segunda-feira, 5 de novembro de 2012

Neticidas - por Nuno Serras Pereira

Com uma frequência exagerada atribui-se ao macho humano a culpa, em virtude da coacção exercida sobre a mulher que ele engravidou, do aborto provocado. Porém, se é verdade que não são poucos os casos em que isso sucede não deixa de ser verdade que há outros em que é a mãe grávida que contra a vontade expressa do pai e apesar de todo o apoio que este presta condena friamente à morte o filho que traz nas suas entranhas, mesmo debaixo do coração materno feito para amar e não para assassinar. A superstição actual de considerar que somente o homem é pecador e que a mulher é imaculada é um absurdo sem qualquer fundamento quer na Revelação quer nos factos da vida.


Os avós, desde há muito, foram sempre vistos como como “reservatórios” de ternura e de carinho que com a prudência e sabedoria adquiridas ao longo dos anos moderavam os excessos disciplinares dos pais, constituindo muitas vezes como que um tribunal de amor ao qual se recorria com a certeza de este moderar a severidade noviça dos pais ainda jovens. No entanto, com o derrancar dos costumes e a corrupção dos tempos tudo isto se perverteu. E o que agora infelizmente se verifica é que se tornou corriqueiro que as avós exercem uma coacção tremenda para que suas filhas homicidiem seus netos nascituros. Acompanham-nas aos abortadouro, invectivam ferozmente quem lhes oferece auxílio e alternativas, e pressionam-nas contra suas vontades a entregarem-se às tenazes e bisturis esquartejadoras de seus netos.

Existirá porventura prova mais eloquente da profundíssima selvajaria facinorosa e atroz daquilo que Portugal padece?

05. 11. 2012

domingo, 4 de novembro de 2012

“Omomafia” nella Chiesa? - di Marco Tosati

In CR

(di Marco Tosatti su blog “San Pietro e dintorni”, La Stampa.it) Riportiamo alcuni brani di un lungo articolo di don Dariusz Oko, Dottore di ricerca del Dipartimento di Filosofia dell’Università Pontificia Giovanni Paolo II di Cracovia, su un tema scottante: e cioè l’omosessualità nella Chiesa.

Il suo testo è stato pubblicato su varie riviste, per ultima sulla prestigiosa rivista teologica tedesca “Theologisches”. “Da molte settimane in Polonia ha luogo un’accesa discussione sulla “omosessualità clandestina nella Chiesa” causata dalle dichiarazioni di don Tadeusz Isakowicz-Zaleski nel suo ultimo libro “Mi importa della verità”. Alcuni negano l’esistenza di questo mondo sommerso e divulgano tesi del tutto contrarie all’insegnamento della Chiesa; in entrambi i casi ciò non corrisponde al vero .

Vista la serietà del problema, mi sento in dovere di prendere la parola, perché anch’io vorrei la verità; ma soprattutto vorrei il bene, il bene fondamentale dell’uomo e della Chiesa, la comunione fondamentale della sua vita”. Scrive Oko : “Il dovere di prendere posizione sul problema dell’omosessualità clandestina nella Chiesa è legato al mio impegno nella critica filosofica dell’ideologia e della propaganda omosessuale (in breve omoideologia e omopropaganda), della quale mi occupo da tanti anni su richiesta e con l’incoraggiamento di molti cardinali e vescovi”. “Ho iniziato il mio lavoro come una lotta contro una mortale minaccia esterna al cristianesimo, ma poco, a poco ho scoperto che la divisione fra esterno ed interno non è così facile.

L’avversario non è soltanto all’esterno della Chiesa, ma è anche già ben radicato al suo interno, pur se spesso dissimulato come un “cavallo di Troia”. Il problema dell’omoideologia e dell’omolobby non esiste soltanto all’esterno della Chiesa, ma è ben presente anche al suo all’interno, dove l’omoideologia diventa omoeresia”. E continua: “Per prima cosa bisogna denunciare una menzogna generalizzata da parte dei mass media che parlano continuamente della pedofilia del clero, mentre il più delle volte si tratta di efebofilia, cioè una degenerazione che non consiste nella attrazione sessuale da parte di maturi maschi omosessuali per i bambini, ma per ragazzi adolescenti in età puberale. È una tipica deviazione legata all’omosessualità.

Le conoscenze principali su questo argomento derivano dal fatto che più dell’80% dei casi di abusi sessuali del clero scoperti negli Stati Uniti sono costituiti da efebofilia, e non da pedofilia. Eppure tutto questo non sarebbe successo senza l’esistenza di quel mondo sommerso del quale i pubblici ministeri hanno svelato soltanto la punta dell’iceberg”. L’autore ricorda alcuni casi eccellenti: quello di mons. Julius Paez in Polonia, di mons. Magee in Irlanda, di Rembert Weakland negli Stati Uniti, oltre al bisessuale fondatore dei Legionari di Cristo. “La condotta di Rembert Weakland, un arcivescovo particolarmente ‘liberale’ e ‘aperto’, che negli anni 1977-2002 ha diretto la diocesi di Milwaukee negli Stati Uniti, dimostra fino a che punto possono spingersi i combattenti preti gay in abito talare. Lui stesso ha ammesso di essere gay e di aver avuto rapporti sessuali continuativi con molti partner.

Nel corso di tutti i 25 anni del suo ufficio, si è sempre opposto al papa ed alla Santa Sede in molte questioni, ed ha particolarmente criticato e respinto l’insegnamento del Magistero della Chiesa cattolica sull’omosessualità. Per di più ha appoggiato e protetto gli omosessuali attivi nella sua diocesi, aiutandoli a sottrarsi alla responsabilità per i reati di carattere sessuale ripetutamente da loro commessi. Alla fine del suo esercizio ha anche attuato una malversazione gigantesca, sottraendo circa mezzo milione di dollari dalla cassa della diocesi per mantenere il suo ex-partner”. Tutti e quattro per molto tempo sono rimasti impuniti, nonostante insistenti voci e ripetute accuse, pervenute a Roma nel corso di molti anni.

Oko denuncia una vera e propria “lobby” interna alla Chiesa: “Per riuscire a nascondere ed a far tollerare un Male del genere bisogna avere uomini nelle cariche importanti, bisogna formare non più soltanto una omolobby, ma una potente congrega, perfino una omomafia. Era d’accordo in tal senso anche Jarosław Gowin, attuale ministro della giustizia polacco, quando, ancora da senatore, parlava dello scandalo degli abusi omosessuali, dei reati di molestie sessuali su giovani e seminaristi, nonché dell’occultamento di questi fatti, commessi da sacerdoti della diocesi di Płock.

Il ministro Gowin ha rivelato che in un suo intervento in Chiesa, durante la causa contro il vescovo Paetz, ha avuto l’impressione di avere a che fare con una sorta di mafia, che, a difesa del proprio interesse, arrivava a negare brutalmente fatti e principi, perfino quelli più evidenti”. Don Oko afferma che “Tutto inizia dal fatto che per un seminarista, con tendenze o con orientamento omosessuale profondamente radicato, è molto più difficile diventare un buon prete”. E per l’omosessuale seminarista o prete le difficoltà sono molte: “Si viene a trovare in una situazione analoga a quella in cui si troverebbe un uomo normale, che per alcuni anni (oppure anche per tutta la vita) ogni giorno dovesse vivere con molte donne attraenti sotto lo stesso tetto, nelle stesse camere da letto e negli stessi bagni. La probabilità di perseverare nella castità diminuirebbe sensibilmente. Bisogna comprendere e cercare di rispettare nel miglior modo possibile i nostri fratelli omosessuali, come ogni persona umana. Essi molte volte provano con tutte le forze a resistere alle loro tentazioni, ed alcuni ci riescono anche, e vivono in modo onesto e perfino santo”.

Per la Chiesa il problema è grandissimo: “Comunque sanno molto bene di rischiare lo smascheramento e il discredito, e perciò si supportano a vicenda. Formano dei gruppi informali, delle combriccole, e perfino una specie di mafia, cercando di dominare soprattutto i luoghi dove albergano potere e denaro. Una volta raggiunta una carica decisionale, cercano di appoggiare e di promuovere prima di tutto le persone dalla natura simile alla loro oppure almeno quelle di cui sono certi che non si opporranno mai per il loro debole carattere.

In tal modo può avvenire che la Chiesa si trovi ad avere in posizioni direttive persone profondamente corrotte, persone molto lontane dal livello spirituale degno di una carica importante, persone false e particolarmente esposte ai ricatti degli avversari del cristianesimo”. E la situazione per chi all’interno della Chiesa tenta di opporsi può essere difficilissima. “Altre volte, quando un vicario tenta di difendere i giovani dalle molestie sessuali di un parroco è proprio lui, e non il parroco, ad essere richiamato all’ordine, vessato ed infine trasferito. Per aver svolto con coraggio il proprio dovere costui si ritrova a vivere esperienze dolorose. Succede che, con un’azione organizzata, egli venga ricattato, umiliato e diffamato sia nell’ambiente parrocchiale che sacerdotale. Inoltre, quando un prete o un frate subiscono loro stessi delle molestie sessuali da altri colleghi e superiori e cercano di chiedere aiuto e difesa ai livelli più alti, può accadere che incontrino un omosessuale ancora più importante”. Don Oko parla dell’esperienza personale nel caso del vescovo Paez, e di altri casi ancora.

Benedetto XVI conduce una lotta serrata contro questo male, e ribadisce che un prete deve essere eterosessuale; altirmenti la rinuncia al matrimonio e la scelta celibataria non avrebbero senso. ”L’insegnamento del papa incontra opposizioni: la comunità omosessuale della Chiesa si difende ed attacca. Ha bisogno anche di strumenti intellettuali, di giustificazioni e perciò l’omoideologia assume, nei suoi ragionamenti, discorsi e scritti, la forma di omoeresia. La ribellione più aperta contro il papa e contro la Chiesa è diretta da alcuni gesuiti statunitensi che si oppongono apertamente e dichiarano che, in contrasto con i principi sopracitati, accetteranno ugualmente seminaristi con tendenze omosessuali, invitandoli perfino di proposito”.

sábado, 3 de novembro de 2012

Deus nos dê Bispos assim: Bishop Jenky emphasizes religious liberty, speaks of ‘grave sin’ of pro-abortion politicians and ‘their electoral supporters’

In CWN 

...

The full text of the letter appears below.
Since the foundation of the American Republic and the adoption of the Bill of Rights, I do not think there has ever been a time more threatening to our religious liberty than the present. Neither the president of the United States nor the current majority of the Federal Senate have been willing to even consider the Catholic community’s grave objections to those HHS mandates that would require all Catholic institutions, exempting only our church buildings, to fund abortion, sterilization, and artificial contraception. This assault upon our religious freedom is simply without precedent in the American political and legal system. Contrary to the guarantees embedded in the First Amendment, the HHS mandates attempt to now narrowly define and thereby drastically limit our traditional religious works. They grossly and intentionally intrude upon the deeply held moral convictions that have always guided our Catholic schools, hospitals, and other apostolic ministries.

Nearly two thousand years ago, after our Savior had been bound, beaten, scourged, mocked, and crowned with thorns, a pagan Roman Procurator displayed Jesus to a hostile crowd by sarcastically declaring: “Behold your King.” The mob roared back: “We have no king but Caesar.” Today, Catholic politicians, bureaucrats, and their electoral supporters who callously enable the destruction of innocent human life in the womb also thereby reject Jesus as their Lord. They are objectively guilty of grave sin. For those who hope for salvation, no political loyalty can ever take precedence over loyalty to the Lord Jesus Christ and to his Gospel of Life. God is not mocked, and as the Bible clearly teaches, after this passing instant of life on earth, God’s great mercy in time will give way to God’s perfect judgment in eternity.

I therefore call upon every practicing Catholic in this Diocese to vote. Be faithful to Christ and to your Catholic Faith. May God guide and protect His Holy Church, and may God bless America.

El valor de denunciar a los Adminiculus Antichristi, sin respetos humanos ni "corporativos"

In RL

Beato, el monje de Liébana, y Eterio, el obispo exiliado de Osma, ocupada por los moros, cuando combaten en su Apologética (a.d. 785) las deviaciones adopcionistas del hereje Elipando, a la sazón ocupando el Arzobispado de Toledo bajo los sarracenos, le llamarán "testículo del Anticristo" ["adminiculus Antichristi"],:


"Estos (los herejes) son los testículos del Anticristo, de cuyo semen es engendrada la pervesa prole que es copulada en la boca del Anticristo... Este Anticristo tiene tantos testículos cuantos son los predicadores de su iniquidad"
[Heterii et Sancti Beati ad Elipandum Epistola (Apologeticum) Obras, I, II, n. 96 ]



Y en función de su actitud de servicio a los cristianos Beato y Eterio explican lo grave que son los heresiarcas en los puestos de pastor y maestro, pues son los que generan las semillas de la herejía y los herejes ("testículos del Anticristo, de cuyo semen es engendrada la pervesa prole")

No existía "corporativismo" y los clérigos y las jerarquías sabían que su deber con Dios era proteger a los fieles, denunciando a los heresiarcas, incluso aunque éstos okuparan las diócesis más importantes.

No es de extrañar que los españoles de la alta Edad Media, disponiendo de estas armas espirituales e intelectuales, frente a toda lógica militar y logística, fueran capaces de liberarse de la ocupación islámica y sus aliados y cómplices herejes (se considera que una de las causas de la facilidad de la ocupación musulmana fue la herejía arriana y su antitrinitarismo que consideraba la doctrina agarena como análoga)

A todos nos vienen a la cabeza los  Elipandos de hoy, que desde sus posiciones privilegiadas, por acción o por omisión (la mayoría), siguen siendo generadores de "perversas proles" en el clero, el laicado, los centros de enseñanza y los media "católicos", etc...

Lo que es preocupante es que tenemos más dificultad cuando queremos recordar émulos actuales de Beato y Eterio, lo suficientemente valientes para pener negro sobre blanco (o en la ondas) denuncias sobre los actuales Elipandos.
























terça-feira, 30 de outubro de 2012

Hilaire Belloc’s The Servile State: A Centenary Reflection - by Allan C. Carlson




This year marks the centennial of Hilaire Belloc’s curious book The Servile State. Recent commentators have been unsure where to place this volume on the ideological spectrum. In the Liberty Fund edition, Robert Nisbet labels Belloc a “libertarian Catholic,” a writer taking his inspiration from the nineteenth century’s Cardinal Newman and Lord Acton.1 In his biography of Belloc, Joseph Pearce also terms his subject’s creed “essentially libertarian.”2 Such labels, though, imply a respect for free-market capitalism that simply cannot be found in The Servile State. Rather, Belloc deemed “the capitalist state” both “unstable” and deadly: “If you left men completely free under a capitalist system, there would be so heavy a mortality from starvation as would dry up the sources of labor in a very short time.”3 And he went on to advocate the use of state power, particularly the power of differential taxation, to dismantle big corporations, to thoroughly soak the rich, and to massively redistribute their property to those without any.4

Considering that agenda, other biographers have labeled Belloc a kind of socialist.5 They cast his political-economic agenda as “childishly simple” and attractive primarily to “shaggy William-Morrisy idealists,” precursors to the Hippies of the 1960s.6 In reality, though, Belloc condemned public ownership of property and indicted the political order of early twentieth-century Britain for introducing a new kind of slavery into the world.

Such confusion, especially among conservative readers, also attends Richard Weaver’s small book Ideas Have Consequences7 and for the same reason. The titles of these volumes are wonderfully adaptable to the vacuous form of discourse common to early twenty-first-century American conservatism. It seems clear that few contemporary conservative pundits who cite these titles have actually read them; fewer still have understood them. For the key to the two books is a common reading of history and an implicit common agenda. Simply put, both Belloc and Weaver saw Europe’s High Middle Ages (circa A.D. 1250) as an era when human society embodied inspiring ideals; and they saw philosophical nominalism, scientific logic, and capitalism (properly defined) as the modern enemies of those social ideals.

Belloc insisted that the critical parts, or cells, of this good society were productive families, secure in their property. The whole objective of his political economy was to break down the corruptions of modern capitalism and socialism, and re-establish families in working homes set on land in freehold tenure. His models were the artisans and the free peasants of the High Middle Ages, a community held together by the Christian church and a religiously infused aristocracy attentive to its duties. To be understood, The Servile State must be read through this lens, one rarely used by Tea Party enthusiasts or talk-show pundits. 

Building on the Insights of Pope Leo XIII

Hilaire Belloc was clear that the inspiration for his analysis in The Servile State was Pope Leo XIII’s 1891 encyclical, Rerum Novarum. On the one hand, this document was “modern,” representing the Roman Catholic Church’s readiness to engage—rather than simply denounce—the new urban-industrial age and the place of wage laborers within it. On the other hand, Rerum Novarum was “reactionary,” for its program aimed at restoring a social-economic order that resembled—in its most important components—that of the High Middle Ages.

For example, the encyclical was agrarian in its insistence that all wealth derived from the land: “the earth, even though apportioned among private owners, ceases not thereby to minister to the needs of all, in as much as there is not one who does not sustain life from what the land produces.” Even those who possessed no soil contributed their labor. In consequence, “it may truly be said that all human subsistence is derived either from labor on one’s own land, or from some toil, some calling, which is paid for either in the produce of the land itself, or on that which is exchanged for what the land brings forth.”8

Leo also affirmed the theory of “labor property,” rooted in the “law of nature.” He wrote:

Now, when man thus turns that activity of his mind and the strength of his body toward procuring the fruits of nature, by such act he makes his own that portion of nature’s field which he cultivates—that portion on which he leaves, as it were, the impress of his personality.

It was “just” that the laborer possess what he had made, and no one had standing to violate that right.9

The “natural and original right of marriage” and “the principle purpose of marriage ordained by God’s authority from the beginning”—namely, to “increase and multiply”—were also linked to the physicality of home, tools, and land: “The right of property . . . must in likewise belong to a man in his capacity of head of a family.” Indeed, this right was “all the stronger” as it found “a wider expression in the family group.” The ability to pass on resources for survival to children through inheritance was also important: “in no other way can a father effect this except by the ownership of productive property.”10

It was in this context that Leo rejected “the main tenet of socialism, [the] community of goods,” because it “would violate a natural right and introduce confusion and disorder into the commonweal.” Indeed, private ownership should “be held sacred and inviolable.” However, this meant something other than merely protecting the assets of the relatively few who—circa 1912—actually owned productive property. Rather, as Leo explained, “the law . . . should favor ownership, and its policy should be to induce as many as possible of the people to become owners.” This would also be the solution to “the social question” of the age: “If working people can be encouraged to look forward to obtaining a share in the land,” then “the gulf between vast wealth and sheer poverty will be bridged over.”11 

The Development of the Capitalist State

Belloc’s project in The Servile State was to analyze how that “gulf” had emerged, what had been the consequences, and how the elements of a good society might be put back together again. An important component of this task was to reframe history, in order to understand how a system of ordered liberty and widely dispersed property had come to an end. Belloc began the story shortly after the fall of the Western Roman Empire. Between A.D. 500 and 1000, he said, the Christianized Europeans—just like the pagan Romans before them—took slavery for granted. However, slaves were no longer “made” by conquest. Rather, “it was poverty that made the slave,” as individuals or families accepted slavery as an alternative to indigence. There was no organized protest against the system based on conscience. Rather, owners and slaves alike accepted slavery as an inevitable aspect of the human condition.

The end of European slavery, according to Belloc, came through “the experiment called the Christian church.” While no church dogma explicitly condemned slavery, the Christian emphasis on spiritual equality undermined its premises. At a physical level, the emergence of the autonomous villa, or estate, eventually rooted the slave. Over time, an implicit bargain emerged between lord and slave family: the latter would be attached to a particular section of land, would pay the lord a fixed amount of crop (or, later, a customary fee), and would retain the balance for consumption or private sale. By A.D. 900, the market in men had come to an end. About the same time, cities began to re-emerge as trading centers. Craft guilds developed as self-governing enterprises to control competition among artisans, assuring good quality, “fair” prices, and secure incomes. Under these circumstances, there could be neither capitalist nor proletarian. Indeed, by A.D. 1250, a well-developed “distributive system” existed in Central and Western Europe (including Britain), with three forms of labor: the serf, secure in his position, who paid regular but limited dues and services fixed by long custom; the freeholder peasant, who supported rulers through taxes; and the guildsman.

All three types of labor also shared in the common property of villages, where rights to graze a cow or gather acorns and firewood were well defined and zealously protected. This was essentially an agrarian system: “Then, as now, the soil and its fixtures were the basis of all wealth.” As Belloc summarized: “all three between them were making for a society which should be based upon the principle of property. All, or most—the normal family—should own. And on ownership the freedom of the state should repose.” It was true that co-operative bodies, such as guilds and religious fraternities, placed certain restraints on personal economic liberty. However, this was for the preservation of a greater liberty resting on real economic democracy.12

The end of the medieval-distributist order came in the sixteenth century, when there arose, according to Belloc, “the dreadful moral anarchy which goes by the name of capitalism.” While most economic historians trace the origin of this economic ideology in Britain to the eighteenth century, Belloc insisted that the change was much older. And in the course of three centuries, it transformed Britain from a land of owners into (by 1912) a place where a third of the people were indigent and 95 percent were dispossessed of all capital and land.13

Capitalism emerged through “the deliberate action of men, evil will in a few, and apathy of will among the many.” The first stage came in the 1530s, an “artificial revolution of the most violent kind,” involving the seizure of monastic lands by King Henry VIII. Prior to this revolution, about a third of England’s land belonged to the squires or county lords; a third belonged to free peasants; and a third to church entities. Most of the land that Henry confiscated, as part of his “Reformation,” eventually wound up in the hands of the squires, who now emerged as a powerful, effectively uncontrolled economic oligarchy. In the 1640s, this group eliminated the monarchy as a threat to its power. The same small oligarchy controlled Parliament and used Enclosure Acts and a Statute of Frauds to chase free peasants off their customary lands and to seize the village commons for consolidation into corporate-style farms.14

Few Property Owners, Many Dispossessed Workers

Reflecting on this startling departure from orthodox history, Belloc concluded that by 1700, “England had already become capitalist,” with “a vast section of her population” proletarianized. It was this change, he insisted, and not the later Industrial Revolution, “which accounts for the terrible social condition in which we find ourselves today.” The introduction of industrial processes—Watt’s condensor, Hargrave’s spinning jenny, and King’s flying shuttle—were not the causes of monopoly. By the time they appeared, England had already been captured by an oligarchy. If these inventions had arrived in the thirteenth century, Belloc insisted, they “would have blest and enriched mankind” and would have been organized on a cooperative basis. Instead, they fostered still further consolidation through the trusts; such economic combinations brought “the ruin of the smaller competition through secret conspiracies entered into by the larger men, and supported by the secret force of the state.”15
Socialism emerged in the nineteenth century as a movement to counter the oligarchy. However, “the effect of socialist doctrine upon capitalist society is [actually] to produce a third thing different from either of its two begetters—to wit, the servile state.”

This was not meant just as a criticism of the modern welfare state, as many conservatives now suppose. Rather, The Servile State marked “the re-establishment of slavery as a necessary component of capitalism.” More specifically, the Servile State existed when ownership of the means of production “by a few” came into “stable equilibrium by the establishment of compulsory labor legally enforceable upon those who do not own the means of production for the advantage of those who do.”16 What did Belloc specifically mean by these claims?

He saw capitalist society dividing into two classes: a small number of free citizens who owned productive property and a dispossessed majority who were masters only of their labor and who had no control over capital or land. The Servile State develops as the ownership class and the government converge around the goal of security. In this form of state capitalism, government provides to the free “security” in their property and profits, rent and interest. For the property-less unfree, the government guarantees security in subsistence. In exchange for a surrender of economic autonomy and for acceptance of permanent status as wage-laborers, the unfree gain a minimum wage which provides “sufficiency and security,” workmen’s compensation insurance which cements a new form of inferior status, and means-tested unemployment and sickness insurance which reinforces their status as proletarians. The inevitable consequence of these measures, Belloc argued, was compulsory labor: the expectation that all unfree adults would be in the wage-labor market. State schooling reinforces the process: “Roughly speaking, it is the generation brought up under the Education Acts of the last forty years which has grown up definitely and hopelessly proletarian.”17 Notably, the children of the unfree learned that property ownership was beyond them, that they must think of themselves as wage earners alone.

Belloc neatly summarized the new servile order: “Subject the proletarian, as a proletarian, and because he is a proletarian, to special laws. Clothe me, the capitalist, as a capitalist, and because I am a capitalist, with special converse duties under those laws.” Laborers accept this surrender “of a mere legal freedom” because the Servile State provides “the very real prospect of having enough and not losing it.” Indeed, Belloc acknowledges that in strict terms of material welfare, the newly enslaved may be better off than if they owned property and were responsible for their own support. Partly for this reason, Belloc concluded that the strains of capitalism would relax “and the community will settle down upon the servile basis which was its foundation before the advent of the Christian faith, from what that faith slowly weaned it, and to which in the decay of the faith it naturally returns.”18 

The Distributist Alternative

How might a community escape this end? In The Servile State, Belloc offered little practical guidance. The clear alternative was rebuilding a social-economic order featuring widely distributed property. However, “Will man want to own? . . . Can I discover any relics of the cooperative instinct . . . ?” Most of the unfree, Belloc mused, seemed content in their servility. Owning property meant bearing responsibility for its protection and maintenance and facing many risks, without guarantee of reward. In comparison, the Servile State offered a meager but secure level of subsistence: a genial form of slavery.19 Most modern men wanted income, the consumption of cheap, industrial goods, and the security of state welfare, not the challenges of property.

It would be in his subsequent The Restoration of Property that Belloc laid out a fairly complete distributist program of reform. Family freedom, he said, required “a jealous watch against, and destruction of, monopoly” and “the safeguarding of inheritance, especially the inheritance of small patrimonies.” The goal was “a society in which property is well distributed and so large a proportion of the families in the state severally own and therefore control the means of production as to determine the general tone of society.” Controversially, Belloc reasoned that since the architects of the Servile State had used law and police powers to build their regime, from Enclosure Acts of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries to the welfare measures of the early twentieth, “in this attempt to restore Economic Freedom, the powers of the State must be invoked.” This would include protection against “direct rapine” and from “the exaggeration of competition.” Guild-like structures should be empowered and official machinery created to foster the propagation of small property.20

Regarding specifics, Belloc favored the use of differential taxes to redistribute property. For example, he would tax “chain” retailers so that one company could run no more than a dozen stores. He would handicap department stores, like Harrod’s, in a similar way. A “turnover tax” would be imposed on large wholesalers; small, family-held firms would be tax-free. Large industrial plants would face a tax on power used; artisans would enjoy protection and subsidized credit. Electricity and the internal combustion engine—both favorable to family-scale production—would be encouraged; steam and water power would be taxed. Agricultural land would be restored to families: “there must be a radical difference in the burdens imposed upon the land occupied, as land (according to our view) should be occupied, by a human family living thereon, and land occupied by others from whom the owners draw tribute.” State policy should support subsistence farming and “privilege” this peasantry “as against the diseased society around it.” Taxes on real estate transactions should “make it easy for the smaller man to buy land from the richer man and difficult for the larger man to buy from the smaller man.” Belloc noted that medieval guilds had not entirely disappeared; doctors and lawyers, for example, still maintained guild-like structures that controlled entry into the professions, mandated certain forms of training, and the like. The trade unions, which bore a “proletarian spirit,” should be replaced by similar guild structures that again controlled quality, regulated training, and set just prices.”21

While the sweep of Belloc’s public-policy agenda would cause mass heart failure at a modern Tea Party rally, he insisted that his project was properly labeled reactionary. He sought the method:

by which a reaction against Capitalism and its product, Communism, may be begun . . . . The main task remains not that of elaborating machinery for the reaction toward right living, but of forwarding the spirit of that reaction in a society which has almost forgotten what property and its concomitant freedom means.22 

Policy Insights for Today

Is The Servile State, with its strong whiffs of medievalism, actually relevant to America, circa 2012? The answer is yes. Certainly, the financial crisis of 2008 and its consequences underscored the reality and perils of a servile economy. The vast majority of Americans put their faith in wages, retirement accounts resting on stocks and bonds, and the government safety net. Faith in all three has been shaken by subsequent events, just as Belloc would have predicted. Jobs were lost; the decline in real wages—evident since the 1970s—accelerated. Individual Retirement Accounts proved to be fragile, ephemeral forms of private property; as the old saying went, you can’t eat a stock certificate.  And the government safety net revealed many holes, sure to become wider and more numerous as lawmakers deal with yawning federal and state budget deficits.

All the same, was not the “housing bubble” the cause of the Panic of 2008? And was it not a consequence, in turn, of the distributist goal of delivering widespread home ownership? Could not Belloc’s very scheme be indicted as the cause of current economic woes?

If still alive, Belloc would probably give three answers. First, he never claimed that everyone should own property. Even under the best of cultural circumstances, many were unfit to bear the responsibilities involved. He certainly would not have approved of issuing mortgages to persons without the means to pay for them. Second, Belloc would have objected to the very nature of the modern American housing market. Laws favoring home ownership should have the purpose of settling families in proper structures and building stable communities. In America, however, home ownership has become in large measure a method of speculative investment. This is the very antithesis of distributist principles. And third, Belloc would have stressed that distributists never sought just home ownership. The goal was to place families in productive homes, with small workshops, loom rooms, food-preservation facilities, chicken coops, and gardens as the norm. Today, he would have added home offices, computer rooms, home-schooling rooms, and so on. The typical American suburban home—commonly prohibited by zoning laws and restrictive covenants from housing any kind of productive work—is simply not part of the distributist vision.

Today, a chastened American population is rediscovering the merits of property ownership, home production, and true liberty. The home-schooling revolution led the way, showing how families could reclaim a vital endeavor from the industrialized maws of public education. Family gardens have returned; so have chicken coops: for proof, examine Backyard Poultry magazine. The home computer and the Internet have opened remarkable opportunities for small home businesses; and the number of such enterprises has climbed sharply during the last twenty years.

From Aristotle to Thomas Jefferson to contemporary writers such as Wendell Berry, the linkage of property ownership and a vital home economy to true liberty and security has endured in the political vision of those who cherish liberty and the family. Whereas raw capitalism ends up in an unholy alliance with collectivism known as the Servile State, the distributism of Hilaire Belloc delivers an economy fit for families. Far from being just a reactionary medievalist, Belloc actually represents the most prescient of analysts and guides to a sustainable and child-rich future. 

Dr. Carlson, president of the Howard Center for Family, Religion and Society, is professor of history at Hillsdale College in Michigan.


Notes
  1. Robert Nisbet, “Introduction,” in Hilaire Belloc, The Servile State (Indianapolis: Liberty Classics, 1977 [1912]), p. 18.
  2. Joseph Pearce, Old Thunder: A Life of Hilaire Belloc (New York: Harper Collins, 2002), p. 195.
  3. Belloc, The Servile State, p. 114.
  4. The full policy implications of The Servile State are drawn out in: Hilaire Belloc, The Restoration of Property (New York: Sheed and Ward, 1936).
  5. Robert Speaight, The Life of Hilaire Belloc (London: Hollis & Canter, 1957), p. 317.
  6. A. N. Wilson, Hilaire Belloc (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1984), pp. 292–94.
  7. Richard Weaver, Ideas Have Consequences (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1948).
  8. Pope Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum [May 1891], http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/leo_xiii/encyclicals/documents/hf_1-xiii_enc_1505189, p. 3.
  9. Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum, p. 4. Emphasis added.
  10. Ibid.
  11. Ibid, pp. 5, 12, 14.
  12. Belloc, The Servile State, pp. 64–81, 87. Emphasis added.
  13. Ibid, p. 82. 
  14. Ibid, pp. 82–94. Emphasis added. 
  15. Ibid, pp. 96–102, 117.
  16. Ibid, pp. 32, 35, 39. Emphasis added.
  17. Ibid, pp. 48–61, 155, 174–184.
  18. Ibid, pp. 143, 161, 198.
  19. Ibid, pp. 131–33.
  20. Belloc, The Restoration of Property, pp. 17, 28, 35.
  21. Ibid, pp. 67–73, 90, 107, 113, 116, 137. Emphasis added. 
  22. Ibid, p. 144.

domingo, 28 de outubro de 2012

Tras perseguir a la Iglesia durante décadas fue bautizado por su hijo al que prohibía ser creyente

In Religión en Libertad 

Dios tiene sus tiempos para encontrarse con las personas y utiliza los instrumentos más inimaginables para realizar su obra. Es lo que ocurrió con Hung Phuoc Lam, un dominico vietnamita, cuya vocación fue utilizada por Dios para transformar el corazón de su padre, un perseguidor de la Iglesia.

Este fraile de la Orden de Predicadores cuenta en su experiencia que nació en una familia pagano-católica puesto que su padre veneraba a sus ancestros y su tía era monja budista mientras que su madre era católica. Aun así, él fue bautizado católico.

Su padre les prohibía ir a la Iglesia
Sin embargo, Phuoc Lam relata que la vida de fe y la de su madre no era nada sencilla. “Mi padre era muy severo y prohibía a mi madre ir a la Iglesia –y por lo tanto también estaba prohibido para mí”. Su padre odiaba el catolicismo por el trato que había recibido en un par de ocasiones por varios curas y religiosas, algo que no admitía. “Desde entonces se llenó de prejuicios contra los sacerdotes y contra la Iglesia, y el resultado inevitable era esta prohibición a los miembros de mi familia”.

La fe en Dios durante tantos años de su madre alimentó también a Hung y como él mismo recuerda, “con Dios todo es posible”. “Sólo puedo decir que esta situación era muy triste. Yo seguí confiando en Dios. Rezaba. Le rogaba que cambiara el corazón de mi padre costara lo que costara. No excluí mi propia llamada”.

“Que Dios cambiara el corazón de mi padre”
El Señor no tardó en responder a las oraciones de este joven vietnamita. Y la respuesta fue contundente. “Dios me llamó a la orden dominica, tenía 26 años y mi padre no aceptó la vocación”, asegura. Entonces fue cuando pudo entender las palabras del Evangelio de San Mateo: “no he venido a traer paz, sino espada”.

Su padre estaba furioso y le decía: “¡te prohíbo ser católico y ahora quieres ser sacerdote! ¿No te das cuenta de cómo son los sacerdotes y las monjas?”. De hecho, tomó una actitud “indiferente” hacía su hijo y casi le abandonó. A pesar de ello, “yo seguí adelante, en silencio, confiando en Dios. Y todos los días recé por él con mi madre”.

“Dios cambió a mi padre”
Hung Phuoc Lam entró en el Noviciado para ser fraile dominico mientras el Señor comenzaba también a actuar en su padre. Pasaron los años pero “Dios cambio a mi padre y lo hizo de verdad”.

¿Qué ocurrió para que se diera este cambio de actitud? La clave estuvo en la profesión de sus primeros votos. Ahí fue cuando aceptó la vocación de su hijo. “Luego hice mis votos finales en la Orden de Predicadores y participó en la celebración y gradualmente fue desapareciendo su prejuicio contra la Iglesia”.

“He sido derrotado por Dios”
De este modo, antes de su ordenación hizo una petición muy importante a su padre: que dejara a su madre ir a la Iglesia. Aceptó y su madre era la mujer más feliz en la faz de la tierra. “Fue una alegría el día de mi ordenación, pues la paz regresó a mi familia. Recibí aquello que pensaba haber perdido”, cuenta ahora.

Dios aún no había acabado su trabajo y en la ordenación el padre fue consciente de la realidad: “he sido derrotado por Dios; no le puedo arrebatar a mi hijo. Mi hijo es sacerdote. Está decidido; es un hecho”.

“Bauticé a mi padre”
Como el Señor es el que maneja los tiempos cuatro años después de hacerse sacerdote ocurrió el hecho más maravilloso. “Mi padre expresó el deseo de ser cristiano”. Fue el hijo el que bautizó a su padre en 2006. El que le dio la vida material era ahora el hijo espiritual. “Bauticé a mucha gente, pero jamás olvidaré el momento en que bauticé a mi padre”.

Afirma este fraile dominico que “Dios derrotó a mi padre y el Señor hizo cosas grandes por mi familia”. Tiene clarísimo que “esto fue obra de Dios y que todo es para su gloria. Me dio mucho más de lo que yo le pedí en 20 años de oración silenciosa y perseverante. Él, con su poder, hace milagros en cosas normales”.

La intercesión de la sangre de los mártires
Su vocación dominica, la conversión de su padre es como dice él mismo una obra de Dios y también por la intercesión de los mártires. Vietnam es una tierra regada por la sangre de los mártires y especialmente por numerosos domínicos que dieron su vida por el anuncio del Evangelio en esta tierra.

Obispos, frailes y laicos derramaron su sangre en Vietnam por amor a Dios y a las almas. Sangre que nunca será balde y que bendice la tierra en la que se esparce. En 1988 Juan Pablo II proclamó santos en la Plaza de San Pedro a un total de 117 mártires vietnamitas de los siglos XVIII y XIX, y cuya memoria se celebra el 24 de noviembre.

Muchos de ellos eran dominicos. Seis obispos de la Orden, entre ellos San Valentín de Berriochoa y San José María Díaz Sanjurjo, 15 frailes dominicos, 2 sacerdotes terciarios dominicos así como decenas de laicos y catequistas de la Orden de Predicadores, fueron asesinados por su fe.

Del total, setenta y cinco fueron decapitados. El resto fueron estrangulados, quemados vivos, descuartizados o torturados en prisión. Todos ellos se negaron a abjurar de su fe y pisotear la Cruz de Cristo. Ahora su sangre sigue dando frutos en el país por el que entregaron su vida.