quarta-feira, 11 de setembro de 2013

Lo que el jesuita Bergoglio hizo realmente durante la dictadura Argentina de Videla

In RL 

"La lista de Bergoglio. Los salvados por el Papa Francisco. Las historias nunca contadas" con prólogo de Adolfo Pérez Esquivel, premio Nobel de la Paz, y editado por la editorial Emi (www.emi.it), es el título de una investigación de Nello Scavo, periodista del diario italiano “Avvenire”, sobre las vicisitudes de varias personas – disidentes, sindicalistas, sacerdotes, estudiantes, intelectuales, creyentes y no creyentes– a quienes el entonces padre Jorge Mario Bergoglio consiguió poner a salvo de la persecución de la junta militar.

El provincial de los jesuitas había construido una red clandestina para salvaguardar a los perseguidos (a los que ofrecía un prontuario de consejos sobre cómo despistar a la policía y la censura) y organizar las fugas al exterior.

El poder de las Fuerzas Armadas en Argentina culminó con el golpe del 24 de marzo de 1976. Los militares hicieron desaparecer al menos a treinta mil personas, quince mil fueron fusilados por la calle, se apropiaron de más de quinientos bebés de mujeres condenadas a muerte. Más de dos millones fueron exiliados.

Aparte de los relatos en primera persona de los perseguidos protegidos por el futuro Papa, el libro (que se publicará en Italia el 1 de octubre) contiene relatos y documentos inéditos, entre ellos, la transcripción del interrogatorio del entonces cardenal Bergoglio, realizado en 2010 en calidad de persona informada de los hechos, ante los magistrados que indagaban sobre la violación de los derechos humanos durante la dictadura. Con fuerza emerge la integridad moral, la coherencia, el valor, a menudo a riesgo de la propia vida, del jesuita que un día sería el papa Francisco.

Jesuita, poco más de ochenta años, Juan Manuel Scannone es el máximo representante de la que desde los años 80 en adelante sería definida como “teología del pueblo”. Hoy Scannone es director del Instituto de estudios filosóficos en la Universidad de Teología y Filosofía San Miguel, la misma de la que fue rector Bergoglio entre 1980 y 1986. “Ahora que mi amigo Jorge es Papa Francisco, puedo contar que sí, él me cubrió las espaldas, me salvó. Y lo hizo en varias circunstancias”.

La dictadura percibía la teología del pueblo como una amenaza, a pesar de su diversidad sustancial de los llamados teólogos marxistas. Sin distinciones, se persiguió y torturó a religiosos, fieles laicos, catequistas, monjas comprometidas en las “villas miseria”.

“Los militares eran incapaces de ser sutiles – explica Scannone –. Para ellos, hablar de ‘liberación’ o de ‘opción preferencial por los pobres’ se traducía en una sola palabra: comunismo”. El régimen vigilaba a él y a sus colegas y hermanos.

“La policía se movía alrededor nuestro, no precisamente porque le importara la seguridad del colegio. Una vez llegaron de noche. Superaron la verja y rodearon el edificio con las camionetas. Fue una verdadera irrupción. Recuerdo aún el estruendo de sus pasos en los pasillos. Estaba oscuro y no conseguí ver cuántos eran. Tenía el corazón en la garganta. Me sentí en el punto de mira. Han venido a cogerme, pensé”.

-¿Por qué precisamente a usted?
- Se me consideraba un representante de la teología de la liberación, corriente que el régimen percibía como humo en los ojos. Bergoglio me dio a entender de varias formas que corría peligros. En aquella época, aún encontrándonos en posiciones teológicas diferentes, aunque no creo que tan distantes, él nunca quiso que fuese silenciado. Ni siquiera cuando algunos obispos intervinieron señalándome como que mis posturas eran consideradas incómodas, por no decir impropias.

- ¿Cómo reaccionó Bergoglio al registro?
- Nos alentó, tranquilizó a todos e intimó a los militares a volver por donde habían venido, Había entre nosotros algunos jóvenes que se habían presentado donde el provincial como estudiantes en “retiro espiritual”. En realidad han hecho falta años para que hayamos podido conocer toda la verdad sobre las acciones de salvamento del padre Jorge.

- ¿Cómo le salvaguardó el futuro papa de la junta militar?
- No eran años fáciles. El padre Jorge se cuidó de nosotros como era, por otro lado, su deber. Hoy las cosas pueden ser observadas y juzgadas con otros ojos, pero entonces Bergoglio hizo lo que en su posición debía hacer. Se relacionaba frecuentemente con el padre general, que estaba al corriente de lo que sucedía, y nos ofrecía consejos sobre cómo evitar el apremiante control del régimen, sin pero jamás deber renunciar a nuestras ideas.

- ¿Hasta el punto de proporcionar una serie de sugerencias para no acabar “absorbido” en un campo de concentración?
- El primero de los consejos fue el de no enviar nunca mis artículos y ensayos a través de la oficina postal de San Miguel y aún menos desde Buenos Aires. Él sospechaba que toda la correspondencia estaba controlada, así como las conversaciones telefónicas. Además, cuando me dirigía a los barrios donde llevaba a cabo mi actividad pastoral, el superior provincial me aconsejó que no fuera nunca solo, y no sólo por razones de seguridad. Así, si la policía, el ejército, la marina o la aeronáutica vinieran a prenderme, habría habido testigos. Esta era una de las formas que Bergoglio nos sugería para evitar desaparecer de la circulación, engullidos en el más completo silencio.

- ¿El padre provincial no dijo nunca a los profesores y a los estudiantes del colegio cuál era la verdadera condición de los jóvenes perseguidos acogidos en San Miguel?
- Bergoglio decía que los chicos que venían aquí estaban en fase de discernimiento vocacional, o que necesitaban ayuda en los estudios. Por ello creíamos que se trataba de ayuda espiritual. Nunca sospechamos que estuviera llevando operaciones “clandestinas”. El padre Jorge no sólo mantuvo el secreto entonces, sino que nunca quiso vanagloriarse de esa particularísima misión suya. Él trabajó no sólo para proteger, tutelar y salvar a padres jesuitas y seminaristas, sino también para esconder a jóvenes estudiantes que estaban en el punto de mira de la dictadura, que eran llevados a nuestro colegio, con todas las cautelas necesarias, con el fin de ponerles a salvo de los raptos de la policía.

- Eran años de miedo...
- El padre Bergoglio no podía correr riesgos. Si uno de los jesuitas del colegio hubiese sido secuestrado, ¿quién aseguraba que el desafortunado no fuese sometido a torturas para revelar esta actividad secretísima? Si los sicarios de Videla hubieran descubierto que los jesuitas de Buenos Aires, bajo la dirección de su superior, operaban clandestinamente en actividades contrarias al “Proceso de reorganización nacional”, ciertamente habría habido consecuencias que sólo hoy podemos imaginar.

- Finalmente, el caso de Yorio y Jalics, los dos jesuitas raptados, torturados y liberados después de casi seis meses...
- El padre Jalics ha desmentido implicación alguna de Bergoglio. Personalmente yo estaba seguro desde hacía años. Pues Bergoglio vivía en nuestra casa de San Miguel precisamente cuando hicieron desaparecer a los dos padres, él me contaba lo que hacía y las informaciones que recogía para descubrir quién podía haberles secuestrado y dónde estaban prisioneros. Puedo dar testimonio de la preocupación y del compromiso del padre provincial para devolver la libertad a ambos.

- ¿Bergoglio consiguió informaciones precisas?
- Sí, y había puesto contra las cuerdas a los generales. Al final los dos padres fueron liberados, pero de forma que no pudieran dar indicaciones precisas sobre quién les había retenido y torturado. Durante todo el periodo de detención, ambos permanecieron siempre encapuchados, y antes de ser liberados fueron narcotizados. Hay que reconocer también que con la ayuda del padre provincial, ambos consiguieron encontrar refugio en el extranjero, para no volver a una nueva y más dramática “desaparición”.

segunda-feira, 9 de setembro de 2013

El deterioro de los hombres que «abortan»: un padre llora a la hija a quien nunca encontró

In RL 

Muchos hombres son responsables directos del aborto -ante el silencio feminista-, por no querer hacerse cargo de sus responsabilidades e inducir a la madre a matar al hijo común. Otros -como el caso que recogía ReL recientemente- se ven impotentes cuando querrían tenerlos, pero la ley no les concede ningún derecho si la decisión de la mujer se inclina por la supresión del embarazo.

Una historia de sufrimiento

El caso que recoge la bloguera católica Rebecca Frech parece responder a una tercera tipología: cuando el aborto se produce por consentimiento común de la pareja. Y también en este caso los efectos sobre la conciencia son devastadores.

Rebecca estaba hablando con un "viejo y querido amigo" sobre la pérdida de su hija Bernadette, cuando ese amigo se vino abajo: "Empezó a llorar y a hablarme sobre su propia pequeña. La niña que nunca conoció y a quien ama sin reservas".

Frech pidió al hombre que escribiese su testimonio de vida en silencio como "padre postaborto", y reproduce en uno de sus últimos posts la historia de esa tragedia.

Un día de agosto de 1988
"Amo a la niña que nunca encontré. Jamás la llevé de la mano, ni le revolví el pelo, ni le canté canción alguna. Pero la amo igualmente": así comienza la historia, anónima, del amigo de Rebecca. Quien lamenta: "No sé si es alta o baja, y los rasgos de su rostro existen sólo en mi imaginación. Estoy seguro de que el tono de su voz y la alegría de su risa rivalizan con el coro de los ángeles. Sus ojos, brillantes, serán marrones, tal vez color avellana. Pero todo eso me lo he perdido. Todo lo que tengo son memorias irreales de cuanto pudo haber sido".

Explica que hace veinticinco años, en el mes de agosto, esa niña a la que hoy ama "fue abortada": "Mi pequeña. Mi única hija. Una niña que agarra mi dedo hasta hoy, pero que nunca me llamará papá. Una niña que nunca sintió el abrazo protector de su padre, porque su padre le falló en el momento en el que más le necesitaba".

Arrepentido y reconciliado con Dios
El hombre que escribe esta historia habla brevemente de sí mismo, aunque afirma ya no ser el que era entonces, ese niño que asistió a un colegio católico, ese adolescente convertido "en un idiota que acudía a las fiestas a emborracharse".

Ya ha dejado atrás los "Si al menos hubiera..." o los "Debería haber hecho...": "Admito que lo que hice, lo que permití que pasara, fue un error. Me he arrepentido y cumplido mi penitencia. Estoy reconciliado con la Iglesia".

Pero "la reconciliación, aunque borra el pecado, no quita la pena": "En mi corazón hay un agujero con forma de niña, y ese agujero nunca será colmado en esta vida".

Diferente actitud de la madre
Dos años después del aborto, el hombre contrajo matrimonio con la chica: "Me casé con la madre de mi hija. Tal vez penséis que me habría ahorrado mucho sufrimiento casándome con otra persona, y no os lo discuto, pero en aquellos días yo estaba convencido de que el aborto no era cosa mía, que yo no era el responsable. No tenía nada que ver conmigo. Fue al pasar el tiempo cuando me enfrenté al  hecho de que yo sí era responsable, de que yo era padre, y necesitaba redención".

El aborto que cometieron sigue siendo, sin embargo, "un tema tabú" entre ellos, "una pared invisible e infranqueable, que sólo se rompió dos veces en los últimos veinticinco años".

"No voy a profundizar en lo que pasó", continúa, "salvo para decir que la única persona que podria ayudarme a soportar el dolor y la pena es la misma persona que rechaza admitir que tengo razones para el dolor y la pena. Ella no quiere o no puede admitir que mató a su hija. Pero es algo de lo que yo tengo que hablar. Seguir adelante sin hablarlo con nadie es más de lo que puedo soportar".

Síndrome postaborto, también en los padres
El amigo de Rebecca afirma que "hay muchos padres que lamentan el aborto y son incapaces de hablar de ello: la culpa, la vergüenza, la inadaptación, el haber fallado en proteger a los débiles, la soledad, el desapego, la incapacidad de establecer relaciones estables, la tensión de la que no se habla, las heridas emocionales... son pesos invisibles que acongojan sus almas. Aman a niños que existen sólo en su corazón, un amor desolado y no correspondido. Lo sé porque lo he vivido".

Y explica cómo y cuándo: "He derramado muchas lágrimas en la soledad de una habitación vacía, en Navidad, cuando todo el mundo se había ido a la cama. Algunas canciones me evocan fuertes emociones, como cuando Fantine canta en Los Miserables "I dreamed a dream" y dice: "Soñé que mi vida podía ser tan diferente del infierno que estoy viviendo".

Algunas escenas de película son devastadoras, como cuando en Salvad al soldado Ryan el capitán John Miller, al morir sobre el puente de la ciudad francesa, le dice al soldado Ryan: "Earn this! ¡Haz que esto valga la pena!".

Y él hizo que valiera la pena, pero yo me quedo preguntándome si valió la pena la decisión que tomé en mi vida. He visto a mis hermanos con sus hijas el día de sus bodas, y pienso que yo nunca seré padre.

Me he postrado en adoración en el suelo de las iglesias ante Dios bendito, rogándole Su paz, pidiéndoLe ayuda para librarme del dolor. Y Él siempre me da paz, pero el agujero en mi vida con forma de niña continúa".

Rezar por intercesión de la pequeña

"Pero no quiero que desaparezca", advierte: "Sé que suena raro, pero es la verdad. En otro tiempo intenté llenar esa ausencia con otras cosas, y sin embargo ahí permanecía. Durante años intenté dar a otros propósitos (algunos buenos, otros no tanto) el amor que era para mi hija, pero ahora comprendo que eso no podía funcionar. Me di cuenta de que el amor nunca quedará satisfecho. Ahora rezo con ella, y pido cosas por su intercesión. Eso es lo que me ha quedado".

Concluye explicando que no busca alivio en la autocompasión: "Lamento con cada fibra de mi ser lo que sucedió aquel día de agosto de 1988, pero no fantaseo sobre lo que pudo haber sido. Hice la elección [choice] del aborto, y sufro las consecuencias de esa elección [choice]. Como también mi esposa, aunque su rechazo a admitir que se equivocó gravemente impide una sanación completa entre los dos. La quiero,  y la he perdonado. No guardo ningún resentimiento hacia ella, y ruego a Dios que ablande su corazón para que pueda empezar a redimirse. Puesto que es la madre de todos mis hijos, he decidido mantener el compromiso hasta el final, sea cual sea el final".

"Por último", concluye, "creo que mi hija nos ha perdonado, y eso me ha ayudado mucho. E incluso espero, por la inexplicable misericordia y bondad de Dios, que Él mismo es también Padre, que finalmente nos encontraremos. Un encuentro entre extraños que siempre se han amado mutuamente, y en el que por fin podré escucharla decir ¡Papá!".


sexta-feira, 6 de setembro de 2013

Why We Should Respect Someone Else’s Conscience - by Anthony Esolen

In Crisis 

The scene is from C. S. Lewis’s That Hideous Strength.  The callow young sociology professor, Mark Studdock, an atheist and a social climber, has been detained in a cubicle deliberately fashioned with odd annoying angles and not-quite-right pictures on the wall.  His detainers aim to break down in him any last sense of the inner harmony between beauty and the moral good, or even between ordinary presentability and decency.  The fight is for the man’s soul.

His instructor presents him with a crucifix and asks him to tread upon it.  It’s a meaningless act, he says.  It isn’t a man, only a cheap piece of carved wood.  There is no moral import to it.  But something in the young man recoils.  He does not believe there was anything special about Jesus.  As far as he knows, Jesus was only a man condemned to a shameful death by his enemies, on a trumped-up political charge.  And all of Jesus’ friends abandoned him on Calvary, and all of the intellectual people that matter to him in England have long abandoned him too.  But for that very reason, to tread upon the crucifix seems base.  Why add that last small act of shaming to all the rest?  The still small voice speaks to him, saying, “This would be foul, petty, ignoble.  You must not do this.”  If he complies, as far as he knows, his career is made.  If he refuses, his career is shot.  He’s a married man, and he’s ambitious, and he needs the money.  It’s only a piece of wood.  The meaning of his life hangs in the balance.  Nor can we ever be sure that a man who betrays so clear a prohibition issued by his conscience will be given that choice again, to undo the evil.

He refuses.

These days in our political and even ecclesiastical battles we hear a great deal about the primacy of the conscience, but almost nothing about what the conscience is and why we should care, not about our own conscience, but about someone else’s.  Robert George, in his new book Conscience and Its Enemies: Confronting the Dogmas of Liberal Secularism (ISI Books), aims to supply the lack.  He reminds us that conscience is, to use Newman’s words, a “stern monitor,” not, as David Hume asserts, much to the comfort of adolescents everywhere, the ratiocinative faculty by which we construct “justifications” for what we wanted to do (or to get out of doing) in the first place.  Rather, the conscience warns us of what we must do and of what we must not do.  “The duty to follow conscience,” George writes, “is a duty to do things or refrain from doing things not because one wants to follow one’s duty but even if one strongly does not want to follow it.  The right of conscience is a right to do what one judges oneself to be under obligation to do, whether one welcomes the obligation or must overcome strong aversion to fulfill it.”

In other words, as George notes, conscience is not a “permissions department.”   It commands and proscribes; and that’s why we spend so much effort trying to circumvent it, muddle it, or stifle it altogether.  Mark Twain gives us a humorous instance of it when Huck Finn must decide whether to rat on the runaway slave Jim or to protect him.  Huck “knows,” in an exterior way, from common chatter, that the “right” thing to do would be to betray his friend and profit by it, but something deep inside him tells him no, and so he too refuses, even though he figures that he’ll probably end up in hell for it.
 
When someone says, “I may do this, because my conscience doesn’t forbid me,” he is treating an absence as a presence.  He feels no command or proscription, and transmutes that insensibility into a proof that what he wants is permissible.  But that doesn’t follow.  It may be morally permissible; it may be downright virtuous; but it may be wicked.  Many an SS officer’s conscience was comfortably silent on the issue of slaughtering Jews.  People steeped in evil may even hug themselves for the benefits their evil confers upon mankind.  So it is that snuffing out the lives of unborn children, in the minds of some, is more than permissible: it is a great and glorious good, to be celebrated with cake and icing.  Conscience can be unformed or deformed; conscience does not determine what is good or evil, but must hearken to the truth of the matter, even if the person cannot articulate just why he must do what he would prefer to leave undone, or why he must not do what he would dearly like to do.

We are not obliged to respect a man’s permission slips.  We are not obliged to throw the hedonist his party.  We are not obliged to buy the adolescent’s toys, or even to stock our shelves with them.  Indeed, when someone asserts that he ought to be allowed to do something because he wants to do it, and because he doesn’t hear the voice of conscience warning against it—he wants to use cocaine, he and his enemy want to engage in a duel, he likes pornography—we needn’t give much standing to his feelings.  His permission slip puts the matter on the table, that’s all.  We need to ask about the nature of what he wants, whether it is indeed morally neutral, or virtuous, or vicious, whether allowing it conduces to the common good.  But it is a different matter entirely when that man’s monitor does speak, “Thou shalt!” and “Thou shalt not!”

Why is that?  Is it because then his preferences or repugnancies are especially strong?  Your dog may have a strong desire to snitch food from a guest’s plate, but we aren’t overriding his conscience when we keep him from doing it.  He may have a strong aversion against going outside in the pouring rain to do his business, but we aren’t shackling his moral sensibility when we make him go out anyway.  That’s because the dog is not a moral agent.  He does not apprehend the good and internalize it, making it his own, allowing it to inform his choices, to build his personality.  We might say that he knows “rules” but not law.

But man is a moral agent.  That isn’t just something accidental to man, as for instance that he has five fingers on a hand and not six.  It is essential to his being.  It isn’t just Christians who believe that.  All the great pagans did also.  It’s why the poet Hesiod says that the Muses, daughters of Zeus, grant to the man they favor the wisdom to craft straight judgments—we might say beautiful judgments, right verdicts—and the eloquence to persuade others of their rightness.

To forbid someone to do what his conscience commands him to do, or, worse still, to compel him to do what his conscience instructs him he must not do, is thus to work violence upon him at the core of his being.  It is not the same as when we restrain people from the evils that their consciences, dormant, silent, do not tell them they must not do, or when, more rarely and with a heavier burden of justification upon us, we compel them to do something which their consciences do not tell them they must do.  For then we are not violating an express decree of the conscience; we are supplying the lack of one.  We may even, but most rarely and with an extraordinarily heavy burden of justification, overrule another man’s conscience, not by compelling him, but by taking the reins ourselves and doing what he will not do; that’s the case when we give blood transfusions to infants in imminent danger of death, over the wishes of parents who object.

But no man has the right to require another to be less than a man, to demote him to the status of a non-moral agent, like a beast, or a cog in a machine.  No man may steal my humanity, by demanding treason against that stern monitor, my conscience.  But this is exactly what is happening before our eyes, in what used to be a free country.  We are demanding obeisance to and participation in things that until eleven o’clock last night almost everyone (and all Christians and observant Jews) believed to be evil, and believed it with strong reasons prescinding from the nature of man and from revelation.

The “enemies of conscience,” as Professor George calls them, simultaneously and incoherently deny the existence of moral truths that bind the conscience—other people’s consciences, while they reserve for themselves a moral right to bind and loose those other people, mechanically, pragmatically, to bring about some vague ideal society.  In such a world, everyone is a god or an ant, but not a man.  More to follow.



Hotels and the Pornography Plague: An Example of Moral Responsibility from Scandinavia - by Robert P. George and Hamza Yusuf

In TPD

A bit more than a year ago, we made public here on Public Discourse a letter we had sent to the chief executive officers of our nation’s largest hotel chains, respectfully asking them to stop offering pornography in their hotel rooms. We said:

We are, respectively, a Christian and a Muslim, but we appeal to you not on the basis of truths revealed in our scriptures but on the basis of a commitment that should be shared by all people of reason and goodwill: a commitment to human dignity and the common good. As teachers and as parents, we seek a society in which young people are encouraged to respect others and themselves—treating no one as an impersonal object or thing. We hope that you share our desire to build such a society.

Pornography is degrading, dehumanizing, and corrupting. It undermines self-respect and respect for others. It reduces persons—creatures bearing profound, inherent, and equal dignity—to the status of objects. It robs a central aspect of our humanity—our sexuality—of its dignity and beauty. It ensnares some in addiction. It deprives others of their sense of self-worth. It teaches our young people to settle for the cheap satisfactions of lust, rather than to do the hard, yet ultimately liberating and fulfilling, work of love.

One hotel chain, Marriott, informed us that they were “phasing out” offerings of pornography in their hotel rooms. Another, Hilton, defended its participation in the pornography business by appealing, dubiously in our view, to libertarian principles. Others, so far as we can tell, have ignored our plea.

We wish to reiterate that plea here, however, by holding up to the American hotel executives the highly laudable actions of Petter Stordalen, owner of Nordic Hotels, one of Scandinavia’s largest chains. Mr. Stordalen, after becoming involved in international efforts to fight the horrific practice of trafficking women and girls into sexual slavery, announced that pornography would no longer be offered to his customers. In a public statement explaining his decision, he said:

The porn industry contributes to trafficking, so I see it as a natural part of having a social responsibility to send out a clear signal that Nordic Hotels doesn't support or condone this.

He’s right. The pornography industry is corrupt through and through—inherently so. It should come as no surprise that it is connected to something as exploitative, degrading, and dehumanizing as human trafficking. Bravo to Petter Stordalen for refusing to continue profiting from peddling the industry’s wares.

Of course, even if trafficking were not part of the reality of the industry, good people should be opposed to pornography and unwilling to profit from it. As we said in our letter to hotel executives:

We beg you to consider the young woman who is depicted as a sexual object in these movies, as nothing but a bundle of raw animal appetites whose sex organs are displayed to the voyeurs of the world and whose body is used in loveless and utterly depersonalized sex acts. Surely we should regard that young woman as we would regard a sister, daughter, or mother. She is a precious member of the human family. You may say that she freely chooses to compromise her dignity in this way, and in some cases that would be true, but that gives you no right to avail yourself of her self-degradation for the sake of financial gain. Would you be willing to profit from her self-degradation if she were your sister? Would you be willing to profit from her self-degradation if she were your own beloved daughter?

The reality is, however, just as Mr. Stordalen depicts it. Human trafficking is part of the reality. And it is time for his fellow hotel executives to face up to that fact.

Indeed, it is time for Mr. Stordalen’s American counterparts to follow his commendable example. If Nordic Hotels can demonstrate this kind of moral and social responsibility, then there is no reason that Hilton Hotels and the other large chains cannot. Let them stop trying to deceive the public—and perhaps even themselves—with rhetoric about respecting or even protecting their customers’ liberty. Pornography is a social plague with horrific real-life consequences for real live people—addicts, spouses, children, communities, girls and women trafficked into sexual servitude.

At this late season of our nation’s experience with the social costs of pornography there is no longer any excuse for supposing that porn is merely a form of harmless naughtiness. Even the socially very liberal nation of Iceland is moving to ban or severely restrict it by law. Whatever one thinks of legal prohibitions or restrictions, everyone should recognize that pornography is a moral and social evil that no decent person would want to profit from or have anything to do with.

Papa convence mulher a não abortar e oferece-se para ser padrinho

In RR 

Anna Romano escreveu ao Papa quando soube que estava grávida, mas nunca esperou o telefonema que a convenceu a deixar avançar a gravidez.

 Foi o desespero que levou Anna Romano a escrever ao Papa Francisco. A mulher, italiana, encontrava-se grávida do seu amante, um homem casado, e este já lhe tinha deixado claro que não iria ajudar a criar o bebé, tentando convencê-la a abortar.

Sob pressão, Anna escreveu ao Papa, mais por desabafo do que por outra razão, e foi com grande surpresa que recebeu um telefonema de Francisco.

“Fiquei estupefacta ao telefone. Ouvi-o a falar. Tinha lido a minha carta. Assegurou-me que o bebé é um dom de Deus, um sinal da providência. Disse-me que nunca estaria sozinha”, conta Romano ao jornal italiano “Il Messagero”.

Após alguns minutos de conversa, a futura mãe encontrava-se novamente cheia de esperança e decidida a levar a gravidez até ao fim. “Ele encheu-me o coração de alegria quando me disse que eu era corajosa e forte pelo meu filho”, recorda.

As palavras do Papa foram ainda tranquilizadoras noutro sentido. Anna disse a Francisco que gostaria de baptizar o filho, mas "tinha medo que não fosse possível", por ser "mãe solteira e divorciada". O Papa não só explicou que seria possível baptizá-lo, como se ofereceu para ser ele próprio o padrinho. “Estou convencido que não terá dificuldade em encontrar um pai espiritual, mas, se não conseguir, estou sempre disponível”, disse Francisco.

Compreensivelmente, Anna Romano já fez saber que, se a criança for rapaz, chamar-se-á Francisco.

Desde a sua eleição, o Papa já pegou várias vezes no telefone para falar pessoalmente com pessoas que sabia estarem a passar dificuldades. Um caso envolveu um rapaz cujo irmão tinha sido morto e, mais recentemente, uma mulher argentina vítima de violação.




quinta-feira, 5 de setembro de 2013

There is no such thing as ‘gay marriage,’ just marriage, period - by William B. May

September 4, 2013 (MercatorNet) - We have all, or nearly all, done it -- talked about "gay marriage" or "same-sex marriage". But according to William B. May, who has been in the thick of the marriage debate in the United States, that's a mistake. MercatorNet asked him to explain.

* * * * *
 
MercatorNet: People trying to defend marriage know that “same-sex marriage” is a contradiction in terms, nonsense in fact, but isn’t it just shorthand for referring to an issue? What’s the harm?
 
William B May: The only reason there is a debate about the legal definition of marriage is because of confusion about its true meaning and purpose. Without truth about marriage, people take positions based on emotion and sentimentality. To restore the truth about marriage we must witness it in a way people can understand.

The first thing to consider is that no one is really proposing to put something called “same-sex marriage” in the law. They take “a man and a woman” and replace it with “two people.” That has consequences that people are not considering. So be careful not to oppose something that is not there.

When they eliminate “a man and a woman” from marriage laws it eliminates the only civil institution that is specifically geared to unite children with their moms and dads – the sole reason for marriage being a privileged institution in the first place. That exposes the hidden agenda and the truth about what is at stake.

Opponents argue that they don’t want to change marriage, and men and woman can still get married, so what is the big deal. The problem is that men and women are not getting married, and  this has created a crisis with increasing fatherlessness and associated consequences, and an increasing number of children living in poverty. Removing this child-centric institution from the law removes authority to actively promote the unique value of men and women marrying before having children. It makes it illegal for public institutions to do so and makes it legally discriminatory for anyone else.
 
What should we say instead of “same-sex marriage”?

Using the term “same-sex marriage” is one of the traps we fall into. It implies the issue is about participation in it by same-sex couples and makes us sound like our only motive is to oppose their aspirations. It is critical to educate people that the issue is redefinition, not participation and that redefining marriage has consequences. Redefining eliminates the only civil institution that is geared to uniting children with their moms and dads. The issue should be whether or not we need such an institution.
 
Why do the terms we use matter so much? Are there implications we are not seeing?

We live in a relativistic culture in which words mean different things to different people. For example when you talk about children needing a mother and father, or say that a married mother and father is good for children, that statement may be true, but different people have different understandings of what children need and what is good. This invariably leads to a debate about outcomes for children and competency in parenting, and who can do a better job, which escalates emotions. Ironically this has little to do with the meaning and purpose of marriage.

Being born into a family with mom and dad united in marriage is a human right, as the Catholic Church teaches, and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child implies (in Articles 7 and 9 ). Our moms and dads are part of our identity and we carry their flesh for all of eternity. With every right there is a corresponding duty to promote respect for that right and in this case to promote civil marriage as the foundation of the family of common ancestry.

It is also important for people to be able to distinguish between a real human right, that can only be recognized by law and never created, and a claimed individual right or license. A human right applies to each and every person without exception. The human right of children to know and, as far as possible, to be loved and cared for their moms and dads is a right that can be known by both reason and our own desire for connection with the man and woman from whom we originated. This is also an experience of God’s plan for creation, but is not dependent in belief in God.
 
What definition of marriage do you recommend we should use in debating this issue?

“Marriage unites a man and a woman with each other and any children born from their union.” That is what marriage is; that is what it does. The trouble is that children and family have been disconnected from marriage.

Factors include no fault divorce making it adult-centric, the separation of sex from procreation and marriage, having children becoming a life-style choice for personal fulfillment, and the increasingly accepted practice of intentionally depriving children of their moms or dads or both through assisted reproductive technology (sperm and egg donation, and surrogacy).

Considering these factors, it is difficult for people to understand marriage by discussing complementarity, procreation, motherhood and fatherhood, etc. It must be expressed in its totality. In reality, marriage unites a man and a woman with each other and any children born from their union. It is a fact, something that the law can only recognise, not change. If the word is redefined in the law, marriage will still exist, but will be no longer recognized in law as such. It becomes discriminatory to advocate that is has any unique value to society, at least under the name of marriage.
 
What do you think of the term “traditional marriage”? Is it useful?

I just use the word “marriage”, but I am careful to use it in a context so people know what I mean. “Traditional marriage” communicates what we mean but nothing about its true meaning and purpose in a way people can understand. Traditional has a connotation of connection with and holding onto the past. However, marriage is about the future.
 
How does this work out at the ballot box? How are referendums worded?

I have felt that defining marriage between a man and a woman in law does not go far enough. The law in some way needs to imply its public interest; clarifying that its purpose is more than recognizing loving, committed relationships between men and women. Perhaps it should state something like, “Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognize. All public institutions must promote its unique value as the only civil institution that unites children with their mothers and fathers.”
 
Click "like" if you support TRADITIONAL marriage.
 
Opponents will object because it reveals the real meaning and purpose of marriage. They argue that children raised by same-sex couples have a right to married parents, but this changes the subject because every child in this situation has lost their mom, dad or both. Arguments that this could provide stability for such children implies that marriage is merely a human creation for some sociological objective. Marriage is about the free choice of a man and woman to make themselves irreplaceable to each other in preparation to receive life as a gift. Marriage is the foundation of the communion of irreplaceability we call the family.

Opponents cause further confusion by saying marriage can’t be about procreation because not all married man and woman have children. That may be so, but every child has a mother and father and has a right, as far as possible, to be born into a family with them united in marriage. All married men and women engage in the same conjugal act, which is a commemoration and renewal of the marriage vows. Even sociologists from across the political spectrum agree that it is important to reestablish a norm for men and women to marry before having children.
 
How can we stay on the front foot in debates on this issue? Can we ever avoid being labeled “bigot”?

When we use the term “same-sex marriage,” it immediately tells people we are against someone and the so-called “rights” they are advocating. It’s an unfortunate tactic of our opponents to attribute motives to those defending marriage in an effort to seek sympathy, discredit, and intimidate. Avoiding the use of the term and instead focusing on what we are for will help greatly.

We can understand the sincere desire of some people to have same-sex relationships recognized, but marriage would have to be redefined in the law in a way that eliminates the only civil institution that unites kids with their moms and dads. How can anyone justify that? This issue is not about homosexuality at all. It is about whether marriage is a reality that not only unites a man and a woman with each other, but with any children born from their union.

What opponents are really proposing is that marriage be redefined in the law to be merely an institution for recognizing committed relationships for the benefit of the adults. What is the public interest in that? We love talking about other people’s sins, so it takes discipline to avoid getting drawn into a conversation about sexual ethics and personal behavior and stay focused on the reality of marriage.
 
Actually, the marriage redefiners seem to agree with you. They don’t use “gay marriage” or “same-sex marriage” either, but talk about “marriage equality”. Why do you think that is?

Their research shows that 58% of people in the US already believe that the purpose of marriage is to recognize committed relationships for adults. So all they have to do is to say same-sex couples want to marry for the same reason anyone else does.

The current understanding of marriage is one of the factors contributing to the fact fewer people are marrying and more than half of children born to women under 30 are outside of marriage. This is a crisis that is touching almost every family. The focus must be on changing current ideas about what marriage is for the benefit of society and our own families instead of focusing on why same-sex couples don’t qualify.

I imagine that marriage redefiners don’t want to use the term “same-sex or gay marriage” because their current approach is more effective, and the terms conjure up “anti-gay” feelings.
 
William B May is president of the United States organization Catholics for the Common Good and played a prominent role in the Proposition 8 effort that successfully restored the definition of marriage between a man and a woman in California – since overturned by the courts. He is the author of Getting the Marriage Conversation Right, a Guide for Effective Dialogue .

quarta-feira, 4 de setembro de 2013

Homosexuality, Identity, and the Grace of Chastity - Courage’s Fr. Paul Check on why chastity is an essential virtue for those with same-sex attraction—and for all Christians

In CWR 

St. Augustine is famous for having prayed, “Lord, make me chaste, but not yet.” Father Paul Check, the director of Courage, suggests that chastity, like justice and mercy, is indeed part of the Good News of Christ and to ignore it is self-defeating. 

The Courage apostolate ministers to people with same-sex attraction who want to live by the Catholic Church’s sexual teachings, providing self-governed and anonymous group meetings around the country. 

Father Check, who served as an officer in the Marine Corps prior to being ordained to the priesthood in 1997, spoke recently with Catholic World Report about the Church’s wisdom in not reducing persons to an identity based solely upon their sexual appetites, and how the average Catholic can respond to the aggressive social agenda of the gay lobby.

CWR: Within Courage, you make a clear distinction between same-sex attraction and the gay lifestyle. Can you clarify the difference? 

Father Check: The most important question ever asked in human history was asked by Our Lord when he said to the apostles, “Who do you say that I am?” It is the question of identity, because it is from an understanding of identity that we then know how to live in a way consistent with that identity. I won’t say that it is always easy, because we have concupiscence, but in order for us to understand the proper way of asking, we first have to clearly answer the question of being. 

With regard to the human person, the question of “Who am I?” is best answered with the understanding that we are children of God redeemed by the blood of Christ and called to be his disciples, and we are invited to grow in this life of grace and glory in the life to come. There is the foundation of the most important or essential part of our identity. 

Now there are other things that make up our identity as well. Our human family, and where we are from geographically. These things are also important but not as important as the fundamental question of our identity, our being children of God. 

We are created as sexual beings and this story is told to us in the book of Genesis, which is not a science book, of course, and does not tell us in precise terms how man came to be but rather precisely who we are and who we are intended to be and to whom we are to look for an understanding of our identity. In that Genesis story it is made plain that God in his wisdom divided the human race in such a way that human nature is expressed in the masculine and the feminine. This is a very rich theological and anthropological question. But for our purposes here, while there is such a thing as human nature, that nature is always expressed very concretely in a person—a person that is either masculine or feminine, so that sexual identity is also something that is integral to who the person is. And in order to know who we are and how that sexual identity is properly expressed we go back to the Genesis story and learn about the union of man and woman, the fruitfulness of God in his plan, and how his gifts of fertility are associated with the sexual faculty and are inherently bound up with sexual intimacy. 

With that preamble, the reason that the Church, it seems to me, avoids the labels of “gay,” “homosexual,” and “lesbian” as nouns is because in her maternal wisdom and charity, and in following the story of who man is, she does not want to collapse someone’s identity into only their sexual appetite. That seems unjust and uncharitable. It takes a bit more charity to say that a person has same-sex attraction than to use the labels that are very popular in the culture today. 

In saying this, of course, I am not in any way minimizing the strength, the intensity, the duration or the frequency of the feelings of same-sex attraction and how important these feelings are to someone’s self-understanding. We only want to give same-sex attraction its proper label. Not too much, but clearly not too little. 

CWR: As a result of that, what do you see in the gay lifestyle that then defeats the ability to have a life of authentic happiness? 

Father Check: Any action that is contrary to the design or the gift of our humanity is going to put us at cross-purposes with ourselves. Some things are easy to see and they are not at all controversial…for instance, if someone consistently tells lies. Not only are they doing an injustice to the person to whom they are lying, but they are also at cross-purposes with their own humanity, in the sense that the power of communication and speech has been given to us to establish trust, and to form relationships—relationships of friendship and relationships of love. So, if I am consistently lying, then I am at cross-purposes with myself and I will frustrate the very desires that I have for human intimacy and for human affection and to know and be known in a personal way. It is easy to see this with regard to speech. It is also easy to see it with regard to eating. If I’m hungry and I eat an entire chocolate cake and wash it down with a bottle of red wine, it is going to put me at cross-purposes with myself. There is something self-defeating about my own actions. 

By analogy, I want to suggest the same thing about the sexual realm. It is very easy for our sexual desires to become misdirected because the fundamental desire of the human heart is for affection, to love and be loved in a personal way, to be known in a personal way. Because that drive is so strong, as it should be, according to the wisdom of God, then we also have to give our own actions and feelings a proper reflection to make sure that we are not engaged in a self-defeating search for happiness in this way. And what makes that difficult, of course, is that the drive for intimacy is strong within us and it is also, like all of the other human faculties, touched by concupiscence, that weakness in the will that can lead us to attempt to fulfill our desires in the wrong way. 

When I speak about this, of course—and most of my work is to present to priests and seminarians on the topic of homosexuality—I try to situate it fully in the context of the virtue of chastity. I think that we have to ask the question: do we believe that chastity is part of the Good News? I know we have it magisterially, but do we have that conviction personally and institutionally, or ecclesiastically? 

Now, I think that people believe that justice is part of the Good News, and mercy is part of the Good News, and salvation and eternal life are part of the Good News, but what about chastity? Do we see and understand that as a virtue chastity is essential, not only for our salvation, of course, but for our human fulfillment consistent with the Genesis story? The way that we have been told we have been made? So that opens up the question widely—and we can then speak about contraception and cohabitation and many other things related to the virtue of chastity, and indeed we must, in order to situate the topic of homosexuality in its proper context. 

CWR: From your research, what is the link between same-sex attraction and parenting, particularly the father’s role especially in men? 

Father Check: Here I very much want to speak as a layman. We are entering the realm of the natural and social sciences and I’m happy to try give some perspective based on my experience but it is not in a strict sense my competence. I’m guided by that by the Church’s own reflection. 

In the three paragraphs in the Catechism of the Catholic Church on homosexuality, the Catechism speaks of the psychological genesis of homosexuality, thereby locating the question within nature, as some disturbance in nature. Therefore, in God’s providence, the reflection on this question properly belongs to the human sciences, in particular the psychological sciences. And we have to think a bit carefully about that word today, because up until very recently in history if we used the word “psychology,” people didn’t immediately think of those suffering with some sort of malady that needed to be cured. If you said that to St. Thomas Aquinas, that wouldn’t come to his mind. Classically, when we think about psychology we think about the powers of the human soul and what is the nature of man, so we are not immediately speaking about therapy or people needing counseling, but about human nature. We are thinking about what is the gift or the design of the person or the human soul in such a way that he or she can realize those deep desires for goodness, truth, and beauty that are imbued. 

So the psychological genesis suggests there is something in the human order that has not yet reached its proper fulfillment. I think we can discern from the context that whatever it is that has not reached proper fulfillment is something not good. Here is what I mean by that. We live in a world that is governed by cause and effect, so things don’t come out of nowhere—they have something that precedes them logically and temporally to bring them about. The Catechism describes the same-sex inclination as objectively disordered. Now, we need to be plain, those words fall very hard on some ears because when they are heard it immediately sounds as if, or can sound as if, we are talking about a person—that a person is somehow disordered, not whole, not complete. But from the context of the Catechism, we can see that is not what is being said at all. What is being said is that the appetite, the erotic attraction to a member of the same sex, is out of harmony with human nature, it is misdirected. And because it is misdirected, and because we live in a world governed by cause and effect, then perhaps with some careful reflection we might be able to ascertain what it is that has caused that disordered attraction. 

But the complexity and very personal nature of this make it difficult to draw straight lines and say what the reason is someone has the homosexual inclination or desire. There are patterns that tend to repeat themselves, but I think what we can say is the tree is known by its fruit, and as Our Lord tells us, bad fruit is going to come from a bad tree. So the objective disorder has a provenance in something that has not been in harmony with the proper development of the person in the affective sense. It doesn’t mean that the person has less value. 

Now it is true that when it comes to the development of the masculine character the role that example plays in a boy’s life, i.e., the role of adult men in his life is something that is very, very important. I love St. Paul’s words to Timothy about fatherhood. He says it is strong, loving, and wise (2 Tim 1:7). And that is exactly right. It is all those things. Strong is protection, discipline, sacrifice, leadership, holding to standards. Loving is benevolence, warmth, compassion, forgiveness, kindness, the proper kind of male sensitivity. And wise—wisdom—is really the virtue of prudence, how to live well. All of us want that from our fathers and we do also from our mothers, but in a different way. 

We are born male and female, but we grow into a masculine or feminine character based on a number of different things. I think, in some ways, the most important and really the first one is the way our fathers love our mothers and our mothers love our fathers. Many priests will come to me and ask during a clergy conference, “What can we do about this situation?”  Well, we have to do more and better pre-Cana. If we help couples understand more about the sacrament into which they are about to enter, then not only do we perhaps forestall a number of problems we can see from sociological data and the rest, but we enrich the lives of the couple, and therefore of their families. And I think that will also help forestall some of the difficulties we are seeing. 

A boy very naturally wants the joy of his father and to be able to see in his father’s eyes that his existence, the son’s existence, is able to produce that joy. I would say one of the common themes among our Courage members—and I’m being very careful not to paint with too broad a brush, but I’m just suggesting a pattern that tends to repeat itself and is therefore of interest—is that a lot of our men didn’t have that sense. And I’m not trying to demonize their fathers. I am not trying to say that they were bad fathers or didn’t love their sons. A lot of the work that I do and that Courage does addresses the issue of perception and how a relationship is perceived. And perhaps someone with a certain type of temperament could perceive something that was not entirely consistent with the reality of the situation, but nevertheless, that perception could have left an acute wound. 

CWR: There is general discussion of a “Peter Pan syndrome” in our culture among both homosexual and straight men, of not wanting to grow up. Do you see a relationship between these two groups of men? 

Father Check: This addresses the issue of manhood in general. There are a number of things that would bear on this impeded development of the human person such that adolescence is prolonged. As an aside, it is an interesting statistic that the average age of a video-gamer in the United States is a 33-year-old-man. I’m not on a campaign against video games, although I have a lot of reservations about them, but a 33-year-old-man, it would seem, according to nature, would have others things engaging him at that point in his life.

The ready availability of pornography which is accessible, anonymous, affordable, and addictive—the four A’s—retards the emotional and moral development of the character and, like video games, turns the person in on himself, where he becomes the center of attention and of action. You can see we are at cross-purposes with ourselves again. I love the phrase from J. Budziszewski, a splendid natural law philosopher who was our keynote speaker at the Courage conference this year, who describes the human person as being “blessedly incomplete.” I like that very much and think it’s right. What it means is that in order to find fulfillment we have to possess ourselves, forget ourselves, and give ourselves in a way that is the exact opposite of the tendency to selfishness and self-preoccupation. 

CWR: What are your thoughts on the recent decision by the Boy Scouts to allow openly homosexual scouts, but not leaders? How will this affect them and how should parents respond? 

Father Check: My first concern is the boys who self-identify as “gay” or “homosexual.” And the question is: why are they doing that? If we go back to our prior discussion about identity, the Church is reluctant to label people in this way, and I think we want to do anything we can to avoid encouragement of that label, particularly for adolescents. The teenage years are a period of discovery and adventure in a certain sense and a time of coming to know oneself. And that has to be guided properly so that self-entanglement doesn’t take place. Many different things are happening at this age and it seems, at best, premature in that stage of development for someone to take a label for himself that is not reflective of his entire being. 

There are a couple of Church documents—one is from the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith and the other is from the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops—that address the question of identity. With regard to young people, those documents state that they should avoid the label and that they could receive the proper spiritual counseling as well as the help of a mental health professional who has a sound Christian anthropology in order to investigate why these feelings have arisen. Again, I think the reliable research indicates that same-sex attraction is a symptom of, or a response to, a kind of emotional wound or deficit. This wound could also be sexual abuse. There is very good data indicating that those with same-sex attraction are seven times more likely to have been the victims of sexual abuse than the population at large. Now, I must quickly say that not everybody who is a victim of sexual abuse winds up having a homosexual inclination—clearly that is not the case.  However, that should be of interest to us because if a young person is self-identifying as having same-sex attraction, that may be, may be, an indication that there was an introduction into the very special and unique realm of sexual intimacy that was either forced or was entered into, clearly, unknowingly and unwillingly, because the emotional development of the person was not ready for such intimacy at that a delicate age. A lot of that does happen, unfortunately, and can misshape someone’s understanding of who he is. 

CWR: Is seems from what you have just said that same-sex attraction is not a fixed reality, but it is more fluid than it is made out to be by the gay lobby. 

Father Check: Another reason that I think the Church has been very prudent in the way she avoids using the words “gay,” “homosexual,” or “lesbian” as nouns is that there is not one profile. 

One Church document, the 2005 text from the Congregation for Catholic Education in Seminaries, addresses this distinction between deep-seated and transitory homosexual feelings. This suggests that the Church recognizes there are those for whom the question is a bit more settled, or is not fluid, but clearly that is not true for everyone. There is the question of fluidity and particularly with regard to adolescence. In Veritatis Splendor, Blessed Pope John Paul II says that we are in some degree changed by our actions, although we have a fixed human nature. The more a young person self-identifies, the more he is already making a choice in order to firm up that identity in his mind. The better hope is to caution a great reserve in this and to charitably and prudently establish trust with the young person and see what may lie behind the same-sex attraction, so that very real help can be given. But encouragement to act out, even if it is just self-identification—certainly encouragement to act out sexually—is not going to be good, but is going to reinforce what is in fact a false identity which can only lead them to unhappiness. The point is that the same-sex attraction or desire can never be acted upon consistent with our human nature and therefore it will always put the person at cross-purposes with himself or herself. 

CWR: One can conclude that your thoughts on gay marriage and the recent DOMA ruling of Windsor v. United States follow along these lines. 

Father Check: Yes, law has a pedagogical purpose to it. And one of the things the law does is to instruct us about natural relationships in the community. So if a law adopts a position that is contrary to human nature, contrary to the law and gift of our nature (to what the philosophers call the natural law), because of human weakness and concupiscence it is likely to have a very bad effect because it will encourage some to make choices that are contrary to their own good. This has proven to be true with regard to contraception, it is true with regard to abortion, it is true with regard to divorce, and it is true with regard to homosexual unions. 

CWR: As the gay culture continues to make headway in our society, particularly through judicial over-reach, what can Catholics do to stem the tide? 

Father Check: The first thing is to find great strength, consolation, and hope in the words of St. Paul: “Where sin abounds, grace abounds all the more” (Rom 5:20). And secondly, “God works good in all things for those who love him” (Rom 8:28). 

Our first response must be a response of faith. Nothing is outside of God’s providence. That is not the same thing as saying that God directly wills certain things, because clearly he does not. But for reasons we may not always be able to see or understand right away, mysteriously God permits certain things to happen, but even those things are not outside the reach of grace. So we need a response of faith in order to trust in the presence of the Lord. 

At the final Mass of the Courage conference this year, the sermon I gave was about the Lord being asleep in the boat. Our Lord slept three times: he slept in the crib, he slept in the boat, and he slept on the cross, but on all three occasions he was with us and knew well the circumstances by which we are influenced for good or ill. So a response in faith is very important. 

We have to want to live chastely, cheerfully, and joyfully. The problem of pornography and the problem of contraception are things that are wide-spread within the Catholic community, including Mass-going Catholics. We have to examine our own conviction that chastity is essential for the joy of human relationships. We cannot expect that other people are only going to do what we say they should do, such as, “Don’t marry someone of the same sex.” We can hardly expect to be a compelling voice if we are not already convinced of the veracity of all that the Church teaches us, so we have to live that virtue cheerfully and joyfully. And if we do, other people will see it and be attracted to it. 

We have to return to that kind of thinking of the early Christians, knowing full well that the current culture will be hostile. It gives us a spirit of purpose. We know it will be hard. Chesterton said, “Christians go gaily into the dark.” Now maybe we have to change that to “Christians go cheerfully into the dark” because of the way that word has been distorted, but Chesterton was right. A down-faced, angry Christian fulminating at the world is not going to be a good instrument of evangelization. We need that trust and confidence in God that St. Thérèse had and showed us so magnificently. We need that now and to try to live it, and we can! God’s grace will make it possible.