quinta-feira, 2 de junho de 2011

Esclarecimento sobre “Da licitude moral do voto”

Uma vez que me chegaram algumas mensagens de correio-e, em resposta ao texto que escrevi sobre a licitude moral do voto, “acusando-me” de no último parágrafo fazer um apelo ao voto útil no psd cumpre-me esclarecer o seguinte:

O texto em questão foi escrito a nível dos princípios com a intenção de esclarecer critérios de juízo moral.

O leitor reparará que ele procura responder a situações hipotéticas recorrendo a expressões condicionais tais como: “podem dar-se circunstâncias”, “em circunstâncias excepcionais poderá”, “se … e houver razões fundadas”, “será nessa circunstância”, “poderá impedir”, “poderiam limitar”, “deverá canalizar”. O escrito não se pronuncia nem ajuíza sobre a realidade que estamos a viver. Aliás, quem costuma ler o que eu escrevo sabe muito bem que não tenho tido pejo de chamar as coisas e as pessoas pelos nomes.

Importava, quanto a mim, esclarecer que o mal, menor ou não, nunca pode ser objecto de escolha moral e que o objecto da escolha moral de quem decide limitar o mal existente ou iminente é o bem, que consiste na limitação desse mal.

Acresce que o católico deve ter uma consciência apurada de que não basta fazer o bem mas que também é necessário combater o mal. Ou melhor, a prática do bem inclui sempre, também, o combate fogoso, veemente e sem tréguas contra o mal.


Nuno Serras Pereira

02. 06. 2011

Advance Directives i - William E. May, Ph.D


by William E. May, Ph.D., Senior Fellow
Link
In Culture of Life Foundation

Introduction

Today legislation requires patients to provide doctors, clinics, hospitals etc. with “advance directives.” An advance directive is a document by which a person makes provision for health care decisions in the event that, in the future, he or she is no longer competent to make such decisions for himself or herself.

Advance directives are of two main types: (1) the “living will” and (2) the “durable power of attorney for health care.” There is a third type called a MOST form (medical order for scope of treatment), which is fast becoming the form of choice in the US. It combines into one form living will provisions, DNR orders, designate of proxy care giver and has a doctor's signature making it a MEDICAL ORDER, hence the name.

Living will

What it is. This is a signed, witnessed or notarized document that a person executes to direct that specified life-sustaining treatments be withheld or withdrawn if he or she is in a terminal condition and unable to make health-care decisions for herself or himself. To be legally binding, a document of this kind must ordinarily be witnessed and sealed by notary public.

Serious problems. Since an attending physician who may be unfamiliar with the signer’s wishes and values has the authority to carry out the directives of the will, its terms may be interpreted in a way not envisioned by its signer. Moreover, the language used in such documents is often vague and general, and fails to distinguish clearly the difference between a choice to commit suicide by forgoing or withholding treatment precisely as a way of ending one’s life or the non-suicidal intention to forgo treatment because of the treatment’s uselessness or burdensomeness. Frequently, models of a living will are promoted by supporters of euthanasia, using language that is easy to interpret in a way favorable to euthanasia. Thus the organization known as Compassion & Choices, created by merger with the Hemlock Society, is committed to secure the legalization of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. This organization on its website offers models of pro-euthanasia and assisted suicide living wills (website https://www.compassionandchoices.org/).

Because of this and because a living will is prepared before a person will be in a situation calling for careful judgment about the appropriateness or non-appropriateness of specific treatments, John Finnis, a strong defender of the inviolability of innocent human life and the great good of human life itself, has written a devastating criticism of living will legislation in England. [2]

The Durable Power of Attorney

What it is. This is a signed, witnessed or notarized document in which the signer designates an agent to make health care decisions for himself or herself in the event that he or she becomes incompetent.

Care in choosing agent; advantages. The agent must be chosen with great care since he will have great power and authority to make decisions about whether health care is to be provided, withheld or withdrawn. The major advantage of appointing a health care decisions agent is that it leaves decision making in the hands of a person of one’s own choosing. The signer of such a document has the obligation to discuss his or her values, wishes and instructions with the agent before and at the time the document is signed, and should choose an agent willing to respect and carry out the signer’s wishes. Thus pro-life people will want their agent to value human life, including bodily life, as good and a precious gift from God, no matter how heavily burdened, and will repudiate euthanasia and/or assisted suicide, which is rooted in the belief that a person’s life is a burden and that death removes this burden.

In 2009 the Roman Catholic Bishops of Maryland and Wilmington, DE published a pastoral letter, Comfort & Consolation: Care of the Sick and the Dying in which they offer criteria for selecting a health care agent with the power of attorney (see pages 27-29). Their criteria were proposed specifically for Catholics. Here I adapt them for all who oppose withholding/withdrawing treatments in order to kill a person intentionally:

· Appoint a person who has the strength of character to make good judgments in painful circumstances and discuss specifics with that person (and also with your primary physician).

· No one should agree to act as an agent for another person if that person would expect or require the agent to do anything that he would directly and intentionally choose in order to cause death, nor should he choose to withhold or withdraw a treatment not because it is useless (futile) or excessively burdensome but rather as a means intentionally and directly to cause death for allegedly merciful reasons.

· Appoint someone who is likely to be available to care for you in the distant future. Since this is so, it may be advisable to name alternate agents, in the event that your first choice proves unable or unwilling to act for you when the need arises.

· In general one should avoid stating that he wants to reject certain treatments under all circumstances or stating without qualification that she want medical remedies restricted in the event that he/she become permanently unconscious or terminally ill. Such stipulation can amount to providing a premature self-diagnosis. The person should allow his health care agent and physician latitude to offer appropriate care based on the individual’s actual condition.

· Include a provision regarding treatment at the time of imminent death. A person on the verge of death can refuse a treatment which would result in only a burdensome prolongation of life. Your advance directive should authorize your agent to observe this norm.

· Periodically review the provisions of your directive and make copies of your directive and distribute them to your agent and each of your health care providers and anyone else you deem appropriate.

The Parents Rights Council (formerly known as the International Anti-Euthanasia Task Force) has developed a very worthwhile document called the “Protective Medical Decisions Document” (PMDD). This can be downloaded from the Parents Rights Council’s website http://www.patientsrightscouncil.org/site/. This is a durable power of attorney for health care document specifically prohibiting suicide, assisted suicide and euthanasia. Among its provisions are the following:

I wish to receive medical treatment appropriate to my condition which offers a reasonable hope of benefit. I direct that food and water be provided to me unless death is inevitable and truly imminent so that the effort to sustain my life is futile or unless I am unable to assimilate food or fluids. I ask that, even in the face of death, I be provided with ordinary nursing and medical care, including pain relief, appropriate to my condition. Nothing should be done which will directly and intentionally cause my death, nor should anything be omitted when such omissions would directly and intentionally cause my death. Euthanasia (an action or omission that of itself or by intent causes death), whether by commission or omission, is not permitted.

In conclusion, I advise persons not to sign living wills. Rather appoint a person whom you trust to be your agent by giving him or her durable power of attorney and consider making use of the Protective Medical Decisions Document available from the Parents Rights Council.

[1] This article is adapted from pp. 302-305 of my Catholic Bioethics and the Gift of Human Life (Second ed.: Our Sunday Visitor, 2008). I have, however, inserted some new material, e.g., that on Compassion & Choices.

[2] See Finnis, “Living Will Legislation,” in Euthanasia, Clinical Practice and the Law, ed. Luke Formally (London: The Linacre Centre for Health Care Ethics, 1994).

quarta-feira, 1 de junho de 2011

Sexual solicitation in confession may be more widespread than believed, canonist says

By Dr. Edward N. Peters

In Homiletic and Pastoral Review

All would agree that if a given piece of advice is bad in the confessional, then a priest’s giving it to a penitent would be, at a minimum, a failure in pastoral care. Depending on circumstances, a priest’s proffering of bad advice in confession might even, as a violation of charity or justice, be sinful. But, that the giving of bad advice in confession could be a crime under Church law would be startling. And yet, exactly this reading of Canon 1387 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law is required, I suggest, in light of sound canonical tradition and recent Roman curial norms.

Canon 1387 states: “A priest who in the act, on the occasion, or under the pretext of confession solicits a penitent to sin against the sixth commandment of the Decalogue is to be punished, according to the gravity of the delict, by suspension, prohibitions, and privations; in graver cases he is to be dismissed from the clerical state.” The image of solicitation that springs to mind here is, of course, that of a priest using the confessional to propose carnal liaisons to a female penitent.1 To be sure, such reprehensible behavior is criminalized by Canon 1387. But neither the text of Canon 1387 (specifically the phrase, “solicits a penitent to sin against the sixth commandment of the Decalogue”) nor the tradition behind the modern canon construes the crime of solicitation that narrowly.

First, the canonical crime of solicitation is not limited to cases wherein a confessor’s bad advice given is only toward a penitent’s sexual misconduct with the priest himself. John Martin, commenting on Canon 1387 in the British-Irish canonical commentary Letter & Spirit (1985) at 799, observes: “The offence is committed whether the priest encourages the penitent to sin either with the priest himself or with any third party.” Thomas Green, writing in the 2000 CLSA New Commentary (at 1591), agrees: “The delict might also be verified if the solicited sexual activity involves the penitent and a third party, not necessarily the priest and the penitent.” And Leon del Amo in the 2004 Code of Canon Law Annotated (at 1077), notes: “The offense consists in soliciting the penitent to sin against the sixth commandment, either with the person soliciting or with a third party.” No commentator on the 1983 Code disputes the understanding of solicitation in Canon 1387 as embracing not only a confessor’s advice toward sexual sin between the penitent and the confessor himself, but also between the penitent and a third party. But to see clearly how a confessor’s giving a penitent objectively immoral advice, even if such advice is directed toward the solitary acts of the penitent alone, can also constitute a form of solicitation, a review of canonical commentary on the crime of solicitation under the earlier, 1917 Code, is helpful.

Solicitation under the 1917 Code

Canon 1387 traces its roots to Canons 904 and 2368 § 1 of the 1917 Code, which two norms incorporated by express reference the celebrated penal constitution of Pope Benedict XIV Sacramentum poenitentiae (1741), one of just a handful of documents considered so important by the architect of the 1917 Code, Cardinal Pietro Gasparri, that he arranged for it to be repromulgated in toto as an appendix to the Pio-Benedictine Code. Benedict XIV’s constitution Sacramentum, while not the first universal legislation against solicitation in confession—that distinction belongs to Pope Gregory XV’s constitution Universi (1622)—yielded the most detailed, and indeed still current, description of solicitation in confession as being committed by a priest who “in regard to any sort of penitent [nb: male or female, young or old], either in the act of sacramental confession or [in times or places closely related to confession], solicits to turpitude or shameful deeds…by words or signs or nods or touch or by a writing to be read then or later” (my translation). It was the phrase “solicits to turpitude or shameful deeds” that Pio-Benedictine commentators saw as bringing immoral advice by a confessor to a penitent concerning any sexual matters, to be acted upon in any context, within the purview of solicitation as a canonical crime.

For example, Patrick Lydon, in his famous Ready Answers in Canon Law (1937) at 483, wrote: “Solicitation exists if the confessor sinfully suggests that the person commit impure acts alone or with others, for example, counsels the use of contraceptives.” Nicholas Halligan, in his well-regarded Administration of the Sacraments (1963) at 248, noted that “it makes no difference whether the confessor solicited a male or female penitent…to sin with him with another or solitarily.” Likewise Abbo-Hannan in the Sacred Canons (1960) II: 30 said: “Indeed, the delict is committed even by wrong advice as to the sinfulness of evil thoughts.” And Felix Cappello, perhaps the greatest commentator on sacramental law under the Pio-Benedictine Code, in his Tractatus Canonico-Moralis de Sacramentis (1944) II: 434, pointed to a response by the Sacred Penitentiary that called for the formal denunciation of a confessor who suggested various immoral practices (chiefly deliberate fantasies and self-abuse) to female penitents who were experiencing the extended absence of their husbands.

Because the broad interpretation accorded solicitation meant that what might have been, in some cases, simply malformed (as opposed to malevolent) advice to a penitent could be construed as a criminal act, commentators under the 1917 Code urged that caution be exercised in accepting allegations of solicitation, and that undue haste in investigating allegations of solicitation be avoided. Several authors noted that sufficient awareness by the confessor regarding the depravity of his advice must be proven before full sanctions could be levied. In making these cautionary remarks Pio-Benedictine commentators would surely be joined by commentators on the 1983 Code although, it seems, this aspect of the question has not yet attracted much attention from them. But, aside from a few prudential caveats, there seems to be no doubt that a confessor’s advice toward immoral activity in sexual matters, whether it concerns acts to be performed by the penitent alone, with a third party, or with the confessor himself, constitutes solicitation in confession and hence is a very serious crime under modern canon law.

Procedural directives

Prosecuting cases of alleged solicitation, however, is difficult for a number of reasons. First, because by definition the crime of solicitation occurs with regard to the sacrament of confession, an accused priest will be very limited in what responses he can make in his own defense. Moreover, the very words or actions by which solicitation might be suspected can be open, often enough, to various interpretations. In recognition of this problem Pio-Benedictine commentators analyzed many hypothetical confessor-penitent exchanges to help ecclesiastical authorities distinguish between what were criminal acts of solicitation and what were perhaps imprudent comments or even inappropriate flirtations. Finally, it is clear that mere rumors of solicitation by a confessor, even if untrue, can be very damaging to the reputation of the priest in question and to the integrity of ministry in the Church, and the discussion of possible cases of solicitation outside the strict confines of the canonical investigation process can lead to the suppression, distortion, or exaggeration of the evidence.

To assist local church leaders in handling cases of alleged solicitation in confession under the Pio-Benedictine Code, the Holy See issued two almost identical sets of instructions—the first in 1922, and a second, slightly expanded, in 1962—regarding the manner of proceeding canonically in solicitation cases.2 Both documents were titled Crimen sollicitationis, and both dealt overwhelmingly (as in 70 out of 74 numbered paragraphs in the 1962 version) with the crime of solicitation in confession. Because both documents also dealt very briefly with the canonical process for the investigation of clergy homosexual acts and child sexual abuse, however, it was in the latter, highly charged atmosphere that these documents, chiefly the 1962 version, were most often discussed—and quite often misconstrued.3

Today, in any event, the procedural norms of Crimen are no longer law. The 1962 instruction (which had replaced the 1922 version) was itself replaced in April-May of 2001 by two documents: first, John Paul II’s motu proprio Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutela, which served as a sort of ecclesiastical enabling legislation, and second, a set of implementing norms issued by Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in its “Epistula ad totius Catholicae Ecclesiae Episcopos.”4 It is within a single sentence—indeed, a single phrase within a sentence—of the CDF implementing norms that modern support for the interpretation of the crime of solicitation to include the rendering of objectively immoral advice on sexual matters to a penitent is, I think, to be found.

According to Art.4 §1,4° of the revised “Substantive Norms” for implementing Sacramentorum, among delicts against the sacrament of penance reserved to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith for judgment is “the solicitation to a sin against the sixth commandment of the Decalogue in the act, on the occasion, or under the pretext of confession, mentioned in Canon 1387 of the Code of Canon Law and in Canon 1458 of the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, if it is directed to sinning with the confessor himself” (emphasis added). It is the reservation of solicitation cases to the Holy See if they were “directed to sinning with the confessor himself” that warrants comment. First, some context.

The adjudication of most canonical crimes is not reserved to the Holy See. This is how it should be. The inherent dignity of particular churches, their responsibility for their own governance, the principle of subsidiarity, all of these factors and others besides suggest that wherever possible, offenses against church order be adjudicated at the local level. When certain crimes are reserved to the Holy See for judgment, it is generally because special difficulties inherent in certain kinds of cases inhibit their effective processing by a local church whose resources might be taxed by unusually complex prosecutions. Similarly, some offenses are so serious that their doctrinal or canonical reverberations could reach beyond the boundaries of the local church, and so an authority above the local level should be involved in trying them. The crime of solicitation in confession seems both serious enough in content and complex enough in the trying that its reservation to Rome, at least under certain circumstances, makes sense in both regards.

Now, as we have seen, commentary on the 1983 Code is unanimous that solicitation in confession occurs when a confessor gives advice to a penitent that countenances or encourages sexual sin by the penitent with the confessor himself or with a third party. Moreover, given the common interpretation of Pio-Benedictine commentators that solicitation occurs even when confessors advise a penitent toward solitary sexual sin (say, that of self-abuse or the use of pornography)—an interpretation not contradicted by any modern scholar and readily embraced within the text of Canon 1387—it seems clear that, even under the revised law, three distinct fact-patterns (namely, solitary sexual sin, sexual sin with a third party, or sexual sin with the confessor) can present themselves in solicitation cases; but only one of these, namely, solicitation directed toward sinning with the confessor himself, is reserved to the Apostolic See for judgment.

The particular depravity of a confessor advising a penitent (of either sex and of any age) toward sexual sin with the confessor himself warrants, I think, this procedural reservation. The confessor is selfishly seeking to satisfy his own lust and is trying to arrange for the violation of his own sacred person contrary to a host of values embraced by the Western Church obligations of celibacy as binding most clerics and of continence binding all clerics (Canon 277). Moreover, if the penitent being solicited is a minor, the confessor might be in violation of one or more civil laws, the additional consequences of which could reach beyond diocesan boundaries. Such considerations support the reservation of solicitation cases in furtherance of sexual conduct with the confessor himself.

But, precisely because the adjudication of solicitation cases is reserved to the Holy See only when a confessor gave immoral advice to a penitent in furtherance of sexual sin with the confessor himself, a confessor’s giving objectively immoral sexual advice to a penitent, to be acted on either by the penitent alone or by the penitent with a third party, remains a crime under the 1983 Code, but one to be tried at the local level.

Local responsibility to hear solicitation cases

The reservation to Rome of only those solicitation cases involving sin with the confessor himself should not in any way diminish appreciation for the depravity of solicitation cases involving confessional advice toward a penitent sinning sexually with a third party or alone. Indeed, it seems much more likely that confessors will offer penitents objectively immoral advice toward activities they foresee happening between penitents and a third party (such as homosexual acts, heterosexual fornication or adultery, contraception, and so on), or acts to be performed by the penitent alone (such as self-abuse, pornography, voyeurism, and so on), than it is that they will try to induce penitents to sins with the confessors personally, which means that these two forms of solicitation in confession are much more likely to occur.

We end these remarks where we began, that is, by recognizing the fact that the very possibility that certain forms of bad advice in confession could constitute a canonical crime is going to be startling. It is quite likely that most younger priests have never been told of this interpretation of the law, however fixed in the canonical firmament it might have been, and that even older priests might have thought that this broad interpretation of solicitation had fallen into desuetude—a position never probable in itself, and, since the appearance of Sacramentorum sanctitatis, etc., a position quite untenable. Yet, however we arrived at the present situation, the harm being done to souls by bad confessional advice in regard to sexual matters is real and requires an effective ecclesiastical response. I have outlined above the penal response to solicitation cases but, before closing, I would like to offer one additional suggestion.

The venerable institution of “canon penitentiary” (Canon 508 §1 and Canon 968) is almost completely absent from the American Catholic landscape. While here is not the place to present the mechanics of reviving this office (an office apparently required, however, at the arch/diocesan level by Canon 508 §2), it does seem useful to suggest that a properly trained canon penitentiary might be in good position to educate arch/diocesan presbyterates as to the basic law regarding solicitation in confession, and to assist confessors with difficult moral cases.5 The point would not be for canon penitentiaries to resolve solicitation allegations (indeed, their special faculties for the remission of certain kinds of censures are, strictly speaking, irrelevant in the adjudication of solicitation cases), but rather, to establish an officer with expertise in helping priests to avoid running afoul of penal law in the first place.

Confessors who, in response to requests by penitents to be led closer to God, offer instead advice toward conduct that leads the faithful further away from him, do damage to those souls and to the wider faith community. Those charged with the care of the community of believers should not delay in advising their priests of the law on solicitation in confession, nor should they hesitate to investigate and, where warranted, to punish such serious crimes promptly.


Dr. Edward Peters holds the Edmund Cardinal Szoka Chair at Sacred Heart Major Seminary in Detroit. His articles and reviews have appeared in numerous journals of canon law around the world, and he serves as a canonical consultant to a number of ecclesiastical persons and institutions. In 2010 Pope Benedict XVI appointed Dr. Peters to a five-year term as Referendary of the Apostolic Signatura.


End notes

1. Anecdotal evidence indicates that some penitents have received bad advice regarding other important areas of moral life (for example in regard to decision-making on bio-medical questions), but Canon 1987 criminalizes only the giving of objectively immoral advice in regard to the sixth commandment of the Decalogue, that is, sexual conduct. See Green, CLSA Commentary (1985) at 927. How the Church should deal with the problem of confessors giving immoral advice regarding, say, euthanasia or infanticide, is not addressed here.
2. An unofficial English translation of the 1962 instruction is available online at http://www.vatican.va/resources/resources_crimen-sollicitationis-1962_en.html.
3. For a refutation of one of the more egregious media misrepresentations of Crimen, see my “Smearing the Pope: The BBC and Benedict XVI,” Catholic World Report (December 2006) at 40-43, available online at: http://www.renewamerica.com/images/columns/080520abbott.pdf. For a good overview of what the 1962 version of Crimen did—and did not—say, see John Beal, “The 1962 instruction Crimen sollicitationis: caught red-handed or handed a red herring?” Studia canonica, 41 (2007), 199–236, available online at http://www.vatican.va/resources/Beal-article-studia-canonica41-2007-pp.199-236.pdf.
4. See John Paul II, Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutela (April 30, 2001), Acta Apostolicae Sedis 93 (2001), 737-739, and Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, “Epistula ad totius Catholicae Ecclesiae Episcopos aliosque … de delictis gravioribus eidem Congregationi pro Doctrina Fidei reservatis” (May 18, 2001), Acta Apostolicae Sedis 93 (2001), 785-788. The CDF implementing norms were themselves modified most recently in 2010 and (even though these modifications do not affect the topic of solicitation in confession) resort should always be had to the current norms when processing contemporary solicitation cases. The revised norms are available online at: http://www.vatican.va/resources/resources_norme_en.html.
5. I am indebted to a conversation with Timothy Ferguson, JCL, of the Tribunal of the Archdiocese of Detroit for suggesting the possibility of canon penitentiaries serving as resource persons for confessors facing difficult sexual morality questions.

terça-feira, 31 de maio de 2011

Da licitude moral do voto

As eleições políticas implicam necessariamente uma escolha moral por parte de quem vota ou de quem se abstém. É sobre alguns aspectos desta escolha que agora me detenho sem considerar a moralidade do político que se apresenta como candidato nem a do líder que decide quem são as pessoas que se apresentam, em nome do seu partido político, à votação dos eleitores.

Já se sabe que em nenhuma circunstância é lícito escolher o mal. Consequentemente nunca é legítimo votar num candidato porque ele advoga o aborto, ou a eutanásia, ou a supressão da liberdade de ensinar e de aprender, enfim porque se propõe repudiar qualquer princípio ou valor inegociável.

Não obstante podem dar-se circunstâncias tais em que a um católico seja lícito votar nas listas desse ou desses partidos não porque mas apesar de apresentarem gente dessa espécie. Aliás, em circunstâncias excepcionais poderá ser inclusive moralmente obrigatório fazê-lo.

Se, por exemplo, o poder estiver nas mãos de políticos perversos cuja governação e legislação se caracterizaram por roubos, matanças e destruições (cf. Jo. 10, 10), quer físicas quer morais, e houver razões fundadas para concluir que o único modo de limitar esses males horrendos será através da votação em um ou mais partidos que, sendo embora deficientes e com alguma perversão, o possam substituir no poder parece claro que o católico ao votar nele/s está, não a procurar o mal mas a escolher o bem possível.

Se o eleitor tem razões fundadas para julgar que o voto num partido limpo será, nessa circunstância, inútil no sentido em que poderá impedir a vitória daquele/s que poderiam limitar o mal, parece evidente que deverá canalizar o seu voto para o bem possível nessa circunstância.


Nuno Serras Pereira

31. 05. 2011

Ativistas e colaboradores gays são o principal sustentáculo da campanha para reeleger Obama

WASHINGTON, D.C., EUA, 9 de maio de 2011 (Notícias Pró-Família) — Colaboradores financeiros de dentro do movimento homossexual estão fornecendo apoio político e financeiro decisivo para as iniciativas para reeleger o presidente Barack Obama em 2012, de acordo com o site Politico.
Em sua reportagem, Politico diz que os grupos homossexuais estão compensando a perda de entusiasmo (e colaboradores financeiros) que Obama enfrenta na esquerda política, e a Casa Branca está aproveitando totalmente essa situação.
Embora tivessem passado a maior parte do governo dele profundamente descontentes com o presidente, os ativistas homossexuais mudaram o tom desde que Obama revogou uma lei de 1993 que proibia homossexuais assumidos de servirem nas forças armadas e impediu seu governo de defender a Lei de Defesa do Casamento (LDC), aprovada em 1996.
Obama sancionou a revogação da proibição (muitas vezes associada a uma política de fiscalização do Pentágono chamada “Não pergunte, não revele”) em dezembro de 2010, permitindo que os homossexuais assumidos sirvam abertamente nas forças armadas logo que os chefes militares tivessem confirmado que as forças armadas estavam prontas.
A decisão de Obama de orientar o ministro da Justiça Eric Holder a não defender a LDC ao ser atacada nos tribunais federais forçou o Congresso a buscar sua própria assessoria jurídica para defender a constitucionalidade da lei.
David Mixner, antigo ativista homossexual de Nova Iorque, disse para o site Politico que as recentes ações de Obama foram decisivas para obter o apoio do movimento homossexual: “Talvez eles não venham a contribuir financeiramente de modo unido para Obama, mas aos poucos eles vão agir”.
A importância de colaboradores financeiros homossexuais também se vê no novo comitê financeiro de Obama. Politico aponta para o fato de que Obama só tinha um homossexual no comitê em 2008, mas para a corrida presidencial de 2012 ele tem 15.
Ao que tudo indica, as opiniões conservadoras sociais dos candidatos do Partido Republicano estão também inspirando indivíduos nos grupos homossexuais de pressão política a trabalharem mais para reeleger Obama.
“O movimento homossexual saboreou uma mudança, e é difícil imaginar um retrocesso”, disse Fred Sainz, porta-voz do [grupo homossexual] Campanha dos Direitos Humanos.
Leia a reportagem completa em inglês aqui.
Artigos relacionados:
Traduzido por Julio Severo: www.juliosevero.com