzada por enseñanzas sobre sexo "contra natura", deseo desordenado o amor peligroso. […] Una de las cuestiones actualmente más urgentes ante la opinión pública de los Estados Unidos es el matrimonio entre personas del mismo sexo, es decir, la concesión de un reconocimiento social y una validez jurídica a las uniones homosexuales, masculinas o femeninas, comparables a las uniones entre heterosexuales» (pág. 293).

Tal posición es contraria a la enseñanza del Magisterio: «La Iglesia enseña que el respeto hacia las personas homosexuales no puede en modo alguno llevar a la aprobación del comportamiento homosexual ni a la legalización de las uniones homosexuales. El bien común exige que las leyes reconozcan, favorezcan y protejan la unión matrimonial como base de la familia, célula primaria de la sociedad. Reconocer legalmente las uniones homosexuales o equipararlas al matrimonio, significaría no solamente aprobar un comportamiento desviado y convertirlo en un modelo para la sociedad actual, sino también ofuscar valores fundamentales que pertenecen al patrimonio común de la humanidad. La Iglesia no puede dejar de defender tales valores, para el bien de los hombres y de toda la sociedad»4. «Para sostener la legalización de las uniones homosexuales no puede invocarse el principio del respeto y la no discriminación de las personas. Distinguir entre personas o negarle a alguien un reconocimiento legal o un servicio social es efectivamente inaceptable sólo si se opone a la justicia. No atribuir el estatus social y jurídico de matrimonio a formas de vida que no son ni pueden ser matrimoniales no se opone a la justicia, sino que, por el contrario, es requerido por ésta»5.

Indisolubilidad del matrimonio
Escribe Sor Farley: «Mi posición personal es que el compromiso matrimonial está sujeto a disolución por las mismas razones fundamentales por las que cualquier compromiso permanente, extremamente serio y casi incondicionado, puede dejar de ser vinculante. Esto implica que pueden darse situaciones en las que hayan cambiado muchas cosas: una o ambas partes hayan cambiado, la relación haya cambiado, la razón original del compromiso recíproco parezca completamente extinguida. Es evidente que el sentido de un compromiso permanente es unir a los que lo asumen no obstante los cambios que sobrevengan. Pero ¿puede ese compromiso resistir siempre? ¿Puede mantenerse absolutamente, de cara a cambios radicales e inesperados? Mi respuesta es que a veces no puede. A veces la obligación debe ser disuelta y el compromiso puede ser legítimamente cambiado» (págs. 304-305).

Dicha opinión está en contradicción con la doctrina católica sobre la indisolubilidad del matrimonio: «El amor conyugal exige de los esposos, por su misma naturaleza, una fidelidad inviolable. Esto es consecuencia del don de sí mismos que se hacen mutuamente los esposos. El auténtico amor tiende por sí mismo a ser algo definitivo, no algo pasajero. Esta íntima unión, en cuanto donación mutua de dos personas, así como el bien de los hijos exigen la fidelidad de los cónyuges y urgen su indisoluble unidad. Su motivo más profundo consiste en la fidelidad de Dios a su alianza, de Cristo a su Iglesia. Por el sacramento del matrimonio los esposos son capacitados para representar y testimoniar esta fidelidad. Por el sacramento, la indisolubilidad del matrimonio adquiere un sentido nuevo y más profundo. El Señor Jesús insiste en la intención original del Creador que quería un matrimonio indisoluble, y deroga la tolerancia que se había introducido en la ley antigua. Entre bautizados, el matrimonio rato y consumado no puede ser disuelto por ningún poder humano ni por ninguna causa fuera de la muerte»6.

Divorcio y nuevas nupcias
Escribe Sor Farley: «Si del matrimonio nacieron hijos, los ex esposos quedarán por años o por toda la vida unidos en relación al proyecto común de ser padres. De todos modos, las vidas de dos personas que estuvieron unidas en matrimonio quedan para siempre marcadas por la experiencia de ese matrimonio. Aunque la profundidad de lo que quede admita grados, algo queda. ¿Pero lo que queda, desaprueba un segundo matrimonio? Yo opino que no. Cualquiera sea la obligación que quede de un vínculo no exige incluir la prohibición de un nuevo matrimonio, del mismo modo que el vínculo entre dos esposos no incluye la prohibición de nuevas nupcias, en caso de que uno de los dos muera» (pág. 310).

Dicha opinión contradice la doctrina católica que excluye la posibilidad de segundas nupcias después del divorcio: «Hoy son numerosos en muchos países los católicos que recurren al divorcio según las leyes civiles y que contraen también civilmente una nueva unión. La Iglesia mantiene, por fidelidad a la palabra de Jesucristo ("Quien repudie a su mujer y se case con otra, comete adulterio contra aquélla; y si ella repudia a su marido y se casa con otro, comete adulterio": Mc 10,11-12), que no puede reconocer como válida esta nueva unión, si era válido el primer matrimonio. Si los divorciados se vuelven a casar civilmente, se ponen en una situación que contradice objetivamente la ley de Dios. Por lo cual no pueden acceder a la comunión eucarística mientras persista esta situación, y por la misma razón no pueden ejercer ciertas responsabilidades eclesiales. La reconciliación mediante el sacramento de la penitencia no puede ser concedida más que aquellos que se arrepientan de haber violado el signo de la Alianza y de la fidelidad a Cristo y que se comprometan a vivir en total continencia»7.

Conclusión
Con esta Notificación, la Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe lamenta profundamente que un miembro de un Instituto de Vida Consagrada, Sor Margaret A. Farley, R.S.M., haga afirmaciones que están en contraste directo con la doctrina católica en el ámbito de la moral sexual. 

La Congregación advierte a los fieles que el libro Just Love. A Framework for Christian Sexual Ethics no está en conformidad con la doctrina de la Iglesia Católica. Por lo tanto, no puede ser usado como si fuese una válida expresión de las enseñanzas de la Iglesia para las sesiones de orientación o formación, ni tampoco para el diálogo ecuménico o interreligioso. La Congregación desea, además, alentar a los teólogos para que cumplan con sus tareas de estudio y enseñanza de la teología moral en plena conformidad con los principios de la doctrina católica.

El Sumo Pontífice Benedicto XVI, durante la audiencia concedida al Cardenal Prefecto el 16 de marzo de 2012, ha aprobado la presente Notificación, acordada en la reunión de la Sesión Ordinaria de esta Congregación el 14 de marzo de 2012, y ha ordenado su publicación.

Roma, en la sede la Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, 30 de marzo de 2012.

William Cardenal LEVADA
Prefecto

+ Luis F. Ladaria, S.I.
Arzobispo titular de Thibica
Secretario

__________________________________________
1 Catecismo de la Iglesia Católica, núm. 2352; cf. Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, Declaración Persona humana acerca de ciertas cuestiones de ética sexual (29 de diciembre de 1975), núm. 9: AAS 68 (1976), 85-87.

2 Catecismo de la Iglesia Católica, núm. 2358

3 Catecismo de la Iglesia Católica, núm. 2357; cf. Gn 19, 1-29; Rm 1, 24-27; 1 Co 6, 10; 1 Tm 1, 10; cf. Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, Declaración Persona humana, núm. 8: AAS 68 (1976), 84-85; Id., Carta Homosexualitatis problema sobre la atención pastoral a las personas homosexuales (1 de octubre de 1986): AAS 79 (1987), 543-554.

4 Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, Consideraciones acerca de los proyectos de reconocimiento de las uniones entre personas homosexuales (3 de junio de 2003), núm. 11: AAS 96 (2004), 48.

5 Ibíd., núm. 8: AAS 96 (2004), 46-47.

6 Catecismo de la Iglesia Católica, núms. 1646-1647 y 2382; cf. Mt 5, 31-32 y 19, 3-9; Mc 10, 9; Lc 16, 18; 1 Co 7, 10-11; Concilio Ecuménico Vaticano II, Constitución pastoral Gaudium et spes sobre la Iglesia en el mundo actual, núms. 48-49; Código de Derecho Canónico, can. 1141; Juan Pablo II, Exhortación Apostólica Familiaris consortio sobre la misión de la familia cristiana en el mundo actual (22 de noviembre de 1981), núm. 13: AAS 74 (1982), 93-96.

7 Catecismo de la Iglesia Católica, núm. 1650; cf. Juan Pablo II, Exhortación Apostólica Familiaris consortio, núm. 84: AAS 74 (1982), 184-186; Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, Carta Annus Internationalis Familiae sobre la recepción de la comunión eucarística por parte de los fieles divorciados que se han vuelto a casar (14 de septiembre de 1994): AAS 86 (1994), 974-979.

Homosexual pressure forced noted psychiatrist, Robert Spitzer, to change stand on therapy - by Gerard van den Aardweg, PhD


Supporters of same-sex marriage notched up a public relations coup earlier this month with the news that Dr Robert Spitzer had recanted his views on the possibility of changing a homosexual orientation. “Psychiatry Giant Sorry for Backing Gay ‘Cure’” was the front-page headline in the New York Times. 
 
Spitzer was indeed a giant. In 1973 he was responsible for deleting homosexuality from an official list of psychiatric disorders. Over the next few decades this effectively normalised homosexual behaviour. But in 2003, something unexpected happened. He published a study in the Archives of Sexual Behavior which showed that some homosexuals could change. He immediately became a traitor to the gay community and a hero for social conservatives.

But now Dr Spitzer, who has just turned 80 and is suffering from Parkinson’s disease, has repudiated this study. He has just published a letter of apology in the Archives of Sexual Behavior: “I believe I owe the gay community an apology for my study making unproven claims of the efficacy of reparative therapy,” he wrote. “I also apologize to any gay person who wasted time and energy undergoing some form of reparative therapy because they believed that I had proven that reparative therapy works with some ‘highly motivated’ individuals.”

The gay community and the New York Times have hailed the letter as a devastating blow to the notion that homosexuals can change. A leading gay advocacy website, ThinkProgress, declared that “Any organization that claims his prior work as valid proof that sexual orientation can be changed is lying with malicious — and harmful— intent.”  
What’s the real story? MercatorNet interviewed Gerard van den Aardweg, a Dutch psychologist who has written extensively on homosexuality.

MercatorNet: Were you surprised by Dr Spitzer’s apology to the gay community?

Gerard van den Aardweg: At first, yes. But after a short while, not very much, for the following reasons.

Some time after his 2003 article I had a conversation with him on the telephone. I asked him if he would continue his research, or even if he would try to guide a few people with homosexual problems and who sought “alternative” professional help, that is, help and support to change as much as possible from homosexual to heterosexual interests.
In his interviews with people who had walked along that path, he certainly had learned a lot, among other things, the great need among many homosexually inclined persons for this kind of help. I felt that Dr Spitzer was the kind of psychiatrist who could do much good for some of these persons. So why not give it a try?

His reply was adamant. No, he would never touch the whole subject ever again. He had nearly broken down emotionally after terrible personal attacks from militant gays and their supporters. There was an outpouring of hatred.

A man can indeed be broken by such a traumatizing experience. At the time, I thought that his stance was perhaps not the most courageous one, but it was certainly understandable. After all, his cautious recognition of the reality of changes in some people with a homosexual orientation already represented an enormous about-face. He had been one of the leading figures of the lobby which in 1973 succeeded in normalizing the definition of homosexuality in the Diagnostic Manual of the American Psychiatric Association. Now the hero of the gay movement had suddenly become a Judas.

But fear is seldom a good counsellor. My guess is that Dr Spitzer in 2003 only dabbled in the water, because he didn’t dare to dive. Unfortunately, his neutral, withdrawn attitude towards the subject of homosexuality did not protect him from fierce pressure to distance himself from his “betrayal”.

In psychiatric and psychological circles it is already very difficult for an ordinary professional to maintain himself and endure hostility, taunting, and marginalization if it becomes known that he or she thinks homosexuality is a disturbance (of whatever sort) and not irreversibly programmed. For a prominent psychiatrist as Dr Spitzer, with his gay-friendly past, this must have been a torment.

So this is my surmise. Not having the conviction and inner dynamic to wholly convert to the pre-1973 position that homosexuality is disordered sexuality, he finally succumbed to pressure.

MercatorNet: Does Dr Spitzer’s recantation really deliver a devastating blow to “ex-gay” organisations and prove that reparative therapy is 20th century snake oil?

I don’t think it is such a serious setback. In the world of ex-gays it is a well-known phenomenon that persons who at first were enthusiastic later feel disillusioned. They might feel that change is not as rapid or deep as they wanted, or they come to doubt whether it is worth all the effort, or they have too superficial an understanding of the emotional and personality or character malformation underlying same-sex attractions.

That is true for people with same-sex attractions (SSA) themselves and sometimes for professionals. I could illustrate this with the case of a Dutch psychiatrist who, though in his heart believing SSA is a psychological disturbance, yet, in a stressful period in his life, publicly regretted his former “disturbance” statements.

In any case, Dr Spitzer has not said that his observations and impressions about change in the individuals he interviewed were false, or that they had lied to him. In his article, he himself brought up this hypothesis, but he was convinced what he heard was on the whole reliable. 

His retraction does not change his results and his results are the only thing that counts. This whole retraction affair is in fact merely a question of media manipulation, not a matter of science. Some nuclear scientists may have regretted their work when they saw its consequences in the field of nuclear weaponry. However the knowledge they acquired was not affected by their regret. (In Dr Spitzer’s case, the results were in fact benign, of course.)

Apart from all this, the need of many persons troubled by SSA is so persistent and universal, as is the common sense insight that something is amiss with homosexuality, that therapy and other constructive efforts will always go on -- if not within academic psychology and psychiatry, then outside of it.

MercatorNet: In his brief letter to the Archives of Sexual Behavior, Dr Spitzer mentions two serious flaws in his 2003 study – that the study design was flawed and that memories of change are scientifically unreliable. Do you think that the study was really flawed?

That the design was flawed is not a new argument. Spitzer made it crystal-clear in his original article that he only wanted to call the attention to the fact that “some” people can deeply change from homosexuality to heterosexuality. The fact that he interviewed volunteers from the ex-gay and therapeutic community was clearly stated.

Now he says his selection was flawed (as in fact are all selections of SSA people in the literature!). But what does this mean? That “I did not demonstrate that all homosexuals can radically change”? No one has ever maintained that. That “Some people with SSA do radically change and others, and more than one of them, substantially change”? That is what he found, no more, no less. His remarks on the skewed distribution of his sample do not invalidate this conclusion.
Memories of change are unreliable? What does he mean?

That, for instance, people who were “profoundly changed” were fantasizing about their past emotions and conflicts? Then his remark is the same as the standard gay contention that those who are changed have never been “really” homosexual.

Well, in that case he proved in 2003 that efforts to change at least can free troubled people from the “delusion” that they were homosexual, and from the concomitants of such delusions, like same-sex cruising, obsessions, partnerships etc. This implies that we need to define homosexual orientation as a same-sex attraction that can never change. Which also implies that you need to have sustained efforts to change to know whether your SSA is real or pseudo.

I do not believe Dr Spitzer believes this argument himself.
A few years ago, I sent him a report on an ex-lesbian woman who after many years was still completely free of same-sex feelings whatsoever, even though she had severely suffered from them until in her mid-30s. Of course Dr Spitzer did not reply that she had merely imagined the infatuations, lesbian jealousies, erotic obsessions, depressions, inferiority feelings and so on. He found the story very interesting, but he asked “but how frequently does this occur?” A good question, of course, but however rare it may be, the reality of her memories (as examined by a sceptical psychiatrist) is beyond doubt.

Suppose memories of former sexual (or other emotional) states cannot be trusted. This means that an enormous part of psychological and psychiatric research, where memories play a role, should be rejected. Naturally, memories of one’s previous sexual life can be inexact, exaggerated, distorted, and embellished. But there is no justification for the contention that in principle they are untrustworthy. Dr Spitzer is clearly seeking a “scientific” justification for his recantation.

MercatorNet: When he published the original article, some psychiatrists invoked the Nuremberg Code of ethics to denounce it as morally wrong. Was it? 

Morally wrong? Not at all. The idea that psychotherapy or other counselling procedures in cases of SSA and studies of their effects in clients or patients who voluntarily participated in such interventions violates a person’s integrity is simply bizarre. There is a stronger case for saying that propaganda for homosexual promiscuity among minors (with consequences such as STDs, HIV infection, enhanced suicide risks, and much psychological misery) is profoundly unethical.

MercatorNet: I’m a bit puzzled by the public attention given to Dr Spitzer’s change of heart. The original article seemed to make a fairly modest point – that it is possible for some homosexuals to change their orientation after some form of reparative therapy. What’s so disturbing about that?

You are right. And I think most ordinary people will see it that way. The whole thing is a media beat-up to support the agenda of the gay movement and the social and political powers that want to impose it on the population. In the US, gay marriage has become a hot political issue. For supporters, it is a PR coup when a prominent psychiatrist like Dr Spitzer suggests he has found evidence for the two gay dogmas: you are born that way and you cannot change.

MercatorNet: New York University constitutional law professor Kenji Yoshino has claimed that Spitzer’s recantation shows that homosexual orientation is immutable. If this is the case, then any form of discrimination against gays will be illegal, just like race, sex, non-marital parentage, and so on. Your comments?

Professor Yoshino confabulates. Dr Spitzer has not contended, let alone proven, that homosexuality is immutable. He only tries to relativize his results. If it were immutable, no conclusion could reasonably be drawn about its legal, moral, or whatever status. The comparison with race, sex, etc. has not a leg to stand on. Allegedly immutable traits, attitudes, or orientations that you are born with can still be disturbances or defects. Would Professor Yoshino advocate the same for people with “immutable” inclinations towards paedophilia, for instance?

MercatorNet: My impression is that very little is known about changes in sexual orientation. But now people are afraid to discuss the topic. Is that the case?

There is much more knowledge and experience in this field than most people realize. Too often it appears that we are groping in the dark regarding the causes, dynamics, and change-possibilities of homosexuality. That is certainly untrue. There is a lot of solid insight and there is a body of well-established facts.

As for change, the Spitzer statistics still belong to this pool of evidence. Profound and lasting changes do occur in a minority of people who make prolonged efforts. Substantial improvements happen more often. Other studies give about the same picture. These are modest results, but hopeful.

People do fear to express their opinions about homosexual behaviour. Professionals fear dissenting from the prescribed ideological “wisdom” about homosexuality. Politicians fear to say anything in public that would irritate the gay community, etc. The ideology of militant gays is being imposed on the West. It implies that the search for the truth about homosexuality, its causes and changeability, has almost become a forbidden activity.

Gerard van den Aardweg is a Dutch psychologist who specialises in homosexuality and marital problems.

domingo, 3 de junho de 2012

Homilia de Bento XVI na Missa de encerramento do encontro mundial de famílias em Milão

In Vatican

Venerados Irmãos,
Distintas Autoridades,
Amados irmãos e irmãs!

Grande momento de alegria e de comunhão é este que vivemos ao celebrar o Sacrifício Eucarístico, nesta manhã. Está reunida com o Sucessor de Pedro uma grande assembleia, composta por fiéis vindos de muitas nações. Nela temos uma expressiva imagem da Igreja, una e universal, fundada por Cristo e fruto da missão que Jesus, como ouvimos no Evangelho, confiou aos seus Apóstolos: «Ide, pois, fazer discípulos de todas as nações, baptizai-os em nome do Pai e do Filho e do Espírito Santo» (Mt 28, 18-19). Saúdo com afecto e gratidão o Cardeal Angelo Scola, Arcebispo de Milão, e o Cardeal Ennio Antonelli, Presidente do Pontifício Conselho para a Família, principais artífices deste VII Encontro Mundial das Famílias, bem como os seus colaboradores, os Bispos Auxiliares de Milão e todos os outros Prelados. Com prazer, saúdo todas as Autoridades presentes. E, hoje, o meu caloroso abraço vai sobretudo para vós, queridas famílias! Obrigado pela vossa participação!

Na segunda Leitura, o apóstolo Paulo recordou-nos que recebemos no Baptismo o Espírito Santo, que de tal modo nos une a Cristo como irmãos e liga ao Pai como filhos, que podemos gritar: «Abba! Pai!» (cf. Rm 8, 15.17). Então foi-nos dado um gérmen de vida nova, divina, que se há-de fazer crescer até à realização definitiva na glória celeste; tornamo-nos membros da Igreja, a família de Deus, «sacrarium Trinitatis» – na expressão de Santo Ambrósio –, «um povo – como ensina o Concílio Vaticano II –  unido pela unidade do Pai e do Filho e do Espírito Santo» (Const. Lumen gentium, 4). A solenidade litúrgica da Santíssima Trindade, que hoje celebramos, convida-nos a contemplar este mistério, mas impele-nos também ao compromisso de viver a comunhão com Deus e entre nós segundo o modelo da comunhão trinitária. Somos chamados a acolher e a transmitir, concordes, as verdades da fé; a viver o amor recíproco e para com todos, compartilhando alegrias e sofrimentos, aprendendo a pedir e a dar o perdão, valorizando os diversos carismas sob a guia dos Pastores. Numa palavra, está-nos confiada a tarefa de construir comunidades eclesiais que sejam cada vez mais família, capazes de reflectir a beleza da Trindade e evangelizar não só com a palavra mas – diria eu – por «irradiação», com a força do amor vivido.

Não é só a Igreja que é chamada a ser imagem do Deus Uno em Três Pessoas, mas também a família fundada no matrimónio entre o homem e a mulher. No princípio, de facto, «Deus criou o ser humano à sua imagem, criou-o à imagem de Deus: Ele os criou homem e mulher. Abençoando-os, Deus disse-lhes: “Crescei e multiplicai-vos”» (Gn 1, 27-28). Deus criou o ser humano, homem e mulher, com igual dignidade, mas também com características próprias e complementares, para que os dois fossem dom um para o outro, se valorizassem reciprocamente e realizassem uma comunidade de amor e de vida. O amor é o que faz da pessoa humana a autêntica imagem da Trindade, imagem de Deus. Queridos esposos, na vivência do matrimónio, não dais qualquer coisa ou alguma actividade, mas a vida inteira. E o vosso amor é fecundo, antes de mais nada, para vós mesmos, porque desejais e realizais o bem um do outro, experimentando a alegria do receber e do dar. Depois é fecundo na procriação generosa e responsável dos filhos, na solicitude carinhosa por eles e na educação cuidadosa e sábia. Finalmente é fecundo para a sociedade, porque a vida familiar é a primeira e insubstituível escola das virtudes sociais, tais como o respeito pelas pessoas, a gratuidade, a confiança, a responsabilidade, a solidariedade, a cooperação. Queridos esposos, cuidai dos vossos filhos e, num mundo dominado pela técnica, transmiti-lhes com serenidade e confiança as razões para viver, a força da fé desvendando-lhes metas altas e servindo-lhes de apoio na fragilidade. Mas também vós, filhos, sabei manter sempre uma relação de profundo afecto e solícito cuidado com os vossos pais, e as relações entre irmãos e irmãs sejam também oportunidade para crescer no amor.

O projecto de Deus para o casal humano alcança a sua plenitude em Jesus Cristo, que elevou o matrimónio a Sacramento. Com um dom especial do Espírito Santo, queridos esposos, Cristo faz-vos participar no seu amor esponsal, tornando-vos sinal do seu amor pela Igreja: um amor fiel e total. Se souberdes acolher este dom, renovando diariamente o vosso «sim» com fé e com a força que vem da graça do Sacramento, também a vossa família viverá do amor de Deus, tomando por modelo a Sagrada Família de Nazaré. Queridas famílias, pedi muitas vezes, na oração, o auxílio da Virgem Maria e de São José, para que vos ensinem a acolher o amor de Deus como o acolheram eles. A vossa vocação não é fácil de viver, especialmente hoje, mas a realidade do amor é maravilhosa, é a única força que pode verdadeiramente transformar o universo, o mundo. Aos vossos olhos foi oferecido o testemunho de tantas famílias, que indicam os caminhos para crescer no amor: manter um relacionamento perseverante com Deus e participar na vida eclesial, cultivar o diálogo, respeitar o ponto de vista do outro, estar disponíveis para servir, ser paciente com os defeitos alheios, saber perdoar e pedir perdão, superar com inteligência e humildade os possíveis conflitos, concordar as directrizes educacionais, estar abertos às outras famílias, atentos aos pobres, ser responsáveis na sociedade civil. Todos estes são elementos que constroem a família. Vivei-os com coragem, pois na medida em que, com o apoio da graça divina, viverdes o amor mútuo e para com todos, tornar-vos-eis um Evangelho vivo, uma verdadeira Igreja doméstica (cf. Exort. ap. Familiaris consortio, 49). Quero dedicar uma palavra também aos fiéis que, embora compartilhando os ensinamentos da Igreja sobre a família, estão marcados por experiências dolorosas de falência e separação. Sabei que o Papa e a Igreja vos apoiam na vossa fadiga. Encorajo-vos a permanecer unidos às vossas comunidades, enquanto almejo que as dioceses assumam adequadas iniciativas de acolhimento e proximidade.

No livro do Génesis, Deus confia ao casal humano a sua criação, para que a guarde, cultive e guie de acordo com o seu plano (cf. 1, 27-28; 2, 15). Nesta indicação da Sagrada Escritura, podemos ler a missão que tem o homem e a mulher de colaborar com Deus para transformar o mundo, através do trabalho, da ciência e da técnica. O homem e a mulher são também imagem de Deus nesta obra preciosa, que devem realizar com o mesmo amor do Criador. Vemos que, nas teorias económicas modernas, prevalece muitas vezes uma concepção utilitarista do trabalho, da produção e do mercado. Mas, o projecto de Deus e a própria experiência mostram que não é a lógica unilateral do que me é útil e do maior lucro que pode concorrer para um desenvolvimento harmonioso, o bem da família e para construir uma sociedade justa, porque traz consigo uma competição exasperada, fortes desigualdades, degradação do meio ambiente, corrida ao consumo, mal-estar nas famílias. Antes, a mentalidade utilitarista tende a estender-se também às relações interpessoais e familiares, reduzindo-as a convergências precárias de interesses individuais e minando a solidez do tecido social.

Um último elemento. O homem, enquanto imagem de Deus, é chamado também ao descanso e à festa. A narrativa da criação termina com estas palavras: «Concluída, no sétimo dia, toda a obra que tinha feito, Deus repousou, no sétimo dia, de todo o trabalho por Ele realizado. Deus abençoou o sétimo dia e santificou-o» (Gn 2, 2-3). Para nós, cristãos, o dia de festa é o Domingo, dia do Senhor, Páscoa da semana. É o dia da Igreja, assembleia convocada pelo Senhor ao redor da mesa da Palavra e do Sacrifício Eucarístico, como estamos a fazer hoje, para nos alimentar d’Ele, entrar no seu amor e viver do seu amor. É o dia do homem e dos seus valores: convivência, amizade, solidariedade, cultura, contacto com a natureza, jogo, desporto. É o dia da família, em que se há-de viver, juntos, o sentido da festa, do encontro, da partilha, também com a participação na Santa Missa. Queridas famílias, mesmo nos ritmos acelerados do nosso tempo, não percais o sentido do dia do Senhor! É como o oásis onde parar para saborear a alegria do encontro e saciar a nossa sede de Deus.

Família, trabalho, festa: três dons de Deus, três dimensões da nossa vida que se devem encontrar num equilíbrio harmonioso. Harmonizar os horários do trabalho e as exigências da família, a profissão e a paternidade e maternidade, o trabalho e a festa é importante para construir sociedades com um rosto humano. Nisto, privilegiai sempre a lógica do ser sobre a do ter: a primeira constrói, a segunda acaba por destruir. É preciso educar-se para crer, em primeiro lugar na família, no amor autêntico: o amor que vem de Deus e nos une a Ele e, por isso mesmo, «nos transforma em um Nós, que supera as nossas divisões e nos faz ser um só, até que, no fim, Deus seja “tudo em todos” (1 Cor 15, 28)» (Enc. Deus caritas est, 18). Amen.

sexta-feira, 1 de junho de 2012

Why Sexual Integrity Isn’t Out-of-Date - by Nathaniel Peters


A book about sex by J. Budziszewski uses natural law arguments to persuade young adults of the moral benefits of purity. 
 
How should we respond to the hookup culture? A number of concerned parents, pastors, and professors from all sides of the religious and political spectrum have expressed concern about the sexual culture that today’s young people inhabit. Some scholars, such as sociologists Mark Regnerus, Jeremy Uecker, and Kathleen Bogle, have published value-neutral analyses that aim to assess current trends and save us from common misperceptions. In empirical terms, they tell us how and why the sexual economy hurts its actors. Others, such as Laura Sessions Stepp and Donna Freitas, have offered more personal—and, for Freitas, spiritual—analyses of problems and possible solutions in modern sexual culture. Interestingly enough, these authors don’t write as traditionalists or social conservatives. They aren’t advocating purity rings or “modest is hottest.” Instead, they seek to help young people make more responsible sexual decisions. Not surprisingly, though, their counsel often aligns with a traditional conception of sexuality and monogamy, even if not perfectly. The science shows that more commitment and fewer sexual partners tend to make people happier.

But what about those who think that morality requires a bit more of us? How can they persuade young people that reserving sexual intimacy for marriage is the right thing to do? In his book On the Meaning of Sex, popular author and political philosopher J. Budziszewski attempts to make such an argument on the basis of human nature and natural law. He begins with an anecdote from teaching. During a classroom discussion of Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World, one of his students, Harris, said he found the characters disgusting. When pressed, Harris clarified that he had no problem with their sexual habits: “Sex doesn’t always have to mean something,” he insisted. What he found disgusting was their factory production of human beings.

But, Budziszewski argues, holding those two positions is not logically consistent:

It shouldn’t have bothered Harris unless procreation is something that ought to take place in the loving embrace of the parents. . . . Moreover, since Harris was revolted that the aspiration to children could ever be separated from the aspiration to union, it would seem that he recognized that these two meanings aren’t merely sometimes joined together, but that they are joined whenever we have sex. . . . Apparently sex means something to us even if we don’t admit to ourselves that it does.

That last sentence conveys Budziszewski’s goal and style of argumentation: He wants to draw attention to the reader’s gut feelings and instincts that may have been trained away by education or social conditioning. He wants to help them see what they know, even if they don’t know that they know it.

After some well-laid-out arguments about function, purpose, and natural law, Budziszewski argues that our bodies and actions have natural purposes. This means that some actions, such as those necessary for sexual union, mean something, whether we want them to or not. To put it another way, they say something, even if that is not what we want them to say: “A bodily action is like a word; we mean things to each other no less by what we do than by what we say. . . . To crush your windpipe with my thumbs is to say to you, ‘Now die,’ even if I tell you with my mouth, ‘Be alive.’ To join in one flesh is to say, ‘I give myself to you in all that this act means,’ even if I tell you with my mouth, ‘This means nothing.’” What sex means is total gift, a union of selves instantiated through bodily union, and it cannot but help mean that. By acting against this nature, which we cannot change, we do damage to ourselves and others.

Budziszewski further argues that human nature entails complementary differences between men and women. He notes that these differences are similar across cultures, both in terms of what people think they are and what they think about them. “Mark it up as another victory of quantitative social science,” he writes: “We can now confirm by counting that what everyone used to know without counting really is true.” He then explores how the particular characteristics of men and women make them attractive—in short, what we mean when we say that someone is sexy. Budziszewski thinks we mean that we find their manliness or womanliness desirable. Womanliness, for instance, “isn’t something she contrives, but something that glows from her. . . . The most compelling and believable signs of being a nice person to marry, make love with, and have children with are the ones that arise spontaneously. They are an outward glory given by an inward and invisible reality. A beautiful woman cannot help giving off such radiance, because it is an effect of what she really is.” Beauty conveys something deeper and more holistic than raw sexual appeal.

Similarly, spousal love is not a matter of feelings but an act of the will. Enchantment is a feeling of emotional infatuation, the moment of “wow” when she enters the room. Love, by contrast, is really about charity, which Budziszewski defines as “a permanent commitment of the will to the true good of the other person.” Erotic charity is a mode of charity bound to one person, and sexual intercourse is a particular act of this charity that fuses two selves together in the union of their flesh. Because love is not about enchantment, but charity, it is an act of the will, not a feeling. Therefore, Budziszewski argues, “it is something that one decides to do, and it can be promised.” To the many young people who claim that permanent, exclusive marriage is impossible because you can’t promise feelings, he would say yes—but marriage is not a promise of feelings.

Not surprisingly, Budziszewski calls for embracing sexual purity, which, he makes clear, is a matter of pursuing goods—goods that will be useful and helpful for marriage—not fleeing from them. Its temporary “no’s” enable one to give a full “yes” at the right time. He sees sexual purity as coming in both masculine and feminine flavors: “One awakens the feminine intuition of something that must be guarded; the other, the masculine sense of something that must be mastered.” And he extols the virtues of purity: decorum, “the conduct befitting the dignity of man as a rational being”; modesty, which “expresses respect for the fragility of this dignity . . . [and avoids] provoking appetites that people should be trying to moderate”; and temperance, finding order and the mean in one’s actions.

Throughout the book, Budziszewski resists invoking God or anything beyond rationally accessible premises. More accurately, he hints at such ideas without developing his hints, nor has he explained why every chapter begins with a quotation from John of the Cross. In the conclusion, though, he argues that sex points to and is ultimately about God: “Nature points beyond herself. She has a face, and it looks up. . . . ultimately, human love makes sense only in the light of divine love. The point is not that divine love means something and that human love doesn’t. Human love means so much, because divine love means still more.” In a variation on C.S. Lewis’s argument for the existence of God based on desire, he notes that even when we love well, mortal love is not enough. Since no human longing is made in vain, this unfulfilled natural desire must point toward a supernatural lover.

But taking this argument into religious waters poses the question of which audience Budziszewski hopes to reach. And that poses the larger question of how effective his efforts—not to mention the broader efforts of like-minded religious believers—actually are. If he wants to strengthen the faithful as they navigate young adulthood, he might well succeed. To be sure, far too many young religious men and women have followed the cultural lead and abandoned chastity. If On the Meaning of Sex gave them better reasons for it, that alone would be a great feat. But how is he to persuade students who press with further questions or actively oppose his views on principle? Budziszewski’s occasionally chivalric language might go over well with young Chestertonians, but many young adults would balk at passages like this one:

When we do attempt the journey back to the commonwealth of sense, we will meet trolls and enchanters on the way. They will obstruct passage, demand tribute, and try to lure us into byways and bogs. But why should that discourage us? We are already begrimed and bewitched. The first thing to do is open our eyes, grasp hold of the nearest branches, and pull ourselves out of the ooze. Odd knights we! Having made ourselves muddy and ridiculous, we may as well journey with a smile.

Likewise, the Arthurian metaphor of the Siege Perilous for a woman, her sexuality, or her reproductive organs is not going to fly outside more traditional Christian circles, and even there it might receive tenuous support.

Inquisitive students will desire more proof that sex has to mean what Budziszewski thinks it means—and why it cannot mean what they might want it to mean. His passages about sexual beauty offer an attractive vision of what it means to be human, but can they pierce the carapace of wounded, ironic disdain? He discusses sexual differences with nuance and care, and many young adults would no doubt find resonances of his words in their lives, but, albeit unfairly, a good number will dismiss it as patriarchal and outmoded.

How then can those who agree with Budziszewski try to show young adults a more excellent way? There are few easy answers, but On the Meaning of Sex’s strengths show where to begin: by offering an eloquent, engaging description of the beauty of men, women, and sexuality. Moreover, it seeks to show young people the wisdom of their desires and repugnance. It tries to preserve good intuitions and gently check misunderstandings, to show them what their hearts know, even if unwittingly. It also hands on the wisdom of our forebears with care and winsomeness. Of course, those who believe that chastity leads to flourishing must also demonstrate it with their lives. But arguments are necessary as well, and both the style and the content of On the Nature of Sex offer a good place to find them.

Nathaniel Peters is a Ph.D. student of theology at Boston College.

Trasnacional del aborto apoya incondicionalmente a Obama

Washington, 31 May. 12 / 11:20 pm (ACI/EWTN Noticias).- La presidenta de los Fondos de Acción de la ONG abortista Planned Parenthood, Cecile Richards, anunció que esta organización invertirá inicialmente 1.7 millones de dólares en apoyar la candidatura de Barack Obama a la reelección como Presidente de los Estados Unidos, atacando a su rival, el conservador Mitt Romney.

De acuerdo a ABC News, la campaña "Out of touch" (Fuera de contacto), comprende videos que se transmitirán en los estados de Florida, Virginia, Iowa y en la capital del país, Washington D.C., criticando a Mitt Romney por su oposición al aborto y ofrecer cortar el financiamiento estatal a Planned Parenthood.

En un comunicado difundido en YouTube el 30 de mayo, Richards anunció que "hoy estoy orgullosa de hacerlo oficial: El Fondo de Acción de Planned Parenthood va a apoyar la campaña para la reelección del presidente Barack Obama".

La dirigente de la organización abortista señaló que "gracias al presidente Obama, las mujeres de todo Estados Unidos tendrán ‘control de la natalidad’ (que incluye el aborto) sin un co-pago".

En el comunicado, también se criticó el ofrecimiento de Romney de "deshacerse" de Planned Parenthood, retirando el financiamiento federal (dinero de impuestos) que recibe la ONG abortista, el cual se estima anualmente en más de 300 millones de dólares, alrededor de un tercio de todo su presupuesto.

"Mitt Romney está fuera de contacto y el presidente Obama tiene nuestro respaldo", aseguró Cecile Richards.

En el video, la líder abortista pidió "en nombre del Fondo de Acción de Planned Parenthood te estoy pidiendo que te pongas de pie por él, con tu voz y con tu voto".

En 2008, la organización abortista, con Richards a la cabeza, invirtió cerca de 10 millones de dólares para "comprar" un millón de votos a favor de candidatos anti-vida en Estados Unidos.

Spitzer's "Retraction": What Does It Really Mean? - by Christopher H. Rosik, Ph.D.

In NARTH

No new scientific finding has discredited the study. The same arguments originally made for or against it, still stand. 

A great deal of attention is currently being given to the recent "retraction" by Robert Spitzer, M.D., of his important study of sexual-orientation change (Spitzer, 2003a). The quotation marks around "retraction" are purposeful, for what has happened should not be characterized as a retraction. While this turn of events has now become a favorite talking point for those opposed to sexual orientation-change efforts (SOCE), the language of retraction reflects politically motivated speech rather than scientific analysis. What follows is intended to help those confused by Spitzer's actions and the subsequent media feeding frenzy to understand what has really occurred. I have outlined below some key points that seem to have been lost in the partisan utilization of this turn of events.

            1. Spitzer has not retracted his study. The proper term for what Spitzer has done is provided in the title to his recent letter of apology: He has reassessed his interpretation (Spitzer, 2012). It appears that he may have originally wished to retract the 2003 study, but the editor of the journal in which the study was published, Kenneth Zucker, Ph.D., denied this request. Zucker has been quoted regarding his exchange with Spitzer as observing:

You can retract data incorrectly analyzed; to do that, you publish an erratum. You can retract an article if the data were falsified-or the journal retracts it if the editor knows of it. As I understand it, he's [Spitzer] just saying ten years later that he wants to retract his interpretation of the data. Well, we'd probably have to retract hundreds of scientific papers with regard to interpretation, and we don't do that. (Dreger, 2012)

What Zucker is essentially saying is that there is nothing in the science of the study that warrants retraction, so all that is left for one to change is his interpretation of the findings, which is what Spitzer appears to have done.

            2. Spitzer's change of interpretation hinges on his new belief that reports of change in his research were not credible. Instead, he now asserts that participants' accounts of change were "self-deception or outright lying" (Spitzer, 2012). In taking this position, Spitzer has aligned himself with original critics of the study. When the original study was published, peer commentaries about the study had been solicited and were published in the same issue. Among those who questioned the reliability of the self-reports of change were many familiar opponents of SOCE: A. Lee Beckstead, Helena Carlson, Kenneth Cohen, Ritch Savin-Williams, Gregory Herek, Bruce Rind, and Roger Worthington.

            3. The case for the credibility of participants' account of change still remains. Remember that nothing about the science of Spitzer's research was flawed. Like all research pursuits, the methodology had limitations, but a reasonable case for accepting the validity of these accounts was made at the time, and still stands today. At the time his study was published, Spitzer (2003a) reported, "...there was a marked reduction on all change measures. This was not only on the three measures of overt behavior and sexual orientation self-identity...but also on the seven variables assessing sexual orientation itself" (p. 410). In addition, 119 of his sample of 200 participants reported achieving "Good Heterosexual Functioning," which was defined in terms of increasing satisfaction in opposite sex sexual behaviors and decreased same-sex fantasy.

            Among the peer commentaries that agreed with Spitzer's original interpretation, Wakefield (2003) noted that, "...to assume without evidence that reports of changes must be deceptions begs the question of whether change sometimes occurs" (p. 457). Spitzer (2003b) himself responded to the critics by noting:

Therefore, the critics are correct in claiming that significant response bias could have been present but they certainly have not proved that it was present. They also did not point to anything in the study results that suggests response bias. I acknowledge that some response bias could certainly have occurred, but I find it hard to believe that it can explain all of the reported changes...Surely if bias were present, one would expect that subjects (as well as their spouses) would be motivated to give particularly glowing accounts of marital functioning. They did not. (p. 471)

            It is curious that Spitzer's (2012) apology seems to imply that he earlier claimed his research proved the efficacy of SOCE. As was understood at the time, the design of Spizter's study ensured his research would not definitively prove that SOCE can be effective. Certainly it did not prove that all gays and lesbians can change their sexual orientation or that sexual orientation is simply a choice. The fact that some people inappropriately drew such conclusions appears to be a factor in Spitzer's reassessment. Yet the fundamental interpretive question did and still does boil down to one of plausibility: Given the study limitations, is it plausible that some participants in SOCE reported actual change?

In spite of all the recent media hoopla, nothing has really changed regarding the interpretive choice one faces regarding the limitations of self-report in this study. Either all of the accounts across all of the measures of change across participant and spousal reports are self-deceptions and/or deliberate fabrications, or they suggest it is possible that some individuals actually do experience change in the dimensions of sexual orientation. Good people can disagree about which of these interpretive conclusions they favor, but assuredly it is not unscientific or unreasonable to continue to believe the study supports the plausibility of change.

            4. There is an unspoken double standard in the reports of Spitzer's reassessment. The probable influence of political and other non-scientific factors in how Spitzer's reassessment is being portrayed can be seen in which interpretations of self-report data receive favored notoriety and which are relegated to unfavored exile. Yarhouse (2003) observed this lack of consistency at the time of the study:

Memory recall of this sort can be unreliable. To be fair, however, much of what we know about LGB experiences, including theories for the etiology of sexual orientation and studies of sexual identity development and synthesis, is based upon retrospective studies utilizing memory recall. Any time proponents of the biological hypothesis for the etiology of homosexuality cite the Bell et al. (1981) study they are referencing a study that utilized retrospective memory recall. The Shidlo and Schroeder (2002) study also relied upon memory recall and is subject to the same criticism. (p. 462).

Spitzer (2003b) had similar observations in defending his findings, implying that demand characteristics could have influenced the self-reports of participants in other related research:

This study had essentially the same design and a similar recruitment strategy of ex-gay subjects as in the Beckstead (2001) and Shidlo and Schroeder (2002) studies. This raises the question of why so very few of their subjects gave answers consistent with a change in sexual orientation whereas the majority of my subjects did. The possibility of researcher bias must be considered. (p. 471).

A triumphal embrace often accompanies self-report data that suggests harm from SOCE, the equivalence of gay and heterosexual parenting, and other foci that fit with the preferred narrative of gay activists. It is unfortunate but not surprising that reports of sexual-orientation change are subject to unrelenting skepticism while other self-report data such as that of Shidlo and Schroeder (2002) seem to be reified as universal fact even though they suffer from similar limitations. If Spitzer's study is to be rejected for its use of self-report data, should not methodologically equivalent research against SOCE receive a similarly skeptical reception? While scientific fairness would seem to demand this, political interests clearly do not.

5. Personal and sociopolitical contexts may provide insights into Spitzer's reassessment. I once spoke briefly with Dr. Spitzer by phone years ago following the publication of his research. He seemed to be a kind and compassionate man who exemplified the spirit of genuine scientific curiosity. No doubt he was grieved that some used his work to make unsupportable claims of SOCE efficacy and this may have resulted in unfulfilled expectations by some gay and lesbian consumers. Yet it is certainly possible that other needs beyond his concern for human welfare were at play in his apology.

            It is hard to imagine the fall from professional grace that Spitzer took due to this study. In a very short period of time, his status within his profession changed from that of a heroic pioneer of gay rights to that of an unwitting mouthpiece for practitioners of SOCE, whom many of his colleagues deem morally reprehensible. Before and after the study was published, Spitzer confirmed that he was getting a high volume of hate mail and anger directed at him (Spitzer, 2003b; Vonholdt, 2000). A decade of being hammered by your friends, colleagues, and the gay community that once revered you would surely take a toll on any of us.

Spitzer currently suffers from Parkinson's disease and is in the twilight of his life, which makes it understandable that he would reflect on what sort of legacy he wants to leave. Hero or villain, icon or pariah-which legacy would anyone prefer to have? I can not say for sure that these non-scientific considerations influenced Spitzer's decision to "retract" his study, but I can say that it is hard for me to conceive how they would not. Spitzer likely knows infinitely more gay and lesbian persons than he does individuals who report change in sexual orientation. This may have made it difficult for him to see that in trying to atone for the harm gay men and lesbians in his professional network claimed resulted from the study, he simultaneously caused harm to participants in his study who experienced change and now are told they were deceived or lying. All of this serves to underscore how personal and subjective the practice of social scientific discourse can be when the subject matter is entangled in a major sociopolitical debate.

Conclusion
           
            A purely scientific approach to the limitations of Spitzer's research would be to conduct more rigorous outcome research, something that he along with others have been calling for all along (Spitzer, 2003a, 2003b; Jones, Rosik, Williams, & Byrd, 2010). Even the APA Task Force's Report on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation (American Psychological Association, 2009) issued a call for such studies to be undertaken. Unfortunately, the reality appears to be that the APA and other institutions in a position to fund and conduct outcome research on SOCE in conjunction with NARTH and other SOCE practitioners have no real interest in doing so. They have nothing to gain by such research, as outcomes unfavorable to SOCE would not meaningfully change their current skepticism, while outcomes favorable to SOCE would be a public relations and public policy disaster for them.

I doubt that Spitzer would "retract" his assessment of the likelihood that needed follow up studies would be conducted (Spitzer, 2003b):

Given the cost and complexity of such a study and the current view in the mental health professions of the benefits and risks of reorientation therapy, such a study is not going to happen in the near future. This is unfortunate because of the real questions raised, albeit admittedly not resolved, by this study (p. 472).

So instead of more and better research on SOCE, we find activists and their supporters in the media pouncing on a change of interpretation in an effort to preempt legitimate scientific debate. Nuance, context, and balanced analysis all be damned. What seems to be foremost is the use of Spitzer's reassessment to bludgeon SOCE supporters into submission and silence. Is it really far-fetched to suspect science is being held hostage to political agendas here?

I sincerely hope that this brief analysis helps clarify what did and did not happen when Spitzer "retracted" his earlier study. No new scientific finding was discovered that discredited SOCE. No egregious methodological flaw was identified. The same arguments forwarded in favor or against the study a decade ago still stand. Legitimate debate about the study's significance can and should still take place. Nothing has changed other than Spitzer has revised his earlier interpretation for what are likely to be a host of understandable but inherently non-scientific reasons. This is his right to do, but let no one tell you that in doing so he has discredited his research or alternative interpretations more favorable to those who report change in their same-sex attractions and behavior.

References

American Psychological Association (2009). Report of the APA task force on appropriate therapeutic responses to sexual orientation. Retrieved from http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbt/resources/therapeutic-response.pdf

Beckstead, A. L. (2001). Cures versus choice: Agendas in sexual reorientation therapy. Journal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy, 5(3/4), 87-115.

Bell, A. P., Weinberg, M. S., & Hammersmith, S. K. (1981). Sexual preference: Its development in
men and women. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

Dreger, A. (2012, April 11). How to ex an "ex-gay" study. [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://psychologytoday.com/blog/fetishes-i-dont-get/201204/how-ex-ex-gay-study

Jones, S. L., Rosik, C. H., Williams, R. N., & Byrd, A. D. (2010). A Scientific, Conceptual, and Ethical Critique of the Report of the APA Task Force on Sexual Orientation. The General Psychologist, 45(2), 7-18. Retrieved from http://www.apa.org/divisions/div1/news/fall2010/Fall%202010%20TGP.pdf

Shidlo, A., & Schroeder, M. (2002). Changing sexual orientation: A consumers' report. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 33, 249-259.

Spitzer, R. L. (2003a). Can some gay men and lesbians change their sexual orientation? 200 participants reporting a change from homosexual to heterosexual orientation. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 32(5), 403-417.

Spitzer, R. L. (2003b). Reply: Study results should not be dismissed and justify further research on the efficacy of sexual reorientation therapy. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 32(5), 469-472.

Spitzer, R. L. (2012). Spitzer reassesses his 2003 study of reparative therapy of homosexuality [Letter to the editor]. Archives of Sexual Behavior. Advance online publication. doi: 10.1007/s10508-012-9966-y

Wakefield, J. C. (2003). Sexual reorientation therapy: Is it ever ethical? Can it ever change sexual orientation? Archives of Sexual Behavior, 32(5), p. 457-459.

Vonholdt, C. R. (2001). Interview with Robert L. Spitzer: Homosexuality and the reality of change. Bulletin of the German Institute for Youth and Society, 1, 33-36. Retrieved from http://www.dijg.de/english/homosexuality-reality-of-change/

Yarhouse, M. A. (2003). How Spitzer's study gives a voice to the disenfranchised within a minority group. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 32(5), 462-463.